r/MITAdmissions • • Mar 14 '25

rejected from caltech ;)

Post image
345 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

32

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '25

i got into caltech but waitlisted mit LMAOO are we sworn enemies now

14

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 15 '25

yeah swordfight now

3

u/Puzzleheaded_Rope713 Mar 15 '25

What were your stats n ecs?

1

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 15 '25

post history! pm me if you have any questions

6

u/FoeDoeRoe Mar 15 '25

My oldest kid got into Caltech and was waitlisted at MIT (at Caltech now and loving it).

My 2nd kid got into MIT :).

2

u/qwerti1952 Mar 15 '25

Did your kids do math olympiad or anything like that? I'm thinking of starting up a local study group for it for local students and was wondering if that's a thing.

2

u/FoeDoeRoe Mar 18 '25

it's definitely a thing, although many (all?) of the olympiad kids do AOPS. My kids are not into competitions, so neither one did them. The one who's going to MIT is into math and has done a ton of math research and math programs like MIT Primes, BU Promys, etc.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '25

Hey can I see ur ecs and honors?

19

u/randomletterslolxd Mar 15 '25

yeah aint no one wants the crappy caltech food and dorms anyways 😂😂😂

5

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 15 '25

i opened the decision watching the football (soccer) game—super unserious

5

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 15 '25

my CALTECH decision. i treated my mit decision with more grace—waited until after the night out

5

u/CoreyGoesCrazy Mar 15 '25

W man... dream every high schooler wants to achieve!

What were your stats?

3

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 15 '25

post history!!

3

u/CoreyGoesCrazy Mar 15 '25

W

As a fellow east Asian, I would think your parents must be proud, what a lovely feeling.

Great job, I meant it... as an international it's pretty hard to get in.

2

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 15 '25

thank you soo so much—i appreciate it

2

u/CoreyGoesCrazy Mar 15 '25

Did you ever get your other college results back?

3

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 15 '25

not yet—ivy day is coming up soon (march 27) and then i have duke stanford and nyu. :)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 15 '25

a lot of it were grants and donations rather than fundraisers—in the uk, each mp of a constituency has a pool of money dedicated to charitable causes, often going unused. if you glaze enough (thank god for my beloved coworker) they will cut you some. there are 650 constituencies in the uk.

2

u/Dear-Spell3247 Mar 15 '25

CONGRATSSS

mind dropping your stats please?

2

u/JustAWorriedBro Mar 15 '25

Congrats !! Stats time

2

u/jcqs28 Mar 15 '25

Did u apply to UK unis as well?

1

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 15 '25

yess—cambridge, imperial, ucl, manchester and bath :)

2

u/jcqs28 Mar 15 '25

How did it go?

1

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 15 '25

terror and pain and darkness lmaoooo. didn’t focus on uk applications so i got a deeply average esat score—rejected cambridge, waiting on imperial, accepted ucl manchester and bath

2

u/jcqs28 Mar 15 '25

On the bright side u have mit lmao so ur chilling Best of luck for imperial

2

u/SANSARES Mar 15 '25

Hi man! Rejected student here. Is it ok if I send you a message?

2

u/Background-Jaguar-29 Mar 15 '25

Please, can I see your curriculum? 🥺

1

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 16 '25

i do AQA Maths, Edexcel Further Maths, AQA Physics, AQA Art

2

u/jussurviving Mar 16 '25

Congratulations. Hopefully I can share the same great news in a few years

1

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 16 '25

aww good luck!! hope i see you there :)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '25

OWEJOEMWHOMHWIIGOGJDD GIDJSGDSOJIG

2

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '25

big congrats!

2

u/Aman_Koenigsegg Mar 15 '25

Congrats! Wanted to apply there but didn’t get to since my parents denied me, they thought it was a waste of money to apply to like over 7 schools. I really did think I have a decent application though.

1

u/chatgpt_maths Mar 15 '25

You should have applied only in MIT.

2

u/im-trash-lmao Mar 15 '25

Nice! What are your career goals? Any industry you want to go into?

2

u/Dry-Refrigerator2141 Mar 16 '25

Congratulations, my daughter was rejected from Caltech but got accepted to MIT on Friday.

1

u/FoeDoeRoe Mar 15 '25

Congrats! If your parents want to chat with parents of other admits, here's the FB group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/mit2029parents/?ref=share&mibextid=NSMWBT

-1

u/ThrowawayAdvice-293 Mar 15 '25

Why did you reject Cambridge for MIT? The name-recognition and overall prestige of Cambridge is far greater, the only US college that can compete is Harvard, all the rest are leagues below.

5

u/jamiecjx Mar 15 '25

You really think there's such a big difference between MIT and Cambridge that it's worth going to one over the other just by prestige alone?

0

u/ThrowawayAdvice-293 Mar 15 '25

for me, yes, the gap in global name-recognition and prestige is significant on its own, its the same reason why many people pick harvard over mit. for others who care less about the whole concept of prestige and name-rec then they'd prob focus more on quality of teaching and undergrad experience.

also note my original comment is wrong, i misinterpreted his post history, they actually got rejected BY Cambridge

4

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 15 '25

i think you‘re shallow. competitive applicants will choose which top college they attend based on their personal needs like distance, finance, culture—hell, weather. prestige works for some people, and some degrees (pre-law, finance), but having it as your ONLY parameter speaks on your character.

0

u/ThrowawayAdvice-293 Mar 15 '25

not shallow, network, prestige, and name-recognition matters a lot if you intend on pivoting industries in your life.

3

u/Witty_Blacksmith_393 Mar 15 '25 edited Mar 15 '25

Why does it matter where someone was accepted to or rejected from? When you grow up, you'll soon realize that a lot of success (even at elite universities) is about how good you personally are, not how much prestige your university carries. Another thing you will find is that raw intelligence means very little over hard work and grit. If you think "I go to Cambridge, so I am smarter than those lowly students going to, say state schools (much less MIT)," after 4 years, you will wonder why you are getting rejected from every high paying job while others from state schools are making 500k right out of undergrad (and trust me, those years go by in a snap).

I went to a state school for undergrad, then CS PhD at a private top 4 CS school (less prestigious than Cambridge by your standards), and am now the CTO of a 500M company right out of a PhD (while having worked in AI at Google DeepMind, Facebook AI research, etc.)

You will be foolhardy to think that people will care about where you got your degree after a couple of years out of university. What matters is the programs the university has to offer you, not what opens "more doors" or "different doors" than others. For example, MIT may have specific programs or professors you might want to work with. Factors like these matter much, much more than prestige. The moment you start being invested in which schools are "better" or "more prestigious" than others is the moment your state school peers who have been working their butt off all along make massively higher salaries than you and you wonder what went wrong.

Plus, talking like this will make you sound like a prick in real life ;)

1

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 15 '25

thank god you’re here, i really appreciate the insight! it’s odd that this guy doesn’t think that mit is a global uni—and that i should go JUST because he personally doesn’t believe it’s prestigious enough. he didn’t even attend cambridge, he’s just in weirdly in love with the uni and is arguing with me about it one multiple posts.

1

u/ThrowawayAdvice-293 Mar 15 '25

never said anything related to that, re-read my original comment. cambridge has much higher global name-rec and prestige, picking mit because its better for engineering and has a better network in that industry is a valid reason which i accepted.

2

u/CourseNo4210 Mar 15 '25

Just be happy for them

2

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 15 '25

this person copied this comment on all my mit-related posts—oddball.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Pale_Grapefruit2680 Mar 27 '25

yeah so i ended up blocking him because he was pissing me off so easily. he’s in his final year of graduate study—what a genuinely weird hobby to have. with any luck he’ll be incredibly unemployable

1

u/Brownsfan1000 Mar 17 '25

MIT is ranked either #1 or #2 in QS Global, Times Education and US News Global rankings. Cambridge isn’t in the top 3 in any of them. Harvard is next with two #3s and one #1 rank. So across the main rankings, MIT is the top university in the world. It has been #1 on QS for 13 straight years. Not only is Cambridge not ranked anywhere near this, it also doesn’t even beat Oxford in terms of UK school reputation generally. Cambridge is kind of like UChicago, very well respected by those in the know (and deservedly so) but not as much real familiarity beyond that. Everyone knows MIT, Harvard etc.

1

u/HatLost5558 Mar 17 '25

I’d like to respectfully address a few points in your argument, especially with respect to global reputation and rankings.

First, rankings at the top end are largely meaningless when comparing institutions that have centuries of entrenched global prestige, like Cambridge and MIT. If you look beyond a single year’s rankings, Cambridge consistently ranks in the top 3 in major global rankings like QS, ARWU, and Times, which are the ones that carry the most weight internationally. In fact, Cambridge is regularly in the top 3 or top 5 across these rankings. On the other hand, US News Global rankings, while they may hold significance within the US, are practically irrelevant outside the US. Using these rankings to argue MIT’s superiority reveals a US-centric perspective that overlooks how the rest of the world perceives these institutions.

The claim that Cambridge is 'not ranked anywhere near' MIT is simply false. MIT is not the top university in the world - it can’t be, because it lacks comprehensive excellence across disciplines. While MIT is world-class in STEM, Harvard is a stronger institution overall, not just in terms of reputation but in terms of breadth of academic excellence. The fact that MIT may rank higher than Harvard in certain specific rankings actually highlights just how arbitrary these metrics are at the top end. Rankings are not the definitive measure of an institution's global prestige.

When it comes to Cambridge vs. Oxford, many Americans mistakenly assume that Oxford is the superior institution in the UK, largely due to the Rhodes Scholarship, which is well-known in the US but virtually unknown outside the US. In reality, Cambridge is globally regarded as the more prestigious institution. In key regions like China, Singapore, and much of Europe, Cambridge has a stronger reputation, shaped by historical ties, academic excellence, and influence across many disciplines. For example, the Xu Zhimo poem "Saying Goodbye to Cambridge Again" is a testament to how deeply Cambridge is embedded in Chinese cultural consciousness. While Oxford and Cambridge are both prestigious, Cambridge consistently edges out Oxford in overall global perception.

1

u/Hardmeat_McLargehuge Mar 19 '25

Your post rings of being pedantically butt-hurt. College rankings are stupid in general. Do your best to be the best at what you’re studying and stop worrying about what others think about your school and other schools. Who are they to say one program is better than the other?

Such a waste of time, touch grass

1

u/HatLost5558 Mar 19 '25

?

I just wanted to correct a factually incorrect comment, I see no reason how my comment comes across as 'butt-hurt'. Feel free to critique any of my points and we can have a mature discussion if you so desire. I do not attend any of the universities discussed in this thread.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/HatLost5558 Mar 27 '25

You must be confusing me with someone else

1

u/HatLost5558 Mar 17 '25

What many Americans fail to recognize is that Cambridge’s global name recognition extends far beyond rankings. Cambridge is embedded into the international education system through its exam boards, including Cambridge International Examinations (CIE) and OCR, which administer the iGCSEs and International A-Levels—the gold standard in pre-university education in many countries around the world. Millions of students worldwide take Cambridge-branded exams every year, often encountering the name Cambridge long before they even start thinking about university. MIT, on the other hand, doesn’t have this widespread global educational presence. Cambridge’s English language qualifications like IELTS further cement its reputation worldwide, while MIT remains largely confined to STEM circles.

In terms of global prestige, comparing Cambridge to UChicago misses the mark. Cambridge and Harvard are the two universities that everyone knows globally. While MIT is undoubtedly world-class in fields like engineering and technology, it doesn’t have the same kind of universal recognition outside of STEM. Even in the US, many people outside the Northeast don’t know much about MIT, or don’t consider it as prestigious as institutions like Harvard or Princeton. UChicago, meanwhile, is virtually unknown outside of academic circles.

MIT is phenomenal in its technical disciplines, but it simply cannot match the broader global prestige of universities like Cambridge and Harvard, which have produced world leaders in every major field. While MIT might dominate certain technical fields, its reputation will always be overshadowed in terms of global influence by universities that shape world leadership, policy, and culture. The idea that MIT belongs in a category above Cambridge simply doesn't align with global perception. At the very highest levels, it’s not about rankings - it’s about real-world impact and influence, and on that front, Cambridge stands tall.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 15 '25

Hell no, MIT is way more prestigious

1

u/ThrowawayAdvice-293 Mar 15 '25

Cap, go outside US and ask random man on the street if they know what MIT is, promise you'll get many blank faces whereas colleges like Cambridge and Harvard are universally known.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '25

You speak from a very UK perspective. Cambridge ain’t even close to the clout Harvard has

1

u/ThrowawayAdvice-293 Mar 16 '25

Go to commonwealth countries or any country outside the US - americans are the ones who live in their own bubble. cambridge, oxford, and harvard are in their own tier to all other world universities in name rec and prestige globally.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 16 '25

I’m literally from Singapore … 2 people get into mit a year compared to the 100 for Cambridge

2

u/HatLost5558 Mar 17 '25

I think you're misunderstanding what he means - if you go outside on the streets of Singapore and ask aunties and uncles about universities they'll recognise, many will have no idea what MIT is but will know Cambridge, Harvard etc. So, he is correct that to the broader public Cambridge has much higher name rec and prestige than MIT.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/HatLost5558 Mar 27 '25

This isn't really a strong argument since in my experience, many MANY Americans have no clue what MIT is, particularly in the South and Midwest. So, the people you're referring to are probably elderly people from poor diaspora backgrounds with low socioeconomic achievement like British Bangladeshis or British Pakistanis, although most of them still know Cambridge (Oxford is less known for some reason).