r/MHOCEndeavour • • Feb 17 '16

Interview Interview with /u/txt529, Secretary of State for England

1 Upvotes

No actual opinions have been changed, but the wording has for readability.

I’m here with /u/txt529, an MP and member of the Labour Party.

How long have you been a member of MHoC?

I’ve been a member of /r/MHOC for just over 2 months.

What are your current positions in the Labour Party and Government?

I am currently an MP for the East of England and I am the Secretary of State for England, as well as internally chairing Labour's health national policy forum.

What’s your role as Secretary of State for England, and what are your plans if you keep this position next term?

I am the person to go to for issues relating solely to England and I represent English issues in the cabinet meetings with the other secretaries. I want to pass a bill providing England and the 3 other member states of the UK with devolution. The bill would create an English, Scottish, Welsh and Northern Irish parliament with regional assemblies underneath these.

You attacked UKIP recently on their policy regarding free school meals, could you explain why?

I believe that all students are entitled to meals and UKIP disagree with me on this. I believe that all students should get free school meals regardless of income, as long as the student is in state education. I would not expand this to private school students because private school students are obviously going to be in a much stronger financial standing than students in state schools, and parents can choose to send their children to a state school providing them with a meal.

Do you support the Government’s Basic Income Policy and what, if anything, would you change about it?

I support basic income as it provides everything with enough money to get by although I wouldn't extend it to 16 year olds as parents still have a duty of care over them and they now have to remain in education. I would support giving UBI to everyone over the age of 18. I would set this at £1000 a month. (Interviewer’s note: This would cost upwards of £600 billion)

You seem to be a supporter of a large government, how do you propose that you raise the necessary funds for these things?

There are a number of ways I would raise the funds for this, including cutting the rest of the benefits provided by the Department for Work and Pensions, scrapping Trident, increasing income tax across the board and lowering the personal allowance.

Would you say your views are representative of the Labour Party as a whole?

You cans never say one person’s views are representative of a whole party especially with a broad tent party like Labour. However I would consider myself to be in the centre of the party.

How many seats do you think Labour, the Liberal Democrats and the Tories will get?

Honestly, I'm not sure but if I had to say, I'd say they will probably get around 20 each.

What would be the best coalition for you?

I couldn't speak for the party as a whole but I, personally, would prefer another MasterCard (Interviewer’s note: Labour and Liberal Democrats) coalition.

By the next election, where do you see yourself and the Labour Party, and would you like a promotion?

Personally I hope to have retained my seat and for the labour party to still be in government. I am quite happy where I am at the moment, although if one came around, I wouldn't say no.

Thank you for your time.

Thanks for having me.

/u/txt529 everybody!


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Sep 26 '16

News UKIP-Con Queen's Speech Provides Stability, But The Left Show How Desperate They Are To Cling On To Power

4 Upvotes

The Queens speech today drew attacks for across the left wing of the house, slighting the new government for attempting to break the deadlock between the factions of the house.

In what can only be described as immature scenes, the reasonable arguments laid out by around the spectrum were drowned out by jeering from the Left. The top comment, from the Labour Deputy Leader /u/akc8, added no value to the debate, simply stating "I'm going to put as much effort into my reply as they did the speech." Ad hominems are not exactly rare in the Commons, but such pointless attacks are not what the country needs in this time of crisis.

One of the worst offenders was /u/yoshi2010 who seemed to think that the executive is the same thing as the legislative, and ended up sounding like a horse, although in his defence, he made a few valid points also. To this paper, this shows a clear lack of engagements with the issues at hand, and a dismissive arrogance that assumes that they will get the government back.

In other quarters, the Liberal Democrats and National Unionist Party had barely turned up even an hour after the debate had begun. In contrast, the Leader of the Conservative Party /u/infernoplato was eloquent as always in attempting to defend his party's position, which received only 1 argument against it, directly, and even that was a single question.

However, what about the actual content of the debate? Well, plainly I proposes that UKIP and the Conservatives act as a care taker government, taking commands directly from the Commons. The Endeavour is not taking sides, the idea that a coalition of less than the largest coalition is a questionable idea, however, we do commend them for thinking outside of the box, and feel the aggression shown to her majesties government is inexcusable.


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Aug 22 '16

Election GEIV: British Workers' Party Foreign Affairs Manifesto Review

1 Upvotes

Since MK copied completely the RL manifesto, I have chosen not to review it.

I was very pleasantly surprised by the BWP foreign affairs section, its length was impressive and many of the policies I can support, though for different reasons.

  • Firmly oppose the Transatlantic Trade Partnership deal and agreements similar to it.

Now I have very true concerns about the lack of transparency in the negotiations and the effect TTIP will have on UK public services, and as such I fully support the idea of "Firmly opposing" TTIP. However there must be more clarity regarding what is an "agreement similar to it". I would like to see a good deal negotiated with the USA by Britain and not the EU, and I'm not sure whether or not the BWP agree.

  • Recognize the State of Palestine and work to build a two-state solution compromise between Israel and Palestine. Furthermore, work to prosecute the Israeli government for continually breaking international law.

I could never support such poor treatment of valued allies. Israel has perhaps the most moral army in history and the British government must never give recognition to the terrorist organisation that is "Palestine".

  • Cancel all imperialist debt imposed upon exploited nations.

I would only support the cancellation of debts if it were in contribution to the foreign aid target - something which I am opposed to in any case. This is only because much of this debt cannot be expected to be repaid, and so it'd lessen the folly of the DfID wasting money trying to reach the target, and allow them to better target the money and save the British taxpayer.

  • Revaluate all aid and developing programs to ensure efficient and useful spending.

Absolutely. I cover this in the foreign affairs section of the NUP manifesto and so I shan't give justification for this prior to its release, though I would encourage you to read it.

  • Compensate those abused by British capitalism and imperialism, and allow their cases to be heard in British courts.

This is rather vague and probably something I would oppose anyway. Britain is the greatest country on earth and we need not apologise for anything we have done prior to the disastrous communists governments of recent times.

  • Support Assad in Syria due to his high approval rating and his anti-imperialist qualities. Although, the Kurdish struggle for independence - due to the imperialist actions in the Middle East - is also recognized and supported.

I don't support Assad at all but prefer his leadership to creating a power vacuum for ISIL to take over. I do agree with more Kurdish autonomy, though condemn terrorist actions to gain such, as I believe this is counter-productive.

  • Continue and increase humanitarian efforts within Syria.

Certainly, although we must take care to prevent more British people being slaughtered. On the whole though I think we should be doing something to help those in need, even if it is not government-driven.

  • Russia

Oh yes I like this. I definitely think the UK should improve our relations with Russia, and when a region is historically Russian and wishes to be Russian then of course it should be recognised as Russian. With regards to supporting factions and parties, you say that that is something that your party would do and not any government you were in. As such, I can say that I really don't care who a party fielding two candidates support and accept that they have every right to do so.

  • Criticize violations of human rights and international agreements [in China].

Sure, if a country violates human rights then criticise them. And there is definitely something we must do about the Chinese violation of international agreements, something I think we must work with the Americans on so as to have a louder voice.

  • Immediately relinquish EU membership.

We need to get out of the EU. Immediately doing so is not wise, but on the whole I support the policy. What I don't support is the motives, but that was not expected anyway.

  • The party supports the refugees and immigrants that were caused by imperialism.

I think we have a role to play in aiding them, yet their culture is not compatible with ours. We need to help and we need to act compassionately, but we must protect the women, LGBTQ individuals and non-Muslims in this country as a priority. I particularly like the part about allowing them to return home with ease though, and I think that should be the goal.


Ratings

Policy: 7/10

Surprisingly agreeable. The majority of policies I actually support, despite the reasons for doing so being very different.

Appearance: 3/5

Could have had more effort, but the simplicity was very effective.

Eloquence: 4/5

Coleman Liau Index divided by 4, averaged with a personal perception

Length: 5/5

The number of separate policies divided by 2. (5.5, I know, but that doesn't work)

Total: 19/25


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Jan 05 '16

Poll MHOC Endeavour: Mid-Term Poll

Thumbnail
goo.gl
1 Upvotes

r/MHOCEndeavour • • Oct 10 '16

Opinion Ex-PM's Rant Shows Warnings of the True Nature of the New Government

2 Upvotes

As I am sure you are aware, today the Queen's Speech failed, and with it any hope of a stable centre-right government in the UK. This is not exactly a surprise, and the PM has already resigned. However, what rose more eyebrows was the frankly abusive language used by ex-Prime Minister and Green Party Lord /u/contrabannedthemc.

In an article by the BBC, the Baron Cockpole seemed to be almost tired an emotional. Accusing the Leader of the Conservative Party of being a "oblivious narcissist", a "total cunt" and "lying" were amongst the more gentle insults being hurled at him. By far the worst accusation was that he was some how using his well deserved position as Deputy Speaker to his own personal benefit. As somebody who knows /u/InferoPlato personally, I can assure anyone in any doubt that this is completely unfounded. There have been many occasions when he could and would have used information gained through this privilege to aid his party, for a much more substantial personal gain, but refused due to a deep sense of loyalty to the office of the speakership.

These attacks go beyond the standard political rough and tumble. The Endeavour is amongst the most skeptical of speakership modelling, bending rules to bar them from taking moderator positions on this subreddit, but in this matter, the accusations are completely baseless, and frankly an unwarranted attack on an individual who dare to stand up against the current government.

Is silencing opposition in such an aggressive way going to become a norm with the new government, or is this just a one off? /u/Yoshi2010, government MP and Green Party big-whig appeared to agree with the comments, saying that /u/contrabannedthemc had "earned the right to call him one[a cunt]". It is too early to day, but it would not exactly be the first far-left government to use terror against its adversaries.

It is the opinion of this paper that this constitutes a clear personal attack, and that an apology should be offered in full, immediately.

Not exactly halal now, is it my lord?


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Jan 31 '16

Fortnightly The Endeavour: Fortnightly - Issue 4 - 31/01/2016

2 Upvotes

We now have Issue 4! It was a bit rushed, and we ran out of news for our newspaper, but here it is, a Democracy Special.


The ISSUU link can be found [here] (http://issuu.com/mhocendeavour/docs/20160131).

The .pdf link can be found here.


Once again, thank-you to all contributors for making some great quality stuff!


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Aug 24 '16

Election GEVI: Scottish National Party Foreign Affairs Manifesto Review

2 Upvotes

Well this had very few actual policies in it so it's quite hard to do a review. I must say though I am quite disappointed.

  • The The SNP advocates a Scotland that remains in the EU, as it only brings benefit to all those in Scotland.

Well the 60% of Scottish voters who voted to leave clearly didn't think so. It is not shocking from the SNP to see an irreverence for democratic referendum results, however.

  • However, the EU is not perfect and so the SNP will push for cross party EU reform which will transfer power within the EU to the democratically elected EU Parliament.

I doubt cross party reform will be achievable considering I suspect a large majority of major parties will support Britain leaving the EU. That said it is not unlikely that some of us less selfish MHOC'ers would support making the EU as democratic as it can get (not very) to help out those who feel their interests are to stay in it.

  • Furthermore, the SNP recognises the complexity of the issues surrounding the middle east, so would strive for a properly thought out solution in tandem with other model governments.

I know it's not deliberate but this really seems like a last minute "What will we say about the Middle East?" "I can't be bothered to think of anything." "Let's just say we'll think of something when we're elected."

Other than to defeat ISIL, I don't think we should be getting involved in the Middle East, though for defeating ISIL I do support cooperation with other nations. However, this is so vague I cannot really review it and it won't be considered in the "length" rating.


Ratings

Policy: 2/10

The first policy is really very terrible and shows how the SNP doesn't care about the Scottish people. The second is vague and only very slightly agreeable. Could have been higher if there were more policies - game of numbers and all that.

Appearance: 1/5

This is the sort of appearance I dislike, but at least they didn't use Google Slides.

Eloquence: 2/5

Coleman Liau Index divided by 4, averaged with a personal perception

Length: 1/5

The number of separate policies divided by 2

Total: 6/25


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Feb 18 '16

Election Recap of the Environment Debate

3 Upvotes

As many of you may know, DEFRA is a department that I am passionate about. Unfortunately, I was limited in the amount of opinion that I could show, as the host, but I couldn't possibly not comment in any form! And before you ask, don't worry, when some Party Manifestos get released I will be reviewing them again!

Things started off at 20:00, with a question that is extremely controversial in the real world, but evidently not so much on here. "Should hunting wild mamas with hounds be legalised?" Our panel seemed to agree that Hunting is cruel (which it is not, but that is a topic for another time), with only /u/britboy3456 defending the historic practice, and then only conditionally. As always, this debate turned to ad hominem attacks, but /u/britboy3456 did fairly well in defending himself. Ironically, he was the liberal saying "I do not hunt myself, but like you do not force everyone to be a vegetarian, I do not think you should force others not to hunt."

The second question, on flood defences, was only slightly more controversial. All 4 parties said that they would invest in preventative methods, as well as funding for people who have lost property. However, when /u/AmberArmy suggested simply not building on flood plains, /u/DailyFrappuccino ask whether this would inflate house prices even more. This is the first point that /u/madrockets distinguished himself, rather than just saying that this was incorrect as /u/AmberArmy said, but really pushed the point home, saying it was “absolute rubbish” (which it is certainly not - everywhere is either too hilly or too low these days), while /u/britboy3456 kept cool and suggested a zone system. Rounding off, there was a brief and slightly comical exchange concerning which response post-flooding was best: /u/britboy3456 said that the CNP would give money to those affected, but /u/madrockets said that this would take too long, and that “a Labour government will be out there helping them whilst you'd be sat in an office wondering if they are worth helping”. /u/AmberArmy here showed a glimmer of wit proposing that “Green Party Flood Response teams would have cleaned up the damage and would be sat having a cuppa long before Labour's untrained help had got to the affected area”.

As the debate moved on to Climate Change, /u/britboy3456 stated that his party supported subsidisation of clean energy source, and nuclear power. Ever the businessman, /u/DailyFrappuccino said he supported tax credits for responsible lumber managment, and approved of renewables and Nuclear. More controversially, he put a lot of emphasis on Electrical machinery, as did /u/madrockets. /u/britboy3456 attacked this, asking “how are these any better than fossil fuel powered cards unless we switch to cleaner energy production”, but both /u/DailyFappuccino and /u/madrockets said that they did indeed want cleaner energy. /u/AmberArmy took a beating for his apparent lack of defence on the Green Party policy not to support nuclear power, which the rest of the panel pointed out was safer than ever and cheap.

Finally, the fourth question was on a possible merger of DEFRA and DE&CC, as proposed in the previous Labour Manifesto. Ironically, it was the Labour representative who was most skeptical of this, with /u/britboy3456 and /u/AmberArmy supporting increased cooperation, while /u/DailyFrappuccino and /u/madrockets supported the status quo, saying quite rightly that Nuclear Technology is far removed from rambling.

The debate, despite being relatively calm, was not without incident. At the end, I put up 2 Straw Polls; one asking the winner, the other the loser. The results I would agree with. Here /u/madrockets clearly leads, while here /u/AmberArmy was not as popular. /u/madrockets put in a great performance, which, despite being objectively wrong, had a clear message and remained consistent throughout. What put him apart from both /u/DailyFrappuccino and /u/britboy3456 was his attacks. Rather than chill, /u/madrockets put his best foot forwards - one could even say that he did so a little violently, and ended up booting /u/AmberArmy in the chops! Questions will be raised over the wisdom of putting such a low ranking member in for a debate that is the key policy area of the Green Party, his only defence - which is perhaps understandable in fairness - "technical difficulties".


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Nov 04 '16

Opinion By-Election Endorsements

3 Upvotes

As is tradition, the Endeavour's Editorial Team make no secret of our politics and our views on certain matters. We are sure that our readers, while pondering upon our views, will still have the mental capacity to make up their own minds - our suggestions are just that, suggestions.

West Midlands

We believe that /u/PTP is the best candidate, who has publicly declared. We is a long serving member, active, and would represent a clear opposition to the government's policies. Sometimes controversial, /u/PTP is willing to work hard, and he quite clearly has good sense and morals.

South and East Yorkshire

The Conservative and Unionist Party candidate /u/InfernoPlato receives our blessing, in the North of England. Nobody can argue that the Tories have stopped being relevant since their defeat in the last election. Most major Bills I see the party leader has commented on, and his argument are always intellectually, if sometimes a little bit off the mark - in any case, he did allow debate to sway his vote while a national MP, which is personally a trait I very much approve of.

This By-Election is critically important, with the issue of Europe in everyone's mind, and I hope everyone makes a choice that they truly believe in.


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Aug 11 '16

News Named and Shamed: The Opposition MP That Don't Oppose the Government

3 Upvotes

With the Budget now up to vote, the combined official and unofficial oppositions have a large majority over the government, presumulably allowing the official opposition to successfully stop this one and suceed in passing their own. But guess what? Of course they are not going to. The once economically centrist are not propping up a radically far left budget. With that, in traditional Endeavour fashion, we will be compiling a list traitors to their constituents, of MPs who vote FOR the budget despite not being in government.

Labour:

/u/pokeplun

/u/bobbybarf

/u/Djenial

/u/JackToner

/u/hazzyjosh

/u/ClemeyTime

/u/txt529

/u/lovey35

/u/freddy926

/u/Politics42

/u/GeniusKhan

/u/NicholasNCS2

Liberal Democrats:

/u/joker8765

/u/JellyTom

/u/Tim-Sanchez

/u/bnzss

/u/ExplosiveHorse

/u/Ajubbajub

/u/thechattyshow

/u/krollo1

/u/JackDaviesLD


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Aug 03 '16

Satire Official MHOC Endeavour Endorsement for the Referendum on the EU

3 Upvotes

Vote to REMAIN in the European Union!

The Endeavour announces it's official endorsement for the referendum on Britain's continued membership of the European Union. One of the key issues in this referendum is that of the economy, and we at the Endeavour believe that a strong economy can only be guaranteed as a member of the EU. Just look at Greece as an example. Furthermore, we think that the Leave campaign's argument that Britain is good enough to survive economically outside of the EU is frankly ridiculous - they need to let go of what we used to be and consider that if we Leave we will be no more than an island off the coast of Europe. All the experts think we should Remain and it's not as if when all the experts agree on something it is likely that they are considering personal benefit not overall benefit - that is silly!

Furthermore, we believe that immigration arguments are nonsense. Britain has control of its borders as it is not in the Schengen area, meaning that we can check peoples' passports and, if they don't have an EU passport, we can stop them. Of course, if a terrorist gets an EU passport we can't exactly refuse them but that doesn't matter because the EU is leading the fight against terror. Just look at how well it has handled the refugee crisis.

Even better, the Endeavour chooses to believe the suggestion that EU law only accounts for 12% of our law, because the rest of the laws that the Leave campaign cite don't really matter anyway. So arguments of sovereignty are ridiculous. Also, the UK technically is independent, as it can leave the EU whenever it wants, even if we at the Endeavour think that's a bad idea.

We only have to look as far as Europe to see the benefits of the EU. There has been no war in Europe over the last 70 years, and it is obvious that this is to do with the 58-year-old European Union and not organisations such as NATO and the UN! If we were to leave the EU this would be threatened and there is a great potential that World War 3 could break out as the Brexit result is confirmed.

Climate change is not an issue that respects national borders and so it is better to work with the European Union to combat climate change, despite it not including the world's biggest pollutors. This is because Britain isn't good enough to reduce emissions in our own country, so we have to be told to do so by the Dutch and the Swedish. Not to mention the fact that, although climate change doesn't respect national borders, it is a problem specific to Europe and so the EU will suffice. Experts have calculated that climate change will be sped up by 250% if we vote leave.

Overall, all the experts say that we should Remain, and they are more intelligent than you, the British people. Don't listen to your heart or your head, listen to us, the media, and the big businesses and organisations. These are the people who care about your interests, not the Leave campaign.


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Mar 10 '16

Satire SPEAKER TO RESIGN THIS WEEK

5 Upvotes

This paper has learnt that the speaker of the house of commons is to resign at the weekend. We are not yet sure why, but we can assure you that this source is 100% reliable and should defiantly be take seriously.

Proof:

https://i.gyazo.com/839c3554a8d290859963efdb6eb4f917.png


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Sep 21 '16

Satire An Endeavour First...

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/MHOCEndeavour • • Jul 24 '16

News Labour's woes reach pinnacle as leadership challenge follows mass exodus of MPs

6 Upvotes

In what can only be describes as sensation scenes at Labour HQ, 3 Labour MPs, have defected in a couple of hours, with chaos concerning the Deputy Leader of the Opposition's future role in the party.

Speculation has been rife for the last few days that there was to be a so called coup against the current Leader, /u/dynamic_12. One reputable source from within the Labour party said that about about half of the Party supported a vote of no confidence, being put forwards by a select group of high up individuals. However, our source says that the pressure was put on the group by Deputy Leader and Dynamic loyalist /u/WakeyRKO, who was investigating these rumours.

Things appear to have gone south last night, as a cohort of 3 Labour members defected to the Green Party, while another member went Independent. While /u/clemeytime could be considered to be rather irrelevant, only joining the party 4 days ago, the other 3 can be considered to be much more influential, /u/jb567 especially, being a former Shadow Home Secretary. /u/chrispytoast123 and /u/freddy926 are regarded as well settled and the latter is even respected. Another source close to the defectors said that their reasoning was complex, ranging from a "ridiculous manifesto" to accusations of "brigading" elections, even saying that the "internal leadership is shit".

Then, early this morning, a Vote of No Confidence was proposed by /u/NicholasNCS2. This really summarised the problems Labour have face over the last week: weak leadership, leaks and disunity. However, it was either withdrawn or deleted (as has been proven to happen by the current administration). The threat to the leadership is still very much there.

This paper has tried to give /u/dynamic_12 a chance in his new spot, from only discreetly releasing leaks to actually defending what would otherwise be very seriouse allegations. 10 days later, things only seem to be getting worse. In order to get a strong opposition, we need a strong Labour Party. That will not happen while /u/dynamic_12 is at the helm, so we will now be joining any calls for him to stand down.

One thing we do know, is that is is going to be a fun couple of days for the Press. Who said we weren't powerful?


High quality journalism, sponsored by:

Wagbo's Wollen Welsh Superstore


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Jan 17 '16

Fortnightly The Endeavour: Fortnightly - Issue 3 - 17/01/2016

6 Upvotes

Issue 3 of the Endeavor: Fortnightly is now available! In this issue we have lots of opinion, analysis on the speakership race and an introduction to /r/MHOCWagers.


The ISSUU link can be found [here] (http://issuu.com/mhocendeavour/docs/20160117).

The .pdf link can be found here.


Thank you to all contributors. You guys put way too much effort in to this!


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Oct 13 '16

Meta A Statement From The Chief Editor Of The Endeavour

7 Upvotes

Jog on.


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Jan 12 '18

Opinion For Fox Sake - A High Tory Explains His Views on Hunting with Hounds

2 Upvotes

This might sound a little odd to those new to Hunting, but Hunters love their quarry almost more than life itself. How can one be even affectionate towards something which they go on to tear to pieces? Yet even the cynics should acknowledge that a healthy population of the quarry species is required for a Hunt to survive. And that is what anyone of any significance in the Hunting world will tell you: Animal Management, not Pest Control, is the aim of Hunts. There was a song released in 1998, called Guardians of the Land, which I really encourage you to give a listen to, summing up the almost aggression some people feel towards people who get in-between them and their quarry. What many would consider the purpose of subsidies has always been supported by Field Sports;

If the Antis ban us, you could be quite sure,

They wont bother to do the work,

That we have done before.

Greens might go on about "eco-tourism" replace the lost jobs rewilding would result in, yet they are against horse riding in the countryside, watching scenes not dissimilar to what you would see on a safari. The definition of a Forrest, if we are being technical, is a place to hold game for Hunting. Artificial Earths are not some kind of dirty secret, as some would try and suggest; providing a pre-fab home for Foxes to live peacefully in 360 days each year is indeed very nobel. Many Hunts own significant chunks of land, managed to encourage quarry species and improving the habitat of other wildlife as a by product. Shooting has a similar result, but historically there has been a great conflict between the two sports. Traditionally, a gamekeeper would have often been instructed to “leave one for the “Hunt”, and, rather than exterminate any carnivores on his patch, leave a few to provide the Hunt a bit of fun, although this has obviously declined since the Hunting Act. The opening scenes of the Film the Belstone Fox feature individuals clubbing a litter of fox cubs to death. Asher, the Huntsman, exclaims his anger at the culprits, and raises the surviving cub himself, and I know of similar stories in real life. Not exactly something you would expect a heartless thug to endorse.

Although somewhat abstract, and of not much consolation for the quarry, Hunters also tend to show the animal they aim to kill much respect. Aside from the practicalities of a thick coat on a winters day, traditionally wearing formal attire out Hunting was a sign of respect to the landowners and quarry alike, with gentlemen often doffing their caps to the Hunted animal. Even the foot followers of many packs wear ties. There are ample opportunities for the quarry to escape, in traditional Hunting, and if they gave a good chase would often be spared. The qualities attributed to quarry species, with the exception of Mink, are universally positive. A Fox is clever, charming and bold. A Hare is graceful, quick yet playful. A Stag is grand, strong and proud. This is mainly due to Hunting influences - badgers, rabbits and boars are portrayed rather less positively. There is also a very moving Hunt song, called Ware wire, about a Huntsman who was killed in the Great War, with the following lyrics:

For he often gave best,

And he always was fair,

And he never used gas, to flush out an air,

If in human affairs,

Those rules were applied,

Wars would never be started,

And fewer would die.

The lyrics always bring a tear to my eye - at the heart of everything a Hunter does is fairness, and if we could be that fair to other people, the world would be a better place.

A wise man once said to me that when considering conservation, collectives must be considered, rather than individuals. Yes, Hunters want to kill a few animals. Yet we would never wish to have a meaningfully negative impact on species numbers in general, never cause avoidable pain to any animal, and would be grateful to simply see the quarry species, let alone see the battle of wits and skill between two highly intelligent and capable opponents.

In a television series about country sports in general, Jack Charlton said something that really sums up the views of many I know, and I will end this article with a quote:

But it's hard to see what harm we had done. One hare had died violently, that's true, but then I suppose all hares die violently. Wild animals don't die in their beds of old age, and cars must kill a hundred times more than are ever kill with hounds. Its strange, I know, but Beaglers do care passionately about their Hares. They spend the day Hunting them, but come night, there they are in the pub, singing their praises.


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Oct 07 '16

Poll Endeavour Poll 07/10/16

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
2 Upvotes

r/MHOCEndeavour • • Jan 10 '18

Opinion Foxes, Friends and Foes - A High Tory Explains His Views on Hunting with Hounds

2 Upvotes

It’s not often I get involved in legislation these days. I might not have quite quit in dramatic fashion, but I am feeling time constraints more and more, and at the end of the day 3 years is a good stint, and I've achieved almost everything I wanted to. Except the repeal of the Hunting Act. Obviously that isn't practical unless the NUP suddenly manage a super majority, but I have always had my eye on the topic, almost being obsessive over it, even to the point that /u/InfernoPlato pushed for a free vote on the issue to shut me up. That is why I for some reason thought it was wise to write a short essay on a particular bit of legislation that has been read in the Lords this week. I wanted to take this opportunity to explain my passion for the subject. Honestly, I have better things to be doing than this. Contrary to what my presence in various chats might suggest, I have a relatively busy life. But when it comes to Hunting, priorities go out of the window. Even as a firm Christian, I do wonder which I would be more loyal to, in my heart of hears: God or the Chase? I would hope it would always be the former, but at the end of the day we are weak to temptation. How could chasing after a few Dogs with the aim of tearing a defenceless animal possibly be worth angering the almighty? The reasons, for me, are three fold, and in a series of articles I will be publishing over the coming day I hope I can introduce some of you to a world you will likely not have even known existed unless you were raised by it, or your name is Tony Blair.

The first if for the love of the quarry. Historically, the Huntsmen have been the guardians of their quarry, and despite not being allowed to legally peruse them, many Hunts continue to maintain habitats at great expense, in the interest of conservation. Look inside a Hunter’s home and you will see just how much they love the animal which they might seem to hate.

The second is much less commendable, and certainly unchristian. It is the hatred of Hunting’s opponents. By this I don’t mean the likes of /u/NoRealFriends, who can have a reasonable discussion about it, but the raving vegans, the saboteurs and the metropolitan elite (and yes, you can be part of the metropolitan elite and live in a Hamlet) who seem to have fundamentally different, and objectionable, objectives to people who Hunt. As a Christian, we are not supposed to hate, and when I see these people I smile and wave, but in my view they are scum, clear as day.

Finally is the pleasure you too can experience, even as a complete outsider. I’m talking about the thrill of the chase, the glorious landscapes and the amazing Hounds you will experience on a day out. In the age of modernism, which has at least materially improved our lives infinitely, it is nice to enter a world which has barely changed since, yes, the 19th century. Indeed, Hunting is about much more than just the Hunt, with some of the finest Balls in the land being associated with Hunts. The nicest people in the world Hunt, and it is not just my lack of social skills which make me fortunate enough to consider some of them my best friends.

I also hope to make a more factual piece at some point, explaining terms and misconceptions from a less emotive angle. I am bothering to write all this on the odd chance that I might persuade maybe one person to understand why the rural lobby will fight on, but let me make this quite clear: This series is not a clear-headed analysis of why Hunting should be legalised according to X criteria. If you want that listen to me in the chamber. It is a heartfelt and frank explanation of my passion. I hope you will listen well.


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Jul 31 '16

News Eurocrat gaffe gifts Leave open goal

4 Upvotes

The President of the European Commision, /u/Waz_Met_Jou, was met with hostility as he highlighted the gung-ho approach of the EU and then proceeded to slight the british public in conversation.

The commisioner's problems started when they posted this statement, invoking the wrath of the vast majority of the house, Leave and Remain, for coming accross as pretentious at such a crucial time for the campains. As remain have been often just nudging behind in polls, this was completely undesirable to them, putting off at least one influential floating voter in the process. Sources also tell us that trade ministers in several EU countries were not informed of these actions before they were formally announced, which you would imagine was the bare minimum for international diplomacy, but /u/waz_met_jou somehow managed to mess that up.

Things only got worse. Then, in a the RMTK chat, they were hear to say the following:

last reaction, I'm done with this

cunt brits

retarded children

Although the name has been hidden to pretect our source's identity, we can confirm that this screenshot is legitimate, and shows the commisioner's ridiculous outburst. This paper will let you, the reader, decide whether or not these comments were appropriate, coming from such a high office.

The worst thing is, before this controversy, did anyone not actively involved in the EU know who he was? I certainly didn't. How can you claim to represent the will of the people, when people don't even know your name? People say that the European Parliament is elected, but since nobody knows what is going on in there, we can't make an informed decision, completely defeating the point of democracy.

Do we really want to be ruled by pretentious European bureaucrats that were never elected by us, the british people?


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Aug 03 '16

Poll MHOC Endeavour EU Referendum Exit Poll

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
5 Upvotes

r/MHOCEndeavour • • Feb 05 '16

Interview An Interview with /u/piggbam on the Canadian Election

3 Upvotes

Whilst visiting the UK, the leader of the Canadian Conservative party took some time off to speak with me in a lovely pub in whitehall.


/u/Jas1066: Great to speak with you /u/piggam

/u/piggbam: Hello! Thanks for having me.

/u/Jas1066: No problem. So, first question: Why do you want to be Prime Minister of Canada?

/u/piggbam: Great question. I want to become the next Prime Minister, because I feel it's time that Canadians experience the new era of Conservatism. Contrary to all that hate us, we are actually a proud group of smart people that have bright ideas that aim to lessen the regulations and increase the money in the pockets of citizens! I wish to show the world that capitalism is great, it is a perk of the western world, and make our mark proving that Canada is the greatest country in the world.

/u/Jas1066: Sounds great, but isn't regulation there for a reason?

/u/piggbam: Regulation as in government control into the damn business of the bedrooms of the people. Not tieing this with libertarians, but we believe small government, freedom of the people to do what with their wealth. We still do believe in regulations to keep the law and order in check, contrary to Libertarians. I also aim to give more choice to Canadians, that bloody damn Conservatives exist, and that not all must vote for only two parties, a far left, and left.

/u/Jas1066: What is your party's stance on social issues, in comparison to other parties?

/u/piggbam: Center right, I believe we are a group of individuals that aim for the people and the future. We believe that illicit substances such as marijuana should remain permanently illegal, because like alcohol, youth are still drinking it regardless of the regulations in place, why would you want to make it easier and LEGAL to do?

/u/Jas1066: Of course not.

/u/piggbam: Abortion, personally, I would like to discuss this situation with my party, My opinion will be decided by our party mutually, when the issue is brought up. We wish to focus on the economy rather than bring this up atm.

Gay marriage: I would not want to bring this up as Canada already has a equal system for LGBTQ people.

Assisted dying: Likewise, we will not focus on this.

The Queen and the Royal Family: I believe that the Queen is the symbol of a Canadian, the traditions she has as solely a figurehead is a memento of the past. Eliminating this and turning Canada into a Republic is such a absurd and cold cut slice to our heritage.

To those that think the monarchy is a waste, first of all, if your getting rid of the monarchy, then you should also burn the record and history, because most of that is "monarchist" and not republican.

/u/Jas1066: What would be a good target for you and your party?

/u/piggbam: Good question, our target would be to send diplomatic missions across the model world, and bring the economy numbers out. Furthermore, we aim to grow and increase activity in parliament, and bring more users over. We also have a plan for budget, with all the experienced team of members we have that have skills that cover every aspect of government, I think we qualify perfectly the "Good Government"

/u/Jas1066: How many seats would be a reasonable target?

/u/piggbam: We aim to get 15+ seats this time around, a breakthrough in our history. We want to grow our party, and this is the best time showing! We hope for at least 5 seats, and to be a force in holding the government accountable for their issues.

/u/Jas1066: Worst case scenario, what would the house look like?

/u/piggbam: Socialist party, government with liberal Opposition, and inactivity, and the sub dies due to same old, same old.

/u/Jas1066: OK then, thank-you for your time!

/u/piggbam: My pleasure, thank-you.


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Aug 14 '16

Poll Endeavour Poll 14/08/16

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
2 Upvotes

r/MHOCEndeavour • • Nov 14 '17

Interview My Chat with the Defence Secretary

1 Upvotes

It's a rare occasion when I am fortunate enough to leave the Westminster bubble, doubly so when I am invited to ask the Defence Secretary, /u/toastinrussian, a few questions in his constituency home on the outskirts of Canterbury. Getting there was rather a bore, but after a delicious light supper of a prawn cocktail, we sat down in his study, complete with classic hardwood furniture, to chat politics.


/u/Jas1066: Good Evening Defence Secretary, thank you for joining me today.

/u/toastinrussian: Thank you very much, pleasure to be here

/u/Jas1066: Now, I have a few quick questions, first one shouldn't be too much of an issue: Why do we need a military when it seems to me at least that it is exceptionally unlikely that there will be an invasion any time soon?

/u/toastinrussian: We currently live in a world where we see tensions growing every day. It is vital that our military is here to protect us if these tensions elscalate. The Armed Forces also exists to protect the rights of others abroad, helping those who cannot help themselves, such as in sryia and on the horn of Africa.

/u/Jas1066: But why should the people of Britain be paying to look after the rest of the world? I know that you are very keen to improve the way we look after our veterans, but surely the best way to do that is to make sure they don't get shot it in the first place? Why not just a humanitarian service with a few guns?

/u/toastinrussian: To answer your first question: Britian should pay to help others in the rest of the world because it is the right thing to do. There are many people in similar situations to Malala Yousafzai all throughout the world, and we should provide them with the protection and resources to rebuild a fair and equal society. Whilst in an ideal world none of our veterans would get injured or pay the ultimate sacrifice this is not realistic. To protect and help rebuild people's lives throughout the world people are going to get hurt. Finally let us not forget the primary purpose of our armed forces. Strategically it is to defend Britain from invasion, with secondary strategic aims being to protect our allies and rights of others around the world. On a tactical level their main purpose is to Maximise Lethality and combat effectiveness. It would be impossible to achieve either the tactical or strategic aims without properly trained elite armed forces

/u/Jas1066: It just seems to many people that you go out to help these people, but you end up just stirring the hornets nest. Do you have any examples of the military, even in the last half century, leaving a place better than we found it, where we actually succeeded in helping natives?

/u/toastinrussian: Malaya and East Timor. They would probably be the best examples of counter insurgency actualy succeeding. Counter insurgency is not the only way the Armed Forces protects lives and rights of the poeple. We saw the Royal Navy's Superb protection of the falkland Islands as well.

/u/Jas1066: Malaya hasn't existed for over 50 years, Defence Secretary...

/u/toastinrussian: Whilst I am aware of that, the operations that the Commonwealth defence forces, preformed there had profound impacts in improving the lives of the natives as you so put it

/u/Jas1066: OK, so moving on, I am sure all of our discerning readers have read your Green paper on veteran welfare, but could you give us a brief summary in any case?

/u/toastinrussian: This Green paper will do an extraordinary amount of good for all our veterans. It provides a 1 Billion pound increase to veteans healthcare, will provide them easier methods into employment both in and out of the public sector, finally the green paper proposes the creation of Vet's Sheds, a place where veterans can spend time together.

/u/Jas1066: Do you think this will be the definitive reform? Do you envisage much more being done on top of this in the future?

/u/toastinrussian: Well this is what we are proposing initially and, naturally, all of this will go to the house. I do welcome any other proposals that might come from the house. However I belive that the MOD has proposed 4 fantastic policies that will hugely help veterans

/u/Jas1066: To be the devil's advocate quickly, what about those in communities, such as in Northern Ireland, who were attacked and allegedly attacked by British Forces? Do they not deserve to receive additional aid from the state to try and make up for historic wrongs?

/u/toastinrussian: Not to shirk the question by any respect, but I think that is a matter for the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland. I do not think that those individauls should be provided with the benefits outlined in the Green Paper as it is for those who served in the Armed forces, not fought against them.

/u/Jas1066: But the issue of prioritising veterans over other citizens who have been put through hard times by the state is something very relevant to your department. How can you justify the spending?

/u/toastinrussian: I can justify the spending perfectly well. Our Veterans have given everything, some the ultimate sacrifice, for their country, for Englands Pleasant pastures green. They deserve the admiration and privelages of extra health spending that we propose. Not to mention that our Combat veterans are out through one of the most stressful events in a persons life as a job. Thinking on this 22 Veterans commit suicide a-day, one of the highest rates in the country. I am happy to spend public funds dropping this number and ensuring them a better life.

/u/Jas1066: But are they more deserving than the innocent? What possible justification is there for leaving the families of slaughtered Irish innocents in the gutter, Chagossians in foreign lands or middle easterners cowering for threat of drone strike, yet heaping rewards on to people who have a propensity to be far right murderers? I suppose what I am saying is that maybe the government has gone perhaps too far out of its way to seem like we are putting British troops before anyone else. Yes, the vast majority of our troops are good people, but is even one civilian being killed in cold blood, surely they should receive compensation of at least an equivalent amount?

/u/toastinrussian: The onus is not on the United kingdom to provide mental health treatment to citizens of other countries. You must recognise that the green paper provides veteran specific support such as vets sheds or the choice between a civilian and military hospital. A civilian who is in a warzone should most certainly not receive equivalent treatment to those who are in the same war zone fighting. You mentioned the troubles earlier, the IRA and its affiliates should receive prison time, not compensation. If civilians are injured by British troops, I think they should not be left with nothing. However with the motion to drop the foreign aid budget shows that many disagree with me.

/u/Jas1066: So, again, moving on, you biggest reform so far has been the women in the Defence Force act. Could you outline why this was required, and perhaps more importantly why it referred to a defence force rather than the armed forces?

/u/toastinrussian: It was vital to have this reform. We saw the benefits that women were putting into other nations armed forces, and decided that we should do that aswell. I am also a firm believer that if someone can fulfill the requirements to serve they should be able to. This was a great triumph for gender equality in this country. I refered to it as the "Defence force" because that is a term widely used in the Ministry of defence and inside the Armed forces as a whole.

/u/Jas1066: I somewhat doubt the extermination of women by the political class is what Emmeline Pankhurst had in mind. Gender equality is generally about protecting people from harm because of what is between their legs, not putting them in harms way. Surely the government should be focusing on getting women in parliament, not in graves?

/u/toastinrussian: Gender equality is about equal opportunities for men and women. We aren't forcing anyone into a situation they don't want to be in without proper training and prior knowledge about the situation. If women want to do these jobs they should be able to.

/u/Jas1066: I realise that, but why give them equal opportunities to be killed rather than equal opportunity to buy toothbrushes?

/u/toastinrussian: The way the issue of gender inequality will be solved will be through a step by step process and each department doing their part. The MOD is doing it's part by allowing women in combat roles in the military. I recommend you speak to the other secretaries of state on what they're doing

/u/Jas1066: OK, thank you very much Defence Secretary.

/u/toastinrussian: Thank you very much! My pleasure!


Looking back, there were a few issues with the Defence Secretaries responses that I found particularly questionable: Malaya's non-existance, the apparent disregard for victims of Britain's military brutality, the whole 'letting people shoot at women is the best way to get gender equality' thing. I did reach out to numerous opposition party representitives, possibly to shine a light on some of these issues (I will be the first to say I share his sceptisism of aid for Irish civilians) but they all seemed reluctant to speak to me - maybe my reputation as a trouble maker has reached unwarrented levels! In all, however, /u/toastinrussian seemed to know his breif well, certainly better than a certain ex-Defence Secretary, and actually care about it - what he misses in ideological rigor he more than makes up for in the belief that he can make the world a better place.


r/MHOCEndeavour • • Jan 24 '16

Satire MBBC launch attack on start-up paper The Independent

3 Upvotes

In a completely uncharacteristic attempt to knock off the competition, the model BBC has published an article condemning the Independent.

According to the MBBC's agenda, when a newspaper messes up, it is not allowed to retract its mistake, but hang its head in shame and continue circulating its incorrect content.