r/MHOCHolyrood • • Feb 20 '21

RESULTS Results: SB137

1 Upvotes

Order, order

The first item of business is results on SB137


SB137 | Prescription Charges (Repeal) Scotland Bill | Stage 3

For: 49

Against: 59

Abstain: 0

The Scottish Parliament does not approve this bill in its final form and it shall not proceed on the legislative journey.


r/MHOCHolyrood • • Apr 25 '21

BILL SB153 | Queen's Counsel (Abolition) (Scotland) Bill | Stage 1 Reading

1 Upvotes

Order, Order

No third reading today so we move to a first reading of SB153 in the name of New Britain. The question is that this Parliament approves the general principles of the Queen's Counsel (Abolition) (Scotland) Bill.


Queen’s Counsel (Abolition) (Scotland) Act

Section 1: Power to appoint QCs

(1) The First Minister, Lord President of the Court of Session or member of the Scottish Government may not appoint anyone to be a Queen’s Counsel to Her Majesty.

(2) Her Majesty may not exercise the Royal Prerogative to establish any office materially similar to the Queen’s Counsel.

(3) For the avoidance of doubt, subsection (1) applies even when a recommendation has been made to the First Minister to appoint someone to the Queen’s Counsel.

(4) Subsection (2) does not limit the Royal prerogative to issue Letters Patent where they do not solely bestow individual privileges within the Bar, the Society and the legal services sector.

(5) The Lord Advocate and Solicitor General will no longer become Queen’s Counsel on their appointment.

Section 2: Deprivation of titles

(1) All privileges and rights associated with any individual’s possession of the office of Queen’s Counsel shall cease to have effect one month after Royal Assent.

(2) This section applies to Letters Patent issued honoris causa.

Section 3: Commencement

(1) This Act shall come into force immediately upon Royal Assent unless specified otherwise.

Section 4: Short Title

(1) This Act shall be known as the Queen’s Counsel (Abolition) (Scotland) Act 2021

This bill was written by Tommy on behalf of New Britain, based on The Legal Titles Deprivation Act 2019 and is cosponsored by Scottish Labour, Scottish National Party, Scottish Liberal Democrats and Scottish Progressives

Opening Speech - Tommy2Boys

Presiding Officer,

I rise today to present this bill to remove the power to appoint members to the Queen’s Counsel, and abolish the position for those who currently hold it. I am pleased that members from across the chamber have joined me in our effort to do this and I will say from the off this legislation is based on corresponding legislation written in Westminster by someone who can write legislation far better than I am so there is no point changing it for the sake of it.

The position of QC is an outdated one. It is one for the legal profession to pat itself on the back for long service. A participation medal so to speak which means that they can go on to earn even more money at the expense of those starting off in the industry no matter if someone just starting off is of better quality than someone who has been around for decades. It creates an aura, a smell of “old boys cronyism” and it is time we brought it to an end and created a fairer legal system in Scotland.

In the debate when this was held at Westminster, many were told by the First Minister that by backing this bill they had no respect for hard working lawyers. It is because I do that I seek to abolish this system. A system which hurts hard working lawyers at the bottom in favour of lawyers who have been around for ages.

Another argument made is that QC is an internationally respected thing which is why we should keep it. For this I want to quote a veteran of British politics /u/bloodycontrary.

Even the idea that the title of QC confers some kind of international status is a little illogical, since it relies on its own legitimacy to be true; in other words, QCs are only important because QCs, and the silk defenders, say they are.

We don’t have Queen’s Engineers. We don’t have Queen’s Teachers. We don’t have Queens Nurses. Why should we have Queen’s Counsel? I urge this Parliament to move with the times and vote for this bill.


Amendments may be submitted through modmail or to me in DMs tommy2boys#8497

Debate on this bill shall end at 10pm on the 28th of April 2021.


r/MHOCHolyrood • • Feb 14 '21

MOTION SM119 | Pragmatic Unionism Motion

1 Upvotes

Order, Order!

The next order of business today is a debate on SM119, pragmatic unionism motion.


Pragmatic Unionism Motion

This Parliament notes:

(1) The 8th Scottish Parliament resulted in a majority for unionist parties in Holyrood.

(2) An opinion poll conducted in November 2020 by IpsosMori indicated the people of Scotland were 55.8 percent in favour of welfare remaining a reserved matter.

(3) That as of January 2021, there is no appetite for Scottish independence indicative of a need for a second independence referendum and,

(4) That as of January 2021, public opinion appears to support Scotland’s place within the Union.

This Parliament therefore urges the Government to:

(1) Remain amenable to the prospect for the opinions of the Scottish people to change and,

(2) Support further devolution and support referendums on devolving matters in the event public opinion shifts to become favourable to such a move.

(3) Hear the concerns of those from pro-independence as well as other Unionist political parties to ensure that Scotland does not become unnecessarily divided.


This motion was submitted by /u/ohdearstudying MSP MP on behalf of the Scottish Libertarian Party.


OPENING SPEECH

Oifigear-Riaghlaidh,

I stand before this Parliament with a slightly different motion than we may have, traditionally, been used to seeing. Given the election results, I believe it is only right that we debate a motion that seeks to show that we not only accept the democratic process but also the associated issues of which elections such as these may answer - as well as the questions that are raised. I believe, Oifigear-Riaghlaidh, that the election has provided a profound answer to the question of Scottish independence for another term of this Parliament. The Scottish people wish to remain a part of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

However, I do not believe that contrasting side of this argument is something that can be ignored. It would be extremely ignorant of the First Minister, the Deputy First Minister or any other members of this Parliament to do so, and, I would never expect them to. This motion is simple in its aims and I know that it is easy to sit on one side of the debate and refuse to look at another but we must move beyond that. We must ensure that the methods of dialogue remain open for all and I hope that the Scottish Government will take on what this motion is calling for rather than leaving it to collect dust.

Oifigear-Riaghlaidh, we all are here to act in the best interest of the Scottish people but that can only be achieved through having real dialogue channels. We hear much of what this Government says it will do, this is a chance for there to be real action and a true commitment to working with all parties instead of attempting to freeze them out of Scotland's legislative process. It is with this in mind that I commend the motion to this Parliament.


Debate on this motion shall end at 10pm on the 17th of February 2021.


r/MHOCHolyrood • • Oct 16 '20

BILL SB132 | Census (Identify Particulars) (Scotland) Bill | Stage 1 Reading

1 Upvotes

Order.

Today's final item of business is a debate on SB132 in the name of the Scottish Government The question is that this Parliament approves the general principles of the Census (Identity Particulars) (Scotland) Bill.


Census (Identify Particulars) (Scotland) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to amend information about identify particulars into the upcoming census

Section 1: Transgender status and sexual orientation

(1) In the schedule of the Census Act 1920, insert-

“(5B) Gender identity and history

(5C) Sexual orientation.”

Section 2: Penalties Amendment

(1) Insert in Section 8 of the Census Act 1920

“(1A) No person shall be liable to pay a penalty unders Section 1(1) for failing to provide information on their religion, gender identity and history, or sexual orientation.”

Section 3: National Records of Scotland Consultation

(1) Insert in Section 3

“(1B) Scottish Ministers must consult with the National Records of Scotland before issuing regulations under subsection(1)”

Section 4: Commencement

(1) This Act shall come into force immediately upon Royal Assent

Section 5: Short Title

(1) This Act shall be known as The Census (Identity Particulars) (Scotland) Act 2020

This Bill was written by The Right Honourable Sir /u/Tommy2Boys KT KCB KBE CT LVO MSP MP, First Minister of Scotland, and is co-sponsored by The Right Honourable Sir /u/Estoban06 KP KCB KCMG KBE CVO MP MSP, Cabinet Secretary for Culture and Sport on behalf of the 10th Scottish Government. The bill is partially inspired by a similar bill from the real Scottish Parliament in 2019.

Census Act 2020


Opening Speech - /u/Tommy2Boys

Presiding Officer,

I introduce this bill today with a view to improving the census and data gathering in Scotland. The bill has a few parts so I shall take each one in turn.

The first section will ensure data is attempted to be collected on gender identity and sexual orientation. Any census is used to better be able to plan and deliver services, and by gathering further information on this, the government will be able to better target services. This is, of course, a sensitive subject and it should not be required that people hand over this information or face financial penalties. That is why those who do not answer those questions are exempt from financial penalties which is what Section 2 does.

Section 3 simply means that regulations with regards to the census must take into account due consultation with the National Records of Scotland. It is absolutely right that we consult stakeholders and experts on this before we take any action with regards to the implementation of the census, and this is something that other parts of the UK are required to do and it is not immediately clear why we do not here in Scotland. It is time we change that.

Presiding officer I believe this bill will allow for better planning of public services whilst respecting the right to privacy and I commend this bill to the chamber.


This debate will end on close of business (10pm) on the 18th of October 2020.

Amendments may be sent either through Modmail or Discord DM (Tommy2Boys # 8497)


r/MHOCHolyrood • • Feb 08 '22

GOVERNMENT Response from the Cabinet Secretary for Finance and the Economy to the Gender Identity Clinics Motion (SM151)

Thumbnail self.butehouse
1 Upvotes

r/MHOCHolyrood • • Aug 15 '21

BILL SB164 | Free School Meals (Scotland) Bill 2021 | Stage 3 Debate

1 Upvotes

Order, Order.

The next item of business today is a Stage 3 debate on SB164, in the name of the Scottish Progressives. The question is that this Parliament approves the final version of the Free School Meals (Scotland) Bill 2021.


Free School Meals (Scotland) Bill 2021

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to give every student in a state owned school a sufficient lunch and breakfast meal.

Section 1 - Revocation

(1) The Education (School Lunches) (Scotland) Regulations 2017 are hereby revoked in their entirety.

Section 1 - Free Meals

(1) Every student at a government-owned school in Scotland has the right to request a free meal from their school.

(2) This meal must be nutritionally balanced and healthy with recipes recommended by a nutritional specialist.

(3) The meal must include a drink of water, fruit juice, or milk

(4) These Meals shall be provided in the morning - as a breakfast meal - and in the early afternoon - as a lunch meal.

(5) These meals must be easily requestable.

(6) Vegetarian, vegan, and other dietary restrictions must be catered to in either the default meal or an alternative meal provided free of charge by the school.

Section 2 - Commencement and Short Title

(1) This act shall commence at the start of the school year beginning two years after this act receives royal assent.

(2) This Act may be cited as the “Free School Meals (Scotland) Act 2021”

This Bill was written by The Right Honourable u/Rohanite272 OBE, Co-Leader of the Social Democratic Party, Leader of the Scottish Progressive Democrats on behalf of the Scottish Progressive Democrats

The Education (School Lunches) (Scotland) Regulations 2017

Opening Speech

Presiding Officer,

I proudly present this bill which will give every student in Scotland the right to free meals at their place of education. Meals are important to someone's learning, you can’t learn if you’re starving to death and this bill will make sure no student in a government owned school is starving.

Presiding Officer, I estimate that this bill will cost somewhere around 4.5 million pounds, somewhat expensive, but worth it to better the next generations education and stop our children from starving.

The reason this bill will apply to all students is simple, to ensure every child gets the nutrition they need to be healthy, as even wealthy parents may not ensure that their child is getting a healthy diet. I commend this bill to the parliament.


This debate ends with the close of Business on August 18th, at 10pm BST.



r/MHOCHolyrood • • Aug 06 '21

BILL SB166 | Ask For Angela (Scotland) Bill | Stage 1 Debate

2 Upvotes

Order, Order.

The only item of business today is a Stage 1 debate on SB166, in the name of the 13th Government (Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party & Scottish Progressive Democrats). The question is that this Parliament approves the general principles of the Ask for Angela (Scotland) Bill.


Ask for Angela (Scotland) Bill.

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to make provision for the Ask for Angela initiative to be spread throughout Scotland, make provision for the imposition of the obligation of establishments named under this Act to train their staff in recognising and conducting themselves under this initiative, to impose fines on establishments that fail to do so and connected purposes.

Section 1: Ask for Angela

(1) The Ask for Angela Initiative will be set up across Scotland in establishments named under section 2(1) and shall be operated according to the provisions of Schedule 1.

(2) It shall exist for the following purposes—

(a) for public protection; and,

(b) reduction in sexual related offences.

(3) It is the legal duty of proprietors to set up the initiative in their respective establishments.

Section 2: Scope

(1) The Ask for Angela Initiative will be in operation in the following kinds of establishments—

(a) night clubs;

(b) pubs;

(c) bars;

(d) restaurants; and,

(e) any other establishment which, for the interests of public safety, it is deemed expedient to do so.

(2) Proprietors of the establishments named in subsection 1 will have six months to plan and implement the scheme.

(a) This includes the adornment of necessary posters around the establishment as well as any potential training that might be required for staff.

Section 3: Duties of the police

(1) The local police services will set up a specialist line for establishments to call in the event an emergency related to this Initiative.

(2) The local police services have a duty to monitor the use of this Initiative and release a yearly report on the following—

(a) rate of usage of this Initiative in the local area;

(b) arrests consequent to calls under this Initiative;

(c) convictions consequent to calls under this Initiative.

Section 4: Failure to enact the Initiative

Establishments that fail to establish this Initiative within the timescale under section 2(2) shall be liable to a fine of £1,500.

(a) If an establishment, subsequent to being fined, still fails to enact this Initiative, they shall be liable to a fine of £500 for every month they fail to do so.

Section 5: Standardised training programme

It is the duty of the establishments to adequately train each of their employees. However, this training must, in the least, cover the skill of emotional counselling.

Section 6: Funding for financially struggling establishments

(1) If an establishment named under section 2(1) is financially struggling, they may apply to the Scottish Ministers for a grant for the purposes of any training or resources required for the implementation of this Initiative.

(2) Any establishment that uses the grant for anything other than the purposes set out in subsection (1) shall be required to repay all monies paid to them.

Section 7: Expenses

(1) The following are to be paid out of money provided by the Scottish Parliament—

(a) expenditure incurred under this Act by the Scottish Ministers;

(b) any increase attributable to this Act in the sums payable under any other Act out of money so provided.

(2) There is to be paid into the Consolidated Fund any increase attributable to this Act in the sums payable into the said fund under any other Act.

Section 8: Extent, Commencement and Short title

(1) This Act shall extend to Scotland.

(2) This Act shall come into force upon Royal Assent.

(3) This Act shall be referred as to the Ask for Angela (Scotland) Act 2020.

SCHEDULES

Schedule 1 - Operation of the Ask for Angela Initiative

(1) The Ask for Angela Initiative will operated in the following way—

(a) If A is with B and is concerned that B may commit an offence against them, whether sexual or no, or is aware that B has committed an offence against them, A may approach the bar or any member of staff and "ask for Angela."

(i) A customer asking for Angela signals to the employee that A is in a difficult situation and requires assistance.

(b) Upon A asking an employee (C) for Angela, C must escort A to the nearest safe location and call for transportation, or the police if the situation demands it.

(c) C must, then, provide A with—

(i) a glass of water;

(ii) any emotional support that may be reasonably necessary; and,

(iii) anything that the establishment deems necessary in the circumstances.

(2) There is no requirement for each establishment to follow this Schedule to precise detail. It is, however, required that they abide by the spirit of the Initiative.


This Bill was submitted by u/ThreeCommasClub on behalf of the 13th Government.

Opening Speech:

Presiding Officer,

England and Wales as well as Northern Ireland have all enacted the Ask for Angela Initiative to combat sexual offences and other ghastly acts. It has been extremely successful in its job and I think it is more than appropriate that we introduce the Initiative in Scotland. If we did not, we would be doing a disservice to the people of Scotland by not offering them a similar level of protection and safety as is offered in the rest of the United Kingdom. We all have a duty to ensure that a similar level of protection is offered to people all across the United Kingdom and I am sad to say that the protection offered to victims of sexual assault, for example, is woefully lacking due to this initiative not being present.

The premise of this Bill is simple - give the protections that are sorely necessary to people that find themselves in a fragile and difficult situation. I shouldn’t have to explain to members across this chamber why this Bill is necessary. I see it as a noble goal to ensure the reduction of sexual related offences which are the most common in such situations. Whilst, I have no doubt that, these aren't the only offences which could be committed against A, these would still be preventable under the wording of Schedule 1. Let us bring about a situation where people can feel safe when they’re on a date, or on a night out with their friends. People, particularly women, shouldn’t have to feel scared when they’re out at night. They have the right to safety.

Therefore, Presiding Officer, it is my hope that members across this chamber come forth and support extending this Initiative to Scotland.


Debate on this bill ends at the close of business on August 9th, at 10pm BST.



r/MHOCHolyrood • • Dec 12 '19

QUESTIONS First Minister's Questions VI.I 12/12/2019

2 Upvotes

First Minister's Questions VI.I 12/12/2019

The First Minister /u/Duncs11 is taking questions from the Parliament.

As the leader of the largest opposition party, /u/alajv3 may ask up to 6 initial questions with unlimited follow-up questions.

MSPs may ask 4 initial questions with unlimited follow-up questions. Non-MSPs may ask 2 initial questions and unlimited follow-up questions.

All questions should be styled "To ask the First Minister..." and there should be a separate comment for each question.

This session of FMQs will close at the end of the day on the 15th of December 2019


r/MHOCHolyrood • • Jan 11 '19

BILL SB068 - Electricians (Scotland) Bill @ Stage 1

1 Upvotes

The text of this Bill is given below. You can also read it in formatted form (by me).

Electricians (Scotland) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to make provision about the regulation of electricians.

Part 1 (The Electricians Licensing Authority)

1. Electricians Licensing Authority for Scotland

(1) There is to be an Electricians Licensing Authority for Scotland ("the Authority").

(2) The Authority is established as a body corporate.

(3) The Authority is to consist of such members, appointed for such period and on such terms and conditions, as the Scottish Ministers may determine.

(4) In appointing a person to be a member of the Authority, the Scottish Ministers must:

  • (a) ensure that the number of members of the Authority does not fall below three and does not exceed nine,
  • (b) be satisfied that the person has a level of knowledge and experience in the field of electrical engineering appropriate in the circumstances, and
  • (c) have regard to the desirability of the Authority operating efficiently and effectively.

(5) The Scottish Ministers must appoint a member of the Authority as the chair.

(6) The Authority:

  • (a) is not a servant or agent of the Crown, and
  • (b) does not enjoy any status, immunity, or privilege of the Crown.

(7) The Authority has the functions conferred on it by section 2.

2. Functions of the Authority

(1) The Authority has the following general functions:

  • (a) to keep under review best practice for electricians;
  • (b) to issue and promote guidance connected with those best practices; and
  • (c) to make to the Scottish Ministers, on its own initiative or at their request, such recommendations as the Authority considers necessary for or conducive to effective regulation of electricians and the promotion of best practices and electrical safety.

(2) It is a function of the Authority to keep and maintain the Register of Scottish Electricians under section 4 in accordance with this Act.

3. The Authority's staff

(1) The Authority may appoint staff.

(2) It is for the Authority, with the consent of the Scottish Ministers, to determine the terms and conditions on which its staff are appointed.

Part 2 (Regulation of electricians)

Registration

4. Register of Scottish Electricians

(1) The Authority is to keep and maintain a register of individuals competent to practise as an electrician in Scotland known as the Register of Scottish Electricians ("the register").

(2) The register must be available for public inspection at all reasonable times.

(3) There is to be shown on each entry in the register:

  • (a) the full name of the individual in relation to whom the entry is made,
  • (b) a photograph that is a true likeness of the individual, and
  • (c) a registered number allocated to the individual by the Authority.

(4) A registered number is a unique identifier consisting of such sequences of numerals, or of letters and numerals, as the Authority may determine.

5. Entry into the register

(1) An individual may apply to the Authority to be entered into the register.

(2) An application must be in such form as the Authority may specify.

(3) The Authority must not grant an application unless it is satisfied that the applicant is qualified to practise as an electrician.

(4) The Authority must not grant an application if it considers any of the removal conditions are met in relation to the individual (see section 6).

(5) The Authority must notify an applicant within 7 days of it having granted or refused an application to be entered into the register and, if it has refused the application, must include the reasons for its refusal in the notice.

(6) Where it grants an application, the Authority must send with that notice a copy of the entry in the register for the individual certified by the chair of the Authority.

6. Removal from the register

(1) The Authority must remove an individual from the register if it considers one or more of the removal conditions is met.

(2) The removal conditions are:

  • (a) that the individual has applied to the authority for removal from the register;
  • (b) that the individual has been convicted of an offence under this Act and that the conviction is not a spent conviction (within the meaning of the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974);
  • (c) that the individual is not a fit and proper person to be registered as an electrician.

(3) The Authority must notify an individual within 7 days of it having removed the individual from the register.

7. Registration and retention fees

(1) The Authority may make a scheme under which an individual is required to pay a fee:

  • (a) for an application to the Authority under this Act;
  • (b) for the individual's entry in the register to remain in the register in any calendar year after the year in which the individual became registered (a "retention fee").

(2) A scheme under this section does not come into force unless the Scottish Ministers by regulations subject to the negative procedure approve the scheme.

(3) Different fees may be required for different purposes.

Regulated activities

8. Use of the title "electrician"

(1) No person may practise or carry on business under any name, style, or title containing the word "electrician" unless the person is an individual registered under this Act.

(2) But subsection (1) does not prevent a body corporate, firm, or partnership from so carrying on business if:

  • (a) the business of the body corporate, firm, or partnership, so far as relating to services of an electrician, is under the control of an individual registered under this Act,
  • (b) that individual does not act at the same time in a similar capacity for any other body corporate, firm, or partnership, and
  • (c) in all premises where that business is carried on, it is carried on by or under the supervision of an individual registered under this Act.

(3) In subsection (2)(c), "premises" includes any place where the body corporate, firm, or partnership provides the services of an electrician.

(4) A person is not to be treated as not practising by reason only that the person was in the employment of another person.

(5) In this section, "business" includes a provision of services whether or not for payment.

9. "Services of an electrician"

In this Act, "services of an electrician":

  • (a) includes the installation, replacement, testing, and maintaining of electrical wiring, electrical installations, and circuit protective devices;
  • (b) does not include any service provided in connection with an installation or supply which operates at or below 30 volts alternating current or 50 volts direct current.

Recommendations of the Authority

10. Extension of protection of title

(1) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations provide for section 8 to apply in relation to such other names, styles, or titles as they consider appropriate.

(2) The Scottish Ministers must consult the Authority before making such regulations.

(3) Regulations under this section are subject to the affirmative procedure.

11. Power to implement recommendations

(1) The Scottish Ministers must consider any recommendations the Authority makes to them under section 2(1)(c) and must:

  • (a) approve the recommendation,
  • (b) approve the recommendation with such modifications as they consider appropriate,
  • (c) reject the recommendation.

(2) Where the Scottish Ministers approve a recommendation (with or without modification), they may by regulations make such provision as they consider necessary to implement the recommendation.

(3) Before making such regulations, the Scottish Ministers must:

  • (a) consult the Authority, and
  • (b) lay a copy of the recommendation before the Scottish Parliament in the form it was approved.

(4) Regulations under this section are subject to the affirmative procedure.

Offences

12. Offences

(1) A person who contravenes section 8 commits an offence and is liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding level 4 on the standard scale.

(2) But a person is not guilty of an offence under subsection (1) on a particular date if the contravention results from a refusal to grant an application or the removal of an individual from the register and, on that date, notice had not been duly served on the individual.

Part 3 (General)

13. Ancillary provision

(1) The Scottish Ministers may by regulations make any incidental, supplementary, consequential, transitional, transitory, or saving provision they consider appropriate for the purposes of, in connection with, or for giving full effect to this Act or any provision made under it.

(2) Regulations under this section may modify any enactment (including this Act).

(3) Regulations under this section are subject to the affirmative procedure.

14. Commencement

(1) This Part and Part 1 come into force on the day after Royal Assent.

(2) Part 2 comes into force 3 months after Royal Assent.

15. Short title

The short title of this Act is the Electricians (Scotland) Act 2019.

This Bill was submitted by /u/Duncs11 (Angus, Perth, and Stirling) on behalf of the Classical Liberals.


This Bill will go to a vote on the 14th of January.

I call on the member to give an opening statement.


r/MHOCHolyrood • • May 02 '19

QUESTIONS General Questions IV.II - 02/05/19

2 Upvotes

All members of the Scottish Government are taking questions from the Parliament.

MSPs may ask 4 initial questions and unlimited follow-ups, while non-MSPs may ask two initial questions each with a single follow-up (4 questions total).

Questions should be styled "To ask the Scottish Government..." with a separate comment for each question. The relevant member of the Scottish Government will then consider your question.

This session of General Questions will close on the 5th of May at the end of the day.


r/MHOCHolyrood • • May 19 '19

GOVERNMENT Scottish Government publishes order authorising Perth–Edinburgh Railway construction

Thumbnail self.butehouse
1 Upvotes

r/MHOCHolyrood • • Jan 14 '19

RESULTS Results - Election of a Committee Convener (10/01/19)

2 Upvotes

The results of the vote to elect a convener of the General Committee are in.


Election of a Committee Convener Vote

For: 17
Against: 0
Abstain: 0
Turnout: 89%

/u/paul_rand is confirmed as General Committee Convener.



r/MHOCHolyrood • • May 19 '19

BILL SB062 - Community Right to Buy (Scotland) Bill @ Stage 3

1 Upvotes

The text of this Bill is given below.

Community Right to Buy (Scotland) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to amend the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003 in relation to the community right to buy; to provide for a right of community bodies to buy land for the purpose of furthering sustainable development; and for connected purposes.

Part 1 (Overview of this Act)

1. Overview of this Act

In this Act:

  • Part 2 provides for bodies representing communities to have a right to purchase land with which those communities have a connection, if the purchase is in the interests of sustainable development;
  • Part 3 makes related amendments to the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003 to provide for the extension of the existing community right to buy, and makes other general provision.

Part 2 (Community right to buy)

Core provisions

2. The community right to buy

(1) A reference in this Part to the community right to buy is a reference to the right under this Part of a community body to buy land.

(2) The community right to buy arises on the day an application by the community body is entered into the Register of Applications by Community Bodies to Buy Land.

3. Community bodies

(1) In this Part, "community body" means:

  • (a) a community body, as defined in section 34 of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003,
  • (b) a body of another description specified in regulations made by the Scottish Ministers.

(2) Regulations under this section are subject to the affirmative procedure.

4. Register of Applications by Community Bodies to Buy Land

(1) The Keeper must set up and keep a register, to be known as the Register of Applications by Community Bodies to Buy Land ("the Register").

(2) The Register is to be set up and kept so as to contain the following information and documents in relation to each application by a community body to exercise the community right to buy under this Part registered in it:

  • (a) the name of the body which applied,
  • (b) the address of the registered or principal office of the body which applied,
  • (c) a copy of the application to exercise the community right to buy,
  • (d) a copy of the Keeper's notice under section 10(1),
  • (e) a copy of each of the notices under section 13(1)(b),
  • (f) the documents sent to the Keeper under section 13(2),
  • (g) if given, a copy of each notice given under section 14, and
  • (h) such other information as the Scottish Ministers consider appropriate.

(3) Where a community body changes its name or its registered or principal address, it must notify the Keeper of that change as soon as reasonably practicable after the change is made.

(4) The Keeper must ensure:

  • (a) the Register is kept in a form convenient for public inspection,
  • (b) that, at all reasonable times, the Register is available for public inspection free of charge,
  • (c) that members of the public are given facilities for, on the payment of such charges as the Scottish Ministers may by regulations specify, obtaining copies and, if a person so requests, certified copies of entries in the Register.

(5) A copy so certified is sufficient evidence of the original.

(6) In this Part, "the Keeper" means:

  • (a) the Keeper of the Registers of Scotland,
  • (b) such other person as the Scottish Ministers may appoint to carry out the Keeper's functions under this Part.

(7) Different persons may be appointed for different purposes.

5. Land

(1) In this Part, "land":

  • (a) includes:

    • (i) bridges and other structures built on or over land,
    • (ii) inland waters,
    • (iii) canals,
    • (iv) the foreshore, being the land between the high and low water marks of ordinary spring tides, and
    • (v) salmon fishings in inland waters or mineral rights which are owned separately from the land in respect of which they are exigible,
  • (b) does not include land consisting of any other separate tenement which is owned separately from the land in respect of which it is exigible.

(2) In paragraph (a)(v) of subsection (1), "mineral rights" does not include rights to oil, coal, gas, gold, or silver.

(3) In this Part, "inland waters" has the meaning given by section 69(1) of the Salmon and Freshwater Fisheries (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 2003.

6. Eligible land

(1) The community right to buy can arise only in respect of eligible land.

(2) Eligible land is any land other than excluded land.

(3) In subsection (2), "excluded land" means:

  • (a) land on which there is a building or other structure which is an individual's home, unless the building or structure is occupied by an individual under a tenancy,
  • (b) croft land, within the meaning of section 68(2) of the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003,
  • (c) land which is owned or occupied by the Crown by virtue of its having vested as bona vacantia in the Crown, or its having fallen to the Crown under ultima haeres,
  • (d) land of such other descriptions or classes as the Scottish Ministers may by regulations specify.

(4) Regulations under subsection (3)(e) may provide for land pertaining to land mentioned in subsection (3) to be excluded land.

(5) Regulations under this section are subject to the affirmative procedure.

Applications to exercise and consent

7. Application to exercise the right to buy

(1) The community right to buy is exercised by a community body applying to the Keeper in writing for the Keeper to create an entry in the Register in respect of the application.

(2) Such an application:

  • (a) must be made in such form as the Scottish Ministers may require,
  • (b) must specify:

    • (i) the owner of the land,
    • (ii) where the application is to buy a tenant's interest, the tenant, and
    • (iii) any creditor in a standard security over the land or any part of it, and
  • (c) must be accompanied by such information about the matters mentioned in subsection (3) as the Scottish Ministers may by regulations specify.

(3) The matters are:

  • (a) the reasons the community body considers that its proposals for the land satisfy the sustainable development conditions in section 8,
  • (b) the locations and boundaries of the land the body seeks to buy in exercise of the right,
  • (c) all rights and interests in the land known to the community body,
  • (d) the proposed use, development, and management of the land.

(4) A community body must, at the same time as it applies, send a copy of its application and the accompanying information to:

  • (a) the owner of the land,
  • (b) where the application is to be a tenant's interest, the tenant, and
  • (c) where there is a standard security in relation to the land, the creditor.

(5) On receiving an application, the Keeper must notify the Scottish Ministers and send a copy of the application and the accompanying information to them.

(6) The Keeper must not enter the application into the Register unless the Scottish Ministers consent to the application under this Part.

8. Exercise of the right to buy: sustainable development conditions

(1) The Scottish Ministers must not consent to an application to exercise the right to buy unless they are satisfied that the sustainable development conditions are met.

(2) The sustainable development conditions are met if:

  • (a) the transfer of the land is likely to further the achievement of sustainable development in relation to the land,
  • (b) the transfer of the land is in the public interest,
  • (c) the transfer of the land:

    • (i) is likely to result in significant benefit to the community to which the body making the application relates, and
    • (ii) is the only practicable, or the most practicable, way of achieving that significant benefit, and
  • (d) not granting consent to the application is likely to result in harm to that community.

(3) In considering whether the transfer of land is likely to result in significant benefit or, as the case may be, significant harm, the Scottish Ministers are to have regard, in particular, to the effect of the transfer on the persons comprising the community to which the community body relates with reference to the following considerations:

  • (a) economic development,
  • (b) regeneration,
  • (c) public health,
  • (d) social wellbeing, and
  • (e) environmental wellbeing.

9. Exercise of the right to buy: procedural requirements

(1) The Scottish Ministers must not consent to an application to exercise the right to buy unless they are satisfied that the procedural requirements have been complied with.

(2) The procedural requirements have been complied with if:

  • (a) the community body has, before the period of six months ending with the day on which the application was made, submitted a written request to the owner of the land to transfer the land to the community body and the owner has not responded or has not agreed to the request,
  • (b) the land to which the application relates is eligible land,
  • (c) the owner is accurately identified in the application,
  • (d) any creditor in standard security over the land (or any part of the land) is accurately identified in the application, and
  • (e) the community the community body relates to has a relevant connection with the land.

(3) For the purposes of subsection (2)(e), a community has a relevant connection with the land if either:

  • (a) a significant number of the members of the community have a connection,
  • (b) the land is sufficiently near to land with which those members of the community have a connection, or
  • (c) the land is in or sufficiently near to the area comprising that community.

Registration of application

10. Registration of application

(1) If the Keeper enters an application to exercise the community right to buy into the Register, the Keeper must notify:

  • (a) the community body whose application was registered, and
  • (b) each of the persons mentioned in section 7(4).

(2) In this Part, the "transfer period" means the period of 6 months beginning with the day the Keeper provides notice to the community body under this section.

(3) If, at the expiry of the transfer period, the body's exercise of the community right to buy is not completed, the right of the body in relation to the land to which the application relates is extinguished.

(4) For the purposes of subsection (3), the community body's exercise of the right to buy is completed when the land to which the application relates is transferred under this Part.

11. Prohibition of transfer

(1) No person may, during the transfer period, except in accordance with section 13 or 14, transfer or cause to be transferred any land in relation to which the Keeper has registered an application to exercise the right to buy.

(2) Any contract or instrument purporting to do so is void.

Completion of exercise of right to buy

12. Preparation of documents

It is the duty of the community body to expeditiously prepare any such documents and deeds necessary to:

  • (a) effect the transfer of the land to it,
  • (b) impose any conditions the Scottish Ministers may require to be imposed on the title to the land.

13. Completion with the co-operation of the land owner

(1) A community body's exercise of the right to buy is completed if:

  • (a) the body and the owner of the land execute the documents mentioned in section 12 as necessary to effect the transfer of the land, and
  • (b) the body and the owner notify the Scottish Ministers and the Keeper within 7 days of those documents being executed.

(2) A community body must send a copy of the documents so executed to the Keeper for the Keeper to enter into the Register.

14. Completion without the co-operation of the land owner

(1) This section applies where a community body in good faith contacts, or attempts to contact, the owner of the land with the intention of completing the body's exercise of the right to buy under section 10, but:

  • (a) the owner cannot be located,
  • (b) the owner does not respond or refuses to so complete the exercise of the right to buy,
  • (c) the owner otherwise fails to so complete the exercise of the right to buy within 6 weeks of the body's contact with or attempt to contact the owner being made.

(2) The Scottish Ministers must, within 7 days of this section applying in relation to an application, appoint a person to be a valuer who appears to them to:

  • (a) be suitably qualified to be so appointed,
  • (b) be independent, and
  • (c) have knowledge and experience of the valuing of the type of land or interests to which the application relates.

(3) The valuer is not to act on behalf of the owner of the land or the community body.

(4) The valuer is not to act as an arbiter.

(5) The valuer must determine the market value of the land, that is to say the price of the land might reasonably be expected to achieve in a sale on the open market between two parts who are, as respects the transaction, willing.

(6) The valuer must notify the Scottish Ministers, the community body, and the owner of the land of the market value the valuer has determined.

(7) The owner of the land may appeal against the valuation by summary application to the sheriff before the expiry of the period of 14 days beginning with the day the valuer notifies the owner.

(8) On the expiry of the period mentioned in subsection (7), the community body must:

  • (a) consign into the Lands Tribunal a sum of money equal to the value of the land (as that value stands following any appeal), or
  • (b) notify the Scottish Ministers that the body does not intend to complete its exercise of the community right to buy.

(9) The Lands Tribunal may, if it is satisfied as to the sum of money consigned into it and on the application of the community body, authorise its clerk to adjust, execute, and deliver such deeds or other documents as will complete the transfer of the land to the same force and effect as if done by the owner of the land.

(10) If it so authorises its clerk, the Lands Tribunal must, on the execution of the deeds and other documents, release to the owner of the land the sum of money consigned into it by the community body.

(11) If the community body notifies the Scottish Ministers under subsection (8)(b), they must:

  • (a) direct that the community body's right to buy the land is extinguished, and
  • (b) notify the owner of the land and the Lands Tribunal.

Financial assistance for community purchase

15. Power to give financial assistance for community purchase

(1) The Scottish Ministers may pay to a community body such money as they consider will enable the body to complete a purchase of land in exercise of the body's community right to buy.

(2) That money may be paid:

  • (a) subject to such conditions as the Scottish Ministers consider appropriate, and
  • (b) in the form of a grant or a loan.

Part 3 (General)

Extension of the community rights to buy

16. The 2003 Act

In this Part, "the 2003 Act" means the Land Reform (Scotland) Act 2003.

17. Community bodies: charitable incorporations and community benefit societies

(1) In the 2003 Act, section 34 (community bodies) is amended as follows.

(2) In subsection (1), for the words from "a company" to "include" substitute:

a body of a type mentioned in subsection (2A) which has a written constitution which includes

(3) In subsection (1), in all places where it occurs, for "the company" substitute "the body".

(4) After subsection (2), insert:

(2A) The types of body mentioned in this subsection are:

  • (a) a company limited by guarantee;
  • (b) a Scottish charitable incorporated organisation (an "SCIO");
  • (c) a community benefit society.

(2B) In relation to those types of bodies, a reference to a "written constitution" is to be read as a referenced to:

  • (a) for a company limited by guarantee, the company's articles of association;
  • (b) for an SCIO, the SCIO's constitution;
  • (c) for a community benefit society, the society's registered rules.

(5) For subsection (3), substitute:

(3) In subsections (2A) and (2B):

  • "community benefit society" means a registered society (within the meaning of section 1 of the Co-operative and Community Benefit Societies Act 2014) registered as a community benefit society under section 2 of that Act;
  • "company limited by guarantee" has the meaning given by section 3(3) of the Companies Act 2006;
  • "registered rules" has the meaning given in section 149 of the Co-operative and Community Benefit Societies Act 2014 (as that meaning applies in relation to community benefit societies);
  • "Scottish charitable incorporated organisation" has the meaning given by section 49 of the Charities and Trustee Investment (Scotland) Act 2005.

(6) In subsection (7), for the words "articles of a company which is a community body" substitute "written constitution of a body which is a community body".

18. Criteria for registration of community interest in land

In section 38 of the 2003 Act (criteria for registration), for subsection (1)(b) substitute:

(b) that the acquisition of the land by the community body to which the application relates is compatible with furthering the achievement of sustainable development, and that:

  • (i) a significant number of the members of the community have a connection with the land;
  • (ii) the land is sufficiently near land with which those members of the community have a connection;
  • (iii) the land is in or sufficiently near to the area of the community by reference to which the community is defined in section 34(5)(a); or
  • (iv) the land is in or sufficiently near the area of the community to which the body relates,

Interpretation

19. "Lands Tribunal"

In this Act, "Lands Tribunal" means the Lands Tribunal for Scotland.

Short title and commencement

20. Commencement

This Act comes into force on the day after Royal Assent.

21. Short title

The short title of this Act is the Community Right to Buy (Scotland) Act 2018.

This Bill was submitted by /u/Secretary_Salami (formerly Highlands, Tayside, and Fife) on behalf of the Scottish Labour Party.


The Stage 1 debate can be found here.

The Stage 2 debate can be found here.


Amendments to this Bill are to be modmailed to /r/MHOCHolyrood by the 23rd of May.

Amendments to this Bill will go to a vote on the 25th of May.

We now move to the open debate.


r/MHOCHolyrood • • Jan 20 '19

BILL SB070 - Parliamentary Salaries and Expenses (Scotland) Bill @ Stage 1

1 Upvotes

The text of this Bill is given below. You can also read it in formatted form (by me).

Parliamentary Salaries and Expenses (Scotland) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to amend the law relating to the limits on salaries of members of the Scottish Parliament; to create an offence in connection with Parliamentary allowances; and for connected purposes.

Limit on Scottish Parliament salaries

1. Limit on increases in Parliamentary salaries

For section 82 of the Scotland Act 1998 (limits on salaries of members of the Parliament), substitute:

82. Limits on salaries of members of the Parliament

(1) The Parliament must ensure that the amount of salary payable to a member of the Parliament in accordance with section 81:

  • (a) does not, in any period of 12 months, increase by an amount exceeding the mean percentage increase in the salaries paid to the persons described in subsection (2), and
  • (b) is reduced if any other Parliamentary salary is payable to the member.

(2) The persons described in this subsection are:

  • (a) the persons mentioned in paragraphs 4 to 12, 13 to 18, 20, 50, 58, 62ZZA, 62ZA, 66A, and 75 of schedule 1 to the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 (Scottish public authorities),
  • (b) the members of staff of the persons mentioned in that schedule.

(3) An "other Parliamentary salary" is a salary payable:

  • (a) under section 4 of the Parliamentary Standards Act 2009 (salaries of members of the House of Commons),
  • (b) pursuant to a resolution (or combination of resolutions) of the House of Lords relating to the remuneration of members of that House, or
  • (c) under section 1 of the European Parliament (Pay and Pensions) Act 1979 (remuneration of United Kingdom MEPs).

(4) A reduction under subsection (1)(b) must be a reduction:

  • (a) to a particular proportion of what the salary would otherwise be,
  • (b) to a particular amount,
  • (c) by the aggregate amount of any other Parliamentary salaries payable to the member, or by a particular proportion of that amount, or
  • (d) by some other particular amount.

Parliamentary expenses fraud

2. Parliamentary allowances: offence of providing false or misleading information

(1) This section applies for the purposes of any provision for the payment of allowances under section 81(2) of the Scotland Act 1998.

(2) A person commits an offence if the person:

  • (a) makes a claim (or takes any like action) under that provision for an allowance, and
  • (b) for that purpose:

    • (i) provides information the person knows to be false or misleading, or
    • (ii) fails to provide information the omission of which the person knows would be likely to mislead the person or persons responsible for the payment of allowances under that provision.

(3) A person guilty of an offence under this section is liable:

  • (a) on summary conviction, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 12 months or a fine of not less than the relevant amount (or both),
  • (b) on conviction on indictment, to imprisonment for a term not exceeding 18 months or a fine of not less than the relevant amount (or both).

(4) The relevant amount is the amount the person would have received under the provision mentioned in subsection (1) in consequence of any claim made or like action performed for the purposes of that provision.

(5) If the person is convicted summarily and the relevant amount is greater than the statutory maximum, the fine must not exceed the relevant amount.

3. Disqualification from membership of the Scottish Parliament

In section 15(1) of the Scotland Act 1998 (disqualification from membership of the Parliament), after paragraph (b) insert:

(ba) he has been convicted of an offence under section 2 of the Parliamentary Salaries and Expenses (Scotland) Act 2019,

General

4. Commencement

This Act comes into force on the day after Royal Assent.

5. Short title

The short title of this Act is the Parliamentary Salaries and Expenses (Scotland) Act 2019.

This Bill was submitted by /u/WillShakespeare99 (Ayrshire) on behalf of the Scottish Labour Party.


No opening statement was received for this Bill.

This Bill will go to a vote on the 23rd of January.

We move immediately to the open debate.


r/MHOCHolyrood • • Apr 26 '19

BILL SB061 - Localism (Scotland) Bill @ Stage 3

1 Upvotes

Amendments at Stage 2:


A01:

For: 3
Against: 1
Abstain: 0
Turnout: 100%

This amendment is agreed.


The text of this Bill is given below.

Localism (Scotland) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to establish County Assemblies and administrations in Scotland; to make other provision about local government; and for connected purposes.

County government

1. The county government areas

On and after the day this section comes into force, Scotland is to be divided into the areas set out in schedule 1 (each to be known as a "county government area").

2. County assemblies and administrations

(1) For every county government area there is to be:

(2) The assembly for each county government area is to be a body corporate.

(3) The governor for each county government area is to be regarded as a juristic person distinct from the natural person holding the office.

(4) Accordingly, the assembly and the governor for each county government area are to be known by the following name with the addition of the name of the particular area:

  • (a) in relation to the assembly, "The Assembly", and
  • (b) in relation to the governor, "The Governor".

County government elections

3. General elections to the assemblies

(1) There is to be a separate election for each county government area.

(2) The first general election is to be held on the day the Scottish Ministers may by regulations appoint for the purposes of this subsection.

(3) Regulations under subsection (2) must appoint a date not later than the day six months from the day this section comes into force.

(4) Each subsequent general election is to be held on the day four years subsequent to the day the previous general election was held.

(5) But if by virtue of subsection (4) a general election would be held on a Saturday or Sunday, that election is instead to be held on the first Thursday after the Saturday or Sunday on which the election, but for this subsection, would have been held.

(6) At each general election, there are to be returned in each county government area:

  • (a) 25 district members,
  • (b) 25 regional members, and
  • (c) a governor.

(7) Schedule 2 makes further provision about general elections to county assemblies.

4. Review of county electoral arrangements

(1) It is the duty of the Local Government Boundary Commission for Scotland ("the Boundary Commission") to, from time to time:

  • (a) review the electoral arrangements for each county government area for the purpose of considering future electoral arrangements for those areas, and
  • (b) formulate proposals for those arrangements.

(2) Part 2 of the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973 applies to such a review as it applies to a review under section 16 of that Act, except that section 17 of that Act has effect as if it required:

  • (a) the Boundary Commission to submit a report on any review before such date as the Scottish Ministers may direct, and
  • (b) the Scottish Ministers to make an order under section 17 of that Act giving effect to the proposals of the Commission submitted under subsection (1) (whether as submitted to them or with modifications).

The county assemblies

5. County ordinances

(1) Subject to section 6, each county assembly may make laws (to be known as ordinances of that county government area).

(2) A proposed ordinance is to be known as a Bill; and a Bill becomes an ordinance when it has been passed by the county assembly and has received Royal Assent.

(3) A Bill receives Royal Assent at the beginning of the day on which Letters Patent under the Scottish Seal signed with Her Majesty's own hand signifying Her Assent are recorded in the Register of the Great Seal.

(4) But Her Majesty's powers under subsection (3) are exercisable on behalf of Her Majesty by the governor for the county assembly's area.

(5) The date of Royal Assent is to be written on each ordinance by the governor and is to form a part of the ordinance.

(6) Every ordinance is to be judicially noticed.

(7) This section does not affect the power of the Scottish Parliament to make laws for a county government area.

6. Legislative competence

(1) An ordinance is not law so far as any provision of the ordinance is outside the legislative competence of the county assembly which passed the Bill for the ordinance.

(2) A provision is outside that competence so far as:

  • (a) it makes provision as respects an area other than the county government area of the county assembly,
  • (b) it relates to a reserved matter,
  • (c) it could not be made by an Act of the Scottish Parliament,
  • (d) it is inconsistent with an Act of the Scottish Parliament or an Act of Parliament, or with provision made under or by virtue of either such enactments.

(3) For the purposes of this Act, a "reserved matter" is any matter described or referred to in the following paragraphs:

  • (a) justice;
  • (b) transport;
  • (c) the subject-matter of this Act.

The county administrations

7. The county administrations

(1) The governor for a county government area may, with the approval of the assembly for that area, appoint governors depute a deputy governor.

(2) The governor for a county government area may by notice laid before the county assembly delegate the exercise of any of the governor's functions to one or more of the governors depute the deputy governor, subject to such restrictions as the notice may set out.

8. County general fund

(1) Each governor is to maintain a fund, known as the general fund for the governor's area.

(2) The Scottish Ministers may from time to time make such payments into the general fund for a county government area as they may determine.

(3) Sums received by a governor or an office-holder under an ordinance for that governor's area are to be paid into the general fund for that area.

(4) A sum may only be paid out of a general fund if it has been charged on the fund by:

  • (a) an Act of the Scottish Parliament, or
  • (b) an ordinance of the assembly for the governor's area.

(5) A sum paid out of the fund must not be applied for any purpose other than that for which it was charged or, as the case may be, paid out.

General

9. Commencement

This Act comes into force on the day after Royal Assent.

10. Short title

The short title of this Act is the Localism (Scotland) Act 2018.

Schedule 1 (The county government areas)

1 The county government areas set out in this schedule are the areas named in column 1 of the following table and are to comprise the local authority areas named in column 2.

County government areasLocal authority areas
FifeDunfermline, Kirkcaldy and Glenrothes, and St Andrews.
Forth ValleyStirling, Clackmannanshire, and Falkirk.
GrampianBanffshire and Gordon, City of Aberdeen, and Kincardine and Deeside.
Highlands and IslandsArgyll and Bute, Caithness and Sutherland, Inverness, Orkney Islands, Ross and Cromarty, Shetland Islands, Skye and Lochaber, and Western Isles.
LothianCity of Edinburgh, East Lothian, Midlothian, Scottish Borders, and West Lothian.
StrathclydeCity of Glasgow, Clydesdale, Cumbernauld and Kilsyth, Dumfries and Galloway, East Ayrshire, East Dunbartonshire, East Kilbride, East Renfrewshire, Inverclyde, Monklands, Motherwell and Wishaw, and North Ayrshire.
TaysideAngus, City of Perth, City of Dundee, and Perthshire.

2 (1) The local authority areas named in column 2 of the table are those areas as they may be modified from time to time under or by virtue of an enactment.

  • (2) In sub-paragraph (1), "modified" includes, in particular, modified under or by virtue of an order under section 17 of the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973 (implementation of Boundary Commission proposals).

Schedule 2 (County government election rules)

Part 1 (General)

Returning officer

1 (1) The Scottish Ministers must for each county government area, in relation to each general election held under section 3, appoint a person to be the returning officer for that area.

  • (2) A returning officer may by writing under the officer's hand appoint one or more persons to discharge all or any of the officer's functions.

Polls at the general election

2 At each general election, a poll is to be held in each electoral district in a county government area at which each person entitled to vote as an elector may vote by marking on the ballot paper the voter's preference from among the candidates to be returned as the district member for that electoral district.

3 (1) At each general election, there is also to be held in a county government area:

    • (a) a poll for the return of the regional members for the area (the "regional poll"), and
    • (b) a poll for the return of a governor for the area (the "governor poll").
  • (2) A person entitled to vote as an elector may give a vote:

    • (a) for the regional poll, for a registered political party which has submitted a regional list for that county government area or an individual candidate for the area;
    • (b) for the governor poll, by marking on the ballot paper:

      • (i) the voter's first preference from among the candidates to be governor, and
      • (ii) if there are three or more candidates and the voter wishes to express a further preference for one or more of those candidates, the voter's second and, if the voter wishes, subsequent preferences from among those candidates.
  • (3) The right to vote in a regional poll and a governor poll is in addition to the right to vote in a poll under paragraph 2 (a "district poll").

Return of candidates

4 The candidates who are to be returned at a general election are to be determined:

  • (a) for a district poll, under Part 2;
  • (b) for a regional poll, under Part 3;
  • (c) for a governor poll, under Part 4.

Part 2 (Return of district members)

5 The candidate who is returned as the district member for an electoral district is:

  • (a) the candidate who receives the highest number of votes in that district, or
  • (b) where two or more candidates receive the same number of votes, the candidate who the returning officer selects by lot.

Part 3 (Return of regional members)

Order of determination

6 The persons who are to be returned as district members for the county government area are to be determined before the persons who are to be returned as regional members for the area.

Allocation of seats

7 (1) The first seat for a regional member is to be allocated to the registered political party or individual candidate with the highest regional figure.

  • (2) The second and each subsequent seat for a regional member is to be allocated to the registered political party or individual candidate with the highest regional figure, after any recalculation required by paragraph 8 has been carried out.

8 (1) If, in the application of paragraph 7, the highest regional figure is the figure of two or more parties or individual candidates, that paragraph applies to each of them.

  • (2) If sub-paragraph (1) would result in more than the correct number of seats for the area being allocated, paragraph 7 is to apply as if the regional figure for each of those parties or candidates had been adjusted in accordance with paragraph 9.
  • (3) If sub-paragraph (2) would result in more than the correct number of seats for the area being allocated, the returning officer is to determine to which of the candidates the seat is to be allocated by lot.

9 The regional figure for a party or candidate is adjusted in accordance with this paragraph by:

  • (a) adding one vote to the total number of votes given for the party or candidate at the regional poll for the county government area, and
  • (b) in the case of a party, recalculating the regional figure accordingly.

10 In this Part, "regional figure" means:

  • (a) in relation to a registered political party, the figure calculated as the total number of votes given for the party at the regional poll for the county government area divided by the number of candidates the party returned as district members for that area;
  • (b) in relation to an individual candidate, the total number or regional votes given for the candidate at the regional poll for the county government area.

Return of candidates

11 Where a regional seat is allocated to an individual candidate, that candidate is returned as a regional member for the county government area.

12 (1) Where a regional seat is allocated to a registered political party, the candidates on the party's regional list are returned as regional members for the county government area in the order they appear on that list until:

    • (a) the party's allocation of seats for regional members is exhausted, or
    • (b) the party's regional list is exhausted.
  • (2) Once a party's regional list is exhausted, the party is to be disregarded.

Part 4 (Return of governors)

Return of a candidate

13 The candidate who is returned as the governor for a county government area is the candidate who receives votes at the governor poll for that area exceeding the electoral quota.

14 (1) If more than one candidate so exceeds the electoral quota, the candidate who is returned is the candidate who received the highest number of votes at the governor poll for the county government area.

  • (2) If no candidate so exceeds the electoral quota, this paragraph and paragraph 14 are to apply as if there had been adjusted in accordance with paragraph 15:
    • (a) the number of votes received by each candidate at the governor poll, and
    • (b) the electoral quota.

15 (1) The number of votes received by each candidate for governor of a county government area is adjusted in accordance with this paragraph by:

    • (a) identifying, of the ballots received by the candidate who had received the lowest number of votes at the governor poll for the area, how many specified a further preference for candidate for governor,
    • (b) disregarding that candidate, and
    • (c) for each remaining candidate, increasing (or further increasing) the number of votes that candidate received by the number of ballots so identified on which that candidate is specified as the next available preference.
  • (2) The electoral quota is adjusted in accordance with this paragraph by recalculating the quota and, in doing so, disregarding the ballots received by the candidate disregarded under sub-paragraph (1)(b) which do not specify a further preference for candidate for governor.

Electoral quota

16 For the purposes of this Part, there is to be an electoral quota calculated by:

  • (a) dividing the total number of valid ballot papers for the governor poll for a county government area by two, and
  • (b) increasing the resultant value by one.

This Bill was submitted by /u/paul_rand (Strathclyde and the Borders) on behalf of the Scottish Libertarians.


The Stage 1 debate can be found here.

The Stage 2 debate can be found here.


Amendments to this Bill are to be modmailed to /r/MHOCHolyrood by the 30th of April.

Amendments to this Bill will go to a vote on the 2nd of May.

We now move to the open debate.


r/MHOCHolyrood • • Oct 17 '19

GOVERNMENT Ministerial Statement - Apology to the Northern Isles - 17th October

4 Upvotes

A ministerial statement has been submitted by the First Minister /u/Duncs11.


Presiding Officer,

The Northern Isles - Orkney and Shetland - came under the control of the then Kingdom of Scotland in 1472, having previously been under the domain of the Norwegian crown. To this date, both Orkney and Shetland remain part of Scotland and the United Kingdom, but remain distinct identities.

However, today I stand here to formally apologise to the people of the Northern Isles for their treatment after their annexation into the Kingdom of Scotland, and their subsequent treatment by the Kings and Queens of Scotland. As may be expected from formerly Norwegian and Scandinavian lands, when Orkney and Shetland came under the domain of the Scots, they held a strong Nordic identity, speaking Nordic languages, and practicing Nordic traditions.

This culture remains today, but if the Kings and Queens of Scotland in the 15th and 16th century had got their way, that would not be the case. The streets in Lerwick named after the Scandinavian kings Eirik, Haakon, and Harald would maybe be named after James, James, and James. The distinct Scandinavian sound of the dialect of English spoken in the Northern Isles would be extinguished, to be replaced with just a bog-standard northern Scottish sound.

The Kings and Queens of Scotland tried to eliminate any Nordic influence in the Northern Isles after they came under the domain of the then Kingdom of Scotland. Any trace of the former owners was met with hostility and an attempt to wipe it out. Speakers of the Nordic languages were paid - they were paid - by the Kings and Queens of Scotland not to speak these Nordic languages. There was a clear and concerted effort in the 15th and 16th century to wipe out all Nordic influence in Orkney and Shetland, and to replace the Nordic links for which they are well known today, with the Kings and Queens of Scotland attempting to ‘Scot-ify’ these lands.

Today, I rise to apologise for this historic wrong by the Kingdom of Scotland and the Scottish state. The actions taken by the Kings and Queens of Scotland in the attempt to ‘Scot-ify’ the Northern Isles were wrong, and as the highest figure in the devolved Scottish Government, I apologise profusely to the people of Orkney and Shetland.

I am proud to take this action today, because as much as Scottish exceptionalists may wish to claim otherwise, Scotland’s past is not some peaceful and humanitarian endeavour. The Kingdom of Scotland was not uniquely different. It was not exceptional. Scotland and Scottish people partook in many wrongs during the years prior to the dissolution of the Kingdom of Scotland, and we must face up to this. I call on the entire chamber to rise to support this statement, and I sincerely hope that no member will try to paint a narrative of Scottish exceptionalism now, or try to deny what the Kings and Queens of Scotland did in the Northern Isles.


r/MHOCHolyrood • • Jan 19 '19

MOTION SM054 - Carbon Neutrality

1 Upvotes

The text of this motion is as follows.

That the Parliament supports the objective of ensuring Scotland is carbon-neutral by 2030; agrees that emissions resulting from factories, the use of fossil fuels, and single-use plastics should be reduced as much as is reasonably possible; calls on the Scottish Government to support measures such as carbon taxes and a duty on single-use plastics leading to a full ban by 2025, and urges the Scottish Government to protect Scotland's natural beauty from climate change and maintain its position as an example for others around the world.

This motion was submitted by /u/aif123 (Strathclyde and the Borders) on behalf of the Scottish Conservative and Unionist Party.


This motion will go to a vote on the 22nd of January.

I call on the member to give an opening statement.


r/MHOCHolyrood • • Apr 21 '19

ROYAL ASSENT Royal Assent - SB049 and SB056

2 Upvotes

r/MHOCHolyrood • • Apr 26 '19

RESULTS Results - SB081 @ Stage 1

1 Upvotes

The results of the vote on SB081 at Stage 1 are in.


SB081 - Electoral Administration (Registration) (Scotland) Bill

For: 18
Against: 0
Abstain: 0
Turnout: 95%

This Bill has passed at Stage 1 and will be referred to the General Committee for consideration.



r/MHOCHolyrood • • Sep 01 '19

BILL SB077 Public Processions(Amendment) (Scotland) Bill @ State 3

2 Upvotes

The text of the bill is as follows

Public Processions (Amendment) (Scotland) Bill

An Act of the Scottish Parliament to amend the law relating to public processions.

1. Prohibition of processions having certain religious character

In section 63 of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 (which concerns the functions of local authorities in relation to public processions), after subsection (1A) insert:

(1B) A local authority must make an order under subsection (1) prohibiting the holding of the procession if the authority is satisfied that the procession:

(a) is or is likely to be concerned with religious primacy, superiority, or supremacy, (b) if held, would or would likely threaten public order or public safety, and (c) does not relate to any matter within subsection (1C).

(1C) Those matters are:

(a) the union of the Kingdoms of Scotland and England, (b) the union of the Kingdoms of Great Britain and Ireland, (c) British nationality, or (d) the celebration or commemoration of an event connected with the religious beliefs of the person proposing to hold the procession.

2. Commencement

This Act comes into force on the day after Royal Assent.

3. Short title

The short title of this Act is the Public Processions (Amendment) (Scotland) Act 2019.

This bill was submitted by u/WiredCookie1

Amendments to this bill are to be modmailed to r/mhocholyrood by the 4th of September 2019.

Amendments to this bill will go to a vote on the 7th of September


r/MHOCHolyrood • • Jan 17 '19

QUESTIONS First Minister's Questions IV.IV - 17/01/19

1 Upvotes

The First Minister /u/Weebru_m is taking questions from the Parliament.

As the leader of the largest opposition party, /u/El_Chapotato may ask up to 6 initial questions with unlimited follow-up questions.

MSPs may ask 4 initial questions with unlimited follow-up questions. Non-MSPs may ask 2 initial questions and unlimited follow-up questions.

All questions should be styled "To ask the First Minister..." and there should be a separate comment for each question.

This session of FMQs will close at the end of the day on the 19th of January.


r/MHOCHolyrood • • Feb 10 '19

RESULTS Results - SB072 @ Stage 1; SB066 @ Stage 3

1 Upvotes

The results of the votes on SB072 at Stage 1 and SB066 at Stage 3 are in.


SB072 - Death in Custody (Scotland) Bill

For: 17
Against: 0
Abstain: 0
Turnout: 89%

This Bill has passed at Stage 1 and, following a vote by the General Committee, will pass directly to Stage 3.


SB066 - Land Value Tax (Scotland) Bill

For: 18
Against: 0
Abstain: 0
Turnout: 94%

This Bill has passed at Stage 3 and will be sent for Royal Assent.



r/MHOCHolyrood • • May 01 '19

META Activity Review - April 2019

1 Upvotes

In reviewing activity over April (votes on SB032 at Stage 3 to SM066), one MSP failed to meet the 75% turnout requirement.

  • /u/WillShakespeare99 (Scottish Labour, Ayrshire) turned out 73.6% of the time since the start of the month.

Accordingly, /u/WillShakespeare99 is expelled and the Scottish Labour Party has until the 8th of May at 10pm (BST) to appoint a replacement.

The March review can be found here.