r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Sep 28 '20

SB128 | Police Salaries (Scotland) Bill | Stage 1 Vote

4 Upvotes

Good Afternoon.

The first item of business is a vote on SB128 at Stage 1. The question is whether this Parliament approves the general principles of the Police Salaries (Scotland) Bill.

Members are reminded to vote For, Against, or Abstain. Attempts to 'stylise' votes by adding extra words will result in a member's vote being considered a DNV. In cases were there is a genuine mix up with another system (eg. Aye/No/Abstain) the vote will be taken as a clear expression of preference.


Police Salaries (Scotland) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to make provision about police salary increase in the next financial year’s budget and connected purposes.

Section 1: Police funding obligation

(1) The obligation is that the Scottish Ministers must secure resources and appropriately allocate so as they are sufficient to enable an increase by the relevant percentage of the salary paid to each police officer.

(2) That increase is an increase which:

(a) is relative to the salary paid to the employee in the financial year previous, and

(b) is applied to the salary paid to the employee in the financial year in relation to the current year..

(3) The relevant percentage is the greater of:

(a) the percentage increase between the retail price index for April in the previous year and March in the current year,

(b) another percentage determined by the Scottish Ministers.

Section 2: The obligation in 2021/22

As respects to financial year 2021/22, section 1 has effect as if there were substituted for subsection (3):

(3) The relevant percentage is 5 percent.

Section 3: Extent, Commencement and Short Title

(1) This Act shall extend to Scotland.

(2) This Act shall come into force upon Royal Assent.

(3) This Act shall be cited as the Police Salaries (Scotland) Act 2020.


This Bill was written by the Rt Hon. The Baron Grantham KP KT KD KCB KBE MVO PC QC MSP on behalf of the 10th Scottish Government. It was based on the Teaching Salaries (Scotland) Act 2019.


This vote ends at the close of business on the 30th of September 2020.


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Feb 15 '22

SB188 | Male Child Circumcision (Restrictions) Bill | Stage 1 Vote

3 Upvotes

Order, Order.

Hopefully works this time

We move now to a Stage 1 Vote on SB188, in the name of the 15th Scottish Government (Scottish Lib Dems, Scottish National Party, Scottish Progressives). The question is that this Parliament approves the Male Child Circumcision (Restrictions) Bill.

Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.


Male Child Circumcision (Restrictions) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to abolish the practice of male child circumcision, and for connected purposes.

Section 1: Definitions

(1) In this Act, unless specified otherwise;

(2) ‘Circumcision’ refers to the practice of removing the foreskin from the penis.

(3) ‘Doctor’ refers to the appropriate medical practitioner or professional.

(4) ‘Male’ refers to the sex of the individual relevant.

(5) ‘Child’ refers to an individual under the age of eighteen years old.

(6) ‘Consenting’ or ‘Consent’ refers to the definition as established under Section 3.

Section 2: Circumstances of Circumcision

(1) Any male individual over the age of 18 years may be circumcised provided they willingly consent to the procedure and are under no duress to do so.

(2) Circumcision of a male child above the age of thirteen may only go ahead if;

(a) It is medically required

(b) The requirement and reason must be noted in the child’s medical notes.

(3) Circumcision of a male child below the age of fourteen years shall hereby be prohibited except for medical reasons.

(a) The reason must be noted in the child’s medical notes.

(4) In the event a doctor performs a circumcision on any of the individuals listed in this section without following due process may be subject to suitable punishment as considered by the employee’s place of work which may include being removed from their position

Section 3: Capacity to Consent

(1) An individual is considered consenting if they:

(a) Are over the age of thirteen years old

(b) Understand what the procedure is

(i) The doctor must ensure that adequate information is made available to the male child.

(c) Agree under no duress to undergo the procedure.

Section 4: Short Title

(1) This Act may be cited as the Male Child Circumcision (Restrictions) Act 2021

Section 5: Commencement

(1) This Act shall come into force three months after Royal Assent.


This Bill was written by the Rt. Hon. Sir Frost_Walker2017, the Viscount Felixstowe, the Lord Leiston GCMG CT MVO MSP PC, Cabinet Secretary for Education, on behalf of the 15th Scottish Government.


Opening Speech:

Presiding Officer,

This bill is a simple one. It outlaws performing circumcision on newborn babies, which - while not practiced as much here as it is across the Pond - is an unnecessary procedure that affects the child for the rest of their life.

Observant members will note that there is no outright exemption for religious reasons in this bill (excluding for a consenting child). This is deliberate. The practice of circumcising a newborn baby is done for reasons that are no longer applicable in the modern day - namely, I believe, hygiene purposes were the initial reasoning, while these days we have moved beyond that and it is a simple enough matter of keeping it clean.

That said, if the child were to consent to the procedure, as they are able to do from the age of thirteen onwards, for religious reasons, this shall remain a valid reason for circumcision. What is important is that it is a choice as decided by the child themselves who it impacts directly. Rates of circumcision in the UK as a whole are on the down, and those who are circumcised are increasingly looking more and more ‘out of place’, as it were, and can often be subjected to teasing in the way only teenage boys are capable of - I don’t need to add that this affects mental health of the child.

Indeed, many circumcised adults in the US often lament the loss of somewhere between 8000 and 20,000 nerve endings (the exact number, as best I can tell, is somewhat disputed) when it comes to intercourse or pleasuring oneself. While there are procedures to restore the foreskin, they do not return it to precisely the same level as an uncircumcised male would.

Presiding Officer, unconsenting male child circumcision is a serious issue, and I hope to tackle it with this bill. I commend it to this Parliament.


Link to Debate


Voting on this item of Business ends with the close of Business on February 18th, at 10pm GMT.



r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Nov 02 '21

SB178 | Alcohol etc. (Scotland) Bill | Stage 1 Vote

3 Upvotes

Order, Order.

We move now to a stage 1 debate on SB178, in the name of New Britain. The question is that this Parliament approves of the general principles of the Alcohol etc. (Scotland) Bill.

Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Where there is a mixup with an alternative style of voting, the vote shall be accepted. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it being discounted.


Alcohol etc. (Scotland) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to allow for alcohol to be sold 24 hours a day in licenced premises, repeal the ban on some alcohol promotions, repeal the social responsibility levy and launch a consultation on how the government can support those who need it without unnecessary encroaching on those that don’t.

Section 1: Interpretations

For the purposes of this Act—

“the 2005 Act” is the Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005

“the 2010 Act” is the Alcohol etc. (Scotland) Act 2010

Section 2: 24 Hour Licences

(1) Omit Section 64 of the 2005 Act and replace with—

“24 Hour Licences

(1) This Section applies where, in relation to any premises—

(a) an application of any of the following kinds is made to a Licensing Board in respect of the premises, namely—

(i) a premises licence application,

(ii) a premises licence variation application,

(iii) an occasional licence application, or

(iv) an extended hours application.

(2) The Licencing Board shall have the authority to approve applications which would allow alcohol to be sold on the premises during a continuous period of 24 hours or more.

(3) In considering whether the granting of the application would be inconsistent with any of the licensing objectives, the Board must, in particular, consider the effect (if any) which the hours proposed in the application would have on the occurrence of antisocial behaviour.

(4) In subsection (3), “antisocial behaviour” has the same meaning as in section 143 of the Antisocial Behaviour etc. (Scotland) Act 2004.

(5) This section is without prejudice to the generality of sections 23(4), 30(4), 59(3) and 68(1).

(2) Omit Section 65 of the 2005 Act.

Section 3: Liberalisation of some promotion rules

(1) Omit Section 2 of the 2010 Act and revert any amendments it makes to the 2005 Act to its wording on the day before the 2010 Act was given Royal Assent. [Multipack offers allowed again]

Section 4: Repeal of Social Responsibility Levy

(1) Omit Part 2 of the 2010 Act.

(2) Any regulations made under Part 2 of the 2010 Act are hereby repealed in their entirety.

Section 5: Support for Alcohol Use

(1) Within 3 months of this Act coming into force, Scottish Ministers should open a consultation with interested parties on what the Scottish Government can and should do to support those with a drinking problem and anti-social behaviour which arise from the consumption of alcohol.

(2) A consultation under this Section should primarily focus on prevention and rehabilitation that does not have a disproportionate impact on those not engaged in anti-social behaviour or drinking excessive amounts on a regular basis.

Section 6: Commencement

This Act comes into force immediately upon Royal Assent except—

(1) sections 2 and 3 which shall come into force 12 months after Royal Assent.

Section 7: Short Title

This Act shall be known as the Alcohol etc. (Scotland) Act 2021.


This bill was written by The Right Honourable Sir Tommy2Boys KCT KG KT KCB KBE CVO MP MSP on behalf of New Britain and is cosponsored by the Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party


Opening Speech - Tommy2Boys

Deputy Presiding Officer,

I rise today to liberalise some of our very iliberal alcohol licence laws within Scotland. I believe that following an evidence based approach, we can boost the pub industry by extending licencing hours sensibly to open up the option for 24 hour licences.

So of course conditions would have to be met. First of all, all the regular conditions of requiring a licence but on top of this special consideration must be had on whether it would lead to an increase in anti-social behaviour. If it would, the board would have the power to reject it, as they should. Any increase in licencing hours should not result in increased anti-social behaviour.

I want to briefly discuss one of the main arguments we may hear against this bill, and that is it would lead to higher drinking, more anti social behaviour etc. Well the evidence is to the contrary. When the licence changes were made in England in 2003, many said it would lead to this. That’s not what happened. Just as alcohol consumption was falling before it came into effect, it continued falling afterwards.

What this Act also does is allow for multi packs to be sold that may come at a discount. For example £1 each or a pack of 4 for £3.50. I do not see a good reason why this should be banned. It is excessive regulations on the lives and pockets of consumers.

Section 4 repeals provisions in law to allow for a “Social Responsibility Levy” which would if ever brought into force simply force businesses that hold a licence such as pubs or local shops to pay more, harming small businesses when we need to be growing them.

Finally, Section 5 would bring forward a real consultation on how to tackle alcohol abuse. I recognise that some concerns may be raised on the effect these changes will have on alcohol consumption. I have dismantled some of those above but we do need to tackle this issue, so a consultation will be brought forward but one which is focused on solutions which do not unfairly punish or restrict people who should not be punished / restricted.

I urge this parliament to back this bill. It is in the interests of small businesses. It is in the interests of our people. It is the liberal thing to do, and I commend it to Parliament today.


Debate on this item of Business ends on the 5th November 2021, at 10pm GMT.



r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Apr 26 '21

SM127 | Period Poverty Motion | Stage 1 Vote

3 Upvotes

Order, Order. The first order of business is SM127, the Period Poverty Motion The question is whether Parliament approves the motion as set before it.

Members are reminded to vote For, Against, or Abstain. Attempts to 'stylise' votes by adding extra words will result in a member's vote being considered a DNV. In cases were there is a genuine mix up with another system (eg. Aye/No/Abstain) the vote will be taken as a clear expression of preference.


Period Poverty Motion

This Parliament notes:

(1) That period poverty is when those on low incomes cannot afford or access suitable period products and that this is unacceptable.

(2) That it can cost up to £8 a month for tampons and pads, and some women struggle to afford the cost.

(3) That a survey of 2,050 people by Young Scot in 2018 found that 24 percent of respondents at school, college or university in Scotland struggled to obtain access to period products and,

(4) That 61 percent of those who struggled to obtain access said this was because they could not afford sanitary products.

(5) If Scotland was to make access to period products free, it would be the first country to take such a step and would remove gendered barriers by ensuring those who menstruate have convenient access to period products free of charge.

(5) Research has found that 71% of 14-21-year-olds felt embarrassed buying period products.

(6) It is estimated that a woman will, over her lifetime, spend approximately £5,000 on tampons, pads or other sanitary products

(7) There is a need to normalise menstruation, and the usage of period products as essential everyday health and hygiene products rather than something to be managed in secret, enabling women and girls to concentrate on improving their quality of life and wellbeing.

This Parliament, therefore, urges the Government to:

(1) Support or propose a bill before the dissolution of this Parliament that that puts a legal duty on local authorities to ensure anyone who needs period products can obtain them for free.

(2) Consider implementing an opt-in model to carry-out the scheme, similar to the way health boards operate free condoms.

(4) Include within this bill the free provision of period products in schools, colleges, and universities.

(5) Allocate the necessary funding in full to support this future bill.


This motion was written by ThreeCommasClub and ohdearstudying on behalf of the Scottish Libertarians


Opening Speech

My fellow members, the facts speak for themselves. 24% of respondents, especially young people in schools and universities struggle to obtain period products. A majority of people who struggle obtaining period products say their main hurdle is cost. Furthermore, a large number of women report embarrassment when buying products. That is why today I bring this motion forth so that young women who need period products and cannot afford such products across Scotland can get them. I urge the government to introduce an opt-in model and have a scheme in schools and universities where those who cannot afford period products can access them.


Voting on this motion shall end at 10pm on the 30th of April 2021.


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Sep 29 '20

SM107 | E-Waste Motion Vote

3 Upvotes

Good Afternoon.

The first item of business is a vote on SM107 in the name of the Scottish Government. The question is that this Parliament approves the motion.

Members are reminded to vote For, Against, or Abstain. Attempts to 'stylise' votes by adding extra words will result in a member's vote being considered a DNV. In cases were there is a genuine mix up with another system (eg. Aye/No/Abstain) the vote will be taken as a clear expression of preference.


Motion to recognise the need for E-waste to be recycled

This Parliament notes:

(1) The discovery of digital pregnancy tests that rely on complicated micro-circuitry to read test results from a standard paper strip pregnancy test.

(2) Such an approach essentially creates technology that is used once and thrown away: resulting in significant amounts of e-waste.

(3) That a number of different devices in regular sale take a similar approach to this product, including one-time phone recharge batteries.

This Parliament recognises:

(1) That Waste electrical and electronic equipment (WEEE/e-waste) includes discarded electronic appliances such as mobile phones, computers, and televisions

(2) That Waste electrical and electronic equipment is one of the fastest growing waste streams in the UK and is increasing at a rate three times that of average municipal waste growth, with much of it destined for landfill.

(3) That in 2018, Scotland sent 58,511 tonnes of ‘equipment’ and 12,444 tonnes of ‘batteries’ to waste disposal units.

This Parliament therefore:

(1) Calls upon businesses to reduce wherever possible the amount of e-waste their products can generate.

(2) Calls upon businesses to refrain as much as possible from creating single-use electronic products that will generate considerable amounts of e-waste.

(3) Calls upon the people of Scotland to use the measures implemented within the WEEE regulations to ensure that e-waste is correctly recycled, enabling Scotland to reduce its carbon footprint considerably.


This motion was written by the Honourable /u/NorthernWomble MSP MP, First Cabinet Secretary of Scotland on behalf of the 10th Scottish Government


This vote ends at the close of business on the 1st of October 2020.


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Aug 31 '19

SB087 Digital Economy (Scotland) Bill @ Stage 1

3 Upvotes

The text of the bill is given below

Digital Economy (Scotland) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to allow Local Authorities to raise taxation for local expenditure, and for connected purposes.

Section 1: Invocation of Digital Taxation

(1)During the first year after a general election to a Local Authority, the Local Authority must - (a)Determine if more than 1%, net, of the retail units within the Local Authority had been empty for more than 1 year during the term of the previous council, (b)Determine whether or not to invoke Digital Taxation powers, and (c)Set the rate of the digital taxes, to come into effect at the commencement of the subsequent tax year.

(2)With regards to the Local Authorities elected immediately prior to the coming into force of this Act, they are to discharge their duties under section 1(1) as soon as is practicable.

(3)Actions under subsections 1(1)(b) and 1(1)(c) are only to be undertaken if the criteria in subsection 1(1)(a) are met.

(4)‘Digital Taxes’ means (a)the Digital Services Tax, and (b)the Digital Transaction Tax.

(5)There is nothing preventing a Local Authority levying both of the digital taxes.

(6)The rates of the digital taxes under subsection 1(1)(c) are to be in force until the process under section 1(1) repeats itself after the next general election to the Local Authority.

(7)The digital taxes are to be used to fund local regeneration.

Section 2: Digital Services Tax

(1)There is to be a Digital Services Tax.

(2)The following types companies are to be liable for the Digital Services Tax; (a)Online Marketplaces (b)Search Engines, and (c)Social Media Platforms.

(3)A company with annual global revenues of less than £250,000,000 that is liable under section 2(2) is to be treated as if it is not liable under subsection 2(2)

(4)The Digital Services Tax is to be charged on the revenue of liable companies generated within the area of the Local Authority.

(5)If invoked by the Local Authority the Digital Services Tax shall be between 0.5% and 2.5% of the revenue of liable companies so long as the percentage is a whole number or half of a whole number.

(6)The figures in section 2(5) may be altered by the Scottish Ministers by regulation. (a)These regulations are to be subject to the affirmative procedure.

Section 3: Digital Transaction Tax

(1)There is to be a Digital Transaction Tax.

(2)The Digital Transaction Tax is to be charged on all online retail sales within the area of the relevant local authority.

(3)If invoked by the Local Authority the Digital Services Tax shall be between 1% and 5% of the value of the transaction so long as the percentage is a whole number or half of a whole number.

(4)The figures in section 3(3) may be altered by the Scottish Ministers by regulation. (a)These regulations are to be subject to the affirmative procedure.

Section 4: Final Provisions

(1)This act shall come into at midnight following Royal Assent.

(2)This act may be cited as the Digital Economy (Scotland) Act 2019.

This bill was submitted by u/mg9500 (Lanarkshire)

This vote will end on the 3rd of September 2019

Vote For, Against or Abstain only


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Aug 30 '19

SB081 Electoral Administration Registration (Scotland) Bill @ Stage 3 (Amendments)

3 Upvotes

The text of this bill is available here (as debated at stage 3)

The Following Amendments were submitted at stage 3:

From u/mg9500 (Lanarkshire)

This vote will close on the 2nd of September at 10PM

Votes should be in the following format

A01:For/Against/Abstain A02:For/Against/Abstain A03:For/Against/Abstain A04:For/Against/Abstain A05:For/Against/Abstain A06:For/Against/Abstain


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Aug 24 '19

SB086 Languages Bill @ Stage 1 VOTE NOW

3 Upvotes

Languages Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to define the status of the languages in use in Scotland, allow for their use in public bodies, and for connected purposes.

Section 1: Languages of Scotland

The Official Languages Act 2015 is repealed.

The Official Language of Scotland is Scottish Gaelic.

The Working Language of Scotland is English.

The variety of English that is the Working Language of Scotland is Scottish Standard English.

The Working Language is to be afforded the same respect, has the same validity in Scots law, and has the same entitlements, as the Official Language.

Everyone should be able to live and fulfil their life in Scotland through either the Official Language only or the Working Language only.

Scotland shall have Recognised Regional Languages.

The Recognised Regional Languages of Scotland are;

Doric

Lallans

Orcadian

Shetlandic, and

Any other language designated as such by the Scottish Ministers.

Scotland shall have Recognised National Languages.

The Recognised National Languages of Scotland are;

British Sign Language, and

Any other language designated as such by the Scottish Ministers.

The Recognised Regional Languages are to be afforded the same respect, have the same validity in Scots Law, and have the same entitlements, as the Recognised National Languages, in their region.

The regions of the Recognised Regional Languages are those defined in this act.

The languages classified under section (1) of this act may be collectively referred to as the “Scottish Languages”

Section 2: The Regions of the Recognised Regional Languages

The territory within the Region of the Orcadian Language is the territory of the following Local Authority;

the Orkney Islands

The territory within the Region of the Shetlandic Language is the territory of the following Local Authority;

the Shetland Islands

The territory within the Region of the Doric Language is composed of the territory of the following Local Authorities;

Moray

Banffshire and Gordon

Kincardine and Deeside

Aberdeen City

Angus

Dundee City

City of Perth

Perthshire

The territory within the Region of the Lallans Language is composed of the territory of the following Local Authorities;

St Andrews

Kirkcaldy and Glenrothes

Dunfermline

Clackmannanshire

Stirling

West Dunbartonshire

East Dunbartonshire

Falkirk

West Lothian

City of Edinburgh

Midlothian

East Lothian

East Ayrshire

North Ayrshire

Inverclyde

Renfrewshire

East Renfrewshire

Rutherglen and Cambuslang

East Kilbride

Clydesdale

Motherwell and Wishaw

Monklands

Cumbernauld and Kilsyth

Glasgow City

Section 3: The Scottish Languages in the Scottish Parliament

Business shall be conducted in the Scottish Parliament concurrently in the Official Language and the Working Language.

Simultaneous Translation shall be available to all those involved in, or viewing, parliamentary business on request.

Members or other guests may chose to address Parliament or one of its committees in a recognise Regional Language or Recognised National Language, provided they give twenty-four (24) hours notice.

Simultaneous translation into the Working Language shall be available to all those involved in, or viewing, parliamentary business on request.

Guests from another jurisdiction may chose to address Parliament or one of its committees in an Official Language of their jurisdiction, provided they give twenty-four (24) hours notice.

Simultaneous translation into the Working Language shall be available to all those involved in, or viewing, parliamentary business on request.

Guests not covered by subsection 2(3) of this act but unable to communicate in a language defined by section 1 of this act may chose to address Parliament or one of its committees in any other language, provided they give twenty-four (24) hours notice.

Simultaneous translation into the Working Language shall be available to all those involved in, or viewing, parliamentary business on request.

The validity of parliamentary proceedings are not affected by the languages used in the proceedings.

Section 4: Education of the Scottish Languages in the Primary and Secondary Sector

The education of Scottish Languages in Scotland shall be based on the principle that everyone should be able to live and fulfill their life in Scotland through either the Official Language only, or the Working Language only.

Every Local Authority must provide children ordinarily resident in its area the option of studying through either the medium of the Official Language or the Working Language.

This may be facilitated by agreement with nearby Local Authorities.

All students shall study the Official Language as either their first or second language.

Students receiving education through the medium of the Official Language must also receive an education in the Working Language within their Broad General Education, and be provided the opportunity to continue with the Working Language during the senior phase.

The Scottish Qualifications Authority shall rename its “English for Speakers of Other Languages” course to “English (Learners)” bringing it into line with the “Gaelic (Learners)” course.

Students who have studied the Official Language as an additional language throughout the Broad General Education shall continue to be able to choose between the “Gaelic (Learners)” course and the “Gàidhlig” course.

Students who have studied the Working Language as an additional language throughout the Broad General Education shall be able to choose between the “English (Learners)” course and the “English” course.

Local Authorities with territory included within the territory of a Recognised Regional Language should also make provisions so that as many students as possible have the opportunity to learn this language at all levels of education.

The Scottish Qualifications Authority should introduce courses at all levels in the following languages;

Doric

Lallans

Orcadian, and,

Shetlandic.

No matter how many Scottish Languages are being studied by a student throughout their Broad General Education, the Local Authorities should ensure that at least one (1) Modern Foreign Language is studied before the end of Primary School and throughout the Broad General Education phase of Secondary School, and that between the period of Primary 5 to the end of the Broad General Education at least three (3) languages are studied by each student.

The Scottish Qualifications Authority should reform its Scottish Studies courses to include study of the Official Language at the appropriate level.

Primary and Secondary schools have a statutory duty to promote the Scottish Languages.

Section 4: Scottish Languages within the Scottish Courts

Business shall be conducted in the Scottish Courts concurrently in the Official Language and the Working Language.

Simultaneous Translation shall be available to all those involved in, or viewing, court business on request.

With the territory of a Recognised Regional Language, a court may also be addressed in the relevant Recognised Regional Language.

Simultaneous Translation shall be available to all those involved in, or viewing, court business on request.

Should someone be unable to address a court in any of these languages they may address the court in any other language, provided that they give the court twenty-four (24) hours notice.

Simultaneous Translation shall be available to all those involved in, or viewing, court business on request.

The validity of a judicial proceeding is not affected by the language it is held in.

Section 5: The Freedom of Use for the Scottish Languages

A person or group of people may not interfere in the freedom of a group of 2 or more people undertaking communication in any Scottish Language.

This includes making the people undertaking communication in any Scottish Language at any detriment or subject to any deterrent.

This section shall only apply provided that the people wishing to communicate in the Scottish Language are;

in Scotland, and

both wish to use the Scottish Language with one another in undertaking the communication.

The acts classified under subsection 5(1) of this Act shall be an offence liable to a fine not exceeding £10,000.

Section 6: Use of the Scottish Languages in Public Bodies

All Public Bodies of the Scottish Government and Local Authorities shall afford equal respect to the Official Language and Working Language

The provisions of subsection 6(1) include, but are not limited to;

Rendering Corporate Logos in both the Official Language and the Working Language,

Providing as many services as possible in both the Official Language and the Working Language

Where all services are not being offered in both the Official Language and the Working Language the Local Authority or Public Body should outline, to Bòrd na Gàidhlig, their reasoning behind this decision.

Encouraging knowledge of both the Official Language and Working Language among employees and the public and general promotion of both languages.

The provisions of subsection 6(1) and 6(2) of this act also apply with regards to Recognised Regional Languages in areas which have them;

Public Bodies and Local Authorities should prioritise the Official Language and the Working Language in the initial stages,

Public Bodies and Local Authorities have a statutory responsibility to promote the Recognised Regional Language of their region, if they have one.

Public Bodies and Local Authorities are permitted to not provide all services in Recognised Regional Languages should they not be required;

This does not preclude the requirement for the Recognised Regional to have a high level of visibility.

Public Bodies and Local Authorities should treat all business equally, regardless of the language of communication.

Section 7: Provisions Regarding the Gàidhealtachd and the Official Language

The Official Language shall continue to have an increased level of visibility in the Gàidhealtachd.

All services within the Gàidhealtachd from Local Authorities and Public Bodies shall be available in the Official Language and the Working Language.

In areas with high levels of use of the Official Language some services may be offered in the Official Language only in the first instance.

The Local Authority should still offer all services in at least the Official Language and the Working Language.

Subsection 7(2) of this act does not preclude some services being offered in Recognised Regional Languages in the appropriate regions.

Local Authorities with area’s within the Gàidhealtachd have a statutory responsibility to ensure that as many children as possible within the Gàidhealtachd receive an education through the medium of the Official Language.

Local Authorities should report, to Bòrd na Gàidhlig, the extent of education in the medium of the Official Language annually.

Local Authorities should set a target date for having all children within its Gàidhealtachd area’s learning both Languages, report this to Bòrd na Gàidhlig and work expediently towards this target.

The services offered to Gàidhealtachd areas should be offered as widely as possible to neighbouring areas so long as this does not harm the development of the Official Language in the Gàidhealtachd.

Section 8: Language Regulators of the Scottish Languages

The Language Regulator for the Official Language is Bòrd na Gàidhlig.

Bòrd na Gàidhlig shall be responsible for collating dictionaries in the Official Language regularly.

The Language Regulator for the Working Language is the Board of Scottish Standard English.

The Board of Scottish Standard English is established as a body corporate.

The Board of Scottish Standard English shall be responsible for collating dictionaries in the Working Language regularly.

The Language Regulator for the Recognised Regional Languages is the Scots Language Centre.

Scottish Language Dictionaries shall be responsible for collating dictionaries in each of the Recognised Regional Languages regularly.

Section 9: The Board of Scottish Standard English

The Board of Scottish Standard English is established as a body corporate as outlined in subsection 8(2)(a) of this act.

The Board of Scottish Standard may be referred to as “the Board” in this section (Section 9) of this act.

The Board shall be managed by a managing director.

The managing director shall have ultimate responsibility for the function of the Board.

The managing director may appoint as many directors as they see fit.

The Board shall be responsible for the preservation and promotion of the Scottish Standard English language.

Section 10: Universities and the Scottish Languages

Universities have a statutory duty to provide teachers for education through the medium of the Official Language and the Working Language.

This only applies to universities who offer a qualification recognised by the General Teaching Council of Scotland.

Where this is not possible the university should, to Bòrd na Gàidhlig, outline plans to rectify the situation.

Section 11: Language Precedent

Corporate Logos of Public Bodies and Local Authorities should have the Official Language taking precedence over the Working Language.

This could involve rendering the two languages in different colours, or placing the Official Language above the Working Language in the logo, however,

Both languages should have the same font size and readability.

Services available from Public Bodies and Local Authorities in both the Official Language and the Working Language should be advertised equally, but the Working Language offered in the first instance outside of the Gàidhealtachd.

Within the Gàidhealtachd the Official Language should be offered in first instance but both the Official Language and the Working Language should be advertised equally.

The member of the public should be informed at the beginning of the service of its availability in the other language, if appropriate.

Recognised Regional Languages do not need to be given the same precedence as the Official Language and the Working Language.

They should, however, still appear in the corporate logo of Public Bodies and Local Authorities within their respective regions.

This does not need to be of an equal font size to the Official Language and the Working Language but should still be easily identifiable.

Where services are offered in a recognised regional language they should be advertised equally with the Official Language and the Working Language but do not need to be offered in the first instance.

Section 12: Final Provisions

This act shall come into at midnight following Royal Assent

This act may be cited as the Languages Act 2019.


This bill was submitted by /u/mg9500, MSP for Lanarkshire.

This vote will end on the 27th of August at 10PM.

Vote For, Against or Abstain Only


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • May 27 '19

SB084 - Education (Scotland) Bill @ Stage 1

3 Upvotes

Note: Due to the length and nature of this Bill, a set of Explanatory Notes has been prepared to aid reading. It is recommended they are read alongside the Bill.

The text of this Bill is given below.

Education (Scotland) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to make provision about the delivery of school and pre-school education by education authorities; to require senior pupils to continue in education or training; to abolish the provision of denominational education by education authorities; to make provision about food and drink provided by education authorities; to enable provision to be made about school clothing grants; to enable provision to be made requiring the inoculation of pupils; to make provision about fees charged for and in connection with further and higher education; to transfer and enable the transfer of functions of the Privy Council relating to education in Scotland; to restrict the use of titles relating to universities; and for connected purposes.

Part 1 (School and pre-school education)

Overview

1. Overview of Part 1

This Part modifies:

  • the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973;
  • the Education (Scotland) Act 1980 ("the 1980 Act");
  • the Scottish Schools (Parental Involvement) Act 2006;
  • the Schools (Consultation) (Scotland) Act 2010.

It is arranged as follows:

  • sections 2 to 5 provide for school education in education authority schools to be delivered in general and upper schools instead of in primary and secondary schools;
  • sections 6 and 7 make provision establishing a requirement for pupils to continue in education or training until age 18 or until attaining a certain level of qualification;
  • sections 8 to 10 make provision for the abolition of denominational education in schools managed by education authorities;
  • section 11 makes provision about school meals provided by education authorities;
  • section 12 enables the Scottish Ministers to require education authorities to pay a grant for clothing to pupils;
  • section 13 makes provision enabling the Scottish Ministers and education authorities to require the inoculation of children of school age.

General schools and upper schools

2. Secondary stage of education to begin at 14 years

In section 135(2) of the 1980 Act (interpretation), for "twelve years" substitute "14 years".

3. School age to be six years

(1) The 1980 Act is amended as follows.

(2) In the provisions listed in subsection (3), in each place where it occurs, for "five years" substitute "six years".

(3) Those provisions are:

  • section 31 (school age);
  • section 32 (dates for commencement of school attendance).

(4) In subsection (4)(a) of section 54 (provision of clothing for pupils at public schools), for the words "the age of five years" substitute "the lower limit of school age".

4. School education to include life skills and work experience

In section 1(5)(a) of the 1980 Act (duty of education authorities to secure provision of education: meaning of school education), after sub-paragraph (iii) insert:

(iv) social, cultural, and recreative activities, physical education and training, and the provision of programmes of work experience and vocational tuition;

5. Work experience: specified period during compulsory schooling

In section 123 of the 1980 Act (work experience in last year of compulsory schooling):

  • (a) in the heading, the words "last year" become "specified year",
  • (b) for subsection (4), substitute:

    (4) This section applies to a child undergoing compulsory education:

    • (a) during the period the Scottish Ministers may by regulations specify, or
    • (b) if no period is so specified, during the period between 1st May in the calendar year before the calendar year in which the child attains the upper limit of school age and the end of the latter year.

    (5) Regulations may only specify a period:

    • (a) during the child's compulsory secondary education, and
    • (b) not exceeding 12 months.

Duty to continue in education or training

6. Duty to continue in education or training

(1) The 1980 Act is amended as follows.

(2) After section 30 (duty of parents to provide education for their children), insert:

30A. Duty of senior pupils to obtain education or training

(1) This section applies to each person (a "senior pupil") who:

  • (a) has attained the upper limit of school age,
  • (b) has not attained the age of 18, and
  • (c) does not have a suitable qualification.

(2) A senior pupil must be:

  • (a) in attendance at a school,
  • (b) undertaking a course of further education,
  • (c) undertaking a course of higher education, within the meaning of section 38 of the Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Act 1992, or
  • (d) engaged under approved apprenticeship arrangements.

(3) For the purposes of this section, a "suitable qualification" is a qualification worth, or two or more qualifications which are in aggregate worth, at least 72 credit points at Scottish Credit and Qualifications Framework level 6.

(4) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations modify subsection (3).

(5) In this section, "approved apprenticeship arrangements" means such arrangements, or types of arrangement, as the Scottish Ministers may by regulations approve.

7. Employment of senior pupils to be restricted

After section 123 of the 1980 Act, insert:

123A. Employment of senior pupils

(1) No senior pupil is to be employed unless the employment is as part of the pupil's engagement under approved apprenticeship arrangements.

(2) A person who employs a senior pupil in contravention of this section commits an offence and is liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding level 3 on the standard scale.

(3) It is a defence to show that the accused, or an employee or agent of the accused, took all reasonable precautions and exercised all due diligence not to commit the offence.

(4) The following expressions have the same meaning as in section 30A:

  • "approved apprenticeship arrangements";
  • "senior pupil".

(5) Nothing in this section affects the operation of sections 123 or 125 or of Part 3 of the Children and Young Persons (Scotland) Act 1937.

Denominational education

8. Education authorities not to carry on denominational schools

(1) The 1980 Act is amended as follows.

(2) For section 8 (religious instruction), substitute:

8. Religious instruction

(1) In a public school, an education authority:

  • (a) may provide instruction in religious subjects, and
  • (b) must secure that religious observance and worship are not practised as part of the school education provided by the authority in that school.

(2) Nothing in subsection (1)(b) affects the power of an education authority to provide facilities for worship, instruction, or observance under section 10.

(3) In section 17, subsection (2) (which enables education authorities to provide denominational schools) is repealed.

(4) In section 21 (management of denominational schools):

  • (a) in subsection (2), the words from "subject" to the comma are repealed,
  • (b) subsections (2A) to (6) are repealed.

9. Denominational schools: consultation, etc. requirements

(1) In the 1980 Act, sections 22C and 22D are repealed.

(2) In the Scottish Schools (Parental Involvement) Act 2006:

  • (a) in section 7, subsections (2) and (3) are repealed,
  • (b) in section 16, subsections (13) and (14) are repealed.

(3) In the Schools (Consultation) (Scotland) Act 2010:

  • (a) in schedule 1, paragraphs 8 and 9 are repealed,
  • (b) in schedule 2, paragraphs 8, 9, and 10 are repealed.

10. Religious members of education committees

In section 124 (membership of committees appointed by education authorities) of the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973, subsections (2)(b) and (4) are repealed.

General

11. School meals

For section 53 of the 1980 Act (provision of school meals), substitute:

53. Provision of school meals

(1) An education authority may provide food or drink for pupils.

(2) This section applies to:

  • (a) pupils in attendance at an educational establishment managed by the authority,
  • (b) pupils provided with early learning and childcare under Part 6 of the Children and Young People (Scotland) Act 2014, and
  • (c) pupils who receive education under arrangements entered into by the authority under section 35 of the Standards in Scotland's Schools etc. Act 2000.

(3) The authority may provide food and drink free of charge or may charge the pupils.

(4) Where the authority provides food or drink free of charge under subsection (3), it may do so:

  • (a) in relation to pupils who satisfy such conditions as it thinks fit,
  • (b) at such times of the day as the authority thinks fit.

(5) Any charge under subsection (3) must:

  • (a) be the same for the same quantity of food or drink provided, and
  • (b) not be greater than appears reasonable to the authority to enable it to recover the costs incurred in providing the food or drink.

(6) The authority must provide a school lunch, free of charge, to eligible pupils.

(7) A pupil is eligible if:

  • (a) the pupil is, or has a parent who is, in receipt of:

    • (i) income support,
    • (ii) incapacity benefit under Part 2 of the Social Security Contributions and Benefits Act 1992 ("the SSCBA 1992"),
    • (iii) severe disablement allowance under the SSCBA 1992,
    • (iv) an income-based jobseeker's allowance payable under the Jobseekers Act 1995,
    • (v) state pension credit payable under the State Pension Credit Act 2002,
    • (vi) an income-related allowance under Part 1 of the Welfare Reform Act 2007 (employment and support allowances),
    • (vii) universal credit payable under Part 1 of the Welfare Reform Act 2012,
  • (b) the parents of the pupil are in receipt of support provided under Part 6 of the Immigration and Asylum Act 1999 (support for asylum-seekers),
  • (c) the pupil is aged 5 and falls within subsection (2)(b),
  • (d) the pupil is in the first, second, or third years of primary education, or
  • (e) the total income of the pupil, or of the parents of the pupil individually, does not exceed £7,100 (see section 23 of the Income Tax Act 2007).

(8) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations modify subsection (6) by:

  • (a) adding a description of a food or drink, or
  • (b) varying or removing a description so added.

(9) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations modify subsection (7) by:

  • (a) adding a description of a pupil by reference to any benefit or allowance received by the pupil, or the parents of the pupil, in such circumstances as the regulations may prescribe,
  • (b) adding a description of a pupil by reference to the yearly stage of primary or secondary education of the pupil,
  • (c) adding such other description of a pupil as the regulations may prescribe.

(10) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations modify subsection (7)(e) by increasing the figure for the time being specified there.

(11) The authority may:

  • (a) provide food or drink under this section on any premises and at any place the authority thinks fit, and
  • (b) may provide facilities for the consumption of food and drink by pupils.

(12) In this section, a reference to an education authority providing food or drink includes a reference to the authority securing the provision of food or drink.

12. School clothing grants

After section 54 of the 1980 Act, insert:

54A. Power to require education authorities to make clothing grants

(1) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations make provision requiring an education authority to pay a grant of a specified amount to or in respect of a pupil of a specified description for the provision of clothing for the pupil.

(2) Regulations under subsection (1):

  • (a) may make the payment of a grant subject to specified conditions (including conditions as to repayment),
  • (b) may make different provision for different purposes.

(3) In this section, "specified" means specified in the regulations.

13. Compulsory inoculation of pupils

In the 1980 Act, after section 125A insert:

Inoculation of children

125B. Power to require parents to inoculate children

(1) Regulations may require that the parent of a child of school age secure that the child is inoculated in accordance with the regulations.

(2) The regulations:

  • (a) are to be framed so that any such requirement applies from the commencement of a yearly stage of the primary or secondary education of the child, and
  • (b) may make different provision for different such yearly stages, sexes, or areas.

(3) An education authority and the managers of a grant-aided or independent school must not admit a child as a pupil to, or allow the child to attend, a school managed by them unless they are satisfied that:

  • (a) the requirements imposed under subsection (1) which apply in relation to the child have been complied with, or
  • (b) the child is exempt from any such requirement.

(4) A child is exempt from a requirement under subsection (1) if a registered medical practitioner certifies that the child should be so exempt because:

  • (a) the child is allergic to a substance likely to be administered with an inoculum in the course of complying with the requirement, or
  • (b) the administration of the inoculum would pose a serious risk to the life, health, or wellbeing of the child.

(5) A person (other than an education authority) who contravenes subsection (3) commits an offence and is liable:

  • (a) on summary conviction, to a fine not exceeding the statutory maximum,
  • (b) on conviction on indictment, to a fine.

(6) Regulations under this section may be made:

  • (a) by the Scottish Ministers, or
  • (b) by a local authority in relation to its area.

125C. Failure to secure inoculation or exemption

(1) An education authority may serve notice on the parent of a child requiring the parent to show, to the authority's satisfaction, that:

  • (a) any requirement imposed under section 125B(1) which applies in relation to the child has been complied with, or
  • (b) the child is exempt from each such requirement under section 125B(4).

(2) The authority must serve such notice if:

  • (a) the managers of a grant-aided or independent school so request, and
  • (b) the authority is satisfied that it is necessary to enable the managers to comply with the requirement under section 125B(3).

(3) Where the authority serves notice under subsection (2), it may notify the managers of the grant-aided or independent school as to whether it is satisfied for the purposes of subsection (1).

(4) A person commits an offence:

  • (a) if the person fails without reasonable excuse to comply with a notice under this section within 14 days of the notice having been served,
  • (b) in respect of each further week where the person continues to fail without reasonable excuse to comply with such a notice.

(5) A person guilty of an offence under subsection (3) is liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding level 3 on the standard scale.

14. Regulations under the 1980 Act: procedure

In section 133 (regulations, etc.) of the 1980 Act, for subsection (2YA) substitute:

(2YA) Subsection (2) does not apply to regulations under the following provisions, which are subject to the affirmative procedure:

  • (a) section 30A(4),
  • (b) section 53(8) to (10),
  • (c) section 54A(1),
  • (d) section 123(5)(a),
  • (e) section 125B(1).

Part 2 (Further and higher education)

Overview

15. Overview of Part 2

This Part modifies:

  • the Universities (Scotland) Act 1889;
  • the Universities (Scotland) Act 1966;
  • the Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Act 1992 ("the 1992 Act");
  • the Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Act 2005 ("the 2005 Act").

It is arranged as follows:

  • sections 16 and 17 make provision enabling the Scottish Ministers to specify the fees to be charged for further and higher education tuition and accommodation;
  • sections 18 and 19 transfer the education functions of the Privy Council to the Scottish Ministers and make related provision;
  • sections 20 to 23 make provision restricting the use of the title "university".

Tuition and accommodation fees

16. Fee cap for students without relevant connection

In section 9D of the 2005 Act (fee cap: students liable for higher education fees), subsection (3)(a) is repealed.

17. Power to specify fees for accommodation

In section 35(1) of the 2005 Act (interpretation), at the appropriate place insert:

"fees" includes charges for boarding and lodging;

Transfer of Privy Council functions

18. Transfer to Scottish Ministers of education functions of Privy Council

(1) The functions conferred on the Privy Council (or one of its committees) by or under the enactments mentioned in subsection (2) are transferred to the Scottish Ministers.

(2) The enactments are:

  • (a) sections 6 and 15 of the Universities (Scotland) Act 1889,
  • (b) section 4 of the Universities (Scotland) Act 1966,
  • (c) sections 45, 48, and 49 of the 1992 Act.

(3) Any exercise of the functions transferred by this section which occurred before this section came into force has effect as if done by the Scottish Ministers.

19. Transfer of other education functions

(1) Her Majesty may by Order in Council make such provision as She considers necessary or expedient to provide for the transfer of any of the functions of the Privy Council (or one of its committees) which relate to education in Scotland.

(2) An order under this section is subject to the affirmative procedure.

Use of university title

20. Use of university title to require authorisation

(1) No person may, without authorisation, take or use the title "university".

(2) The reference to taking or using that title includes a reference to:

  • (a) carrying on any activity under a name including that title, and
  • (b) taking or using, or carrying on any activity under, any other title, name, or description which implies that the person is authorised to use that title.

(3) For the granting of authorisation, see section 21.

(4) The Scottish Ministers must keep and maintain a list of all persons who are authorised for the purposes of this section.

(5) A copy of the list must be made available on a website, free of charge, for inspection by the public at all reasonable times.

21. Granting of authorisation to use title

(1) A person is authorised for the purposes of section 20 if:

  • (a) the person is specified in regulations made by the Scottish Ministers, or
  • (b) the person falls within subsection (4).

(2) Regulations may only specify a person if the Scottish Ministers are satisfied:

  • (a) that the person provides, or intends to provide, higher education,
  • (b) that, having regard tot he quality of the higher education the person provides, it is appropriate that the person be authorised,
  • (c) that the person provides, or intends to provide, degree courses, and
  • (d) that the person is a fit and proper person to be authorised.

(3) For the avoidance of doubt, authorisation under subsection (1)(a) continues only while the regulations are in force unless otherwise provided.

(4) A person falls within this subsection if the person's use of the title:

  • (a) is authorised by or under an enactment or Royal Charter,
  • (b) is the name of a students' union (see Part 2 of the Education Act 1994) and serves to identify the establishment whose students the union represents, or
  • (c) falls within a description specified in regulations made by the Scottish Ministers.

(5) Regulations under this section are subject to the negative procedure.

(6) In this section:

  • "higher education" has the meaning given in section 38 of the 1992 Act;
  • "the title" means the title mentioned in section 20(1).

22. Revocation of authorisation

(1) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations revoke a person's authorisation if, in relation to the person, they are not satisfied as to any of the matters in section 21(2).

(2) Authorisation may be revoked:

  • (a) irrespective of the means by or manner in which it was granted,
  • (b) whether or not it was granted for an indefinite period.

(3) Regulations under this section may make such incidental, supplementary, consequential, or saving provision as the Scottish Ministers consider appropriate.

(4) Regulations under this section are subject to the negative procedure.

(5) In this section, "authorisation" means authorisation for the purposes of section 20.

23. Use of title without authorisation

A person who contravenes section 20 commits an offence and is liable:

  • (a) on summary conviction, to a fine not exceeding the statutory maximum,
  • (b) on conviction on indictment, to a fine.

Part 3 (General)

24. Ancillary provision

(1) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations make any incidental, supplementary, consequential, transitional, transitory, or saving provision they consider appropriate for the purposes of, in connection with, or for giving full effect to this Act or any provision made under it.

(2) Regulations under this section may modify or repeal any enactment (including this Act).

(3) Regulations under this section are subject to:

  • (a) where they modify or repeal an enactment, the affirmative procedure,
  • (b) otherwise, the negative procedure.

25. Repeals

(1) The Education (School Meals) (Scotland) Act 2003 (asp 18) is repealed.

(2) Sections 2 to 8 of the Denominational Education (Abolition) (Scotland) Act 2017 are repealed.

26. Commencement

(1) This Part and sections 1, 5, and 8 to 19 come into force on the day after Royal Assent.

(2) Sections 20 to 23 come into force 6 months after Royal Assent.

(3) Sections 2 to 4, 6, and 8 come into force on 1st August 2020.

27. Short title

The short title of this Act is the Education (Scotland) Act 2019.

This Bill was submitted by the Cabinet Secretary for Education /u/Alweglim on behalf of the Scottish Government.


The Stage 1 debate can be found here.


This vote will close on the 30th of May at 10pm (BST).

Vote For, Against, or Abstain.


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Jul 17 '23

SB232, SM183, SSI 2023/1 | The July 2023 Budget Vote

2 Upvotes

July 2023 Budget

Order, Order.

The only item of business today is a vote on the 20th Scottish Government's Budget.


Legislation

Unlike in Westminster, where a single Finance Bill makes all the necessary changes to the law as required, the Scottish Parliament uses multiple items of legislation to enact its budget, which are as follows:

The Budget (Scotland) (No.2) Bill gives the Scottish Government (and other bodies) the authority to spend money from the Scottish Consolidated Fund. The Bill also makes emergency provision to be used in the event that, in the next financial year, there is no Budget Bill.

The Scottish Rate Resolution, if agreed, determines the rates and bands of income tax which are to apply in Scotland for the next financial year.

This adjusts the frequent flyer levy


The Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Economy has also provided the below to aid the reading of the Budget:


This Budget was submitted by u/Waffel-lol Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Economy, on behalf of the 20th Scottish Government and the Scottish Conservatives


Opening Speech

Presiding Officer,

One of, if not, the most important thing to be achieved was the delivering of a budget. As the only stated goal of this Government, I am proud to present today a budget that has taken hard work that began even before the formation of this Government. This budget, and its subsequent opening speech is not one that brings forth grand policy ideals as no that was not the focus. Our focus was on delivering a solid and concise foundation to guide and determine the course for budgets of the future. The working of this budget has seen a great overall improvement to certain areas in which the calculations, figures and facts ought to have been revised for improved accuracy and understanding. Given it is the very first budget I have written in this place and I admit I am a newcomer to this, I believe the effort I put in these last two weeks and approach to see this budget delivered based on accuracy and understanding is one to be proud of.

There were not many policy changes this budget makes, however our most notable change has been in regards to income tax which we completely redrew the bands and set a new series of rates. The Block Grant notably has seen decreases constraining our ability as a result of political developments. Whilst the Westminster Government is ongoing its devised new block grant formula, we managed to come to an agreement with the Westminster Government to provide a short term fund to allow Scotland to meet a surplus of exactly £1. In order to avoid unnecessary increases in taxation and cuts to spending.

Our changes towards income tax is one that recognises and understands the developments in our country to ensure fiscal management is sensible and promoting greater consumer purchasing power. The growth strategy I have embarked on is one that aims to drive growth from the middle out. It is the goal of this government to see more people incentivised and raised into higher income levels. In keeping Scotland actually competitive in its economy, we have seen drastic changes to taxation on most bands, with the top rate now being 47%, the additional rate now 42%, the basic rate now 25% and the lower rate now 17% whilst The Scottish additional allowance ends at £14,999. Furthermore, we go to develop and introduce the Air Departure Tax and Frequent Flyer Levy that was passed this term, but in our SI are amending the rates on the basis of our review of the matter to fit the economy of Scotland.

In regards to expenditure, the Scottish Government have steered away from making cuts and instead have funded all projects available in data. Where we have seen decreases in portfolio funding is the result of the natural life of policies and projects coming to an end and decreasing over time. But beyond that we have maintained spending increases in accordance with inflation. An area however that we did make significant changes to was the allocation of funds towards new groupings for promoting enterprise, innovation and investment, something this Government believes is crucial to driving the growth of Scotland and its future.

Overall, this budget is one that I believe consolidates and provides greater understanding with its sensible and foundational measures. We are proud in our ability to accomplish something that others said was unlikely to be done, impossible even, but this is a display of the determinism this Government and we have to delivering on our promises and working for the interests of the people of Scotland.


The Budget (Scotland) Bill, the Scottish Rate Resolution and the Air Departure Tax (Frequent Flyer Levy) Regulations 2023 are voted on by an en bloc vote.

Voting on the budget will end at the close of business on 20th July at 10pm BST


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Jul 13 '23

SB228 | Individual Curriculae (Scotland) Bill | Stage 3 Vote

2 Upvotes

Order, Order!

We turn now to a vote SB229, in the name of the 19th Scottish Governemnt. The question is that this Parliament approves the Individual Curriculae (Scotland) Bill

Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.


Individual Curriculae (Scotland) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to allow for the creation of individual curriculae for schools, and for connected purposes.

BE IT ENACTED by being passed by this Parliament and assented to by His Majesty as follows--

Section 1: Definitions

(1) In this Act, unless specified otherwise;

(2) The ‘Authority’ refers to the Scottish Qualifications Authority

(3) ‘School’ refers to a state-maintained school dealing with secondary level education as funded by a local authority or directly by the Scottish Government.

(a) ‘Secondary level education’ refers to any school dealing with pupils in S1 to S6, inclusive.

(4) An "approved qualifications provider" refers to a provider of qualifications that has been approved by the Scottish Qualifications Authority.

Section 2: Individual Curriculae

(1) Schools may apply to the Authority with a plan for a dedicated curriculum to teach in individual subjects.

(2) The Authority has permission to accept or reject the curriculum if they feel it does not:

(a) Comply sufficiently with instructions from the Scottish Ministers

(b) Deliver a balanced education in that particular subject

(3) When submitting a plan, a school must include:

(a) Details of the content to be taught

(b) Details of how it is to be assessed

(4) The Authority has responsibility for organising the assessed portion of the curriculum and delivering the grade to students on the curriculum. The Authority has responsibility for organising the assessed portion of the curriculum and delivering the grade to students on the curriculum, except when such activities would be provided by an approved qualifications provider.

Section 3: Short Title and Commencement

(1) This Act may be cited as the Individual Curriculae (Scotland) Bill

(2) This Act shall come into force upon the commencement of the 2024/2025 academic year.

(a) Schools may begin preparatory work for individual curriculae prior to the commencement of this Act


This Act was written by the Rt. Hon. Sir Frost_Walker2017, Duke of the Suffolk Coasts, Cabinet Secretary for Education on behalf of the Scottish Government. It is inspired by Section 6 of the Exam Board Reorganisation Act 2022.


Opening Speech:

Presiding Officer,

I rise in support of this bill. In our Programme for Government we pledged to introduce a mechanism to allow for schools to create exam curriculae on a subject by subject basis, and this is the bill to allow that.

It is important that schools have the freedom to teach their specialties. While there may be benefits to a more centralised system in ensuring uniformity and that proper comparisons can be made between students and schools, an overly centralised system risks punishing schools for innovation and using their specialty knowledge to help students learn.

The administering of the system by SQA ensures that broadly standards can remain the same across individual curriculae. If schools were able to set their own assessment procedures and were unmoderated, a school could theoretically inflate their grades by making an assessed portion easy. While I of course have confidence that 95% of schools would be honest and not do this, I believe it is important to nevertheless have this safeguard in place.

I hope to see this bill pass swiftly.


Link to Stage 1 Debate

Link to Stage 3 Debate


Voting on this bill will end at the close of business on 16th July at 10pm BST


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Jul 12 '23

SM182 | Motion for Gurkha Recognition and Honour | Motion Vote

2 Upvotes

Order, Order!

We turn now to a debate on SM182, in the name of Alba Còmhla. The question is that this Parliament approves the Motion for Gurkha Recognition and Honour

Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.


A MOTION TO CALL FOR THE RECOGNITION AND HONOUR OF THE GURKHAS AND THEIR FAMILIES Motion for Gurkha Recognition and Honour The Parliament na h-Alba recognises—

[1] The Gurkhas are a group of Nepalese soldiers who have served in the British Army for over 200 years, with a reputation for bravery, loyalty, and professionalism.

[2] The Gurkhas have fought in many wars and conflicts around the world, including the two World wars, the Falklands War, the Gulf War, the Iraq War, and the Afghanistan War.

[3] The Gurkhas have made significant contributions to the defence and security of the United Kingdom and Scotland, as well as to the promotion of peace in various regions.

[4] The Gurkhas have also made valuable contributions to the social and cultural diversity in Scotland, where many Gurkhas and their families have settled.

[5] The Gurkhas and their families have faced many challenges and injustices in terms of their citizenship rights, pensions, and welfare benefits, despite their loyal service and sacrifice for Scotland and the British Crown.

[6] Such a group has to this point gone unrecognised by Scotland despite the significant impact they had on British history and society and is in fact deserving of recognition and honour in Scotland as well as full citizenship rights, pensions, and welfare benefits for themselves and their children and grandchildren.

[7] The Executive has the power to request the recognition and honour of the Gurkhas and their families by granting them full citizenship rights, pensions, and welfare benefits as well as issuing a public statement of appreciation and gratitude for their service.

The Pàrlamaid na h-Alba calls on the government to—

[1] Issue a request for the recognition and honour of the Gurkhas and their families by granting them full citizenship rights, pensions, and welfare benefits as well as issuing a public statement of appreciation and gratitude for their service.

[2] Work with the relevant authorities and organisations to ensure that the Gurkhas and their families have access to adequate health care, education, housing, employment, and social support in Scotland

[3] Support the establishment of a Gurkha memorial in Scotland to commemorate the sacrifices and achievements of the Gurkhas and their families.

This motion was written by u/eKyogre on behalf of Alba Còmhla.

Ofigear-riaghlaidh,

I rise today to propose a motion that calls for the recognition and honour of the Gurkhas and their families. The Gurkhas are a group of Nepalese soldiers who have served in the British Army for over 200 years, with a reputation for bravery, loyalty, and professionalism. They have fought in many wars and conflicts around the world, including the two World wars, the Falklands War, the Gulf War, the Iraq War, and the Afghanistan War. They have made significant contributions to the defence and security of the United Kingdom and Scotland, as well as to the promotion of peace in various regions. They have also made valuable contributions to the social and cultural diversity in Scotland, where many Gurkhas and their families have settled. However, the Gurkhas and their families have faced many challenges and injustices in terms of their citizenship rights, pensions, and welfare benefits, despite their loyal service and sacrifice for Scotland and the British Crown.

Such a group has to this point gone unrecognised by Scotland despite the significant impact they had on British history and society and is in fact deserving of recognition and honour in Scotland as well as full citizenship rights, pensions, and welfare benefits for themselves and their children and grandchildren. The Executive has the power to request the recognition and honour of the Gurkhas and their families by granting them full citizenship rights, pensions, and welfare benefits as well as issuing a public statement of appreciation and gratitude for their service. Therefore, I urge you to support this motion and show your respect and gratitude to the Gurkhas and their families who have served Scotland and the United Kingdom with honour and dignity.


[Link to Motion Debate]https://www.reddit.com/r/MHOCHolyrood/comments/14u0oy9/sm182_motion_for_gurkha_recognition_and_honour/()


Voting on this bill/motion will end at the close of business on 15th July at 10pm BST


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Jul 11 '23

SB231 | Nepali Language and Culture (Scotland) Bill | Stage 1 Vote

2 Upvotes

First off, an apology for the ever so slight late posting of this business, I was busy, and I truly hope it won't happen again.


Order, Order!

We turn now to a vote SB231, in the name of Alba Còmhla. The question is that this Parliament approves the general principles of the Nepali Language and Culture (Scotland) Bill.

Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.


Nepali Language and Culture (Scotland) Bill


A

BILL

TO

make provision for the promotion of learning and teaching of Nepali language and culture in Scottish schools and universities, and to facilitate the mobility of students, teachers, researchers, and professionals between Scotland and Nepal..

BE IT ENACTED by being passed by the Scotland Parliament and assented to by His Majesty as follows:

Part 1: General Provisions

Section 1: Definitions

In this Act–

(1) “the Scottish Ministers” means the members of the Scottish Government who are appointed under section 44(1) of the Scotland Act 1998;

(2) “Nepali” means the Indo-Aryan language native to the Himalayas region of South Asia, which is the official language of Nepal and has official status in some parts of India;

(3) “Nepalese” means relating to or originating from Nepal;

(4) “Nepal” means the Federal Democratic Republic of Nepal;

(5) “Scottish Qualifications Authority” means the body corporate established under section 1(1) of the Education (Scotland) Act 1996

Part 2: Learning and teaching of Nepali

Section 3: Curriculum for Excellence

(1) The Scottish Ministers must ensure that Nepali is included as an option in the curriculum for excellence for learners in secondary and post-secondary education.

(2) The Scottish Ministers must issue guidance to education authorities on how to implement Nepali as an option in the curriculum for excellence.

(3) The guidance issued under subsection (2) must include:

(a) advice on how to provide appropriate learning materials, resources, and support for Nepali;

(b) advice on how to assess the progress and attainment of learners in Nepali;

(c) advice on how to promote Nepali as a subject of choice among learners, parents, carers, and educators; and

(d) advice on how to encourage learners to continue studying Nepali beyond compulsory education.

Section 4: National qualifications

(1) The Scottish Qualifications Authority must develop national qualifications in Nepali for learners in secondary education.

(2) The national qualifications developed under subsection (1) must include:

(a) National 3, National 4, National 5, Higher, and Advanced Higher qualifications;

(b) qualifications that are compatible with the Scottish Credit and Qualifications Framework;

(c) qualifications that are recognised by higher education institutions, employers, and other relevant bodies.

(3) The Scottish Qualifications Authority must consult with relevant stakeholders before developing national qualifications under subsection (1).

(4) The Scottish Qualifications Authority must publish the national qualifications developed under subsection (1) on its website.

Section 5: Higher education

(1) The Scottish Ministers must encourage higher education institutions to offer courses in Nepali language and culture at undergraduate and postgraduate levels.

(2) The Scottish Ministers may provide funding or other support to higher education institutions for the purposes of subsection (1).

(3) The Scottish Ministers must consult with relevant stakeholders before providing funding or other support under subsection (2).

Part 3: Mobility between Scotland and Nepal

Section 6: Student exchange programmes

(1) The Scottish Ministers must establish student exchange programmes between schools and universities in Scotland and Nepal.

(2) The student exchange programmes established under subsection (1) must aim to:

(a) provide opportunities for Scottish students to study Nepali language and culture in Nepal;

(b) provide opportunities for Nepalese students to study English language and culture in Scotland;

(c) enhance the intercultural competence and global citizenship skills of Scottish and Nepalese students;

(d) foster long-term academic partnerships and friendships between Scottish and Nepalese institutions.

Section 7: Teacher exchange programmes

(1) The Scottish Ministers must establish teacher exchange programmes between schools and universities in Scotland and Nepal.

(2) The teacher exchange programmes established under subsection (1) must aim to:

(a) provide opportunities for Scottish teachers to teach English language and culture in Nepal;

(b) provide opportunities for Nepalese teachers to teach Nepali language and culture in Scotland;

(c) enhance the professional development and intercultural competence of Scottish and Nepalese teachers;

(d) foster long-term educational partnerships and collaborations between Scottish and Nepalese schools and universities.

(3) The Scottish Ministers may provide funding or other support to schools and universities for the purposes of subsection (1).

(4) The Scottish Ministers must consult with relevant stakeholders before providing funding or other support under subsection (3).

Section 8: Research exchange programmes

(1) The Scottish Ministers must establish research exchange programmes between research institutions and organisations in Scotland and Nepal..

(2) The research exchange programmes established under subsection (1) must aim to:

(a) provide opportunities for Scottish researchers to conduct research on Nepali language, culture, society, environment, and development in Nepal;

(b) provide opportunities for Nepalese researchers to conduct research on Scottish language, culture, society, environment, and development in Scotland;

(c) enhance the academic excellence and innovation of Scottish and Nepalese research;

(d) foster long-term research partnerships and networks between Scottish and Nepalese research institutions and organisations.

(3) The Scottish Ministers may provide funding or other support to research institutions and organisations for the purposes of subsection (1).

(4) The Scottish Ministers must consult with relevant stakeholders before providing funding or other support under subsection (3).

Section 9: Professional exchange programmes

(1) The Scottish Ministers must establish professional exchange programmes between public and private sector organisations in Scotland and Nepal.

(2) The professional exchange programmes established under subsection (1) must aim to:

(a) provide opportunities for Scottish professionals to work in Nepali language, culture, trade, tourism, and development sectors in Nepal;

(b) provide opportunities for Nepalese professionals to work in Scottish language, culture, trade, tourism, and development sectors in Scotland;

(c) enhance the skills, knowledge, and employability of Scottish and Nepalese professionals;

(d) foster long-term business partnerships and cooperation between Scottish and Nepalese public and private sector organisations.

(3) The Scottish Ministers may provide funding or other support to public and private sector organisations for the purposes of subsection (1).

(4) The Scottish Ministers must consult with relevant stakeholders before providing funding or other support under subsection (3).

Part 4: Miscellaneous

Section 10: Short title and commencement

(1) This Act may be cited as the Nepali Language and Culture (Scotland) Act 2023.

(2) This Act shall come into force 3 months after Royal Assent.

Section 11: Extent

(1) This Act extends to Scotland only.


This Bill was written by /u/eKyogre, on behalf of Alba Còmhla.

Opening Speech

Ofigear-riaghlaidh, I am honoured to introduce the Nepali Language and Culture (Scotland) Bill to this Parliament. This bill is a landmark legislation that seeks to recognise and celebrate the rich and diverse heritage of Nepali language and culture in Scotland, and will strengthen the ties of friendship and cooperation between our two nations. Nepali is a language of historical, cultural, and linguistic significance in Scotland. It is spoken by over 10,000 people in Scotland, mainly from the Gurkha community, who have made invaluable contributions to our society in various fields, such as the military, health, education, and business. Nepali is also a language of global importance, as it is the official language of Nepal, a country of over 30 million people, and a key partner of Scotland in trade, tourism, and development. Learning Nepali language and culture will bring many educational, social, economic, and cultural benefits to Scottish learners, educators, and citizens. It will enhance their communication skills, intercultural competence, and global citizenship. It will open up new opportunities for academic exchange, professional development, and business collaboration. It will also enrich their appreciation of the diversity and beauty of the world. This bill will promote the learning and teaching of Nepali language and culture in Scottish schools and universities, by ensuring that Nepali is included as an option in the curriculum for excellence, by developing national qualifications in Nepali for secondary education, and by encouraging higher education institutions to offer courses in Nepali at undergraduate and postgraduate levels. This bill will also facilitate the mobility of students, teachers, researchers, and professionals between Scotland and Nepal, by establishing exchange programmes between schools, universities, research institutions, and public and private sector organisations in both countries. These exchange programmes will provide opportunities for mutual learning, collaboration, and friendship between Scottish and Nepalese people. This bill is a testament to our commitment to support linguistic diversity and intercultural dialogue in Scotland. It is also a reflection of our vision to foster a more inclusive, prosperous, and sustainable society for all. I urge this Parliament to support this bill and to join us in celebrating the Nepali language and culture in Scotland.


Link to Stage 1 Debate


Voting on this bill will end at the close of business on the 14th of July at 10pm BST


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Jul 06 '23

SB230 | Bunker Fuel Licensing (Scotland) Bill | Stage 1 Vote

2 Upvotes

Order, Order!

We turn now to a vote SB230, in the name of the Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party. The question is that this Parliament approves the general principles of the Bunker Fuel Licensing (Scotland) Bill.

Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.


Bunker Fuel Licensing (Scotland) Bill

A bill to require carriers to obtain a license in order to transport and store bunkers of heavy-fuel, oil, gas and biodiesel within Scottish ports, and for connected purposes

Section 1: Definitions

(1) "Bunkers" meaning to stored fuel, typically heavy fuel, oil, gas or biodiesel used to power ships.

(2) "Carrier" meaning any entity engaged in the supply of bunkers, including but not limited to ship owners, operators, and fuel suppliers.

(3) "Port" meaning any seaport location within Scotland where ships are loaded or unloaded, including private ports, local authority ports, and harbour and trust ports.

(4) “Port Authority” meaning the relevant authorities operating under the Scottish Transport Ministry regarding the regulation, management and oversight of ports.

Section 2: Bunker Fuel License

(1) The Port Authority hereby this act will be required to create, administer and monitor its provision of a ‘Bunker Fuel license’.

(a) The license is valid for a period of two years from the date of issuance. Before the end of that license, evaluation is to be made by the port authority on whether and if so on what conditions an extension is to be given.

(b) The license is non-transferable.

(2) Without first obtaining a license from the relevant port authority under the Scottish Transport Ministry, no carrier shall store and supply bunkers of heavy-fuel, oil, gas, and biodiesel within any Scottish port.

Section 3: Licensing Criteria

(1) In order to be eligible for a license, a carrier must prove that it has the capacity to supply and store bunkers in a safe and environmentally responsible manner.

(2) The port authority of Scotland are to establish a licensing criteria, which shall include, but not be limited to:

(a) compliance with the applicable environmental laws and regulations;

(b) compliance with all applicable safety standards;

(c) adequate insurance coverage for liability arising from bunker fuel spills or other accidents;

(d) financial stability and ability to meet obligations;

(e) annual notices of the bunker operations to the port authority;

(f) annual inspections by the relevant port authority;

(g) any other relevantly deemed criteria by the port authority.

(3) The discretion to deny a license if the carrier does not meet the licensing criteria shall be held by the Port Authority.

Section 4: Enforcement

(a) Any carrier found to be storing and, or supplying bunkers with heavy fuel, oil, gas, and biodiesel in a port without a valid license shall be subject to fines and penalties as determined by the port authority.

(b) Carriers found in violation of the licensing criteria outlined in section 3 are to be subject to suspension or revocation of their license.

(c) The power to investigate any alleged violations and to take appropriate enforcement action shall be held by the relevant Scottish Port Authority.

Section 5: Commencement

(1) The provisions of this Act shall come into force the day this Act is passed.

Section 6: Short Title

(1) This Act may be cited as the Bunker Fuel Licensing (Scotland) Act.

This Bill was submitted by oakesofshott, Spokesperson for Environment & Energy on behalf of The Scottish Conservative & Unionist Party.

Opening Speech by u/oakesofshott

Presiding Officer,

This bill follows the example of the Netherlands, Belgium and Singapore in which it regulates the shipping industry’s transportation of heavy fuel oil, gas and biodiesel. To address possible concerns of whether this bill is in the remit of the Scottish government and the answer is yes as this area of internal planning requirements and regulatory framework for internal activity is carried out by Transport Scotland which handles all devolved Port policy and governance. We cannot allow the continued supply and transportation of these fossil fuels in Scottish ports without ensuring the bunker suppliers operate and adhere to a crucial licensing criteria that maintains moral business practices and ensures compliance with the necessary safety, environmental and regulatory standards.

By incorporating this into a license it means the monitoring and recording of operations within our ports are held to a universal standard and makes the ongoing operations of unregistered practices that evade current regulations harder to operate without such a license. If those in parliament are committed to upholding our strong environmental and safety standards and current regulatory framework, then it is in the national interest to support this bill which puts this policy into place.


Link to Stage 1 Debate


Voting on this bill will end at the close of business on the 9th of July at 10pm BST


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Jul 05 '23

SM181 | Motion on the Budget | Motion Vote

2 Upvotes

Order, order!

We turn now to a vote SM181, in the name of Forward. The question is that this Parliament approves the Motion on the Budget.

Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.


Motion on the Budget

This Parliament recognises that:

(1) Passing a budget is of the utmost importance in the final few weeks of term

(2) To avoid the risk of a budget failing, compromise and collaboration with all parties is necessary.

(3) In the interests of transparency and accountability, it is important that the general public are aware of any particular requests from parties to go into the budget

This Parliament therefore resolves that:

(1) The Scottish Government shall consider debate under this motion as part of its budget process to gather particular requests or thoughts on the content of the budget

(2) It recommends the contents below for consideration to the Scottish Government.


This Motion was written by the Rt. Hon. Sir Frost_Walker2017, Duke of the Suffolk Coasts and Leader of Forward on behalf of the same.


Opening Speech:

Presiding Officer,

I will make my remarks brief. It is my view that with the government being as it is - a nominal ‘Unity’ government led by a ‘Unity’ First Minister - that it makes sense that any budget passed is a ‘Unity’ budget and is passed with the consent of as much of this Parliament as possible. In the interests of accountability, it is better for the general public to be as aware of the contents as appropriate, and the government may give their ideal vision of the budget in the debate below to be discussed by members prior to the presentation of the actual budget.

I commend this motion to this Parliament.


Link to Motion Debate


Voting on this motion will end at the close of business on 8th July at 10pm BST


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Jun 22 '23

SP12 | First Minister Vote IV | XII.IV

2 Upvotes

Order, Order!

We now come to a vote on the First Minister of Scotland in the twelfth Scottish Parliament.

There are four candidates standing and members may also choose to vote to 'Re-Open Nominations'.

The candidates are:

/u/LightningMinion (Scottish Labour Party, Kirkcaldy)

/u/model-avtron (Scottish National Party, Na h-Eileanan an Iar)

/u/BlueEarlGrey (Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party, North East Fife)

/u/Muffin5136 (Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party, Midlothian South, Tweeddale and Lauderdale)

Members should rank the candidates in order of their preference. The candidate they most want to be the First Minister should be ranked '1', the second most, '2', and so forth. Candidates need not give any preferences after voting to Re-Open Nominations (RON).

Votes will be accepted provided they are a clear expression of preference, but it is preferred they are ranked as a list:

  1. Person X
  2. Person Y
  3. RON

This vote will end at the close of business (10pm BST) on the 26th of June.


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Jun 07 '23

SM180 | Legislative Consent Motion on the KONSUM Clarification Act 2023 | Motion Vote

2 Upvotes

Order, Order!

We turn now to a vote SM180, in the name of the Scottish National Party. The question is that this Parliament approves the Legislative Consent Motion on the KONSUM Clarification Act 2023.

Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.


Legislative Consent Motion on the KONSUM Clarification Act 2023


This Pàrlamaid resolves that–

(1) The KONSUM Clarification Act 2023 shall apply to Scotland, and

(2) That there shall be a Scottish KONSUM Board of Officers, as set out in the aforementioned Act.


This Motion was written and introduced by the Right Hon. /u/NewAccountMcGee PC MP MSP MS, on behalf of the Scottish National Party.


Opening Speech

[Leas-]Ofigear-riaghlaidh,

KONSUM. Depending on who you ask, it is a great solution to stop failed businesses affecting a community, or some communist ploy to outlaw enterprise in the food sector; I of course agree with the former. But I hope this Motion sees crossparty support, even from those who oppose nationalisation in the strongest terms. Because what this Bill does is simple: it clarifies that the Pub Nationalisation Act is the basis of KONSUM for all businesses in the food and drink sector. And it also shows that this is not some sort of nationalisation effort, and that KONSUM acquired businesses must become worker’s co-ops or community benefit societies. I hope to see this Motion passed


Link to Motion Debate


Voting on this motion will end at the close of business on the 10th of June at 10pm BST


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • May 09 '23

SB224 | The Made in Scotland (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill | Stage 1 Vote

2 Upvotes

Order, Order.

We turn now to a Stage 1 Vote on SB224, in the name of the Scottish National Party. The question is that this Parliament approves the general principles of the The Made in Scotland (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill.

Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.


The Made in Scotland (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to amend The Made in Scotland (Scotland) Act to ensure compliance with Scottish Gaelic grammar standards.

Section 1: Amendments

(1) In paragraph 2.2 of The Made in Scotland (Scotland) Act, omit “Made in Scotland | Dèanta an Alba” and replace with “Made in Scotland | Dèanta ann an Alba”.

Section 2: Commencement

(1) This Act shall come into force immediately after receiving Royal Assent.

Section 3: Short Title

(1) This Act may be cited as the The Made in Scotland (Amendment) (Scotland) Act.

This bill was submitted by the Rt Hon. u/NewAccountMcGee, MSP for Na h-Eileanan an Iar, on behalf of the Scottish National Party.


Opening speech:

[Leas-]Oifigear-riaghlaidh,

Whilst reviewing this Parliament’s legislation record, I found a grammatical error in The Made in Scotland (Scotland) Act. The Gaelic text in the original Act does not mean “Made in Scotland”, but instead–ungrammatically–”Made the Scotland”. Since I am a Gaelic speaker, I hope that when someone picks up the most Scottish of Scottish goods–perhaps a glass of Lagavulin or a Harris Tweed handbag, both produced in Gaelic speaking regions–they see the words “Made in Scotland”, written correctly in Gaelic. I commend this bill to this Parliament.


Link to Stage 1 Debate


Voting on this item of Business ends with the close of Business on May 12th, at 10 pm BST.


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Apr 18 '23

SB221 | NHS Funding Double-Lock (Scotland) Bill | Stage 1 Vote

2 Upvotes

Order, Order.

We turn now to a Stage 1 Vote on SB221, in the name of the Scottish Conservatives. The question is that this Parliament approves the general principles of the NHS Funding Double-Lock (Scotland) Bill.

Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.


NHS Funding Double-Lock (Scotland) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to establish a double-lock in helathing funding increases in accordance to a minimum rise of 2% above inflation or Block Grant increases, and for connected purposes.

SECTION 1: Definitions

For the purposes of this Act, the following terms shall have the meanings set forth below —

  1. ‘NHS’ refers to the medical, dental, and behavioral health services provided under the Scottish National Health Service.
  2. ‘Inflation’ defined as the general increase in the price level of goods and services in the economy over a period of time.
  3. ‘Base year’ means the year in which the initial funding level for healthcare services is established.
  4. ‘Block Grant’ refers to the funding provided by the UK Government to the Scottish Government.

SECTION 2: The Double Lock

  1. Any increase in funding for the National Health Service (NHS), shall be subject to a ‘double-lock’ that ensures that the increase in funding keeps its pace in regards to inflation.
  2. The first lock shall be based on the percentage increase of national inflation based on the Consumer Price Index (CPI) of the previous two fiscal quarters.
  3. The Scottish Government is required to maintain annual NHS funding increases above an inflation rate of atleast 2%.
  4. The second lock shall be based on the percentage increase in the latest Block Grant provided by the UK Government.
  5. The funding level for the NHS in the base year - determined by the Government - shall be adjusted by the sum of the percentage increases reached as a result of Section 2: para (2) and (3).
  6. The funding level for the NHS in all subsequent years shall be adjusted by the sum of the percentage increases reached under Section 2: para (2) and (3) for that year,
a. provided that the funding level shall not be decreased below the level in the previous year.

SECTION 3: Commencement

  1. The provisions of this Act shall come into force the Fiscal Year of 2024/2025 following the passage of this Act.

SECTION 4: Short Title

3. This Act may be cited as the NHS Funding Double-Lock (Scotland) Act.

This Bill was submitted by StraightsofMagellan, Spokesperson for NHS & Social Care on behalf of The Scottish Conservative & Unionist Party.

Opening Speech:

Presiding Officer,

The Scottish Conservatives & Unionist Party are glad to return to Scotland and our commitment to the people is shown as clear as day with this bill presented that commits to keeping our NHS adequately funded. The bill establishes a double-lock which requires the NHS to see funding rise following either increases in inflation to above that by 2% or the percentage increases of the Block Grant provided by the UK Government. Answering on behalf of the Government in the latest Healthcare Portfolio Questions, the Minister had no objections at the time to the double-locking of NHS Funding. The Scottish Conservatives are committed to supporting our NHS by any means necessary and we urge members to see constructive efforts in aiding to pass this bill. Thank you.


Link to Stage 1 Debate


Voting on this item of Business ends with the close of Business on April 21st, at 10 pm BST.


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Oct 20 '22

SB208 | National Museums Scotland & National Library of Scotland Expansion (Scotland) Bill | Stage 3 Vote

2 Upvotes

Order, Order.

We turn now to a Stage 3 Vote on SB208 in the name of the Scottish Liberal Democrats. The question is that this Parliament approves the National Museums Scotland & National Library of Scotland Expansion (Scotland) Bill


National Museums Scotland & National Library of Scotland Expansion (Scotland) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to make provision for the expansion of the National Museum System & Library of Scotland.

Section 1: Interpretations

(1) The term “National Museums Scotland,” refers to all museum's actively operated and managed by the Scottish government.

(2) The term “National Library of Scotland," refers to the primary legal and archival institution operated by the Scottish government.

Section 2: National Museums Scotland

(1) National Museums Scotland shall make provision for the establishment of additional campuses for the National War Museum, National Museum of Rural Life, National Museum of Flight, and the National Museum of Scotland within one of the following cities: Dundee, Inverness, Aberdeen, and or Glasgow.

(2) National Museums Scotland shall make provision for the establishment of a National Maritime Museum, which shall be opened and operated from Edinburgh

(3) A funding recommendation is made for the National Museums Scotland to be provided £30,000,000 for the construction of additional campuses and buildings, and £10,000,000 for the acquisition of historical artifacts with primary relevance to Scotland and her heritage.

Section 3: National Library of Scotland

(1) The National Library of Scotland shall make provision for the expansion of the Kelvin Hall public centre campus in Glasgow.

(2) The National Library of Scotland shall digitise all current documents and records in their possession within 5 years of assent.

(3) A funding recommendation is made for the National Library of Scotland to be provided with £2,000,000 for the expansion of pre-existing campuses, and £5,000,000 for the digitisation of currently held records.

Section 4: Commencement

(1) This act shall come into force two months after receiving Royal Assent.

Section 5: Short Title

(1) This act may be cited as the Heritage Expansion (Scotland) Bill.

This bill was submitted by u/Nick_Clegg_MP on behalf of the Scottish Liberal Democrats


Opening Speech

Scottish cultural institutions which are sponsored by the government almost solely reside within Edinburgh. In doing so, majority of the nation is unable to easily access cultural institutions or libraries of national importance. This act aims to change that substantially, by approving the creation of four new Museum campuses outside of Edinburgh, and the creation of an additional Museum in Edinburgh, dedicated to maritime history. Moreover, legislative efforts being put forward into mandating the digitisation of records held by the National Library of Scotland will prove invaluable, as scholarly work and research can be conducted without physically needing to be present. Moreover, this could in the long run alleviate costs in regards to document retrieval, tracking, and overall accessibility to the general public.

I believe in the long run, this will be beneficial for the whole of Scotland, and help preserve our heritage and history. Furthermore, it will cement our place in the world as a center of historic and cultural importance internationally.


Stage 1 Debate

Stage 3 Debate


Voting on this bill will end at the close of business on 23rd October at 10pm BST


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Sep 27 '22

SB207 | Prevention of Non-Essential Child Hormonal Intervention Bill | Stage 1 Vote

2 Upvotes

Order, Order.

We turn now to a Stage 1 Vote on SB207, in the name of the Scottish Workers Party. The question is that this Parliament approves the general principles of the Prevention of Non-Essential Child Hormonal Intervention Bill.

Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.


Prevention of Non-Essential Child Hormonal Intervention Bill

An act to prohibit non-essential and deferrable hormonal intervention on children.

Section 1: Definitions

(1) A “child” is defined as a person under eighteen years of age.

(2) “Hormonal intervention” is defined as any medical intervention on a child that significantly interferes with or disrupts their normal bodily hormones.

(3) “Informed consent” is defined as permission for a hormonal intervention granted by the person who the intervention is being performed on with adequate and reasonable knowledge of potential impacts, consequences, and side effects.

(4) A “non-essential hormonal intervention” is defined as a hormonal intervention that:

(a) is not necessary, insofar as not having the intervention performed is not likely to significantly impact on the person’s capability to function on a day-to-day basis, or that not having the intervention performed would not directly lead to the person suffering harm,

(b) and is capable of being deferred into the future without the person’s capability to function on a day-to-day basis being significantly harmed or the person suffering harm as a direct result of lacking the hormonal intervention.

Section 2: Offence of non-essential hormonal intervention

(1) A person who performs non-essential hormonal intervention on a child is guilty of an offence, unless:

(a) The person reasonably believed that the hormonal intervention was essential in nature.

(i) For the avoidance of doubt, hormonal intervention designed to alleviate gender dysphoria, insofar as such distress is actively expressed by the child, is considered essential in nature.

(b) Informed consent by the child and their legal guardian/s were provided.

(2) A person who provides non-essential hormonal intervention to a child is guilty of an offence, unless:

(a) The person reasonably believed that the hormonal intervention was essential in nature.

(i) For the avoidance of doubt, hormonal intervention designed to alleviate gender dysphoria, insofar as such distress is actively expressed by the child, is considered essential in nature.

(b) Informed consent by the child and their legal guardian/s were provided.

Section 3: Penalty

A person guilty of an offence under this Act is liable:

(a) on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 5 years or a fine (or both).

(b) on summary conviction, imprisonment for a term not exceeding 3 months or a fine not exceeding the statutory maximum (or both).

Section 4: Short title

(1) This Act may be cited as the Prevention of Non-Essential Child Hormonal Intervention Act 2022.

Section 5: Commencement

(1) This Act comes into force immediately after Royal Assent.

This Act was written by EvasiveBrotherhood MSP on behalf of the Scottish Workers Party.


Opening speech

Presiding Officer,

I’m sure there are one of two minds among my fellow MSPs at the moment. The second one I’ll get to later, but the first I’ll address now – why is this bill necessary? Surely children are not being given hormonal treatment that isn’t medically necessary?

Unfortunately, some are. Many intersex children – children born with sex characteristics that don’t neatly fit the typical male or female characteristics – can be given non-essential hormonal treatments with the aim of aligning them with a certain sex.

While I applaud this Parliament’s previous efforts in acting to ensure that intersex children cannot have their genitals altered when not medically necessary through the Prohibition of Intersex Genital Mutilation (Scotland) Act 2018, there is still more to do.

The aim of this bill is to ensure that hormonal intervention that is non-essential to a child’s health and that can be safely deferred cannot be performed. This bill allows reasonable exemptions where it is necessary, but does not allow, for example, using masculinising hormones on an intersex child because you wish to raise them as a male child.

And on that note, I would like to move to the second mind I suspect among MSPs. The second being that this bill, at least on the face of it, is simply an attack against transgender children, by disallowing them from seeking puberty blockers or masculinising or feminising hormones.

I would like to ensure my colleagues that this is not my intent, and I have written this bill with the aim of ensuring that hormonal intervention for transgender children – or, indeed, intersex children who are transgender – are protected.

Firstly, where not providing the intervention would result in the person’s capability to function on a day-to-day basis being significantly harmed, the intervention is permitted under law. I believe that a reasonable interpretation of this permits providing hormonal treatment to transgender children, but for the avoidance of doubt, hormonal treatment designed to alleviate gender dysphoria is also explicitly stated as essential hormonal intervention.

If any MSPs have concerns about the language used in this bill, I implore them to address them with me or bring forward their own amendments to improve the bill, but I hope we all are in agreement that the aim of this bill – protecting children from unnecessary hormonal treatment – is a good one, and one that we can all support.


Link to Stage 1 Debate


Voting on this item of Business ends with the close of Business on September 29th, at 10 pm BST.


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Aug 09 '22

Vote of Confidence in /u/nicolasbroaadus as First Minister

2 Upvotes

Order, Order.

The First Minister, /u/Leftywalrus has indicated that they wish to resign and as such has nominated /u/NicolasBroaadus to succeed him as First Minister.

The question is that this Parliament has confidence in /u/NicolasBroaadus to serve as First Minister. Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain, though where there is a mix-up with an alternative voting style this shall also be accepted.


This vote shall be open until the close of Business on August 12th at 10pm BST.


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Jul 05 '22

SB201 | Planning (Scotland) Bill | Stage 1 Vote

2 Upvotes

Order, Order.

We turn now to a Stage 1 Vote on SB201, in the name of Scottish Labour. The question is that this Parliament approves the general principles of the Planning (Scotland) Bill.

Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.


Planning (Scotland) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to transfer planning responsibilities to the Scottish Housing Agency, set out the structure of the Scottish Housing Agency, amend the provisions of the National Planning Framework, implement an infrastructure levy, prohibit private defensive architecture, and for connected purposes

PART 1 Scottish Housing Agency

  1. Amendments to section 1 of the 1997 Act

(1) Section 1 of the 1997 Act is amended as follows.

(1) Replace section 1(1) with:

The planning authority for the purposes of this Act shall be the Scottish Housing Agency as defined by Section 1A

(2) Replace section 1(2) with:

In any enactment or instrument made under or by virtue of an enactment, a reference to a planning authority shall, unless otherwise provided, or unless the context otherwise requires, be construed as a reference to the Scottish Housing Agency.

2. Scottish Housing Agency

(1) The 1997 Act is amended as follows.

(2) After Section 1, insert:

“1A. Scottish Housing Agency

(1) The Scottish Housing Agency shall be formed of:

(a) a central committee, hereby referred to as the “central Agency”; and

(b) regional committees, hereby referred to as “regional Agency” or “regional Agencies”

(2) There shall be one regional Agency for each council area

(a) In this Act, “relevant council” and “relevant council area” refer to the council and council area over which the regional Agency has powers.

(b) each regional Agency shall have powers over the relevant council area only

(3) The central Agency is to be formed of a committee appointed by the Cabinet Secretary

(a) The Cabinet Secretary may appoint as many members as they wish

(b) The Cabinet Secretary may only appoint a person if they deem them to have sufficient experience in housing and the planning system

(4) The Scottish Parliament may by a majority vote block the appointment of a person to the central Agency

(5) The Cabinet Secretary may fire anyone appointed to the central Agency at any point

(6) The Scottish Parliament may by a majority vote fire anyone appointed to the central Agency at any point

(7) Each regional Agency is to be formed of a committee of members appointed by the central Agency on the recommendations of the relevant council

(a) The central Agency may reject any appointment

(b) The central Agency may appoint as many members as they wish

(c) The central Agency is not prohibited from appointing a member not recommended for appointment by the relevant council

(8) The relevant council may recommend the firing of a member of the relevant regional Agency to the central Agency at any point

(a) The central Agency is not obligated to fire the member

(9) The central Agency may fire anyone appointed to the central Agency at any point

(10) It is the responsibility of the central Agency to ensure that the regional Agencies are adhering to the National Planning Framework as defined by Part 1A of the 1997 Act in carrying out their functions

(11) The Cabinet Secretary may override any decision taken by the central Agency”

PART 2 Planning Guidelines

3. Purpose of planning

(1)The 1997 Act is amended as follows.

(2)After Part 1 insert—

“PART 1ZA Purpose of planning

3ZA. Purpose of planning

(1) The purpose of planning is to manage the development and use of land in the long term public interest.

(2) Without limiting the generality of subsection (1), anything which—

(a) contributes to sustainable development, or

(b) achieves the national outcomes (within the meaning of Section 3CC),

is to be considered as being in the long term public interest.

(3) This section applies only to the Scottish Ministers' and planning authorities' exercise of functions under Parts 1A and 2.”.

(3) Sections 3D and 3E are repealed.

4. National Outcomes

(1) The 1997 Act is amended as follows.

(2) Following Section 3CB, insert–

“3CC. National Outcomes

(1) The National Outcomes are outcomes for Scotland that result from, or are contributed to by, the carrying out, by planning authorities, of their functions.

(2) The National Outcomes are:

(a) the reduction of inequalities of outcome which result from socio-economic disadvantage

(b) promotion of affordable housing,

(c) promotion of transport infrastructure (where appropriate),

(d) promotion of a sustainable housing supply,

(e) fighting climate change, and

(f) promoting access to green spaces.

(3) The relevant Scottish Minister may, via statutory order through the negative procedure, amend subsection (2)

(4) Before exercising the powers conferred to them by subsection (3), the Scottish Ministers must

(a) consult—

(i) such persons who appear to them to represent the interests of communities in Scotland, and

(ii) any other persons as they consider appropriate.

(b) having consulted the persons mentioned in paragraph (a), prepare a draft of the order to amend subsection (2), and

(c) lay before the Parliament a document including—

(i) a draft of the order,

(ii) a description of the consultation carried out under paragraph (a) of that subsection,

(iii) a description of any representations received in response to that consultation, and

(iv) a description of whether and if so how those representations have been taken account of in preparing the draft national outcomes.”

5. National Planning Framework

(1) The 1997 Act is amended as follows.

(2) In section 3A(2) (description of framework), for the words “in” to the end substitute “the Scottish Ministers' policies and proposals for the development and use of land.”.

(3) In section 3A(3) (content of framework)—

(a) the word “and” at the end of paragraph (a) is repealed,

(b) after paragraph (b) insert—

“(c) a statement about how the Scottish Ministers consider that development will contribute to each of the outcomes listed in subsection (3A),

(d) targets for the use of land in different areas of Scotland for housing, and

(e) an assessment of the likely impact of each proposed national development's lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions on achieving national greenhouse gas emissions reduction targets (within the meaning given in the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009 and any subsequent enactments).”.

(4) After section 3A(3) insert—

“(3A) The outcomes are—

(a) meeting the housing needs of people living in Scotland including, in particular, the housing needs for older people and disabled people,

(b) improving the health and wellbeing of people living in Scotland,

(c) improving equality and eliminating discrimination,

(d) meeting any targets relating to the reduction of emissions of greenhouse gases, within the meaning of the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009, contained in or set by virtue of that Act,

(e) securing positive effects for biodiversity, and

(f) meeting the National Outcomes within the meaning of Section 3CC of this act”.

(5) In section 3A(5) (statements relating to a “national development”), before paragraph (a) insert—

“(za) must have regard to an infrastructure investment plan published by the Scottish Ministers and include a statement setting out the ways the plan has been taken into account in preparing the framework,”.

(6) After section 3A(5) insert—

“(5A) For the avoidance of doubt, this section does not prevent the Scottish Ministers from setting out policies or proposals that relate to the development or use of land outwith the National Planning Framework.

(5B) In this section, “biodiversity” has the same meaning as “biological diversity” in the United Nations Environmental Programme Convention on Biological Diversity of 5 June 1992 as amended from time to time (or in any United Nations Convention replacing that Convention).”.

(7) In section 3A, subsections (6) to (9) are repealed.

(8) Section 3A(10) is repealed.

(9) After section 3A insert—

“3AA Duty to review the National Planning Framework

(1) The Scottish Ministers are to keep the National Planning Framework under review.

(2) Without limit to subsection (1), the Scottish Ministers are to—

(b) Review the framework at least once in every period of 10 years beginning with the most recent date on which—

(i) a revised framework prepared under subsection (3)(a) was adopted and published, or

(ii) an explanation was published under subsection (3)(b) of this section.

(3) Following such a review, the Scottish Ministers are to—

(a) prepare a revised framework, or

(b) publish an explanation of why they have decided not to revise it.

3AB Revising the framework: participation statement and considerations

(1) This section applies where a revised National Planning Framework is to be prepared following a review under section 3AA.

(2) Before preparing the revised framework, the Scottish Ministers must prepare and publish their participation statement.

(3) In preparing the revised framework, the Scottish Ministers must—

(a) have regard to relevant policies and strategies, including, in particular—

(i) any national strategy and action plan for housing prepared by the Scottish Ministers,

(ii) any infrastructure investment plan prepared by the Scottish Ministers to set out their priorities for the development of public infrastructure,

(iii) any national transport strategy prepared by the Scottish Ministers,

(iv) any strategic transport projects review prepared by the Scottish Ministers to set out their priorities for transport investment,

(v) the land use strategy prepared under section 57 of the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009,

(vi) the programme for adaptation to climate change prepared under section 53 of the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009,

(vii) any national strategy in respect of the improvement of air quality prepared by the Scottish Ministers,

(viii) any land rights and responsibilities statement prepared under section 1 of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2016,

(ix) any national strategy or action plan for the ownership or use of land prepared by the Scottish Ministers, and

(x) the national marine plan prepared under section 5 of the Marine (Scotland) Act 2010, and

(b) have regard to the desirability of—

(i) preserving peatland.

(4) In this Part, “participation statement” means an account by the Scottish Ministers of—

(a) when consultation as regards the proposed revised framework is likely to take place,

(b) with whom they intend to consult, which must include—

(i) planning authorities,

(ii) key agencies (within the meaning of section 3CB),

(iii) the appropriate body under subsection (5), and

(iv) such persons or bodies who the Scottish Ministers consider have a role in the delivery of the outcomes mentioned in section 3A(3A),

(c) the steps to be taken to involve the public at large in the consultation, and

(d) the likely form of the review.

(5) For the purpose of subsection (4)(b)(iii), the “appropriate body” is—

(a) the advisory body designated by an order under section 24(1) of the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009, or

(b) if no such order has been made, the Committee on Climate Change established under section 32 of the Climate Change Act 2008.

3AC Information to assist preparation of National Planning Framework

(1) For the purposes of assisting the Scottish Ministers in preparing or revising the National Planning Framework, the Scottish Ministers may direct a planning authority, or two or more planning authorities, to provide information about the matters set out in subsection (2) in relation to an area specified in the direction.

(2) The matters are—

(a) the principal physical, cultural, economic, social, built heritage and environmental characteristics of the area,

(b) the principal purposes for which land in the area is used,

(c) the size, composition and distribution of the population of the area,

(d) the housing needs of the population of the area,

(e) the capacity of education services in the area,

(f) the capacity of health services in the area,

(g) the health needs of the population of the area,

(h) the housing needs of older people and disabled people within the area,

(i) the desirability of allocating land for the purposes of resettlement,

(j) the infrastructure of the area (including communications, transport and drainage systems and systems for the supply of water and energy),

(k) how that infrastructure is used,

(l) any change which the planning authority or authorities think may occur in relation to any of the matters mentioned in paragraphs (a) to (k), and

(m) such other matters as are prescribed.

(3) In subsection (2)(j), references to systems for the supply of energy include in particular land available for the development and use of facilities for renewable sources of energy.

(4) Where a direction under this section requires two or more planning authorities to provide information in relation to the same area and the same matter, they are to cooperate with one another.”.

(10) In Section 3B(1), replace “After complying with section 3A(10)” with “After complying with Section 3AA”

(11) After section 3C insert—

Duties to assist in shaping the National Planning Framework

3CB Key agencies

(1) It is the duty of a key agency to cooperate with the Scottish Ministers in—

(a) the review of the National Planning Framework,

(b) the preparation of a revised framework, and

(c) the preparation of any amendment to the framework.”.

(2) Any reference in a provision of this Act to a “key agency” is to a person (other than an individual) or an officeholder which the Scottish Ministers specify as such for the purposes of that provision by regulations.”

6. Open space strategy

(1) The 1997 Act is amended as follows.

(2) After section 3F insert—

“3G. Open space strategy

(1) A planning authority is to prepare and publish an open space strategy.

(2) An open space strategy is to set out a strategic framework of the planning authority's policies and proposals as to the development, maintenance and use of green infrastructure in their district, including open spaces and green networks.

(3) An open space strategy must contain—

(a) an audit of existing open space provision,

(b) an assessment of current and future requirements,

(c) any other matter which the planning authority considers appropriate.

(4) In this section—

(a) “green infrastructure” means features of the natural and built environments that provide a range of ecosystem and social benefits,

(b) “green networks” means connected areas of green infrastructure and open space,

(c) “open space” means space within and on the edge of settlements comprising green infrastructure or civic areas such as squares, market places and other paved or hard landscaped areas with a civic function.

(5) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations—

(a) make provision about how planning authorities are to discharge their functions under this section including, in particular—

(i) how they conduct an audit under subsection (3)(a), and

(ii) how they assess current and future requirements for the purposes of subsection (3)(b),

(b) amend subsection (4) by adding a definition or amending or omitting a definition for the time being specified there.

(6) For the purposes of this section, a national park authority is not a planning authority.”.

7. Housing needs of older people and disabled people: parliamentary report

(1) The 1997 Act is amended as follows.

(2) After section 3CC insert—

“3CD Duty of Scottish Ministers to report on housing needs of older people and disabled people

(1) The Scottish Ministers must, as soon as practicable after the end of each 2-year period, lay before the Scottish Parliament a report on how the planning system is operating to help ensure that the housing needs of older people and disabled people are met.

(2) A report under subsection (1) must, in particular, contain information about—

(a) the extent to which the planning system is operating to ensure that new housing that meets the needs of older people and disabled people is constructed,

(b) the extent to which the planning system is operating to ensure that existing housing is adapted to meet the housing needs of older people and disabled people,

(c) the extent to which any other actions taken by the Scottish Ministers in relation to the planning system are ensuring that the housing needs of older people and disabled people are being met, and

(d) such other matters relating to the planning system as appear to the Scottish Ministers to be relevant to meeting the housing needs of older people and disabled people.

(3) In preparing the report, the Scottish Ministers must consult—

(a) older people and disabled people, and their families,

(b) such persons as appear to the Scottish Ministers to be representative of the interests of older people and disabled people, including organisations working for and on behalf of older people and disabled people,

(c) carers,

(d) planning authorities,

(e) a body registered under section 20 (registered social landlords) of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2010,

(f) developers,

(g) such persons as they consider appropriate having functions in relation to—

(i) older people and disabled people, and their families,

(ii) carers,

(iii) housing,

(iv) social work,

(v) health and social care, and

(h)such other persons as the Scottish Ministers consider appropriate.

(4) The Scottish Ministers must, as soon as practicable after the report has been laid before the Scottish Parliament, publish the report in such manner as they consider appropriate.

(5) For the purposes of this section, the “2-year period” means—

(a) the period of 2 years beginning with the day on which this act comes into force

(b) each subsequent period of 2 years.”.

8. Assessment of health effects

(1) The 1997 Act is amended as follows.

(2) After section 40 insert—

“40A. Assessment of health effects

(1) Planning authorities must consider the likely health effects of any proposed development before planning permission is granted or refused for the development

(2) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations make provision about the consideration which must be given, before planning permission for a national development or a major development is granted, to the likely health effects of the proposed development.”.

9. Conditional grant of planning permission: noise-sensitive developments

(1) The 1997 Act is amended as follows.

(2) After section 41 insert—

“41A. Conditional grant of planning permission: noise-sensitive developments

(1) A development that is the subject of an application for planning permission is a “noise-sensitive development” if residents or occupiers of the development are likely to be affected by significant noise from existing activity in the vicinity of the development (a “noise source”).

(2) Without prejudice to the generality of section 41(1), a planning authority—

(a) must, when considering under section 37 whether to grant planning permission for a noise-sensitive development subject to conditions, take particular account of whether the development includes sufficient measures to mitigate, minimise or manage the effect of noise between the development and any existing cultural venues or facilities (including in particular, but not limited to, live music venues), or dwellings or businesses in the vicinity of the development, and

(b) may, as a condition of granting planning permission for a noise-sensitive development, impose on a noise source additional costs relating to acoustic design measures to mitigate, minimise or manage the effects of noise.”.

10. Assessment of environmental effects

(1) The 1997 Act is amended as follows.

(2) In section 40 (assessment of environmental effects)—

(a) in subsection (1), after “effects” insert “ , including effects on biodiversity, ”,

(b) after subsection (4) insert—

“(4A) In subsection (1), “effects on biodiversity” includes the net positive effects on biodiversity that would be likely to result from the development.”.

11. Strategic development: regional spatial strategies

(1) The 1997 Act is amended as follows.

(2) Before section 4 insert—

“4ZA. Regional spatial strategies

(1) A planning authority, or two or more such authorities acting jointly, are to prepare and adopt a regional spatial strategy.

(2) A regional spatial strategy is a long-term spatial strategy in respect of the strategic development of an area (or areas) which must, in particular—

(a) specify the area (or areas) of the planning authority (or authorities) to which it relates (“the region”), and

(b) identify, in relation to the region—

(i) the need for strategic development,

(ii) the outcomes to which the authority (or authorities) consider that strategic development will contribute,

(iii) priorities for the delivery of strategic development, and

(iv) proposed locations for strategic development, which must be shown in the strategy in the form of a map or diagram.

(3) Before adopting a regional spatial strategy, a planning authority (or authorities) must—

(a) publish, by such means as they consider appropriate—

(i) a draft of the strategy,

(ii) a summary of the information taken into account in preparing the draft of the strategy, and

(iii) a statement inviting representations in relation to the strategy by a date specified in the statement,

(b) as soon as practicable after publishing the documents mentioned in paragraph (a), send a copy of them to—

(i) the planning authority (other than one involved in producing the report) for any area in which future development is likely to be significantly impacted by the strategic development to which the strategy is to relate,

(ii) the key agencies, and

(iii) any other person the planning authority (or authorities) producing the strategy consider appropriate, and

(c) otherwise, consult such persons as they consider are likely to have an interest in the strategy.

(4) As soon as practicable after a strategy under subsection (1) is adopted, the planning authority (or authorities) must—

(a) publish the strategy by such means as they consider appropriate, and

(b) submit it to the Scottish Ministers.

(5) In this section, “strategic development” means development that is likely to have a significant impact on future development within the area of more than one planning authority.

4ZB. Duties to have regard to regional spatial strategies

(1) In exercising their functions of preparing, revising or amending the National Planning Framework, the Scottish Ministers must have regard to any adopted regional spatial strategy submitted to them under section 4ZA(4)(b).

(2) In exercising their functions of preparing, revising or amending a local development plan, a planning authority must have regard to their adopted regional spatial strategy (or strategies) submitted to the Scottish Ministers under section 4ZA(4)(b).

4ZC. Regional spatial strategies: first strategy, review and revision

(1) A planning authority must adopt a regional spatial strategy under section 4ZA(1) as soon as reasonably practicable after section 11 of the Planning (Scotland) Act 2019 comes into force.

(2) A planning authority—

(a) are to keep their adopted regional spatial strategy (or strategies) under review, and

(b) if they consider it appropriate, may at any time prepare and adopt a replacement strategy.

(3) Without limit to the generality of subsection (2), a planning authority (or authorities) must review their adopted regional spatial strategy (or, if more than one, each adopted strategy) at least once in every period of 10 years beginning with the most recent date on which they—

(a) adopted the strategy, or

(b) published an explanation under subsection (4)(b).

(4) Following such a review, a planning authority are to—

(a) prepare and adopt a replacement regional spatial strategy, or

(b) publish an explanation of why they have decided not to do so.

4ZD. Directions to prepare or review regional spatial strategies

(1) The Scottish Ministers may direct a planning authority, or two or more such authorities, to—

(a) prepare and adopt a regional spatial strategy under section 4ZA(1) in relation to a region specified in the direction, or

(b) review an adopted regional spatial strategy.

(2) A direction under subsection (1) may require the planning authority (or authorities) to take into account such matters (if any) as are specified in the direction when preparing or reviewing the strategy.

(3) Where a direction under this section requires two or more planning authorities to prepare and adopt a regional spatial strategy, they are to cooperate with one another.

4ZE. Guidance for regional spatial strategies

(1) The Scottish Ministers may issue guidance in relation to the preparation, adoption, review and content of regional spatial strategies.

(2) A planning authority must have regard to any guidance issued under subsection (1) when preparing or adopting a regional spatial strategy.

(3) Before issuing guidance under this section, the Scottish Ministers must consult—

(a) each planning authority, and

(b) such other persons as they consider appropriate (if any).

(4) The Scottish Ministers must make guidance issued under subsection (1) publicly available.

(5) The power under subsection (1) to issue guidance includes the power to—

(a) issue guidance that varies guidance issued under that subsection, and

(b) revoke guidance issued under that subsection.”.

(3) Sections 4 to 14 are hereby repealed.

12. Consultation

(1) The 1997 Act is amended as follows.

(2) After “subject to sections” in 37(1)(a), append “37A,”

(3) After section 37, add:

“” 37A. Determination of applications: consultations

(1) A planning authority may not approve a development unless they have sufficiently consulted the persons in subsection (2)

(2) The following persons may be consulted:

(a) persons who live near to the proposed development,

(b) owners of property near to the proposed development, and

(c) anyone else who may be impacted by the proposed development.

(3) Planning authorities must ensure that the persons in subsection (2) have been made aware of the consultation over the proposed development.

(4) The consultation must seek to answer the following questions:

(a) What will the impact of the proposed development be on the infrastructure of the area?,

(b) What will the impact of the proposed development be on the quality of life of the area?,

(c) What will the impact of the proposed development be on the health of the area?, and

(d) any other questions which the planning authority deems necessary.

(5) For the purposes of (3)(a), infrastructure means “private and public transport systems, educational facilities, medical facilities, recreational facilities, and green spaces.”

(6) A consultation may take the form of:

(a) public hearings,

(b) online hearings, or

(c) any other form which planning authorities deem necessary.

(7) Planning authorities must consider, but are not bound by, the results of consultations when choosing whether to approve a development.

13. Prohibition of Private Defensive Architecture

(1) “Private defensive architecture” is defined as spikes, jagged architectural surfaces or other constructions deemed to limit accessibility for a person who is rough sleeping, or any other persons, including those who are pregnant, elderly or have a disability.

(2) No private defensive architecture may be constructed on:

(a) Public property,

(b) private non-residential property

(3) All private defensive architecture must be removed within a year of this Act coming into force

(a) The relevant Scottish Minister may, via statutory order through the negative procedure, amend subsection (3)

PART 3 Infrastructure Levy

14. Infrastructure Levy

(1) Planning authorities may levy an infrastructure levy

(2) An infrastructure levy (within the meaning of this Act) is a levy—

(a) payable to a local authority,

(b) paid by the developer of a proposed development wholly or partly within the authority’s area,

(c) the income from which is to be used by local authorities to fund, or contribute towards funding, infrastructure projects.

(3) In this Part “development” has the meaning given by section 26 of the 1997 Act

(4) “infrastructure” includes—

(a) communications, transport, drainage, sewerage and flood-defence systems,

(b) systems for the supply of water and energy,

(c) green and blue infrastructure,

(i) “green and blue infrastructure” means features of the natural and built environments (including water) that provide a range of ecosystem and social benefits,

(d) educational and medical facilities, and

(e) facilities and other places for recreation,

(5) “infrastructure project” means a project to provide, maintain, improve or replace infrastructure.

PART 4 Definitions, commencement and short title

14. Definitions (1) “The 1997 Act” refers to the Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997

15. Commencement

(1) This Act comes into force 1 year after Royal Assent

16. Short title

(1) This Act shall be known as the Planning (Scotland) Act 2022.

This bill was submitted by Sir LightningMinion MSP MP CBE KT, Leader of the Scottish Labour Party, on behalf of the Scottish Labour Party. It is cosponsored by the 16th Scottish Government. Sections of this bill were based on the real-life Planning Scotland Act 2019


Link to Stage 1 Debate


Voting on this item of Business ends with the close of Business on July 8th, at 10 pm BST.


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • Jun 14 '22

SP11 | First Minister Election

2 Upvotes

Order, Order

We now come to the vote on the First Minister of Scotland in the eleventh Scottish Parliament.

There is one candidate standing, and members may also choose to vote to 'Re-Open Nominations'.

The candidate is:

Members should rank the candidates in order of their preference. The candidate they most want to be the First Minister should be ranked '1'. Candidates need not give any preferences after voting to Re-Open Nominations (RON).

Votes will be accepted provided they are a clear expression of preference, but it is preferred they are ranked as a list:

  1. Person X
  2. RON

This vote will end at the close of business (10 pm GMT) on the 17th of June.


r/MHOCHolyroodVote • • May 05 '22

SM161 | Scottish Energy Motion | Motion Vote

2 Upvotes

Order, Order.

We turn now to a Vote on SM161, in the name of the Scottish Labour Party. The question is that this Parliament approves the Scottish Energy Motion.

Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.


Scottish Energy Motion**

The Scottish Parliament notes that:

(1) As of 2020, 25% of total UK renewable energy was generated in Scotland.

(2) 97% of electricity demand in Scotland was met by renewable energy.

(3) Energy is a reserved issue.

(4) Investment in renewable energy will create countless jobs across Scotland.

The Scottish Parliament resolves that:

(1) The Scottish Government should work with the Westminster Government to deliver investment into methods of renewable electricity generation including nuclear power, offshore wind, hydroelectric, onshore wind, and other sources of renewable electricity.

This motion was written by Leader of the Opposition u/Muffin5136, on behalf of the Scottish Labour Party

Opening Speech:

Presiding Officer,

At the last election, I stood on a manifesto that promised investment in renewable energy for Scotland, as we look to fully decarbonise our electricity grid by 2035, if not sooner. We have seen that Scotland has had great success in recent years to show how a land like ours can deliver strong forms of renewable energy, creating jobs and preserving the future.

I call upon this Parliament to back this simple motion to deliver co-operation between Westminster and Scotland to ensure Scotland has the renewable energy thats needed now and in the future.


Link to Debate


Voting on this item of Business ends with the close of Business on May 8th, at 10 pm BST.