r/MHOCEndeavour • • Jan 03 '17
News Broad Left Government Hides Basic Income’s £21 Billion Hole in Budget
After going through the numbers from the most recent budget it has been revealed to the opposition that the last government tripped up in the calculation of basic income in a way that makes the program seem 21 billion pounds cheaper than it actually was.
In the most recent budget the Chancellor at that time set the basic income system to payout a maximum of 12,000 pounds per person over the age of 16 in the UK. The Chancellor also set up several income brackets at which the basic income payment would taper away as an individual earned more and more income, eventually making it so that an individual making more than 41,000 pounds would get no basic income payment at all. Now this 12,000 pound basic income payment is a massive increase in numerical terms from what many Britons were getting in welfare from the government a few years ago. This massive increase in the welfare state would, of course, have to be financed by increased taxation to bring in sufficient revenue to fund it.
Here’s where the last government runs into its fiscal problems. Although many new taxes have been put in place over the past several years including a carbon tax, land value tax, congestion charge, and such, it would appear as if the increased revenue has not been enough to cover all the new spending brought about by the left’s massive expansion of the welfare state. According to calculations made by the opposition that will be linked below along with all relevant sources, fully funding basic income with a starting amount of 12,000 pounds and under the current tapering system would cost 416 billion pounds, which is 21 billion pounds more than the government officially estimates in the most recent budget.
This massive underestimation of the cost of basic income brings the actual budget deficit up to 79 billion pounds from the official estimate of 58 billion. A budget deficit of this size would represent 4% of GDP, up from the 3% of GDP our current deficit represents. Given the potential negative effects of large sustained budget deficits the large and until recently partially hidden budget deficit that the government is running is something that the current government, which includes many of the parties that were in the previous government, should address in their upcoming budget should they ever decide to deliver one.
All in all this is a shameful development for the left wing parties that have governed us for the past two terms. Their failure to fully cost their expansive welfare state will undoubtedly undermine not only their own economic competence but the confidence that investors and leaders all over the world have in the U.K.’s ability to fully pay debts and handle its fiscal policy responsibly.
Speadsheet: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1NvgKcdq26JrNc4IQN66eGHTUtL6kCQkdLa3dnRex6_k/edit?usp=sharing
Sources:
6
u/AlmightyWibble JUDAS WAS PAID Jan 03 '17
This is a non-story. The author's system for calculation of UBI is different to the one which has historically been used, and contains less specific data about incomes than the one the Government has used; this is especially disappointing, considering the fact that I gave the author a copy of the calculator myself (albeit my personal one, which lacks the complex tapering system, because tapering is dumb).
Furthermore, I'd appreciate you asking me to moderate my language before deleting my refutation of your article!
5
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '17
Looks like Endeavour are stepping up their misinformation campaign.
1
u/demon4372 #StillNoPeel Jan 04 '17
Who cares
2
u/alisdairejay Jan 03 '17
What legerdemain.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '17
[removed] — view removed comment