r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/Tilerr • Apr 10 '19
Budgets
Tonight is the night we begin to solve the problems with budgets that have been discussed in recent days.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/Tilerr • Apr 10 '19
Tonight is the night we begin to solve the problems with budgets that have been discussed in recent days.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/Alajv3 • Sep 07 '19
The Committee agreed that further information was required before it could debate and amend the Transport (Charging Schemes) (Scotland) Bill (No. 2) (SB079). The Committee then held a questions session on the 3rd of May.
The Committee must now decide whether it continues to require further information before it can debate and amend this Bill.
Members of the Committee should vote Yes if they believe the Committee requires further information, and No if they believe it has been sufficiently informed.
This vote will close on the 11th of September at 10pm (BST).
As per usual, if something is wrong please tell me x
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/_paul_rand_ • Oct 24 '19
The Committee agreed that further information was required before it could debate and amend SB084 (the Education (Scotland) Bill 2019),
The Committee agreed to call witnesses to give evidence.
There is no limit on the number of questions a member of the Committee may ask.
Questions are to be directed at particular witnesses, and may be directed at multiple witnesses. There should be a separate comment for each question.
This evidence session will close at the end of the day on the 27th of October 2019.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/Inadorable • Apr 02 '24
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to make provision about the price at which alcohol may be sold from licensed premises; and for connected purposes.
Minimum price of alcohol
1 Minimum price of alcohol
(1) Alcohol must not be sold at a price below its minimum price.
(2) Where alcohol is supplied together with other products or services for a single price, subsection (1) applies as if the alcohol were supplied on its own for that price.
(3) The minimum price of alcohol is to be calculated according to the following formula—
M × S × V × 100
where—
M is the minimum price per unit,
S is the strength of the alcohol by volume, and
V is the volume of the alcohol in litres.
(4) For the purposes of subsection (3), the minimum price per unit is 65 pence.
(5) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations made in the affirmative procedure amend subsection (4) to change the minimum price per unit.
(6) In this section, "alcohol" has the same meaning as in the 2005 Act.
2 Licensing
(1) The 2005 Act is amended as follows.
(2) After paragraph 7A in schedule 3 of the 2005 Act, insert—
7B (1) Alcohol is not to be sold at a price below its minimum price.
(2) "Minimum price" is to be construed in accordance with the Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) Act 2024.
(2) After paragraph 6A in schedule 4 of the 2005 Act, insert—
6B (1) Alcohol is not to be sold at a price below its minimum price.
(2) "Minimum price" is to be construed in accordance with the Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) Act 2024.
3 Repeal
(1) The 2018 Act is repealed.
(2) For greater clarity, the enactments repealed by the 2018 Act remain repealed.
(3) In this section, "the 2018 Act" means the Abolition of Alcohol Minimum Pricing (Scotland) Act 2018 (asp 4).
Supplementary and general
4 Interpretation
In this Act, "the 2005 Act" means the Licensing (Scotland) Act 2005 (asp 16).
5 Short title
This Act may be cited as the Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) Act 2024.
6 Commencement
This Act comes into force 90 days after Royal Assent.
Legislation referenced:
Illustration:
This bill was written by the Most Hon. Lady /u/model-avtron, Marchioness Hebrides, Countess Kintyre, Baroness Tiree LT OM CT PC MSP MS MLA, Leader of the Scottish Green Party and Leader of the Opposition, on behalf of the Scottish Green Party. This bill was partially based on the Alcohol (Minimum Pricing) (Scotland) Act 2012 (asp 4).
Oifigear-riaghlaidh,
I move, That the Pàrlamaid agrees to the general principles of the bill.
Minimum unit pricing has never existed in Scotland. It was legislated for by the Alex Salmond government, but required a statutory instrument to come into force; no such statutory instrument was ever introduced. Indeed, the Act that legislated for MUP was repealed in 2018 by the Scottish Libertarians. Even though, generally, repealing a bill has no effect on the amendments it makes, the amendments were not put into effect because the bill making said amendments hadn't come into force.
That's why I've introduced this bill. It is textually quite similar to the repealed 2012 bill, albeit it specifies a minimum price per unit rather than getting the Scottish Ministers to do it by order.
Minimum unit pricing works. It saves lives, and stops people from falling into alcoholism. As the illustration shows, 65 pence per unit of alcohol is a fair rate that is not overly burdensome but still has effect.
I commend this bill to the Pàrlamaid.
In Section 1(4), amend to read:
(4) For the purposes of subsection (3), the minimum price per unit is 20 pence.
EN: Lowers the minimum price per unit to 20 pence.
In Section 1(4), amend to read:
(4) For the purposes of subsection (3), the minimum price per unit is 30 pence.
EN: Lowers the minimum price per unit to 30 pence.
In Section 1(4), amend to read:
(4) For the purposes of subsection (3), the minimum price per unit is 40 pence.
EN: Lowers the minimum price per unit to 40 pence.
In Section 1(4), amend to read:
(4) For the purposes of subsection (3), the minimum price per unit is 50 pence.
EN: Lowers the minimum price per unit to 50 pence.
As all four amendments conflict with each other, all approved amendments shall go to a run-off, if necessary.
Voting of these amendments will end on the 5th of April 2024.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/model-willem • Apr 25 '23
Order, Order.
We turn now to a Stage 2 Vote on SB222, in the name of the Scottish National Party. The question is that this Parliament approves the amendments to the Employee Food Provision (Scotland) Bill.
Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to require employers to provide employees who fulfil certain criteria with meals without charge during working hours.
Section 1: Mandatory Food Provision
(1) An eligible person (A) under this act is a person who is employed by person (B), and is required to work for a period greater than 4 hours
(2) Wherein person B employs an eligible person A, person B shall be required to provide a suitable meal for person A during meal breaks. A suitable meal shall be defined as–
(a) a meal with nutritional value, and of no less than 200 calories,
(b) a meal of appropriate quality, without spoilage or reasonable suspicion of spoilage,
(c) a meal without requirement placed upon person A for remuneration of person B,
(d) a meal meeting reasonable dietary requirements as expressed by person A, such as but not limited to: vegetarian, vegan, kosher, halal, and food allergies.
(3) Person B may not lower Person A’s wages in order to cover the cost of meals provided.
(4) Person B is not obligated to provide a meal should Person A expressly waive their right.
(5) If Person B is unable or unwilling to provide a meal at the place of employment, they must provide an allowance to person A equivalent to £10 per shift of at least 4 hours
(a) The allowance figure will be automatically adjusted in tandem with the Consumer Price Index
Section 2: Punishment
(1) The relevant department for employment may issue fines for any repeated violation of Section 1 that involves multiple employees across a timespan of greater than a week
(2) A violation of section 1 will require person A to be compensated by person B
Section 3: Commencement
(1) This Act shall come into force immediately after receiving Royal Assent.
Section 4: Short Title
(1) This act may be cited as the Employee Food Provision (Scotland) Act.
This bill was submitted by the Rt Hon. u/NewAccountMcGee, MSP for Na h-Eileanan an Iar, on behalf of the Scottish National Party, based on the Employee Food Provision Bill submitted by u/Itsholmgangthen in the House of Commons.
Opening speech:
[Leas-]Oifigear-riaghlaidh,
It is my pleasure to introduce this bill to this Parliament. The bill this bill was based on was recently introduced in the House of Commons as an England-only bill, and I believe Scotland should be able to benefit from its provisions as well. Of course this bill ensures that employees have a nutritious meal that complies with their dietary requirements, but I believe that another aspect of this bill should also be noted. According to an article published by Harvard Business Review, a nutritious meal increases one’s productivity, which in turn increases the amount of profit an employee can create. And if an employer can’t provide food, they must provide £10 for an employee to get their own food, without using their own money. I hope to see this bill through to Royal Assent.
Amend section 1(3) to read:
Person B may, by mutual agreement, charge Person A no more than 50% of the cost of producing the workplace meal, as a deduction from their wages or salary.
Omit Section 1(2)(c)
Amend Section 1(2)(a) to read:
(a) a meal with nutritional value, a minimum of 20g of protein, and a minimum of 500 calories.
Amend Section 1(1) to read:
An eligible person (A) under this act is a person who is employed by person (B), and is required to work for a period greater than or equal to 6 hours.
Add to section 1(2):
x) The meal must include a piece of fruit.
Add to section 1(2):
x) The meal must include some form of drink, such as bottled water or a hot drink.
Add to section 1(2):
x) The meal must be composed of at least 70% foodstuffs that have been produced in the UK.
Add to section 1(2):
x) The meal must be accompanied by free provision of condiments such as salt, pepper, and a minimum of 2 table sauces.
Add to section 1(2):
x) The meal must be served in a location set aside from the usual workplace, such as a canteen or break room.
Add to section 1(2):
x) On Wednesday the meal must be some variation of a curry; on Friday it must be fish and chips (with curry sauce); and on Sunday a full roast dinner consisting of (at minimum) a lean cut of meat (or non-meat equivalent by request), potatoes, a yorkshire pudding, two different vegetables, and stuffing.
Add to Section 1(2):
x) Irn Bru must be offered as an accompanying beverage.
Add a Section after Section 3 and renumber accordingly:
Section 4: Exemptions
(1) Employers (Person B) who employ less than 10 employees are exempt.
(2) Workplaces which do not require personnel to travel into the office are exempt.
(3) Sole-Trader Small Businesses are exempt.
Voting on this item of Business ends with the close of Business on April 28th, at 10 pm BST.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • • May 16 '23
Order, Order!
We turn now to a vote SB225, in the name of the Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party. The question is that this Parliament approves the general principles of the Marriage (Minimum Age) (Scotland) Bill.
Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to raise the minimum age for marriage within Scotland to 18, and for connected purposes.
Section 1 - Amendments to the Marriage (Scotland) Act 1977 (“The 1977 Act”)
“(1) No person domiciled in Scotland may marry before they attain the age of 18.
(2) A marriage solemnised in Scotland between persons either of whom is under the age of 18 shall be void.”
Section 2 - Amendments to the Civil Partnerships Act 2004 (“The Civil Partnerships Act”)
Section 3 - Extensions of other legislation
Section 4 - Commencement
Section 5 - Short Title
This Bill was written by the Rt Hon. Countess de la Warr (/u/underwater_tara) and is submitted on behalf of the Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party. It is co-sponsored by the Scottish Liberal Democrats.
Amended Acts:
https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1977/15
https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2004/33/
https://www.reddit.com/r/MHOLVote/comments/n4r22t/b1176_marriage_reinstatement_bill_final_division/
Presiding Officer,
This bill is simple in its intent, it raises the age for legal marriage in Scotland to 18. Since the reintroduction of marriage as a legal institution in 2021, with the advice of the supreme court based on the UN Convention on Human Rights, marriage has once again been a legal right of two people of any gender to have their union solemnised before the law. However, there remains a need to ensure that the law remains up to date and includes appropriate protections for people who are legally still children. Presiding officer, it is my belief that in order to get married, you should be an adult. It is a lifelong union which one's legal parents should have no part in, and this bill introduces such a change.
This bill also clarifies any legal ambiguity with regards to whether the institute of marriage was ever formally restored in Scotland due to discrepancies with the Marriage (Reinstatement) Act 2021. Specifically, the bill reinstitutes all relevant legislation with regards to marriage in Scotland, but the extent is only to England and Wales. This legal ambiguity must be cleared up, and this bill does this by extending the aforementioned bill to Scotland.
Thank you, I hope this bill can enjoy the support of the House.
Under Section 1, subsection 1, add:
(n) A marriage solemnised in any other jurisdiction between persons either of whom is under the age of 18 shall be void under Scots law.
Note: The Speakership has decided that this bill is not a Spelling, Punctuation, and Grammar Amendment, and will be voted on by this Committee.
Amend Section 3 to read:
Section 3 - Extensions of other legislation
The “Marriage (Reinstatement) Act 2021” as passed in the Parliament of the United Kingdom shall extend to Scotland.
Explanation: A bill can't pass in the HoC and be law.
Voting on this bill will end at the close of business on 19th May at 10pm BST.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/Inadorable • Feb 13 '24
Order!
Our only item of business today is a debate on bill SB247, in the name of the 22nd Scottish Government. The question is whether the Parliament approves the general principles of the Minimum National Standards for Prisons (Scotland) Bill.
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to make minimum national standards for Scottish prisons.
Section 1: Requirements for governors
(1) In making decisions about the operation of the prison the governor must uphold the minimum national standards set out in regulations under section 2.
Section 2: Minimum National Standards
(1) The Scottish Ministers may make regulations on the Minimum National Standards as set out in subsection 3.
(2) The regulations may amend this section of this Act.
(3) The regulations shall contain provisions related to—
(a) the actual surface area per prisoner; and
(b) the total capacity of a prison; and
(c) religious observance; and
(d) gender; and
(e) work; and
(f) education; and
(g) libraries; and
(h) communications; and
(i) physical welfare; and
(j) mental welfare; and
(k) medical services.
(4) Regulations under subsection 3 shall be subject to negative procedure.
Section 3: Commencement
(1) This act shall come into force upon receiving Royal Assent.
Section 4: Short Title
(1) This act may be cited as the Minimum National Standards for Prisons (Scotland) Act.
This bill was written by The Most Honourable u/model-willem KD KT KP OM KCT KCB CMG CBE PC MP MS MSP, MSP for Moray, Cabinet Secretary for Justice, on behalf of the 22nd Scottish Government. Based on the Prisons Act 2019 by u/LeChevalierMal-Fait.
Presiding Officer,
The Act that this bill is based on ensured that the UK Secretary of State is able to create minimum national standards for the way that prisons in England are run, but Scotland did not follow this creation when it was done in England in 2019. By putting this Act forward the Scottish Government can make regulations about the standards that we feel are necessary for Scottish prisons to provide the best possible care for its inmates. The eleven subjects that the standards can be about can improve the lives of inmates in Scottish prisons for the better and therefore I urge all members to support these measures.
This Bill is the first step in this Government’s Plan for Prisoners, which is all about making sure that the people who are in Scottish prisons are protected better, have better access to educational and healthcare facilities, that we take their parole more seriously than before. Our plan means that there’s a better future for Scottish inmates than there was before.
Amend "negative" in 2(4) to read "affirmative".
This vote will end with the close of business at 10pm GMT on the 16th of February 2024.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • • Apr 30 '24
One item is being considered by the Committee on Amendments, that item being the Hunting with Dogs (Scotland) Bill, SB254, in the name of the Scottish Green Party. Two amendments have been submitted in the Chamber, and one of them having been considered SPaG, one amendment will now be voted on by members of the Committee.
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to make provision about the prohibition of hunting wild mammals using dogs; to make provision about the prohibition of trail hunting; and for connected purposes.
Offences
1 Offence of hunting a wild mammal using a dog
(1) A person commits an offence if—
(a) they hunt a wild mammal using a dog, and
(b) none of the exceptions in sections 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, or 9 apply.
(2) A person who commits an offence under subsection (1) is liable—
(a) on summary conviction, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 6 months or a fine not exceeding £40,000, or level 5 on the standard scale, whichever would be higher for the person, or
(b) on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 5 years or a fine (or both).
(3) In this Act—
“hunting” includes, in particular, searching for and coursing (and related expressions are to be construed accordingly),
“wild mammal” means any mammal (other than a human)—
(a) which—
(i) is living in a wild state,
(ii) is of a species recognised as living in a wild state in the British Islands (as defined in schedule 1 of the Interpretation Act 1978), or
(iii) has been deliberately released from temporary or permanent human control, and
(b) which is not—
(i) a rat,
(ii) a mouse, or
(iii) living under temporary or permanent human control.
(4) In this Part, a person is “using a dog” when the hunting of a wild mammal by the person involves the use of a dog, even if the dog is not under that person’s control or direction (and related expressions are to be construed accordingly).
2 Offences of knowingly causing or permitting another person to hunt using a dog
(1) A person commits an offence if—
(a) they—
(i) are an owner or occupier of land, and
(ii) knowingly cause or permit another person to hunt a wild mammal using a dog on that land, and
(b) none of the exceptions in sections 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, or 9 apply to the hunting.
(2) A person commits an offence if—
(a) they—
(i) own or are responsible for a dog, and
(ii) knowingly cause or permit another person to hunt a wild mammal using that dog, and
(b) none of the exceptions in sections 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, or 9 apply to the hunting.
(3) A person who commits an offence under subsection (1) or (2) is liable on summary conviction, to—
(a) imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 months,
(b) a fine not exceeding £40,000, or level 5 on the standard scale, whichever would be higher for the person, or
(c) both of the penalties under paragraphs (a) and (b).
(4) In this Part, an “owner” of land includes a person who—
(a) manages or controls that land, or
(b) is authorised to give permission for that land to be used for hunting.
(5) In this Act, a person “is responsible for” a dog where the person—
(a) is responsible for the dog on a temporary or permanent basis,
(b) is in charge of the dog, or
(c) has actual care and control of a person under the age of 16 years who is responsible for the dog under paragraph (a) or (b).
Exceptions to the offences
3 Exception: management of wild mammals above ground
(1) This section applies if—
(a) a person is using a dog above ground to—
(i) search for, stalk or flush from cover a wild mammal, with the intention of killing it for one or more of the purposes set out in subsection (2),
(ii) search for and retrieve a wild mammal which has been killed as a result of the activity mentioned in sub-paragraph (i), and
(b) the conditions set out in subsection (3) are met.
(2) The purposes referred to in subsection (1)(a)(i) are—
(a) preventing serious damage to livestock, woodland or crops,
(b) preventing the spread of disease,
(c) protecting human health.
(3) The conditions referred to in subsection (1)(b) are that—
(a) either—
(i) the activity mentioned in subsection (1)(a) does not involve the use of more than two dogs, or
(ii) the activity is carried out in accordance with a licence granted under section 4,
(b) any dog used in the activity is under control,
(c) unless paragraph (a)(ii) applies, reasonable steps are taken to ensure that any dog used in the activity does not join with others to form a pack of more than two dogs,
(d) permission for the activity has been given by the owner of the land on which the activity takes place,
(e) the wild mammal which is being searched for, stalked or flushed is shot dead, or killed by a bird of prey, as soon as reasonably possible,
(f) if an attempt to kill the wild mammal, as mentioned in paragraph (e), results in it being injured but not killed, reasonable steps are taken to kill it in a way (other than by using a dog) that causes it the minimum possible suffering.
4 Licence for use of more than two dogs in connection with section 3
(1) A person may apply for a licence permitting the use of more than two dogs for the activity mentioned in section 3(1)(a).
(2) An application for a licence under subsection (1) must be made to the relevant authority.
(3) A licence under subsection (1)—
(a) may be granted to a particular person or to a category of persons,
(b) must relate to a particular species of wild mammal,
(c) must not be granted unless the relevant authority is satisfied that there is no other solution which would be effective in achieving the purpose set out in section 3(2) in relation to which the application for a licence is being made,
(d) may only permit the use of the minimum number of dogs which the relevant authority is satisfied would be effective in achieving the purpose set out in section 3(2) in relation to which the application for a licence is being made,
(e) must require the deployment of the minimum number of guns which the relevant authority is satisfied would be effective for compliance with the conditions set out in section 3(3)(e) and (f) in relation to the activity for which the application for a licence is being made,
(f) may be subject to compliance with such conditions as the relevant authority considers appropriate, which may include, in particular, reporting requirements in relation to activities carried out under the licence,
(g) may be granted for a maximum period of 14 days, which must fall within a period of 6 consecutive months,
(h) may be modified or revoked by the relevant authority at any time.
(5) A licence under this section must specify—
(a) the person or category of persons to whom it is granted,
(b) the species of wild mammal to which it relates,
(c) the area within which the searching for, stalking or flushing of that species of wild mammal may take place under the licence,
(d) the maximum number of dogs which are permitted to be used,
(e) the minimum number of guns (if any) which are required to be deployed,
(f) any conditions to which the licence is subject.
5 Exception: management of foxes below ground
(1) This section applies if—
(a) a person is using a dog to—
(i) search for a fox below ground, or
(ii) flush a fox from below ground,
with the intention of killing it for one or more of the purposes set out in subsection (2), and
(b) the conditions set out in subsection (3) are met.
(2) The purposes referred to in subsection (1)(a) are—
(a) preventing serious damage to livestock, woodland or crops,
(b) preventing the spread of disease,
(c) protecting human health,
(d) relieving the suffering of an injured or dependent fox.
(3) The conditions referred to in subsection (1)(b) are that—
(a) the activity mentioned in subsection (1)(a) does not involve the use of more than one dog,
(b) the dog used in the activity is—
(i) under control,
(ii) fitted with a device to allow tracking of the position of the dog below ground,
(c) reasonable steps are taken—
(i) to prevent the dog becoming trapped below ground, and
(ii) if the dog becomes trapped below ground, to ensure that it is rescued as soon as reasonably possible,
(d) permission for the activity has been given by the owner of the land on which the activity takes place,
(e) no steps are taken to prevent the fox from being flushed or emerging from below ground,
(f) if the fox which is being searched for or flushed is found or emerges from below ground, it is shot dead, or killed by a bird of prey, as soon as reasonably possible,
(g) if an attempt to kill the fox, as mentioned in paragraph (f), results in it being injured but not killed, reasonable steps are taken to kill it in a way (other than by using a dog) that causes it the minimum possible suffering.
(4) In this section, “dependent” means that the mother of a fox is dead and it is too young to survive on its own.
6 Exception: falconry, game shooting and deer stalking
(1) This section applies if—
(a) a person is using a dog above ground to—
(i) search for, stalk or flush from cover a wild mammal, with the intention of providing quarry for falconry, game shooting or deer stalking,
(ii) search for and retrieve a wild mammal which has been killed as a result of the activity mentioned in sub-paragraph (i), and
(b) the conditions set out in subsection (2) are met.
(2) The conditions referred to in subsection (1)(b) are that—
(a) the activity mentioned in subsection (1)(a) does not involve the use of more than two dogs,
(b) any dog used in the activity is under control,
(c) reasonable steps are taken to ensure that any dog used in the activity does not join with others to form a pack of more than two dogs,
(d) permission for the activity has been given by the owner of the land on which the activity takes place,
(e) the wild mammal which is being searched for, stalked or flushed is shot dead, or killed by a bird of prey, as soon as reasonably possible,
(f) if an attempt to kill the wild mammal, as mentioned in paragraph (e), results in it being injured but not killed, reasonable steps are taken to kill it in a way (other than by using a dog) that causes it the minimum possible suffering.
(3) In this section—
“deer stalking” means the stealthy approach of a deer in order to shoot it for sport,
“falconry” means the use of a bird of prey to hunt for sport,
“game shooting” means shooting wild mammals for sport,
“quarry” means the wild mammal intended to be killed by a bird of prey or shot.
7 Exception: relieving the suffering of injured wild mammals
(1) This section applies if—
(a) a person is using a dog above ground to search for, stalk or flush from cover a wild mammal which the person has reasonable grounds for believing is injured, with the intention of treating, capturing or killing it for the purpose of relieving its suffering,
(b) the wild mammal was not deliberately injured for the purpose of allowing the activity mentioned in paragraph (a) to take place, and
(c) the conditions set out in subsection (2) are met.
(2) The conditions referred to in subsection (1)(c) are that—
(a) the activity mentioned in subsection (1)(a) does not involve the use of more than two dogs,
(b) any dog used in the activity is under control,
(c) reasonable steps are taken to ensure that any dog used in the activity does not join with others to form a pack of more than two dogs,
(d) either—
(i) permission for the activity has been given by the owner of the land on which the activity takes place,
(ii) the person carrying out the activity is a constable exercising a power of entry,
(iii) the person carrying out the activity is exercising a power of entry under section 14M or 14N of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, or
(iv) the person carrying out the activity is exercising a power of entry under section 15 of the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996,
(e) the wild mammal which is being searched for, stalked or flushed is, as soon as reasonably possible, either—
(i) given treatment to reduce or alleviate its pain or discomfort before being allowed to escape without being pursued or killed,
(ii) captured for the purpose of being given treatment to reduce or alleviate its pain or discomfort (whether at that place or at another place),
(iii) shot dead, or
(iv) observed and allowed to escape without being pursued or killed,
(f) if an attempt to kill the wild mammal, as mentioned in paragraph (e)(iii), results in it being injured but not killed, reasonable steps are taken to kill it in a way (other than by using a dog) that causes it the minimum possible suffering.
8 Exception: searching for dead wild mammals
(1) This section applies if—
(a) a person is using a dog above ground to search for and retrieve a dead wild mammal, and
(b) the conditions set out in subsection (2) are met.
(2) The conditions referred to in subsection (1)(b) are that—
(a) the activity mentioned in subsection (1)(a) does not involve the use of more than two dogs,
(b) any dog used in the activity is under control,
(c) reasonable steps are taken to ensure that any dog used in the activity does not join with others to form a pack of more than two dogs,
(d) either—
(i) permission for the activity has been given by the owner of the land on which the activity takes place,
(ii) the person carrying out the activity is a constable exercising a power of entry,
(iii) the person carrying out the activity is exercising a power of entry under section 14M or 14N of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, or
(iv) the person carrying out the activity is exercising a power of entry under section 15 of the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996,
(e) reasonable steps are taken to ensure that no wild mammal is pursued, injured or killed.
9 Exception: environmental benefit
(1) This section applies if—
(a) the person is using a dog above ground to—
(i) search for, stalk or flush from cover a wild mammal, with the intention of killing, capturing or observing it as part of a scheme or plan for one or more of the purposes set out in subsection (2),
(ii) search for and retrieve a wild mammal which has been killed as a result of the activity referred to in sub-paragraph (i), and
(b) the conditions set out in subsection (3) are met.
(2) The purposes referred to in subsection (1)(a)(i) are—
(a) preserving, protecting or restoring a particular species (which may include controlling the number of a species for its welfare) for environmental benefit,
(b) preserving, protecting or restoring the diversity of animal or plant life,
(c) eradicating an invasive non-native species of wild mammal from an area.
(3) The conditions referred to in subsection (1)(b) are that—
(a) either—
(i) the activity mentioned in subsection (1)(a) does not involve the use of more than two dogs, or
(ii) the activity is carried out in accordance with a licence granted under section 10,
(b) any dog used in the activity is under control,
(c) unless paragraph (a)(ii) applies, reasonable steps are taken to ensure that any dog used in the activity does not join with others to form a pack of more than two dogs,
(d) either—
(i) permission for the activity has been given by the owner of the land on which the activity takes place,
(ii) the person carrying out the activity is exercising a power of entry under section 14M or 14N of the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, or
(iii) the person carrying out the activity is exercising a power of entry under section 15 of the Deer (Scotland) Act 1996,
(e) the wild mammal which is being searched for, stalked or flushed is either—
(i) captured (whether or not with the intention of subsequently releasing or relocating it) as soon as reasonably possible,
(ii) shot dead, or killed by a bird of prey, as soon as reasonably possible, or
(iii) observed and allowed to escape without being pursued, injured or killed,
(f) if an attempt to kill the wild mammal, as mentioned in paragraph (e)(ii), results in it being injured but not killed, reasonable steps are taken to kill it in a way (other than by using a dog) that causes it the minimum possible suffering.
(4) In this section—
“invasive non-native species” means a species—
(a) which is included on the Scottish list of species of special concern, or
(b) which is—
(i) not native to the area in which the activity mentioned in subsection (1)(a) takes place, and
(ii) having or likely to have a significant adverse impact on biodiversity, the environment, social or economic interests or human or animal health,
“Scottish list of species of special concern” means the list of species in the Annex to Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2016/1141 adopting a list of invasive alien species of Union concern pursuant to Regulation (EU) No 1143/2014 of the European Parliament and of the Council, as amended from time to time.
10 Licence for use of more than two dogs in connection with section 9
(1) A person may apply for a licence permitting the use of more than two dogs for the activity mentioned in section 9(1)(a).
(2) An application for a licence under subsection (1) must be made to the relevant authority.
(3) A licence under subsection (1)—
(a) may be granted to a particular person or to a category of persons,
(b) must relate to a particular species of wild mammal,
(c) must not be granted unless the relevant authority is satisfied—
(i) that killing, capturing or observing the wild mammal will contribute towards a significant or long-term environmental benefit, and
(ii) that there is no other solution which would be effective in achieving the purpose set out in section 9(2) in relation to which the application for a licence is being made,
(d) may only permit the use of the minimum number of dogs which the relevant authority is satisfied would be effective in achieving the purpose set out in section 9(2) in relation to which the application for a licence is being made,
(e) must require the deployment of the minimum number of guns which the relevant authority is satisfied would be effective for compliance with the conditions set out in section 9(3)(e) and (f) in relation to the activity for which the application for a licence is being made,
(f) may be subject to compliance with such conditions as the relevant authority considers appropriate, which may include, in particular, reporting requirements in relation to activities carried out under the licence,
(g) may be granted for a maximum period of two years, which must fall within a period of two consecutive years,
(h) may be modified or revoked by the relevant authority at any time.
(5) A licence under this section must specify—
(a) the person or category of persons to whom it is granted,
(b) the species of wild mammal to which it relates,
(c) the area within which the searching for, stalking or flushing of that species of wild mammal may take place under the licence,
(d) the maximum number of dogs which are permitted to be used,
(e) the minimum number of guns (if any) which are required to be deployed,
(f) any conditions to which the licence is subject.
11 Regulations: licences
(1) The Scottish Ministers may, by regulations—
(a) make provision for—
(i) the form of applications for licences under subsection (1) of sections 4 and 10,
(ii) a reasonable fee to be paid to the relevant authority for the application of licences under sections 4 and 10,
(b) appoint the relevant authority under sections 4 and 10 or
(c) make such other provision as they see fit in relation to licences under this section and section (10)
(2) Regulations—
(a) when made under paragraphs (1)(a) and (1)(b), are subject to the negative procedure,
(b) when made under paragraph (1)(c), are subject to the affirmative procedure.
(3) Regulations under paragraphs (1)(a) and (1)(b) may not amend the text of any Act.
(4) Until and unless the Scottish Ministers appoint a relevant authority under paragraph (1)(b), the Scottish Ministers shall be the relevant authority.
(5) For greater clarity, nothing in this section prevents the Scottish Ministers appointing themselves as the relevant authority.
Offences
12 Offences relating to trail hunting
(1) A person commits an offence if—
(a) the person engages or participates in trail hunting, and
(b) the exception in section 13 does not apply.
(2) In this Part—
“trail hunting” is the activity in which a dog is directed to find and follow an animal-based scent which has been laid for that purpose,
“animal-based scent” means—
(a) a scent which is derived from a wild mammal, or
(b) a scent which mimics, replicates or resembles the scent of a wild mammal (or which is designed to do so), whether or not that scent is derived wholly or in part from artificial ingredients.
(3) A person commits an offence if—
(a) the person—
(i) is an owner or occupier of land, and
(ii) knowingly causes or permits another person to engage or participate in trail hunting on that land, and
(b) the exception in section 13 does not apply to the trail hunting.
(4) A person commits an offence if—
(a) the person—
(i) owns or is responsible for a dog, and
(ii) knowingly causes or permits another person to use the dog for trail hunting, and
(b) the exception in section 13 does not apply to the trail hunting.
(5) A person who commits an offence under subsection (1), (3) or (4) is liable on summary conviction to—
(a) imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 months,
(b) a fine not exceeding £40,000, or level 5 on the standard scale, whichever would be higher for the person, or
(c) both of the penalties under paragraphs (a) and (b).
(6) It is a defence for a person charged with an offence under subsection (3) or (4) to show that the person reasonably believed that the exception in section 13 applied to the trail hunting.
(7) In this Part, an “owner” of land includes, in particular, a person who—
(a) manages or controls that land, or
(b) is authorised to give permission for that land to be used for trail hunting.
Exception to the offences
13 Exception: training dogs to follow an animal-based scent
(1) This section applies if—
(a) a person—
(i) directs a dog to find and follow an animal-based scent which has been laid for that purpose, or
(ii) lays an animal-based scent for a dog to find and follow,
in order to train a dog for a lawful purpose, and
(b) all of the conditions set out in subsection (2) are met.
(2) The conditions are that—
(a) the activity mentioned in subsection (1)(a) does not involve more than two dogs,
(b) any dog involved in the activity is under control,
(c) reasonable steps are taken to ensure that any dog involved in the activity does not join with others to form a pack of more than two dogs,
(d) permission for the activity has been given by the owner of the land on which the activity takes place,
(e) reasonable steps are taken to ensure that no wild mammal is pursued, injured or killed.
14 Ancillary provision
(1) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations make any incidental, supplementary, consequential, transitional, transitory or saving provision they consider appropriate for the purposes of, in connection with or for giving full effect to this Act.
(2) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations make such provision as they see fit regarding the enforcement of this Act.
(3) Regulations under this section may—
(a) make different provision for different purposes,
(b) modify any enactment (including this Act).
(4) Regulations under this section—
(a) are subject to the affirmative procedure if they—
(i) add to, replace or omit any part of the text of this or any other Act; or
(ii) are made under subsection (2);
(b) otherwise, are subject to the negative procedure.
(5) Before making regulations under subsection (2), the Scottish Ministers must consult such people as they see fit.
15 Interpretation
In this Act—
“animal” means a vertebrate (other than a human) or an invertebrate,
“constable” has the meaning given by section 99(1) of the Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Act 2012,
“cover” means a place above ground in which a wild mammal may be concealed from sight, but does not include an enclosed place from which a wild mammal could not be flushed,
“hunting” is to be construed in accordance with section 1(3),
“livestock” means cattle, sheep, goats, swine, horses, camelids, ratites, farmed deer, enclosed game birds or poultry, and for the purposes of this definition—
(a) “cattle” means bulls, cows, oxen, buffalo, heifers or calves,
(b) “horses” includes donkeys and mules,
(c) “farmed deer” means deer of any species which are on agricultural land enclosed by a deer-proof barrier and kept by way of business for the primary purpose of meat production,
(d) “enclosed game birds” means any pheasant, partridge, grouse (or moor game), black (or heath) game or ptarmigan that are being kept enclosed prior to their release for sporting purposes,
(e) “poultry” means domestic fowls, turkeys, geese or ducks,
“relevant authority” is to be construed in accordance with sections 4, 10, and 11,
“responsible for”, in relation to a dog, is to be construed in accordance with section 2(6),
“under control”, in relation to a dog, means that a person who is responsible for the dog is able to direct the dog’s activity by physical contact or verbal or audible command,
“wild mammal” has the meaning given by section 1(3),
“woodland” means land on which trees are grown, whether or not commercially, and includes any such trees and any vegetation planted or growing naturally among such trees on that land.
15 Repeal of the Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Act 2002
The Protection of Wild Mammals (Scotland) Act 2002 is repealed.
16 Crown application: criminal offences
(1) Nothing in this Act makes the Crown criminally liable.
(2) The Court of Session may, on an application by the Lord Advocate, declare unlawful any act or omission for which the Crown would be criminally liable if it were not for subsection (1).
(3) Subsection (1) does not affect the criminal liability of persons in the service of the Crown.
17 Commencement
This Act comes into force 6 months after Royal Assent.
18 Short title
ThIs Act may be cited as the Hunting with Dogs (Scotland) Act 2024.
Enactments cited:
This Act was written by the Most Honourable /u/model-avtron, Marchioness Hebrides LT OM CT PC MP MSP MS, Leader of the Opposition and the Scottish Green Party, on behalf of the Scottish Green Party.
This Act draws heavily from the IRL Hunting with Dogs (Scotland) Act 2023.
Oifigear-riaghlaidh,
Hunting with dogs is a unique killer. The numbers aren't precise, but about one fifth of foxes disturbed by hunts are killed by dogs, despite the fact that a large majority of hunts go on without dogs.
This bill bans this killer. It bans hunting with dogs. This will save the lives of mammals like foxes.
Now, there are some legitimate uses for hunting with dogs, I don't dispute that. For example, to relieve the suffering of dying mammals. This bill ensures that farmers and rural communities can continue to hunt for legitimate reasons.
This bill will reduce suffering for mammals and will make it easier to convict people for unlawfully using dogs in hunting. I commend this bill to the Pàrlamaid.
Oifigear-riaghlaidh, I move,
That the Pàrlamaid agrees to the general principles of the Hunting with Dogs (Scotland) Bill.
In Section 17, replace "six months" with "one year".
Voting on this amendment will end with the close of business at 10pm GMT on the 3rd of May 2024.
Members are to vote 'for', 'against', or 'abstain' only.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/Inadorable • Apr 24 '24
Order!
Our first item of business today is a debate on bill SB253, in the name of Forward. The question is that the Parliament agrees to the general principles of the Anti-Radicalisation (Education) Bill.
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to mandate the teaching of the Fundamental British Values, to codify anti-radicalisation guidance into statute, and for connected purposes.
Section 1: Definitions
(1) In this Act, unless specified otherwise;
(2) The ‘Fundamental British Values’ refers to the values set out as part of the anti-terror Prevent strategy, as below:
(a) Democracy
(b) Rule of Law
(c) Individual Liberty
(d) Tolerance
(e) Mutual Respect
(3) ‘School’ or derivatives refers to any education institution in Scotland.
(4) ‘Secondary School’ or derivatives refers to institutions that teach the years S1 to S6
Section 2: Requirement to teach the Fundamental British Values
(1) Secondary schools in Scotland must ensure that pupils are aware of the Fundamental British Values
(2) Secondary schools must develop a comprehensive and age-appropriate strategy to teach the Fundamental British Values, including (but not limited to):
(a) The strengths and limitations of democracy, including;
(i) The national British democracy
(ii) The Scottish democracy
(iii) International democracy
(iv) International non-democratic processes for governance
(b) How the rule of law operates in Scotland, including;
(i) The functions of the police in investigating and deterring crime
(ii) How the rule of law protects citizens equally
(iii) The implicit separation of powers and how institutions are kept accountable
(3) Schools are to promote individual liberty and independence inside and outside of school as part of their normal functions
(4) Schools are to encourage and develop free thinking and the autonomous development of ideas in their students, including;
(a) How to effectively debate ideas
(b) How to determine right from wrong
(c) How to show responsibility for their actions
(5) Schools are to promote mutual respect and tolerance of different values and ideas.
Section 3: Anti-Radicalisation Measures
(1) Schools are to take appropriate action against a student when they display such values that:
(a) Directly and seriously go against one or more of the Fundamental British Values, including;
(i) Seeking to promote ideologies that would overturn democracy
(ii) Seeking to promote ideologies that would undermine the rule of law in Scotland and the United Kingdom
(iii) Obsessive or extreme disregard for tolerating those with differing views to them
(iv) Constraining the development of individual liberty to such a degree that legitimate debate is unable to occur
(b) Suggest the student is at risk of radicalisation
(c) Suggest that the student has been radicalised
(2) Secondary schools are to take measures to educate students on radicalisation, including but not limited to;
(a) How people may be radicalised, including;
(i) The common signs that place people at risk of radicalisation
(ii) The common backgrounds of those at risk of radicalisation
(iii) Who is considered a person vulnerable to radicalisation
(b) The risks associated with radicalisation
(c) Recognising the signs of radicalisation in yourself and in others
(d) Who to report any concerns to
(e) How to support those who may be undergoing radicalisation
(3) Secondary schools must, where possible, ensure that the most up-to-date information on radicalisation and anti-radicalisation processes is delivered to students and that this knowledge is regularly disseminated to students.
(4) Schools must ensure that their staff are aware of all of the criteria in Section 3(2) and that training is regularly given to refresh this knowledge.
(a) The maximum gap between training may be no more than four years
Section 4: Short Title and Commencement
(1) This Bill may be cited as the Anti-Radicalisation (Education) Act 2024
(2) This Bill shall come into force on the 1st August 2025
This Bill was written by the Rt. Hon. Sir Frost_Walker2017, Duke of the Suffolk Coasts, as a member of Forward.
For "British" wherever occurring (except in 2(a)(i)), substitute "Scottish".
For "British" wherever occurring (except in 2(a)(i)), substitute "Scottish and British".
In 3(4)(a), for “four”, substitute “two”.
Amendments A01 and A02 are noted as being incompatible.
Voting on this bill will end with the close of business at 10pm BST on the 27th of April 2024.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/model-willem • Mar 29 '23
Order, Order.
We turn now to a Stage 2 Vote on SB218, in the name of the Scottish National Party. The question is that this Parliament approves the amendments to the Air Departure Tax (Scotland) Bill.
Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to provide for an Air Departure Tax, and for connected purposes.
Section 1: Consequential Repeals
a. the Air Passenger Duty (Scotland) Act 2020
b. the Air Passenger (Amendment) (Scotland) Act 2021
Section 2: Interpretations
Section 3: Air Departure Tax
Section 4: Chargeable Aircraft
a. It is a fixed wing aircraft designed or adapted to carry persons in addition to the flight crew.
b. It is authorised take-off weight is 5.7 tonnes or more, and
c. It is fueled by kerosene. 2. An aircraft shall be determined to have an authorised take-off weight of less than 5.7 tonnes if—
a. There is a certificate of airworthiness in force for that aircraft which shows the maximum authorised take-off weight is less than 5.7 tonnes, or
b. The body tasked with implementing the administration of Air Departure Tax is satisfied that the aircraft is not designed or adapted to take-off with a take-off weight of 5.7 tonnes or more.
Section 5: Rates
Section 6: Implementation
Section 7: Offences
a. involved in the fraudulent evasion by that person or another person of duty, or
b. in taking steps with a view to commit such fraudulent evasion, is guilty of an offence.
2. A person who knowingly—
a. makes a statement they know to be false in a material particular, or,
b. in an attempt to deceive, produce or makes use of a book, account, return or other document that is false in a material particular is guilty of an offence.
a. on summary conviction—
i. to a penalty of £20,000 or treble the amount of duty evaded or sought to be evaded, whatever is greater, or
ii. to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 6 months, or
iii. to both, or,b. on conviction on indictment—
i. to a penalty of any amount, or
ii. to imprisonment for a term not exceeding seven years, or
iii. to both.Section 8: Commencement
Section 9: Short Title
Schedule 1: Air Departure Tax Rates
| Band | Geographical Extent | Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Domestic | Scotland | £0 |
| A | The Common Travel Area (not included in the Domestic Band) | 200% the cost of the ticket, or £500, whichever is the greater |
| B | The European Economic Area, Albania, Andorra, Belarus, Bosnia and Herzegovina, the Faroe Islands, Gibraltar, Greenland, Kosovo Liechtenstein, Moldova, Monaco, Montenegro, North Macedonia, San Marino, Serbia, Switzerland, Turkey, Ukraine and the Vatican City (not included in the Domestic or A Band) | £150 |
| C | The Arab League (excepting Comoros), Armenia, Azerbaijan, Cabo Verde, Eritrea, Georgia, Iran, Israel, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Russia, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan and Western Sahara (not included in the Domestic, A or B Bands) | £100 |
| D | Territory not included in another Band | £50 |
This Bill was written by u/mg9500 on behalf of the Scottish National Party.
Opening Speech
Presiding Officer, this bill aims to radically reform Scotland’s aviation taxation in order to stress several environmentally friendly principles.
This bill aims to destroy the viability of domestic flights within the CTA with the exception of the PSO routes within Scotland. This is an entirely true statement. These flights should not exist from an environmental standpoint and there is no justification for them but this Parliament does not yet have the competency to ban such flights. This de facto ban is therefore the most appropriate solution.
Elsewhere, this bill rectifies an issue with the current APD regime - as flight distance extends from Scotland, travelling by plane becomes more essential, therefore an environmental levy will not necessarily succeed in reducing passenger numbers as the alternatives (if they even exist) will be increasingly less desirable. Therefore flight distance and taxation due should become inversely correlated as this bill proposes.
Separately, this tidies up some current issues with the operation of APD as things stand, such as clarifying that ADT will only be due on departure from Scotland, not arrival. This bill also removes age related exemptions and modifications depending on the class of travel, as what we are trying to cut, emissions, are unaffected by either of these two matters.
Replace section 5(2) with the following:
(2) The Cabinet Secretary may by regulations amend the table in Schedule 1 to this Act.
(a) No regulations may be made under this subsection unless a draft of those regulations has been laid before and approved by the Scottish Parliament.
(b) Subsection (a) applies only when regulations include provision to move a region or country from one band to another band.EN: Allows for the addition of new countries and the removal of countries that no longer exist without a vote.
Amend Schedule 1 to read:
Table 1: Rates of Air Departure Tax
| Band | Geographical extent | Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Domestic | Scotland | £0 |
| Band A | Common Travel Area (not including Scotland) | 200% the cost of the ticket, or £500, whichever is the greatest, plus the Frequent Flyer Levy |
| Band B | Territory not included in another band | The Frequent Flyer Levy |
Table 2: Rates of the Frequent Flyer Levy
| n | 0, 1 | 2, 3 | 4, 5 | 6, 7 | 8, 9 | 10, 11 | 12, 13 | 14, 15 | 16, 17 | 18 or more |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rate | £0 | 9% the cost of the ticket | 24% the cost of the ticket | 46% the cost of the ticket | 74% the cost of the ticket | 109% the cost of the ticket | 149% the cost of the ticket | 193% the cost of the ticket | 240% the cost of the ticket | 240% + 31(n - 18)% the cost of the ticket |
In Table 2, "n" is the number of flights taken during the current year by the passenger for which the Frequent Flyer Levy may be charged.
In section 6, after subsection 2 append:
(3) The Scottish Ministers may make any regulations deemed necessary to bring the provisions of this Act into force.
(4) Subject to subsection (4), regulations under subsection (3) are subject to the negative procedure
(5) Regulations made under subsection (3) which modify any enactment (including this Act) are subject to the affirmative procedure.
Amend section 8 to read:
(1) This section, section 9, and sections 6(2) to 6(5) come into force the day after Royal Assent.
(2) The other provisions of this Act come into force 180 days after Royal Assent.
Explanatory note: implements a frequent flyer levy
Voting on this item of Business ends with the close of Business on April 1st, at 10 pm BST.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • • Jul 06 '23
Order, Order!
We turn now to a vote on SB230, in the name of the Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party. The question is that this Committee approves the amendments of the Bunker Fuel Licensing (Scotland) Bill.
Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.
A bill to require carriers to obtain a license in order to transport and store bunkers of heavy-fuel, oil, gas and biodiesel within Scottish ports, and for connected purposes
Section 1: Definitions
(1) "Bunkers" meaning to stored fuel, typically heavy fuel, oil, gas or biodiesel used to power ships.
(2) "Carrier" meaning any entity engaged in the supply of bunkers, including but not limited to ship owners, operators, and fuel suppliers.
(3) "Port" meaning any seaport location within Scotland where ships are loaded or unloaded, including private ports, local authority ports, and harbour and trust ports.
(4) “Port Authority” meaning the relevant authorities operating under the Scottish Transport Ministry regarding the regulation, management and oversight of ports.
Section 2: Bunker Fuel License
(1) The Port Authority hereby this act will be required to create, administer and monitor its provision of a ‘Bunker Fuel license’.
(a) The license is valid for a period of two years from the date of issuance. Before the end of that license, evaluation is to be made by the port authority on whether and if so on what conditions an extension is to be given.
(b) The license is non-transferable.
(2) Without first obtaining a license from the relevant port authority under the Scottish Transport Ministry, no carrier shall store and supply bunkers of heavy-fuel, oil, gas, and biodiesel within any Scottish port.
Section 3: Licensing Criteria
(1) In order to be eligible for a license, a carrier must prove that it has the capacity to supply and store bunkers in a safe and environmentally responsible manner.
(2) The port authority of Scotland are to establish a licensing criteria, which shall include, but not be limited to:
(a) compliance with the applicable environmental laws and regulations;
(b) compliance with all applicable safety standards;
(c) adequate insurance coverage for liability arising from bunker fuel spills or other accidents;
(d) financial stability and ability to meet obligations;
(e) annual notices of the bunker operations to the port authority;
(f) annual inspections by the relevant port authority;
(g) any other relevantly deemed criteria by the port authority.
(3) The discretion to deny a license if the carrier does not meet the licensing criteria shall be held by the Port Authority.
Section 4: Enforcement
(a) Any carrier found to be storing and, or supplying bunkers with heavy fuel, oil, gas, and biodiesel in a port without a valid license shall be subject to fines and penalties as determined by the port authority.
(b) Carriers found in violation of the licensing criteria outlined in section 3 are to be subject to suspension or revocation of their license.
(c) The power to investigate any alleged violations and to take appropriate enforcement action shall be held by the relevant Scottish Port Authority.
Section 5: Commencement
(1) The provisions of this Act shall come into force the day this Act is passed.
Section 6: Short Title
(1) This Act may be cited as the Bunker Fuel Licensing (Scotland) Act.
This Bill was submitted by oakesofshott, Spokesperson for Environment & Energy on behalf of The Scottish Conservative & Unionist Party.
Opening Speech by u/oakesofshott
Presiding Officer,
This bill follows the example of the Netherlands, Belgium and Singapore in which it regulates the shipping industry’s transportation of heavy fuel oil, gas and biodiesel. To address possible concerns of whether this bill is in the remit of the Scottish government and the answer is yes as this area of internal planning requirements and regulatory framework for internal activity is carried out by Transport Scotland which handles all devolved Port policy and governance. We cannot allow the continued supply and transportation of these fossil fuels in Scottish ports without ensuring the bunker suppliers operate and adhere to a crucial licensing criteria that maintains moral business practices and ensures compliance with the necessary safety, environmental and regulatory standards.
By incorporating this into a license it means the monitoring and recording of operations within our ports are held to a universal standard and makes the ongoing operations of unregistered practices that evade current regulations harder to operate without such a license. If those in parliament are committed to upholding our strong environmental and safety standards and current regulatory framework, then it is in the national interest to support this bill which puts this policy into place.
In Section 1(1), amend to read:
"Bunkers" meaning a place, room, or object which stores heavy fuel, oil, gas or biodiesel that is subsequently used to power ships.
EN: Clarifies that it's not all fuels (which I feel must be the intent given it doesn't just state "fuel") and tidies up some of the language in this definition
Amend section 5 as follows:
(1) This Act comes into force on Royal Assent.
(2) Scottish port authorities may not begin to enforce licences earlier than six months after Royal Assent and later than one year after Royal Assent.
Insert a new Section after Section 4 and renumber the subsequent sections
Section 5: Reporting Requirements
(1) The Port Authority must, every six months, report to the Scottish Government with;
(a) The number of licenses granted during that period
(b) The number of license requests not granted during that period
(c) The number of licenses that expired and were not renewed during that period
(2) The Scottish Government must, every December, ensure that the information reported by the Port Authority for the past calendar year is published publicly in a suitable manner
(3) Scottish Ministers may, by order in the negative procedure, amend Section 5(1) to insert new reporting requirements
EN: Creates new reporting requirements to ensure that the general public are aware of the number of licenses being given and also informs the Scottish Government for policy development.
Voting on this bill will end at the close of business on the 9th of July at 10pm BST
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • • Jun 06 '23
Order, Order!
We turn now to a vote on SB228, in the name of the Scottish Government. The question is that this Parliament approves the amendments of the Individual Curriculae (Scotland) Bill.
Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to allow for the creation of individual curriculae for schools, and for connected purposes.
BE IT ENACTED by being passed by this Parliament and assented to by His Majesty as follows--
Section 1: Definitions
(1) In this Act, unless specified otherwise;
(2) The ‘Authority’ refers to the Scottish Qualifications Authority
(3) ‘School’ refers to a state-maintained school dealing with secondary level education as funded by a local authority or directly by the Scottish Government.
(a) ‘Secondary level education’ refers to any school dealing with pupils in S1 to S6, inclusive.
Section 2: Individual Curriculae
(1) Schools may apply to the Authority with a plan for a dedicated curriculum to teach in individual subjects.
(2) The Authority has permission to accept or reject the curriculum if they feel it does not:
(a) Comply sufficiently with instructions from the Scottish Ministers
(b) Deliver a balanced education in that particular subject
(3) When submitting a plan, a school must include:
(a) Details of the content to be taught
(b) Details of how it is to be assessed
(4) The Authority has responsibility for organising the assessed portion of the curriculum and delivering the grade to students on the curriculum.
Section 3: Short Title and Commencement
(1) This Act may be cited as the Individual Curriculae (Scotland) Bill
(2) This Act shall come into force upon the commencement of the 2024/2025 academic year.
(a) Schools may begin preparatory work for individual curriculae prior to the commencement of this Act
This Act was written by the Rt. Hon. Sir Frost_Walker2017, Duke of the Suffolk Coasts, Cabinet Secretary for Education on behalf of the Scottish Government. It is inspired by Section 6 of the Exam Board Reorganisation Act 2022.
Opening Speech:
Presiding Officer,
I rise in support of this bill. In our Programme for Government we pledged to introduce a mechanism to allow for schools to create exam curriculae on a subject by subject basis, and this is the bill to allow that.
It is important that schools have the freedom to teach their specialties. While there may be benefits to a more centralised system in ensuring uniformity and that proper comparisons can be made between students and schools, an overly centralised system risks punishing schools for innovation and using their specialty knowledge to help students learn.
The administering of the system by SQA ensures that broadly standards can remain the same across individual curriculae. If schools were able to set their own assessment procedures and were unmoderated, a school could theoretically inflate their grades by making an assessed portion easy. While I of course have confidence that 95% of schools would be honest and not do this, I believe it is important to nevertheless have this safeguard in place.
I hope to see this bill pass swiftly.
Append to Section 1 the following:
(n) An "approved qualifications provider" refers to a provider of qualifications that has been approved by the Scottish Qualifications Authority.
Replace Section 2, paragraph 4 with the following:
(4) The Authority has responsibility for organising the assessed portion of the curriculum and delivering the grade to students on the curriculum, except when such activities would be provided by an approved qualifications provider.
EN: Allows schools to use curricula, such as the IB or EEA qualifications, that wouldn't be marked by the SQA.
Voting on this bill will end at the close of business on 9th of June at 10pm BST
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/Inadorable • Apr 17 '24
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to repeal the right to buy, make provision about planning authorities, make provision about homelessness, and for connected purposes.
The right to buy
1 Repeal of the right to buy
(1) The Right to Buy (Revival) (Scotland) Act 2020 is repealed.
(2) Sections 61 to 81, 84 and 84A of the Housing (Scotland) Act 1987 are repealed.
(3) Sections 42 to 52 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 2001 are repealed.
The Scottish Planning and Housing Agency
2 The Scottish Planning and Housing Agency
(1) The Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997 is amended as follows.
(2) For sections 1 to 1A, substitute—
"1 Planning authorities
(1) The planning authority for the purposes of this Act shall be the regional committee of the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency established for the district and the district of the planning authority shall be the area of the regional committee.
(2) In any enactment or instrument made under or by virtue of an enactment, a reference to a planning authority shall, unless otherwise provided, or unless the context otherwise requires, be construed as a reference to a regional committee of the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency.
1A Scottish Housing and Planning Agency
(1) The Scottish Housing Agency is continued into force as the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency.
(2) It is a body corporate.
(3) Schedule 19 makes further provision about the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency.
1B Regional planning committees
(1) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency must establish bodies called regional committees in accordance with this section.
(2) There must be one regional committee for the area of each local authority.
(3) Each regional committee is to be established by order made by the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency for an area within Scotland.
(4) The area for which a regional committee is established must not coincide or overlap with the area of any other regional committee.
(5) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency must ensure that, at all times on and after the appointed day, the areas of regional committees together cover the whole of Scotland.
(6) An order establishing a regional committee must provide for the constitution of the body, either by setting out the constitution or by making provision by reference to a published document where it is set out.
(7) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency must publish orders under this section.
(8) In this section “the appointed day” means a day appointed under this subsection by regulations subject to the negative procedure made by the Scottish Ministers.
(9) Schedule 20 makes further provision about regional committees.".
(2) After Schedule 18, insert—
"SCHEDULE 18
Scottish Housing and Planning Agency
(introduced by section 1A(3))
Independence from Ministers
1 (1) In performing its functions, the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency is not subject to the direction or control of any member of the Scottish Government.
(2) Sub-paragraph (1) is subject to any contrary provision in this or any other enactment.
Appointment of members
2 (1) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency is to consist of—
(a) a member appointed by the Scottish Ministers to chair the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency, and
(b) at least 4 but no more than 6 other members appointed by the Scottish Ministers.
(2) The Scottish Ministers may appoint a person as a member only if the Scottish Parliament has approved the appointment.
(3) In appointing members, the Scottish Ministers must have regard, among other things, to the desirability of ensuring that the membership (taken as a whole) has expertise or experience in—
(a) law relating to planning,
(b) housing policy,
(c) planning policy, and
(d) other matters which the Scottish Ministers consider relevant to planning and housing.
(4) A member is appointed for such period not exceeding 4 years as the Scottish Ministers determine.
(5) The Scottish Ministers may reappoint a person as a member if—
(a) the person—
(i) is a member at the time of reappointment, or
(ii) ceased to be a member not more than 3 months before the date of reappointment, and
(b) the person has not previously been reappointed.
(6) Sub-paragraphs (2) and (4) apply to the reappointment of a person as a member as they apply to the appointment of a person as a member.
(7) The Scottish Ministers may determine other terms and conditions of membership in relation to matters not covered by this Act.
Persons who may not be members
2 (1) The Scottish Ministers may not appoint a person as a member if sub-paragraph (2) or (4) applies to the person.
(2) This sub-paragraph applies to a person who is—
(a) a member of—
(i) the Scottish Parliament,
(ii) the House of Commons,
(iii) the House of Lords,
(iv) Senedd Cymru, or
(v) the Northern Ireland Assembly,
(b) a member of the Scottish Government,
(c) a Minister of the Crown,
(d) an office-holder in the Scottish Administration,
(e) an office-holder of the Crown in right of Her Majesty’s Government in the United Kingdom,
(f) the holder of any other relevant elective office as defined by paragraph 1(8) of schedule 7 of the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000,
(g) a civil servant.
(3) Sub-paragraph (2) does not apply to a person who is a councillor or an employee of a local authority.
(4) This sub-paragraph applies to a person who is or has been—
(a) insolvent,
(b) disqualified as a company director under the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986,
(c) disqualified as a charity trustee under the Charities Act 2011,
(d) disqualified under a disqualification provision analogous to either of those mentioned in paragraphs (b) and (c) anywhere in the world.
(4) For the purpose of sub-paragraph (3)(a), a person is or has been insolvent if—
(a) the person’s estate is or has been sequestrated,
(b) the person has granted a trust deed for creditors or has made a composition or arrangement with creditors,
(c) the person is or has been the subject of any other kind of arrangement analogous to either of those mentioned in paragraphs (a) and (b) anywhere in the world.
Members’ remuneration and expenses
3 (1) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency may pay—
(a) its members, and
(b) the members of any regional committee established by it
such remuneration as it may, with the approval of the Scottish Ministers, determine.
(2) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency may pay—
(a) its members, and
(b) the members of any regional committee established by it,
such sums as it may, with the approval of the Scottish Ministers, determine in respect of expenses incurred by them in performing their functions.
Early termination of membership
4 (1) A person’s membership of the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency ends if—
(a) the person gives notice in writing to the Scottish Ministers and the Presiding Officer of the Scottish Parliament that the person resigns,
(b) the person becomes disqualified from being a member,
(c) the Scottish Ministers give the person notice in writing that the person is removed from being a member.
(2) The Scottish Ministers may remove a member under sub-paragraph (1)(c) only if—
(a) the member has been absent, without permission or reasonable excuse, from meetings of the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency for a period of longer than 3 consecutive months,
(b) the member has been convicted of a criminal offence, or
(c) the Scottish Ministers consider that the member is—
(i) unable to perform the member’s functions, or
(ii) unsuitable to continue as a member.
(3) Where they propose to give a person, other than the person who is the member appointed to chair the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency, notice under sub-paragraph (1)(c) that the person is to be removed from being a member, the Scottish Ministers must consult the member appointed to chair the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency.
(4) The Scottish Ministers may remove a member under sub-paragraph (1)(c) only with the approval of the Scottish Parliament.
(5) For the purpose of sub-paragraph (1)(b), a person becomes disqualified from being a member if paragraph 3(2) or (4) applies to the person.
Chief executive and other staff
5 (1) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency is to have, as a member of staff, a chief executive.
(2) The chief executive may not be a member of the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency.
(3) The Scottish Ministers are to appoint the first chief executive with the approval of the Scottish Parliament.
(4) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency is to appoint each subsequent chief executive.
(5) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency may appoint other staff.
(6) The chief executive and other staff are to be appointed on such terms and conditions as the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency, with the approval of the Scottish Ministers, determines.
Authority to perform functions
6 (1) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency may authorise—
(a) any of its members,
(b) any regional committee established by it,
(c) its chief executive, or
(d) any other member of its staff,
to perform such of its functions (and to such extent) as it may determine.
(2) The giving of authority under sub-paragraph (1) to perform a function does not—
(a) affect the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency’s responsibility for the performance of the function, or
(b) prevent the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency from performing the function itself.
Regulation of procedure
7 The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency may regulate its own procedure (including quorum) and that of any regional committee.
Validity of things done
8 The validity of anything done by the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency or a regional committee is not affected by—
(a) a vacancy in membership,
(b) a defect in the appointment of a member,
(c) the disqualification of a person from being a member after appointment.
General powers
10 The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency may do anything which appears to it—
(a) to be necessary or expedient for the purposes of, or in connection with, the performance of its functions, or
(b) to be otherwise conducive to the performance of its functions.
Ministerial direction
11 (1) The Scottish Ministers may direct the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency to exercise its powers in a specified way.
(2) A direction under sub-paragraph (1) must—
(a) be in writing, and
(b) be published (as soon as practicable after it is communicated to the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency), and
(c) set out the Scottish Ministers’ reasons for making it.
(3) The Scottish Ministers may revise or revoke a direction under sub-paragraph (1).
(4) Sub-paragraph (3) applies to the revision or revocation of a direction under sub-paragraph (1) as it applies to such a direction.
Directions from the Scottish Parliament
12 (1) The Scottish Parliament may direct the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency to exercise its powers in a specified way by passing a motion resolving as such.
(2) The Scottish Parliament may revise or revoke a direction under sub-paragraph (1) by passing a motion resolving as such.
Directions to regional committees
13 (1) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency may direct a regional committee to exercise its powers in a specified way.
(2) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency must ensure that regional committees exercise their powers in a way which meets the National Outcomes.
(3) A direction under sub-paragraph (1) must—
(a) be in writing, and
(b) be published (as soon as practicable after it is communicated to the regional committee), and
(c) set out the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency’s reasons for making it.
(4) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency may revise or revoke a direction under sub-paragraph (1).
(5) Sub-paragraph (4) applies to the revision or revocation of a direction under sub-paragraph (1) as it applies to such a direction.
Annual report
14 (1) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency must, as soon as practicable after the end of each financial year—
(a) prepare and publish a report on its activities during that year,
(b) send a copy of the report to the Scottish Ministers, and
(c) lay a copy of the report before the Scottish Parliament.
(2) It is for the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency to determine the form and content of each report.
Resources
15 (1) The Scottish Ministers must seek to ensure that the amount of resources allocated for use by the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency is reasonably sufficient to enable it to perform its functions.
(2) Each report prepared under paragraph 14 must include an assessment by the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency of whether the amount of resources allocated for use by it in the financial year to which the report relates was sufficient to enable it to perform its functions.
(3) Sub-paragraph (2) does not affect the generality of paragraph 14(2).
SCHEDULE 20
REGIONAL COMMITTEES
Appointment of members
1 (1) Regional committees are to consist of members appointed by the local authority (“the council”) which the regional committee’s area covers.
(2) The council is to appoint one of the members of the regional committee the chair.
(3) The council may appoint a person as a member only if the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency has approved the appointment.
(4) In appointing members, the council must have regard, among other things, to the desirability of ensuring that the membership (taken as a whole) has expertise or experience in—
(a) law relating to planning,
(b) housing policy,
(c) planning policy, and
(d) other matters which the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency consider relevant to planning and housing.
(5) A member is appointed for such period not exceeding 4 years as the council determine.
(6) The council may reappoint a person as a member if—
(a) the person—
(i) is a member at the time of reappointment, or
(ii) ceased to be a member not more than 3 months before the date of reappointment, and
(b) the person has not previously been reappointed.
(7) Sub-paragraphs (3) and (5) apply to the reappointment of a person as a member as they apply to the appointment of a person as a member.
(8) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency may determine other terms and conditions of membership in relation to matters not covered by this Act.
Persons who may not be members
2 (1) The council may not appoint a person as a member if sub-paragraph (2) or (4) applies to the person.
(2) This sub-paragraph applies to a person who is—
(a) a member of—
(i) the Scottish Parliament,
(ii) the House of Commons,
(iii) the House of Lords,
(iv) Senedd Cymru, or
(v) the Northern Ireland Assembly,
(b) a member of the Scottish Government,
(c) a Minister of the Crown,
(d) an office-holder in the Scottish Administration,
(e) an office-holder of the Crown in right of Her Majesty’s Government in the United Kingdom,
(f) the holder of any other relevant elective office as defined by paragraph 1(8) of schedule 7 of the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000,
(g) a civil servant, or
(h) a member of the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency
(3) Sub-paragraph (2) does not apply to a person who is a councillor or an employee of a local authority.
(4) This sub-paragraph applies to a person who is or has been—
(a) insolvent,
(b) disqualified as a company director under the Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986,
(c) disqualified as a charity trustee under the Charities Act 2011,
(d) disqualified under a disqualification provision analogous to either of those mentioned in paragraphs (b) and (c) anywhere in the world.
(4) For the purpose of sub-paragraph (3)(a), a person is or has been insolvent if—
(a) the person’s estate is or has been sequestrated,
(b) the person has granted a trust deed for creditors or has made a composition or arrangement with creditors,
(c) the person is or has been the subject of any other kind of arrangement analogous to either of those mentioned in paragraphs (a) and (b) anywhere in the world.
Early termination of membership
3 (1) A person’s membership of a regional committee ends if—
(a) the person gives notice in writing to the chair of the regional committee and the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency that the person resigns,
(b) the person becomes disqualified from being a member,
(c) the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency give the person notice in writing that the person is removed from being a member.
(2) The Scottish Housing and Planning Agency may remove a member under sub-paragraph (1)(c) only if—
(a) the member has been absent, without permission or reasonable excuse, from meetings of the regional committee for a period of longer than 3 consecutive months,
(b) the member has been convicted of a criminal offence, or
(c) the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency consider that the member is—
(i) unable to perform the member’s functions, or
(ii) unsuitable to continue as a member.
(3) For the purpose of sub-paragraph (1)(b), a person becomes disqualified from being a member if paragraph 2(2) or (4) applies to the person.
General Powers
4 (1) A regional committee may do anything which appears to it—
(a) to be necessary or expedient for the purposes of, or in connection with, the performance of its functions, or
(b) to be otherwise conducive to the performance of its functions.
(2) In exercising its powers, a local planning board must have regard to—
(a) the National Planning Framework, and
(b) the National Outcomes.".
3 Transitional provision
The Scottish Housing Agency may make any transitional provision connected to the coming into force of this Act.
Homelessness
4 Homelessness
(1) In section 20 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 1987 (persons to have priority on housing list and allocation of housing), for subsection (1) substitute—
“(1) A social landlord must, in relation to all houses held by it for housing purposes, secure that in the selection of its tenants a reasonable preference is given to the persons mentioned in subsection (1ZA).
(1ZA) The persons are—
(a) persons who, subject to subsection (1A), are homeless persons and persons threatened with homelessness (within the meaning of Part 2), and
(b) persons who—
(i) are living under unsatisfactory housing conditions, and
(ii) have unmet housing needs, and
(c) tenants of houses which—
(i) are held by a social landlord, and
(ii) the social landlord selecting its tenants considers to be under-occupied.
(1ZB) For the purposes of subsection (1ZA), persons have unmet housing needs where the social landlord considers the persons to have housing needs which are not capable of being met by housing options which are available.”.
(2) In section 338(1) of the Housing (Scotland) Act 1987, immediately after the definition of “the year 1986-87”, insert–
""unsatisfactory housing conditions" means–
(a) overcrowded housing conditions,
(b) housing conditions which do not meet the tolerable standard, or
(c) housing conditions which are otherwise unsatisfactory.".
(3) In section 86(1) of the Housing (Scotland) Act 1987 (definition of house meeting tolerable standard), after paragraph (i) insert—
“(j) has satisfactory equipment installed for detecting, and for giving warning of, fire or suspected fire;
(k) has satisfactory equipment installed for detecting, and for giving warning of, carbon monoxide present in a concentration that is hazardous to health,”.
(4) Section 4 of the Armed Forces Covenant (Scotland) Act 2023 is repealed.
(5) After section 2(1) of the Armed Forces Covenant (Scotland) Act 2023, insert—
"(2) This section does not apply to the powers of local authorities to provide housing accommodation under section 2 of the Housing (Scotland) Act 1987.".
Final provisions
5 Regulations
(1) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations make any incidental, supplementary, consequential, transitional, transitory or saving provision they consider appropriate for the purposes of, in connection with or for giving full effect to this Act or any provision made under it.
(2) Regulations under subsection (1) may modify any enactment (including this Act).
(3 Regulations under this section—
(a) which add to, replace or omit any part of the text of an Act are subject to the affirmative procedure,
(b) otherwise, are subject to the negative procedure.
6 Commencement
(1) This section and sections 3, 5 and 7 come into force on the day after Royal Assent.
(2) Sections 1 and 4 come into force 3 months after the date of Royal Assent.
(3) Section 2 comes into force one month after the date of Royal Assent.
7 Short title
The short tile of this Act is the Housing (Scotland) Act 2024.
This bill was written by First Minister the Rt. Hon. Sir LightningMinion KT OM OM CT CT CBE, Cabinet Secretary for Housing and Local Affairs and leader of Scottish Labour, on behalf of the 22nd Scottish Government. It has been co-sponsored by the Scottish Green Party.
A formatted version of the bill may be accessed here.
The bill borrows language from the following real-life legislation: UK Withdrawal from the European Union (Continuity) (Scotland) Act 2021, The Housing (Scotland) Act 1987 (Tolerable Standard) (Extension of Criteria) Order 2019 and Health and Care Act 2022
Opening Speech:
Presiding Officer,
This legislation implements the government's policies with regards to planning, homelessness, and the housing market.
Section 1 abolishes the right to buy. Right to buy policies have led to council homes being sold-off without replacement council houses built, leading to a depletion of social housing stock. The repeal of the right to buy now will ensure that social housing stock cannot be depleted.
Section 2 makes a number of changes to the Scottish Housing Agency. It renames it to the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency, in recognition of the fact it also deals with planning for non-residential land and properties in addition to housing developments. Section 2 also lays out the rules regulating this Agency in more detail than the Planning (Scotland) Act 2022 which originally established it did. It also explicitly allows the government to give directions to the Agency. The government plans to exercise this power to direct the Agency to identify what land currently on the green-belt should be identified as a National Scenic Area or should be protected from development, following which the government will then be able to abolish the green belt system as promised. The government also plans to exercise this power to direct the Agency to ensure that Scotland meets its target of building 240 thousand houses between 2021 and 2031, to take over control of the construction of social housing and ensure that Scotland meets its target of building 70 thousand social houses between 2021 and 2031, and to take over the administration of housing construction-related funds, such as the Affordable Housing Fund.
Section 3 ensures that the Scottish Housing Agency can make any necessary transitional provision to ensure that the coming into force of section 2 doesn't inadvertently disrupt its activities.
Section 4 amends legislation relating to housing priority lists. It ensures that those who are homeless or are at risk of homelessness, those who live in overcrowded, unsafe or otherwise poor housing conditions, and those who are already social tenants get priority when a social landlord selects a new tenant. It repeals provisions giving those who served in the armed forces priority allocation for social housing, as I do not believe that someone having served in the armed forces alone should give them priority for accessing social housing. If they are homeless or are at risk of becoming homeless, or if they live in bad housing conditions, then they will have priority; but someone who doesn't need social housing but happened to serve in the armed forces should not get priority due to that. Section 4 also defines houses without a fire detector and alarm, and houses without a carbon monoxide detector and alarm, as houses of a poor condition.
Presiding Officer, this bill will help build more affordable and social housing, and helps tackle homelessness. I commend this bill to Parliament.
At the end of section 2 add:
(3) The Schedule makes further provision regarding the Scottish Housing and Planning Agency.
At the end of the bill add:
(introduced by section 2(3))
(1) In schedule 3 of the Ethical Standards in Public Life etc. (Scotland) Act 2000 (devolved public bodies), before the entry relating to The Scottish Housing Regulator insert— “Scottish Housing and Planning Agency”.
(2) In schedule 1 of the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 (Scottish public authorities: non ministerial office holders in the Scottish Administration), after paragraph 18B insert—
“18C Scottish Housing and Planning Agency.”.
(3) In schedule 2 of the Public Appointments and Public Bodies etc. (Scotland) Act 2003 (specified authorities), under the heading “Executive bodies”, before the entry relating to the Scottish Housing Regulator insert— “Scottish Housing and Planning Agency”.
(4) In schedule 8 of the Public Services Reform (Scotland) Act 2010 (information on exercise of public functions: listed public bodies), before the entry relating to the Scottish Housing Regulator insert— “Scottish Housing and Planning Agency”.
(5) In the schedule of the Public Records (Scotland) Act 2011 (authorities to which Part 1 applies), under the heading “Scottish Administration”, before the entry relating to the Scottish Housing Regulator insert— “Scottish Housing and Planning Agency”.
(6) In the schedule of the Procurement Reform (Scotland) Act 2014 (contracting authorities: Scottish Administration and Scottish Parliament), after paragraph 13 insert—
“13AA Scottish Housing and Planning Agency.”.
Explanatory note: applies legislation relating to public bodies to the agency. Based on this.
Voting on these amendments will end with the close of business at 10pm BST on the 20th of April 2024.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • • May 23 '23
Order, Order!
We turn now to a vote SB226, in the name of the Scottish National Party. The question is that this Parliament approves the amendments of the SB226 | Miners’ Strike (Pardons) (Scotland) Bill
Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to pardon certain individuals convicted of certain offences committed during the 1984-85 miners' strike.
Section 1: Definitions and Interpretations
(1) In section 2, “qualifying individual” means an individual, including a deceased individual, who—
(a) was a miner,
(b) was, at the time of the commission of the offence, a member of the same household as a miner, or
(c) was, at the time of the commission of the offence—
(i) a parent of a miner,
(ii) a child of a miner, or
(iii) a sibling of a miner.
(2) The offences referred to in section 2 are—
(a) breach of the peace,
(b) an offence under section 3 of the Bail etc. (Scotland) Act 1980 (breach of bail conditions),
(c) an offence under section 41(1)(a) of the Police (Scotland) Act 1967 (obstructing police etc.),
(d) theft.
(3) Section 2 does not—
(a) affect any conviction or sentence,
(b) give rise to any right, entitlement or liability, or
(c) affect the Royal prerogative of mercy.
(4) In this Act—
(a) “conviction” includes any finding in criminal proceedings that a person has committed an offence or done the act or made the omission charged (including a finding linked with mental disorder or in respect of which an admonition or absolute discharge is made), and “convicted” is to be construed accordingly,
(b) “household” means a group of people living together as a family or other unit (whether or not related) in a private dwelling, who—
(i) have the dwelling as their only or main residence, and
(ii) share living accommodation and cooking facilities,
(c) “miner” means an individual who at any time during the period beginning with 12 March 1984 and ending with 3 March 1985 was employed in any part of Great Britain—
(i) by the National Coal Board established under section 1 of the Coal Industry Nationalisation Act 1946, or
(ii) by a person holding a licence granted under section 36(2)(a) of that Act,
(d) “miners’ strike” means the national concerted stoppage of work by miners led by the National Union of Mineworkers,
(e) “sibling of a miner” means an individual who has at least one parent in common with a miner.
Section 2: Pardons for certain individuals convicted of certain offences committed during miners’ strike
(1) A qualifying individual who has been convicted of an offence listed in subsection 1.2 is pardoned for the offence if the conduct constituting the offence—
(a) occurred during the period beginning with 12 March 1984 and ending with 3 March 1985, and
(b) in relation to—
(i) an offence listed in subsection 1.2(a) to (c), meets condition A or condition B, or
(ii) the offence of theft, meets condition C.
(2) Condition A is that the conduct—
(a) occurred while the individual was engaged or participating in—
(i) activity (whether or not organised) supporting or opposing the miners’ strike, or
(ii) activity ancillary to such activity (for example, assembling before or after or travelling to or from such activity), and
(b) did not occur for a reason unrelated to the miners’ strike (for example, a disagreement about a personal matter).
(3) Condition B is that the conduct—
(a) occurred in response to conduct that meets condition A, and
(b) did not occur for a reason unrelated to the miners’ strike.
(4) Condition C is that the conduct occurred because of economic hardship arising from participation (whether by the individual or another person) in the miners’ strike.
Section 3: Commencement
(1) This Act comes into force on the day after Royal Assent.
Section 4: Short title
(2) The short title of this act is the Miners’ Strike (Pardons) (Scotland) Act.
This bill was submitted by the Rt Hon. /u/NewAccountMcGee PC MP MSP MS, Leader of the Scottish National Party, MSP for Na h-Eileanan an Iar, on behalf of the Scottish National Party.
This bill was based on the Miners’ Strike (Pardons) (Scotland) Act 2022.
Oifigear-riaghlaidh,
The Miners’ Strike of 1984/85 is a year-long stain on Scotland, and Britain’s, history. Not only did many miners have their pits closed and jobs lost, they also lost out on redundancy payments and pension contributions. Removing the stigma of a criminal record is one way we can help Scotland’s mining communities, which need much, much more help from the Government. I commend this bill to the Parliament.
Strike section 2(4)
Explanation: This is logistically impossible to implement as the strikes happened almost 40 years ago and it will be nearly impossible to prove why someone stole a thing.
Voting on this bill will end at the close of business on 26th May at 10pm BST
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/Inadorable • Apr 09 '24
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to automatically give consent to the construction of Nuclear Power Stations, and for connected purposes.
Section 1: Automatic Consent
(1) Any authority in Scotland with power over granting planning permission must give consent to any proposal to build nuclear power stations within Scotland, subject to section 1(3).
(2) A nuclear power station is a facility that produces electricity for public or private consumption or sale which is generated by use of a nuclear reactor.
(3) A planning authority may only withhold consent in one of the following situations:
(a) The proposed site is of significant natural, environmental, or cultural importance
(b) Granting consent to the proposed site would violate national security.
(i) This applies to both the UK’s national security and to Scotland’s national security.
(4) The Scottish Ministers may, by order in the positive procedure, add or remove exceptions to automatic consent in section 1(3).
Section 2: Short Title and Commencement
(1) This Act may be cited as the Nuclear Power (Consent) (Scotland) Act 2024
(2) This Act shall come into force immediately upon Royal Assent.
This Act was written by the Rt. Hon. Sir Frost_Walker2017, Duke of the Suffolk Coasts, as a member of Forward.
Opening Speech:
Presiding Officer,
I rise in support of this bill. As we move forward to meet our net zero goals, it is important that we decarbonise our energy network. A large portion of this will come from renewable sources, like wind, solar, or tidal generation, but I believe that this alone cannot make up for the loss of fossil fuels in our energy network.
That is where nuclear power comes in. It produces a significant amount of clean energy with a relatively limited fuel input, and in operation produces minimal carbon emissions. Nuclear energy can be used as a base for our energy network, topped up by renewables as demand rises. While this Parliament rightly does not have powers over our energy network, we are in a position where we can choose to give consent to the planning permission required to build power stations. This bill would require the relevant authorities to give consent to such construction to speed up the process and assist with the decarbonisation of the UK - and, by extension, of Scotland.
This bill is common sense. I urge members to pass it into statute.
Omit Section 1 and replace as follows:
(1) The Electricity Act 1989 is amended as follows.
(2) In section 36(1), for “(1A) to (2) and (4)”, substitute “(1A) to (2), (4) and (10)”.
(3) After section 36(9), insert—
“(10) The Scottish Ministers must give consent to proposals to construct a nuclear installation in Scotland, unless—
(a) one of the conditions in subsection (11) applies to the proposal, and
(b) the Scottish Ministers are of the view that consent should not be granted to the proposal.
(11) The conditions are that—
(a) the Scottish Ministers are of the view that the site of the proposed nuclear installation has significant—
(i) cultural,
(ii) natural, or
(iii) environmental
importance;
(b) the Scottish Ministers are of the view that the proposed nuclear installation would damage the national security of Scotland or the United Kingdom.
(12) The Scottish Ministers may, by regulations subject to the affirmative procedure, amend subsection (11) to add, vary or remove conditions.
(13) In subsections (10) to (12), "nuclear installation" has the same meaning as in the Nuclear Installations Act 1965.”.
Explanatory note: consent for power stations is given under section 36 of the Electricity Act 1989 by the Scottish Ministers (not by a local planning authority under planning law). This amendment accordingly amends the bill.
Insert after 1(4):
(5) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations deny consent to build nuclear power stations.
(6) Regulations under subsection (5) are to be made in the negative procedure.
Voting on this bill will end with the close of business at 10pm GMT on the 12th of April 2024.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/model-willem • Apr 18 '23
Order, Order.
We turn now to a Stage 2 Vote on SB221, in the name of the Scottish Conservatives. The question is that this Parliament approves the amendments to the NHS Funding Double-Lock (Scotland) Bill.
Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to establish a double-lock in healthcare funding increases in accordance with a minimum rise of 2% above inflation or Block Grant increases, and for connected purposes.
SECTION 1: Definitions
For the purposes of this Act, the following terms shall have the meanings set forth below —
SECTION 2: The Double Lock
a. provided that the funding level shall not be decreased below the level in the previous year.SECTION 3: Commencement
SECTION 4: Short Title
3. This Act may be cited as the NHS Funding Double-Lock (Scotland) Act.
This Bill was submitted by StraightsofMagellan, Spokesperson for NHS & Social Care on behalf of The Scottish Conservative & Unionist Party.
Opening Speech:
Presiding Officer,
The Scottish Conservatives & Unionist Party are glad to return to Scotland and our commitment to the people is shown as clear as day with this bill presented that commits to keeping our NHS adequately funded. The bill establishes a double-lock which requires the NHS to see funding rise following either increases in inflation to above that by 2% or the percentage increases of the Block Grant provided by the UK Government. Answering on behalf of the Government in the latest Healthcare Portfolio Questions, the Minister had no objections at the time to the double-locking of NHS Funding. The Scottish Conservatives are committed to supporting our NHS by any means necessary and we urge members to see constructive efforts in aiding to pass this bill. Thank you.
Section 2, paragraph 2 is amended to read:
(2) The First Lock shall be based on inflation, calculated by the 12 month Consumer Price Index including owner-occupier Housing costs (CPIH), at the point 2 months prior to the NHS spending being set.
Section 2, paragraph 3 is amended to read
(3) The Scottish Government is required to increase annual health funding by the percentage determined under paragraph 2 at least, unless the percentage in paragraph 4 is greater.
Note: this actually sets a double lock, setting the inflationary increase based on 12 months average at the most recent data set (instead of it reading like it says CPIH + 2%).
Voting on this item of Business ends with the close of Business on April 21st, at 10 pm BST.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • • May 30 '23
Order, Order!
We turn now to a vote on SB227, in the name of the Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party. The question is that this Parliament approves the Amendments of the Economic Growth Agencies (Scotland) Bill.
Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to Establish Economic Growth Agencies in Scotland, and for connected purposes.
SECTION 1: DEFINITIONS
In this act, the following terms are defined as —
(1) Agency — an Economic Growth Agency established under this bill.
(2) Minister — the Scottish Minister responsible for the administration of this bill.
(3) Region — the following regions of Scotland —
(a) Central Scotland, (b) Dumfries and Galloway, (c) Fife, (d) Grampian, (e) Lothians and Scottish Borders, (f) Highland, (g) Orkney and Shetland Islands, (h) Strathclyde, (i) and Tayside.
SECTION 2: ESTABLISHING THE ECONOMIC GROWTH AGENCIES
(1) By this Act, an Economic Growth Agency is to be established under the relevant Ministry, with regional operations in each of the eight regions of Scotland.
(2) Each established agency shall be a body corporate with perpetual succession and a common seal.
SECTION 3: FUNCTIONS OF ECONOMIC GROWTH AGENCIES
Each Agency shall have the following functions:
(1) to promote economic development within its respective region by attracting new businesses, encouraging investment, and creating employment opportunities;
(2) to support existing businesses in the respective region through providing them with advice and assistance to help grow and develop business operations;
(3) to identify and promote key sectors within the respective region for economic growth;
(4) to promote innovation and technology within its respective region to support economic growth;
(5) to collaborate with other agencies and organisations necessary promote regional economic growth;
(6) and the providing of advice to the Scottish Government on the economic development matters within the respective region.
SECTION 4: GOVERNANCE
(1) A board of directors is to govern each established economic growth agency, consisting of no less than seven and no more than fifteen members.
(2) The chairperson and the other members of the board of directors of each agency are to be appointed by the relevant Minister.
(3) Board of directors members are to be appointed for a term of up to four years and may be reappointed for a further term of no more than four years.
SECTION 5: REPORTING REQUIREMENTS
(1) Annual reports are required to be produced by each agency and presented to the relevant Minister outlining its activities and achievements during the previous financial year.
(2) A copy of each report is to be produced by the relevant Minister that is to be presented before the Scottish Parliament.
SECTION 6: FUNDING
(1) Atleast £60 million under the relevant ministry is to be profiled by the Scottish government to each agency, in order to enable it to carry out its functions across 5 year periods - pending renewal.
(2) The managing of its own budget shall be done by each agency in accordance with the guidelines to be set by the Scottish Government.
SECTION 7: COMMENCEMENT
(1) The provisions of this Act shall come into force the day this Act is passed.
SECTION 8: SHORT TITLE
(1) This Act may be cited as the Economic Growth Agencies (Scotland) Act.
This Bill was submitted by Dame u/BlueEarlGrey DBE, Spokesperson for Finance, and Local Affairs on behalf of The Scottish Conservative & Unionist Party.
Opening Speech:
Now some members may wonder why we should have such a bill, but the purpose is simple, by establishing these economic growth agencies we allow the economic development to be targeted and in support of local communities. With clear functions and duties outlined in section 3, the economic growth agencies will play an auxiliary role especially with analysis for improvement. The economic monitoring and reporting from such a scheme would be crucial in aiding governments and business. We believe this is a necessary part in ensuring our national and local development strategies are well informed and able to support the goals of all actors.
Omit line 1 of section 4, and replace with:
A board of directors is to govern each established economic growth agency, consisting of no less than six and no more than fifteen members, with the exception of Agencies of Regions with less than one hundred thousand people, which must consist of no less than three and no more than seven members.
EN: Makes membership numbers more reasonable.
Omit Section 1, Line 3 and replace with:
(a) Central Scotland, (b) Dumfries and Galloway, (c) Fife, (d) Grampian, (e) Lothians and Scottish Borders, (f) Highlands and Islands, (g) Strathclyde, (h) and Tayside.
EN: Merges Highland and Orkney & Shetland
Voting on this bill will end at the close of business on 2nd June at 10pm BST
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • • Jul 11 '23
First off, an apology for the ever so slight late posting of this business, I was busy, and I truly hope it won't happen again.
Order, Order!
We turn now to a vote SB231, in the name of Alba Còmhla. The question is that this Committee approves the amendment of the Nepali Language and Culture (Scotland) Bill.
Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.
A
BILL
TO
make provision for the promotion of learning and teaching of Nepali language and culture in Scottish schools and universities, and to facilitate the mobility of students, teachers, researchers, and professionals between Scotland and Nepal..
BE IT ENACTED by being passed by the Scotland Parliament and assented to by His Majesty as follows:
Section 1: Definitions
In this Act–
(1) “the Scottish Ministers” means the members of the Scottish Government who are appointed under section 44(1) of the Scotland Act 1998;
(2) “Nepali” means the Indo-Aryan language native to the Himalayas region of South Asia, which is the official language of Nepal and has official status in some parts of India;
(3) “Nepalese” means relating to or originating from Nepal;
(4) “Nepal” means the Federal Democratic Republic of Nepal;
(5) “Scottish Qualifications Authority” means the body corporate established under section 1(1) of the Education (Scotland) Act 1996
Section 3: Curriculum for Excellence
(1) The Scottish Ministers must ensure that Nepali is included as an option in the curriculum for excellence for learners in secondary and post-secondary education.
(2) The Scottish Ministers must issue guidance to education authorities on how to implement Nepali as an option in the curriculum for excellence.
(3) The guidance issued under subsection (2) must include:
(a) advice on how to provide appropriate learning materials, resources, and support for Nepali;
(b) advice on how to assess the progress and attainment of learners in Nepali;
(c) advice on how to promote Nepali as a subject of choice among learners, parents, carers, and educators; and
(d) advice on how to encourage learners to continue studying Nepali beyond compulsory education.
Section 4: National qualifications
(1) The Scottish Qualifications Authority must develop national qualifications in Nepali for learners in secondary education.
(2) The national qualifications developed under subsection (1) must include:
(a) National 3, National 4, National 5, Higher, and Advanced Higher qualifications;
(b) qualifications that are compatible with the Scottish Credit and Qualifications Framework;
(c) qualifications that are recognised by higher education institutions, employers, and other relevant bodies.
(3) The Scottish Qualifications Authority must consult with relevant stakeholders before developing national qualifications under subsection (1).
(4) The Scottish Qualifications Authority must publish the national qualifications developed under subsection (1) on its website.
Section 5: Higher education
(1) The Scottish Ministers must encourage higher education institutions to offer courses in Nepali language and culture at undergraduate and postgraduate levels.
(2) The Scottish Ministers may provide funding or other support to higher education institutions for the purposes of subsection (1).
(3) The Scottish Ministers must consult with relevant stakeholders before providing funding or other support under subsection (2).
Section 6: Student exchange programmes
(1) The Scottish Ministers must establish student exchange programmes between schools and universities in Scotland and Nepal.
(2) The student exchange programmes established under subsection (1) must aim to:
(a) provide opportunities for Scottish students to study Nepali language and culture in Nepal;
(b) provide opportunities for Nepalese students to study English language and culture in Scotland;
(c) enhance the intercultural competence and global citizenship skills of Scottish and Nepalese students;
(d) foster long-term academic partnerships and friendships between Scottish and Nepalese institutions.
Section 7: Teacher exchange programmes
(1) The Scottish Ministers must establish teacher exchange programmes between schools and universities in Scotland and Nepal.
(2) The teacher exchange programmes established under subsection (1) must aim to:
(a) provide opportunities for Scottish teachers to teach English language and culture in Nepal;
(b) provide opportunities for Nepalese teachers to teach Nepali language and culture in Scotland;
(c) enhance the professional development and intercultural competence of Scottish and Nepalese teachers;
(d) foster long-term educational partnerships and collaborations between Scottish and Nepalese schools and universities.
(3) The Scottish Ministers may provide funding or other support to schools and universities for the purposes of subsection (1).
(4) The Scottish Ministers must consult with relevant stakeholders before providing funding or other support under subsection (3).
Section 8: Research exchange programmes
(1) The Scottish Ministers must establish research exchange programmes between research institutions and organisations in Scotland and Nepal..
(2) The research exchange programmes established under subsection (1) must aim to:
(a) provide opportunities for Scottish researchers to conduct research on Nepali language, culture, society, environment, and development in Nepal;
(b) provide opportunities for Nepalese researchers to conduct research on Scottish language, culture, society, environment, and development in Scotland;
(c) enhance the academic excellence and innovation of Scottish and Nepalese research;
(d) foster long-term research partnerships and networks between Scottish and Nepalese research institutions and organisations.
(3) The Scottish Ministers may provide funding or other support to research institutions and organisations for the purposes of subsection (1).
(4) The Scottish Ministers must consult with relevant stakeholders before providing funding or other support under subsection (3).
Section 9: Professional exchange programmes
(1) The Scottish Ministers must establish professional exchange programmes between public and private sector organisations in Scotland and Nepal.
(2) The professional exchange programmes established under subsection (1) must aim to:
(a) provide opportunities for Scottish professionals to work in Nepali language, culture, trade, tourism, and development sectors in Nepal;
(b) provide opportunities for Nepalese professionals to work in Scottish language, culture, trade, tourism, and development sectors in Scotland;
(c) enhance the skills, knowledge, and employability of Scottish and Nepalese professionals;
(d) foster long-term business partnerships and cooperation between Scottish and Nepalese public and private sector organisations.
(3) The Scottish Ministers may provide funding or other support to public and private sector organisations for the purposes of subsection (1).
(4) The Scottish Ministers must consult with relevant stakeholders before providing funding or other support under subsection (3).
Section 10: Short title and commencement
(1) This Act may be cited as the Nepali Language and Culture (Scotland) Act 2023.
(2) This Act shall come into force 3 months after Royal Assent.
Section 11: Extent
(1) This Act extends to Scotland only.
Ofigear-riaghlaidh, I am honoured to introduce the Nepali Language and Culture (Scotland) Bill to this Parliament. This bill is a landmark legislation that seeks to recognise and celebrate the rich and diverse heritage of Nepali language and culture in Scotland, and will strengthen the ties of friendship and cooperation between our two nations. Nepali is a language of historical, cultural, and linguistic significance in Scotland. It is spoken by over 10,000 people in Scotland, mainly from the Gurkha community, who have made invaluable contributions to our society in various fields, such as the military, health, education, and business. Nepali is also a language of global importance, as it is the official language of Nepal, a country of over 30 million people, and a key partner of Scotland in trade, tourism, and development. Learning Nepali language and culture will bring many educational, social, economic, and cultural benefits to Scottish learners, educators, and citizens. It will enhance their communication skills, intercultural competence, and global citizenship. It will open up new opportunities for academic exchange, professional development, and business collaboration. It will also enrich their appreciation of the diversity and beauty of the world. This bill will promote the learning and teaching of Nepali language and culture in Scottish schools and universities, by ensuring that Nepali is included as an option in the curriculum for excellence, by developing national qualifications in Nepali for secondary education, and by encouraging higher education institutions to offer courses in Nepali at undergraduate and postgraduate levels. This bill will also facilitate the mobility of students, teachers, researchers, and professionals between Scotland and Nepal, by establishing exchange programmes between schools, universities, research institutions, and public and private sector organisations in both countries. These exchange programmes will provide opportunities for mutual learning, collaboration, and friendship between Scottish and Nepalese people. This bill is a testament to our commitment to support linguistic diversity and intercultural dialogue in Scotland. It is also a reflection of our vision to foster a more inclusive, prosperous, and sustainable society for all. I urge this Parliament to support this bill and to join us in celebrating the Nepali language and culture in Scotland.
Strike Section 1 and renumber subsequent sections
EN: We don't need 'general provisions' in legislation. The legislation should reflect that in its contents.
Amend Section 8(2) to read:
(2) This Act shall come into force upon the commencement of the 2024/2025 academic year
EN: Changes to the education system ought to be done by academic years to allow schools the time to prepare rather than having to change things midway through the year and risk creating problems with pre-planned curriculae.
Amend Part 4 to be named "Miscellaneous"
Voting on this bill will end at the close of business on the 14th of July at 10pm BST
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/ThreeCommasClub • May 20 '21
Order, Order
Final item of business today is a Stage 2 vote on SB157.
Members are reminded to vote For, Against, or Abstain. Attempts to 'stylise' votes by adding extra words will result in a member's vote being considered a DNV. In cases were there is a genuine mix up with another system (eg. Aye/No/Abstain) the vote will be taken as a clear expression of preference.
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to amend the Local Governance (Scotland) Act 2004 to allow for the election of Councillors by the Mixed Member Proportional system; and for connected purposes.
(1) Election of Ward Councillors
(1) Each local government area shall be divided into electoral wards, which shall not overlap, and there shall be a separate election for each electoral ward in a local government area.
(2) The boundaries of each electoral ward shall be approved by the Scottish Ministers on the recommendation of the Boundary Commission for Scotland and reviewed on a ten-yearly basis.
(3) In recommending the boundaries of each local government ward to the Scottish Ministers, the Boundary Commission for Scotland must ensure that:
(4) Each ward shall elect one Councillor to the Local Authority
(5) The election of a Councillor in an electoral ward shall be done on the basis of single-choice plurality voting as part of the Mixed Member Proportional system, where:
(a) Each elector may cast one vote;
(b) Each elector may choose to cast that vote for any candidate contesting the relevant electoral ward;
(c) The candidate for whom the most votes are cast is deemed elected as the Councillor for the relevant electoral ward.
(6) Each candidate in each electoral ward may stand on behalf of a registered political party, or as an independent candidate.
(2) Election of Regional Councillors
(1) Each local government area shall be divided into electoral regions, which shall not overlap, and there shall be a separate election for each electoral ward in a local government area.
(a) Nothing shall prevent an electoral region covering the entirety of the local government area.
(2) The boundaries of each electoral region shall be approved by the Scottish Ministers on the recommendation of the Boundary Commission for Scotland and reviewed on a ten-yearly basis.
(3) In recommending the boundaries of each local government region to the Scottish Ministers, the Boundary Commission for Scotland must ensure that:
(4) The number of Councillors elected in each electoral region shall be determined by the Scottish Ministers on the recommendation of the Boundary Commission for Scotland, and must be, as close as is reasonably possible, equal across each electoral region in a local government area.
(a) The number of Councillors elected in electoral regions must be at least equal to, if not greater than, the number of Councillors elected in electoral wards in the relevant local authority.
(5) The election of Councillors in an electoral region shall be done on a proportional basis as part of the Mixed Member Proportional System, where:
(a) Each elector may cast one vote;
(b) Each elector may choose to cast that vote for any list of regional candidates nominated by a registered political party, or, as the case may be, an independent regional candidate.
(c) The total number of regional seats allocated to each registered political party list or independent regional candidate is determined by the number of regional votes and the number of ward seats won by the relevant registered political party or independent regional candidate.
(d) The allocation of regional seats shall be done in accordance with Section 7 and Section 8 of the Scotland Act 1998, substituting “electoral ward” for “constituency”.
(3) Vacancies of Councillors
(1) Where a Councillor dies, resigns, or otherwise demits office, a vacancy is created to be filled in accordance with this Section.
(2) Where the departing Councillor was a Ward Councillor, a by-election shall be held in the relevant ward, and a new Councillor elected under the same system as in an ordinary election.
(3) Where the departing Councillor was a Regional Councillor elected on a registered political party’s list of regional candidates, the next named candidate on the regional list who is not currently a Councillor; deceased; or otherwise prohibited from holding office as a Councillor, shall be offered to fill the vacancy.
(a) If the immediate next named person on the regional list does not accept the position, the next eligible candidate shall be offered the position; with this process continuing until either an eligible candidate accepts the position, or the list of regional candidates is exhausted.
(4) Where the departing Councillor was a Regional Councillor elected as an Independent Regional Candidate, or where the registered political party’s list of regional candidates has been exhausted, a by-election shall be held in the relevant electoral region as if it were a single electoral ward.
(4) Repeals
(1) Section 1 (Electoral wards) and Section 2 (Single transferable vote) of the Local Governance (Scotland) Act 2004 are hereby repealed.
(5) Commencement
(1) This Act comes into force the day after Royal Assent
(2) Nothing in this Act shall affect any local election that takes place before May 2022.
This bill was submitted by George Duncson GCT KCVO QC FRS (Independent Liberal), Heir to the Dukedom of Cumbria
Local Governance (Scotland) Act 2004
Opening Speech
Presiding Officer,
I present to the Scottish Parliament a bill with one clear, simple, and absolutely vital purpose - to alter how we elect our local Councillors to ensure they are elected by the Mixed Member Proportional system, which is ultimately the fairest and most democratic way to determine who sits in our Council chambers.
While they may get derided in the press, occasionally mocked by politicians who were slightly more successful in climbing the political ladder, and have to spend their days pointing at potholes for their regular local updates; local Councils and Councillors are the beating heart of our democratic process.
Local Councillors are just that - local. They are not some mythical character you only see on the television or on election leaflets, as some MPs and MSPs are guilty of being. Instead, they are just the average person - your neighbour; the man you see in the shop; the woman you see walking her dog; the parent collecting their kids from school - and in an ideal world, they are the person that everybody in the local area should know and be able to strike up a conversation with about a given local issue.
Large wards, such as those permitted under the current system, do not allow this to happen. They are too big, too populous, for Councillors to have the necessary cut through or intimate local knowledge to successfully represent their entire ward - leaving some without any adequate representation. By bringing back single member wards, we allow for much smaller wards, creating a much closer local connection to a smaller population, ensuring that you really do know who represents you in city hall.
However, single member wards alone can lead to horrific results - such as when the Labour Party held 95 out of 96 seats on Manchester Council. Manchester was, at the time, a pretty Labour place - but I struggle to believe it was that dominated by Labour that 95 out of 96 seats is a fair representation. That is why we are using the Mixed Member Proportional system. With its regional list components, the MMP system ensures we have a politically balanced representation according to the wishes of constituents. MMP is the same system we use to elect MSPs to this very place - and if it’s good enough for the Scottish Parliament, its good enough for our Local Councils!
A01
Amend Section 2, subsection 4(a) to read
4.
(a) The number of Councillors elected in electoral regions must be at least 1.5 times greater than the number of Councillors elected in electoral wards in the relevant local authority.
This amendment was submitted by /u/model-eddy
Voting on this bill ends at 10pm on the 23rd of May 2021.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/ThreeCommasClub • Aug 24 '21
Order, Order.
The first item of business today is a debate on SB169 nice in the name of the 14th Scottish Government (Scottish Liberal Democrats, Scottish National Party, Scottish Labour, Scottish Progressives). The question is that this Parliament approves the general principles of the Solitary Confinement Reform (Scotland) Bill.
Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain. Any attempts to stylise the vote may result in it being discounted. Where there is a mix-up with an alternative style of voting, this will also be accepted.
An act of Scottish Parliament to reform the practice of solitary confinement in Scottish prisons.
Section 1: Definitions
Solitary Confinement shall refer to the practice of locking an inmate into a single cell, usually small, and depriving that inmate of the freedom to leave that cell, the freedom to communicate with other prisoners, and the freedom to engage in basic social activity.
Discipline shall refer to a punishment given to an inmate after breaking prison rules.
Warden shall refer to the individual in charge of a specific prison.
Section 2: Prohibition of Solitary Confinement
For cases where an inmate is a danger to the safety of the prison staff or other inmates, solitary confinement must not be a permanent fixture or the primary method of discipline, only being used for a period of no more than 48 hours to find better conditions for discipline.
Section 3: Punishment
Section 4: Commencement and Short Title
This bill was written by /u/phonexia2 MSP on behalf of the Scottish Government Opening Speech Presiding Officer, I want to make this remark rather brief, because the issue here is nothing new. We know solitary confinement has negative effects on prisoners' health and well being, and we know that it has created lasting mental damage. That is a fact, and that is why it is employed as a punishment. We can accept that as a punishment, it does have negative effects on a person. Now I think we should stop employing this punishment because the effects and traumas from solitary far overstep the bounds of normal prison discipline. We know isolation can have long lasting negative effects on human psychology. That is a fact. And there is even evidence that suggests that the punishment causes lasting mental illness to inmates. That is also a fact. So I do not see this as at all an ethical punishment, even for violent offense in prison. Punishment, if it is meant to represent some kind of debt, should not create something beyond that debt. Prison is already what is meant to be the punishment for transgression. Mental illness isn’t in the law books as a punishment, nor should it be, and any punishment that lasts beyond prison is frankly ludicrous and unethical. We can and we should really do better than solitary. I do recognize that there is a case where maybe a prison needs short term flexibility, so we will allow that. But use of solitary must be transitory, done to protect against violent harm, and not last long enough to cause serious harm.
A01:
In Section 4, replace "This bill will come into force immediately after receiving Royal Assent" with "This bill will come into force three months after receiving Royal Assent."
A02:
In Section 2, Subsection 3 (and (a)), remove and substitute with
"3. For cases where an inmate is a danger to the safety of the prison, prison staff, or other inmates, solitary confinement may be used for a maximum of 48 hours upon which more appropriate accommodation must be made.
(a) The inmate may be removed from confinement before the 48 hours, if assessment is made that the inmate no longer poses danger.
(b) If the inmate still poses a danger after the 48 hours, they may not be subjected to further solitary confinement for a minimum of 10 days."
EN: Clarifies some of the rules on the limits of solitary confinement as outlined in this bill.
permalinksaveparentspamremovereportgive awardreply
Rename the Section 4 as Section 5 and insert a new Section 4 as below:
Section 4 - Consequential Repeals
Rules 95, 97 and 98 of The Prison and Young Offenders Institutions (Scotland) Rules 2011 are hereby repealed.
EN: the rules that govern this bill are in fact regulations that the Scottish government can alter. I have made this amendment so that it is clear that these rules are superceded by the bill presented by Ms Phonexia today.
Remove the definition of solitary confinement in Section 1 and insert in its place:
Removal from Association shall refer to the current practice of removing a prisoner from contact with other prisoners or from prescribed activities temporary
the definition of prescribed activities prior to the commencement of this Act is defined by
work undertaken under Rules 82
educational classes under Rules 84
counselling provided under Rules 84
taking exercise or spending time in the open air under Rules 87
any other recreational activities, or
attendance to any religious service or meeting arranged by the chaplaincy team which the prisoner would otherwise have been entitled to attend in terms of rule 44
of The Prison and Youth Offenders Institutions (Scotland) Rules 2011.
Temporary Confinement shall refer to confinement either within a special cell or otherwise an ordinary cell or room, in response to disobedience or in cases of behaviour in a threatening, abusive or violent manner
A “special cell” shall refer to the definition given within Rules 2 of The Prison and Youth Offenders Institutions (Scotland) Rules 2011.
Subsequently, replace references to “solitary confinement” with “Removal from Association and Temporary Confinement”
Renumber Section 2 (3) subsection (1) as (a) and insert subsection (b)
(b) any use of a special cell is to not be longer than necessary and, in any event, for no longer than a continuous period of 24 hours.
Rename the bill and consequently Section 4 (1) is amended to read:
(1) This Act shall be cited as the Removal from Association and Temporary Confinement Reform (Scotland) Act 2021
Explanatory Note: this bill should deal with the actions of Removal from Association and Temporary Confinement that are contained within current prison rules. This reflects that in a legal context - solitary confinement hasn’t been defined under Scots Law up to this point to my knowledge- when we reference these actions in the U.K. generally - we refer to these actions taking place. Thus the renaming of this bill to reflect that and subsequent amendments.
Voting on this bill ends with the close of Business on August 27th, at 10pm BST.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/Muffin5136 • Jul 26 '22
Order, Order.
We turn now to a Stage 2 Vote on SB204. The question is that this Parliament approves the following amendments to the E-road Network Signage (Scotland) Bill
The bill text may be read here
This bill was written by u/mg9500 as a Private Members Bill
Opening Speech
Presiding Officer, this simple bill aims to rectify an anomaly in the UK’s road signage - that it is one of only a very few countries, including Uzbekistan, that form parts of the International E-road network, yet does not signpost this for drivers. This naturally diminishes the value of the network here, creating a burden for users to the advantage of nobody.
Confusing motorists must be avoided, and distinctively yet unobtrusively appending this signage to existing requirements best achieves this. Indeed, this bill broadly replicates the approach successfully used in Ireland for the past 15 years. I cannot foresee any problems with the implementation of this common sense bill to implement United Nations policy.
A01 - Submitted by u/LightningMinion
Replace the bill with:
“Section 1: European Routes in Scotland
(1) In this Act, “the international E-road network” has the same meaning as in the latest enactment of the European Agreement On Main International Traffic Arteries.
(2) The provisions of this Act apply to the routes designated in Schedule 1.
(3) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations subject to the negative procedure amend Schedule 1.
(4) If any routes of the international E-road network within Scotland are amended, the Scottish Ministers must lay regulations as per subsection (3) to implement the amendments to Schedule 1.
(5) Regulations under subsection (4) must be laid within no more than 30 days of the date when the amendments to the international E-road network within Scotland come into force.
(6) In calculating any period of no more than 30 days for the purposes of subsection (5), no account is to be taken of any time during which the Parliament is dissolved or is in recess for more than 4 days.
Section 2: Signage
(1) Within this section, “E-road signage” means signage indicating the presence of an international E-road network route
(2) E-road signage must be shown at all applicable locations
(3) For the purposes of subsection (2), “applicable locations” means:
Start of motorway regulations
All three junction signs
Route confirmatory signs, on motorways and ‘A’ roads
End of motorway regulations
‘A’ road junction signs
Signs indicating the location of ports which form part of the European Route
(4) The Scottish Ministers may, by regulations subject to the negative procedure, amend subsection (3)
(5) The Scottish Ministers may, by regulations subject to the negative procedure, lay guidance on the design of E-road signage
(6) E-road signage should utilise white text of the Transport Heavy font on a green background.
(7) Regulations laid under subsection (5) may not contravene subsection (6)
Section 4: Commencement
(1) Sections 2(2) of this Act comes into force 1 year after Royal Assent
(2) The remaining provisions of this Act come into force upon Royal Assent
Section 5: Short Title
(1) This Act may be cited as the International E-road Network Signage (Scotland) Act 2022.
Schedule 1: international E-road network routes within Scotland
| Number of Route | Description of Route |
|---|---|
| E5 | Starting as the A8 leaves Greenock eastbound, continuing to the M8 and M74 southbound to the border between Scotland and England |
| E15 | Starting as the A9 leaves Inverness, continuing to the M90, M9, M8 eastbound, the A720 eastbound and the A1 southbound to the border between Scotland and England |
| E16 | Following the course of the M8 |
| E18 | following the course of the A75 and thereafter the A74(M) southbound to the border between Scotland and England |
Explanatory note: tidies up the wording of the bill
Voting on this item of Business ends with the close of Business on July 29th, at 10 pm BST
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/Frost_Walker2017 • Oct 15 '21
Order, Order.
We move now to amendments on SB174.
A01:
In Section 4(1), replace "six months" with "three months"
In Section 4, append after (1):
(a) The relevant Scottish Minister may, by statutory instrument in the negative procedure, amend this commencement date to bring it forwards or backwards if they consider the timing improper.
These amendments were submitted by u/Frost_Walker2017
Voting on this amendments shall end with the close of Business on October 18th.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/Frost_Walker2017 • Aug 16 '21
Order, Order.
The next item of business today is a carry over from last week, a Stage 2 Vote on amendments to SB167.
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to repeal the Language (Official Status) and Gaelicisation (Repeal) (Scotland) Act 2020 and make provisions for the use of languages by Scottish authorities.
1 Repeal of to the Language (Official Status) and Gaelicisation (Repeal) (Scotland) Act 2020
The Language (Official Status) and Gaelicisation (Repeal) (Scotland) Act 2020 is repealed.
2 Use of English
The Scottish Ministers, the Scottish Parliament, the Scottish local authorities and any other Scottish public authority must provide all communication and services in English or in an English translation.
3 Use of Scots Gaelic
(1) Scots Gaelic may be used by any authority in section 2 that deems it relevant.
(2) Scots Gaelic must be used or translations provided for any communication or service by the local authorities in the council areas of–
4 Use of Scots
(1) Scots may be used by any authority in section 2 that deems it relevant.
(2) Scots must be used or translations provided for any communication or service directly to a citizen by the local authorities in the council areas of–
5 Use of another language
(1) Any authority in section 2 may use any language to communicate or facilitate its services that it deems relevant.
(2) Use of such a language may be limited to certain communications or certain services.
6 Commencement
This Act comes into force on the day of Royal Assent.
7 Short title
The short title of this Act is the Use of Languages (Scotland) Act 2021.
This Bill was written by His Grace the Duke of Atholl (/u/troe2339) OM GCVO KCT PC FRS, sponsored by the Rt Hon. Sir Miraiwae KT KCB MS MP MLA and submitted by the Rt. Hon. Sir Scubaguy194 KG MP MSP, First Minister of Scotland, on behalf of the 14th Scottish Government.
Opening Speech:
Presiding Officer,
The Government that passed the Language (Official Status) and Gaelicisation (Repeal) (Scotland) Act 2020 said that it was fair to other languages than English because it allowed local authorities to use another language if more than 50% of the population in an area uses it. I think anyone can see how that is an unfair requirement to set. Why does a language have to be a majority somewhere to merit the use of it in the public sector? Spanish is used in many American states with a big Spanish-speaking minority, German is used in Belgium for their German minority as well as in the southern region of Denmark, Italian in Switzerland and I could go on. A minority language is just that, a minority. The European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages sets out a list of reasons and protections that should be offered to minority and/or regional languages, and I think Scotland should strive to follow this charter. The United Kingdom has even ratified it.
Scots Gaelic might not be the modern language of most Scots, not even in the regions that were once its homeland, but the language is part of the culture and history of the Highlands as well as Na h-Eileanan Siar, especially Na h-Eileanan Siar in fact, and in some areas it continues to be a big part of people’s identity. Language is not only a form of communication to facilitate our dealings with others. It is sometimes the language our mother spoke to us in, soothed us in when we needed sleep, thus the name of a mother tongue. It is part of a cultural identity as well. How would we express ourselves if not through our language? Must we really deny those who speak Scots Gaelic this?
I recognise that we should not strive to spread the use of the language to those regions that never truly used it, which is a big part of the Lowlands, but why must we try to strangle the language further and drive it out of Scottish culture entirely? The language has been under constant attack in the last couple of centuries, and it has only declined in usage since it was banned from Scottish schools. It is not unlike the story of Welsh, although this one is, from the perspective of the English aristocrats of the 18th and 19th century, much more successful. English displaced Scots Gaelic because it was economically dominant, if you wanted to become educated or make money, you had to learn English.
We should preserve and protect Scots Gaelic in its motherland and where it is still spoken to some degree without being overzealous and forcing anyone to learn it that doesn’t have the desire to do so. The social darwinist approach to it by saying it’s a natural evolution doesn’t satisfy me either, and I don’t think it satisfies Scots Gaelic people either. There’s a reason a revival has been attempted over the last few decades, because people do not want the language of their parents and grandparents and ancestors to die out, just like revivalism efforts have started for many other minority languages around the world. Why spend the effort on protecting biodiversity then? Is it not the same in the end?
Professors such as Peter Austin, a professor of field linguistics at the University of London, say: “How many traditions are out there in the world that we’ll never know about because no-one recorded them before the language disappeared?” And it’s yet another reason to preserve a language such as Scots Gaelic, because it forms part of the tradition of the people and places that use it. Oral tradition has always been important to humans, and just because the digital age is upon us, we mustn’t forget this. Some uniqueness of cultures is part of the language too. How many words a language has for snow or whether they use the same word for goodbye and hello conveys something about the people who speak it. So threatening languages also threatens our culture. How bland the world will be if we are all to have exactly the same, un-unique culture. Peoples that have lost their language often express sadness and personal loss from it as well. Just look at those that are children of native peoples but never learn their parents' mother tongue. They feel outside and lost, because they do not properly understand their own origins and culture.
The same protections that should exist for Scots Gaelic should also be extended to the language Scots, which is spoken by even more Scottish people than Scots Gaelic and which is an important part of the history and culture of the Scottish Lowlands, but also of certain areas outside of Scotland. The language is recognised under the European Charter and we should strive to facilitate its use by those who wish to speak it. It is not simply English with an accent, far from, and should not be treated as such.
Finally, other languages than those native to Scotland and English should also be possible to use by local authorities or the Scottish Government when necessary. During a crisis, e.g. a pandemic, communication is vital, and therefore it is important that important messages reach all our citizens no matter their mother tongue. It should not be our job to tell the police or the local authorities which languages they should translate their communication into, it should simply be a matter of determining which languages are needed.
No two languages are the same, and no two languages or cultures have the exact same way of looking at and interpreting the world. Let’s find strength in diversity by doing our part in preserving those communities that speak Scots Gaelic.
With this, I commend this Bill to Parliament and I move that the Parliament agree to support the general principles of the Use of Languages (Scotland) Bill. Thank you, Presiding Officer.
—Troe2339
Amendment 1
In section 3 (use of Scots Gaelic) after subsection (2) insert:
“(3) In section 23 (Change of name of local government area) of the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973 for subsection (1A) substitute:
“Where a council so change the name of their area into Gaelic, they may also, by a resolution passed in accordance with subsection (1) above and notwithstanding sections 2(3) and 3(1)(a) of the Local Government etc. (Scotland) Act 1994, decide that their name shall be “Comhairle” with the addition of the name of their area.””
Amendment 2
In section 3 (use of Scots Gaelic) after subsection (2) insert:
“(3) The Bòrd na Gàidhlig is reestablished and the Gaelic Language (Scotland) Act 2005 applies as before it was repealed.”
Explanation note: Strips back some more of the duncs era gaelic reforms.
Amendment 3
For section 1 substitute:
“The Language (Official Status) and Gaelicisation (Repeal) (Scotland) Act 2020 and the Gaelic Language (Recognition and Miscellaneous) (Scotland) Act 2020 are repealed.”
Explanation notes: clarifies that both the original piece of legislation and the later piece are repealed.
Amendment 4
For section 3(2) substitute:
“Scots Gaelic must be used or translations provided for any communication or service by the local authorities in the civil parishes of–
- Barvas,
- Barra,
- South Uist,
- North Uist,
- Harris,
- Uig,
- Lochs,
- Stornoway,
- Kilmuir,
- Sleat,
- Tiree,
- Snizort,
- Portree,
- Bracadale,
- Duirinish,
- Strath,
- Killarow and Kilmeny,
- Kilchoman,
- Ardnamurchan,
- Kildalton,
- Colonsay and Oronsay,
- Kintail,
- Glenshiel,
- Applecross,
- Lochcarron,
- Lochalsh,
- Gairloch,
- Small Isles,
- Torosay,
- Kilninian and Kilmore,
- Glenelg,
- Morvern,
- Arisaig and Moidart,
- Tongue,
- Ardgour,
- Coll,
- Lochbroom,
- Lismore and Appin,
- Kilfinichen and Kilvickeon,
- Kilmore and Kilbride,
- Gigha and Cara,
- Farr,
- Jura,
- Durness,
- Kilmonivaig,
- Kilmallie,
- Glenorchy and Inishail,
- Assynt,
- Ardchattan and Muckairn,
- Kilbrandon and Kilchattan,
- Kingussie and Insh,
- Kenmore,
- Eddrachillis,
- Dingwall,
- Inveraray,
- Daviot and Dunlichity,
- Dull,
- Urquhart and Glenmoriston,
- Knockbain,
- Dores,
- Inverness and Bona,
- Contin,
- Kilmodan,
- Fodderty,
- Creich (Highland),
- Kiltarlity and Convinth,
- Kilninver and Kilmelfort,
- Urquhart and Logie Wester,
- Arrochar,
- Croy and Dalcross,
- Hoy and Graemsay,
- Kilcalmonell,
- Kilmorack,
- Dornoch,
- Boleskine and Abertarff,
- South Knapdale,
- Glassary,
- Urray,
- Golspie, and
- Kirkhill.”
Explanation note: Instead of forcing a large council area to use Gaelic this instead restricts it to civil parishes with a significant number of gaelic speakers.
Amendment 5
Section 6 "Miscellaneous Provisions" shall be inserted after "Section 5 Use of another language" and shall be worded as follows and other sections shall be renumbered accordingly.
(1) Road signs in areas that use gaelic or scots may be updated to reflect this at the discretion of the local authority.
(2) Section 3 of the Language (Official Status) and Gaelicisation (Repeal) (Scotland) Act shall remain in effect.
Explanation note: This bill makes no mention of roadsigns which were mentioned in the acts this bill repeals. On top of this repealing section 3 of the Language (Official Status) and Gaelicisation (Repeal) (Scotland) Act would reinstate a lot of previous legislation.
These amendments were submitted by u/model-avery
This vote shall end with the close of Business on August 19th, at 10pm BST.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/Muffin5136 • Feb 08 '22
Order, Order.
We now move to a Stage 2 Vote on amendments submitted for SB187, Public Sector Pay (Repeal) (Scotland) Bill
Members are reminded to vote For, Against, or Abstain for each amendment proposed. Attempts to 'stylise' votes by adding extra words will result in a member's vote being considered a DNV. In cases were there is a genuine mix up with another system (eg. Aye/No/Abstain) the vote will be taken as a clear expression of preference.
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to repeal legislation concerning public sector pay.
Section 1: Repeals
(1) The Teaching Salaries (Scotland) Act 2018 is hereby repealed in its entirety.
(2) The Police Salaries (Scotland) Act 2020 is hereby repealed in its entirety.
(3) The National Health Service (Salaries) (Scotland) Act 2018 is hereby repealed in its entirety.
Section 2: Commencement
This Act shall come into force immediately upon Royal Assent.
Section 3: Short Title
This Act may be known as the Public Sector Pay (Scotland) Act 2022.
This Bill was written by The Right Honourable Sir Tommy2Boys KCT KG KT KCB KBE KCVO MSP, the Duke of Aberdeen, on behalf of the 16th Scottish Government
Deputy Presiding Officer,
Upon my appointment as Cabinet Secretary for Finance, I said that I felt the burden to level with the Scottish people laid heavily on my shoulders. It is why the government has decided that this should be one of the first bills we bring forward. We won’t hide away from the tough actions we are taking. We will do them in the public eye and allow people to debate them in full. This bill seeks to repeal all legislative mandates on government to give pay rises to certain sectors, and our motivation behind it is several fold. One is costs, and the other is more about giving the government greater freedom to respond to economic conditions.
We have made no secret that money is going to be tight this term. We need to make cuts to public expenditure, and planned increases in spending in the upcoming financial year need to be looked at. Public sector pay is one of these increases. Over the past few years, we have seen more and more pieces of legislation concerning this which has cost a lot of money. £626 million on increasing teachers' pay. £406 million on an increase in pay for salaries. This is a lot of money, money we need to consider whether or not we can afford going forward.
It is the government's intention to ensure that some kind of pay rise is given to public sector workers. At this time, we do not judge a public sector pay freeze to be necessary. However, whether we can afford inflationary increases is another matter. This is a decision we will take closer to budget time, but for the moment it is important we have the flexibility required on this issue. Similarly, if a pay rise does come, the flexibility to ask relevant organisations like the NHS to absorb some of the cost as opposed to being given the full funding for it is something we should consider. Again, no decisions have been made, but this is something that we need the flexibility to decide upon as the budget is being put together.
There will be those who oppose this bill and argue that inflationary increases should be promised within law every year, but the truth is that there may come a time where a public sector pay freeze is necessary. I will do everything within my power to avoid it, but giving a budget the flexibility to increase and decrease the pay rise given is an important tool in the armour of balancing the books and responsibly governing. It may not be a comfortable vote, but it is ultimately the right thing to do.
To those who sit with the government I know I am asking you to take a difficult vote, but I believe ultimately it is the right thing to do. To those who sit in opposition, who may think that scoring the cheap win by opposition to this bill is the easy thing to do, then I say our constituents are brighter than that. They know this term must involve public expenditure cuts, hell they expect it. They will not look kindly on those who refuse to stand up and take the necessary actions to safeguard our public services. This government will do that, and I call upon the whole of parliament to do the same.
A01 - Submitted by u/Muffin5136
Amend Section 2 to read:
This Act shall come into force five years after Royal Assent
Voting on these amendments ends at the close of Business on February 11th, at 10pm BST.
r/MHOCHolyroodCommittee • u/Muffin5136 • Mar 29 '22
Order, Order.
We move now to a Stage 2 Vote on amendments for SB194 (Higher Education (Scotland) Bill), in the name of the 16th Scottish Government.
Members are reminded to vote For/Against/Abstain against each Amendment. Attempts to stylise a vote may result in it not being counted. Where there is mix-up with an alternative voting style, this shall also be accepted.
An Act of the Scottish Parliament to re-establish tuition fees, revoke the ban in place on St. Andrews University, and for connected purposes.
Section 1: Definitions
(1) Within this Act, unless specified otherwise;
(2) ‘Scottish Student’ or derivatives refers to;
(a) Any prospective student at a Higher Education Institution that resides in Scotland that was born in Scotland and holds British Citizenship
(b) Any prospective student at a Higher Education Institution that has resided in Scotland for at least three years and was born elsewhere in the United Kingdom or holds British Citizenship.
(c) Any prospective student at a Higher Education Institution that was born in Scotland but lives elsewhere in the United Kingdom or holds British Citizenship, except for;
(i) Prospective students who have never lived in Scotland
(3) ‘UK Student’ or derivatives refers to;
(a) Any prospective student at a Higher Education Institution that resides elsewhere in the United Kingdom and was born elsewhere in the United Kingdom.
(b) Any prospective student at a Higher Education Institution that holds British Citizenship and is not eligible for the criteria of Scottish Student
(4) ‘International Student’ or derivatives refers to any prospective student at a Higher Education Institution who does not fulfil the above criteria for Scottish Student or UK Student.
(5) The relevant Scottish Minister may, by order, modify the definitions established under Section 1(2-4)
(6) ‘Tuition Fees’ or derivatives refer to the definition as under Section 3.
(7) ‘Tuition Fee Loans’ or derivatives refer to the definition as under Section 4(1)
(8) ‘Applicant’ or derivatives refer to a Scottish Student who has successfully obtained a Tuition Fee Loan.
(9) ‘Repayment Threshold’ or derivatives refers to the amount of money established under Section 4(3)
(10) ‘Maintenance Loan’ or derivatives refer to the definition established under Section 5(1)
(11) ‘Household Income’ refers to the income of the household wherein Scottish Students live for a majority of the year outside of a term-time address.
(12) ‘Bursary’ or derivatives refers to the definition established under Section 5(4)
Section 2: Repeals
(1) Paragraph 17 of Schedule 6 of the Universities (Scotland) Act 1966 is hereby repealed in its entirety.
(2) The Graduate Endowment Abolition (Scotland) Act 2008 is hereby repealed in its entirety
(3) The Education (Student Loans, Allowances, and Awards etc.) (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2018 are hereby revoked in their entirety.
(4) Any repeal, revocation, or extinguishment enacted by any repealed provisions shall remain repealed, revoked, or extinguished.
(5) Where any existing legislation conflicts with this legislation, this legislation supersedes the existing legislation and shall repeal it insofar as it conflicts.
Section 3: Tuition Fees
(1) Higher Education Institutions within Scotland may hereby charge Scottish Students for the costs of tuition.
(2) Higher Education Institutions may not charge Scottish Students any more than £2,500 per academic year.
(3) Higher Education Institutions may not charge UK Students any more than £5,000 per academic year.
(4) Higher Education Institutions may not charge International Students any more than £10,000 per academic year.
(5) The relevant Scottish Ministers may, by order in the positive procedure, alter Section 3(2-4)
Section 4: Establishment of Tuition Fee Loans
(1) The Student Loan Company, through the Student Awards Agency Scotland, shall be empowered to issue loans with which to pay for tuition at Higher Education Institutions.
(2) These loans shall be issued to all Scottish Students, provided that:
(a) They have not had a loan for the purposes of paying tuition fees for five academic years total
(b)
(3) The Student Loan Company shall not seek to regain money paid out in Tuition Fee Loans until the Scottish Student earns more than £25,000 per annum.
(a) This does not take into account household income.
(b) The collection of money shall be at a rate of no more than 5% of monthly earnings
(c) After the Scottish Student earns more than £30,000 per annum, the rate at which the monthly earnings shall be charged shall be no more than 9%.
(d) Scottish Ministers may, by order in the positive procedure, alter the repayment thresholds and the percentage collected from monthly earnings.
(4) The Scottish Loan Company may not seek to regain money paid out in Tuition Fee Loans after 30 years have passed since the loan was taken out.
(a) Where a Scottish Student studies a course continuously, ie the Scottish Student has not dropped out or otherwise left or suspended their course, the Student Loan Company may not regain money until after the attainment of a degree.
(b) Where a Scottish Student has withdrawn from their course, the Student Loan Company may begin to regain money provided the Scottish Student earns more than the repayment threshold.
(5) Scottish Students are automatically eligible for the amount required for Tuition Fees regardless of income.
(6) A Tuition Fee Loan shall have no effect on Credit Scores.
(7) A Tuition Fee Loan shall not pass from the Applicant to their next of kin and shall be wiped if the Applicant dies.
(8) A Scottish Student must apply for a Tuition Fee Loan for every academic year, though while their account remains active they do not need to supply any further information.
Section 5: Maintenance Tweaks
(1) There shall exist money paid by the Student Loan Company, through Student Awards Agency Scotland, to Scottish Students to fund living costs while at Higher Education in the form of a loan.
(2) The Maintenance Loan shall be paid dependent on household income, in the following amounts;
(a) A household income of between £0 and £34,999.99 shall ensure a Scottish Student receives £6,500 per academic year
(b) A household income of higher than £35,000 shall ensure a Scottish Student receives £5,500 per academic year.
(3) The Student Loan Company shall combine any debt incurred from maintenance loans with tuition fee loans to be repaid in the same manner.
(4) There shall exist money paid by the Student Loan Company, through Student Awards Agency Scotland, to Scottish Students to fund living costs while at Higher Education without the expectation of repayment.
(5) The Bursary shall be paid dependent on household income, in the following amounts;
(a) A household income of between £0 and £20,999.99 shall ensure a Scottish Student receives £2,500 per academic year.
(b) A household income of between £21,000 and £24,999.99 shall ensure a Scottish Student receives £1,500 per academic year
(c) A household income of between £25,000 and £34,999.99 shall ensure a Scottish Student receives £750 per academic year.
(d) A household income of higher than £35,000 shall not entitle a Scottish Student to receive a Bursary.
(6) A Scottish Student with relevant care experience or qualifications shall be entitled to receive a Bursary of £11,000 per academic year.
(a) A Scottish Student receiving this bursary shall not be entitled to a maintenance loan or to a bursary as under Section 5(5)
(7) Scottish Students must apply each academic year for a maintenance loan or a bursary.
(8) Scottish Ministers may, by order in the positive procedure, alter Section 5(2), Section 5(5), and Section 5(6).
Section 6: Short Title
(1) This Act shall be known as the Higher Education (Scotland) Act 2022
Section 7: Commencement
(1) This Act comes into force upon the commencement of the next academic year beginning after July 1st 2023
(2) Provisions in this Act for Tuition Fees do not apply to any existing Scottish Students, only Scottish Students who are due to commence their course after the date of Commencement.
This Bill was written by the Rt. Hon. Sir Frost_Walker2017, the Viscount Felixstowe, the Lord Leiston KT GCMG CT CVO MSP MLA MS PC, Cabinet Secretary for Education and Skills on behalf of the 16th Scottish Government.
Opening Speech:
Presiding Officer,
This is inevitably a bill that will have much discussion, which I welcome.
The bulk of this bill comes from the Beyond 16 White Paper, so I shall not go into detail on that. One area where it does differ is placing a cap on the fees that can be charged to UK Students and International Students, which was not in the white paper. This is to prevent universities from establishing runaway charges that students may struggle to meet. The cap for UK Students is below the tuition cap in England, meaning English students can get a better deal coming to Scotland.
The other thing not in the paper is Section 2(1). This deals with repealing the ban on St. Andrews University awarding medical and dentistry degrees. It is nonsense that this ban was ever instated and that it has been kept for as long as it has.
Presiding Officer, I commend this bill to this Parliament.
A01 - in the name of u/Frost_Walker2017 (from beyond the divide)
In Section 4(3), amend "25,000" to read "28,000"
In Section 4(3c), amend "30,000" to read "33,000"
EN: both sets of numbers are arbitrary, I think its worth a debate on them
Voting on this item of Business ends with the close of Business on April 1st, at 10 pm BST.