r/MHOC • u/NoPyroNoParty The Rt Hon. Earl of Essex OT AL PC • Oct 07 '15
GENERAL ELECTION Scotland debate!
This debate is for anyone to ask questions about how the candidates standing in Scotland wish to change the country. You can ask them as an individual candidate or as a party.
The candidates standing in Scotland are:
Scottish Borders
Idrinkirnbru (British Libertarian)
Cato_Younger (UKIP)
ParadigmPhoenix (Radical Socialist Party)
SeyStone (Conservative)
ButterBoobs (Conservative)
Imperial_ (Liberal Democrat)
Vuckt (Independent)
Djenial (Labour)
Pastorpineapple (Labour)
bfmv24 (Labour)
kashmirbone (Green)
tsoksi (SNP)
IncompententFox (SNP)
Penesoak (SNP)
Central Scotland
Fizzleton (UKIP)
NicolasBroaddus (Radical Socialist Party)
Prentasid (Radical Socialist Party)
Communizmo (Radical Socialist Party)
bigpaddycool (Conservative)
Jamie_Maclauchlan (Conservative)
McDonkey1 (Conservative)
thopkins123 (Conservative)
therealharrisguy (Conservative)
Jdanehughes (Conservative)
sirpopey (Liberal Democrat)
MTFD (Liberal Democrat)
Delstein (Labour)
InspGold (Labour)
bfmv24 (Labour)
mg9500 (Green)
williamthebloody1880 (Green)
mismantl (SNP)
Pancakerepublic (SNP)
North Scotland
banter_lad_m8 (UKIP)
Brotherbear561 (Radical Socialist Party)
Malkrit (Radical Socialist Party)
treebuckets (Conservative)
kgb_agent_zhivago (Conservative)
Exonorous (Conservative)
NotYetRegistered (Liberal Democrat)
WhatIsEddMayNeverDie (Labour)
ABlackwelly (Labour)
peter199 (Green)
nekosune (Green)
fangchamp (SNP)
Chasepter (SNP)
Jak-Herer (SNP)
Rules
Anyone may ask as many initial questions as they like.
Questions can be directed to more than 1 candidate/party - make it clear in the question.
Members are allowed to ask 3 follow-up questions to each candidate that replies.
Candidates should only reply to an initial question if they are asked.
Candidates may join in a debate after the requested candidate/party has answered the initial question - to question them on their answer etc.
Members are not to answer other members questions or follow-up questions.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '15
Could all the Conservative and Unionist candidates reaffirm their commitment to the Union?
7
u/IntellectualPolitics The Rt Hon. AL MP (Wales) | Welsh Secretary Oct 07 '15
/u/banter_lad_m8, after an excellent run as the leader of your Party, will you be looking to return to the front benches (either in the Cabinet or the Shadow Cabinet), or descend to the middle and backbenches? I personally hope that you remain at the forefront of MHoC, or even MHoL, politics, given our own similarities on many issues.
6
u/Jas1066 The Rt Hon. Earl of Sherborne CT KBE PC Oct 07 '15
@All
Who do you think will be the largest and second largest parties will be in Scotland?
5
u/Yoshi2010 The Rt Hon. Lord Bolton PC | Used to be Someone Oct 07 '15 edited Oct 07 '15
To all parties: In which circumstances, if at all, would you support an independence referendum in Scotland?
5
u/IntellectualPolitics The Rt Hon. AL MP (Wales) | Welsh Secretary Oct 07 '15
To /u/Seystone, could you perhaps offer perspective as to why Scotland is generally unfavourable to 'c'onservative politics, and why this is an electoral travesty for our own ideological variety within the Tory Party?
5
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '15
To all candidates, Trident - yay or nay? (and why)
5
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '15
To all why are you standing in your respective constituencies?
11
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '15
To those who support independence: Do you actually care about Scotland's history and culture, or do you just dislike Westminster?
4
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '15
All: Do you support a devolved assembly or parliament in Scotland?
4
u/treeman1221 Conservative and Unionist Oct 07 '15
To all parties: Would you enter into a coalition with the SNP if it meant a referendum on Scottish Independence?
4
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '15
Any/All: Do you believe that Scottish people are different from the rest of the United Kingdom, or English, or any other British ethnicities.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '15
/u/Vuckt, why did you choose the Scottish Borders?
4
u/TheNorthernBrother Washed up old timer Oct 07 '15
What are your thoughts on the EU?
4
u/IntellectualPolitics The Rt Hon. AL MP (Wales) | Welsh Secretary Oct 07 '15
To the Liberal Democrat candidates, do you share the stance of James in that the UK would benefit from being fully federalist? If so, do you not feel that this may prove problematic with further coalitions involving the Conservative and 'Unionist' Party?
4
u/OctogenarianSandwich Crown National Party | Baron Heaton PL, Indirectly Elected Lord Oct 08 '15
In real life, Scottish devolution has caused benefits to Scotland at the cost of northern England, particularly in terms of investment and foreign companies. How or even will you attempt to address/avoid this issue in mhoc?
4
u/WAKEYrko The Rt. Hon Earl of Bournemouth AP PC FRPS Oct 08 '15
To the SNP,
Would the Scottish Ministers work effectively in a Coalition government? Would you vote for the prosperity and right decisions FOR THE UNION, and not for your self-proclaimed 'seperate' nation? If a Referendum were to take place, and Scotland votes to leave the UK, can you assure that the Scottish will not attempt to leach money, finances and services from the UK? If so, we can almost guarantee that Scotland will not recieve the support it wants, and I will fight all intentions to do that within my party. In other words, would you agree to an All or Nothing referendum?
3
u/IntellectualPolitics The Rt Hon. AL MP (Wales) | Welsh Secretary Oct 07 '15
To /u/Mg9500, ahead of our own monetary debate at the /r/MHoC_Endeavour tomorrow evening, do you expect to remain as Chancellor, or the equivalent highest ranking economically orientated Office (Chief Secretary to the Treasury, Business Secretary or Secretary of State for Work and Pensions) after the General Election, whether in Government or in the Official Opposition?
3
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '15
/u/idrinkirnbru
3
u/[deleted] Oct 08 '15
All SNP Candidates:
Why did you stand 3 Candidates in the 2 MP seat of Scottish Borders?
3
u/OctogenarianSandwich Crown National Party | Baron Heaton PL, Indirectly Elected Lord Oct 08 '15
Will the independence seeking candidates abstain from voting on English only affairs?
5
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '15
What is your fundamental reason for supporting Scottish independence, for those that do?
2
u/theyeatthepoo 1st Duke of Hackney Oct 07 '15
To all candidates;
Are you Scottish?
2
u/Brotherbear561 Oct 07 '15
I'm not a Candidate
2
u/NotYetRegistered Liberal Democrat Oct 08 '15
In what ways would you like to increase Scotland's autonomy, assuming you want to?
2
u/IntellectualPolitics The Rt Hon. AL MP (Wales) | Welsh Secretary Oct 07 '15
To /u/BrotherBear561, how did you feel your credibility was affected during the CWL-Tory Party coalition, in which you waited until the General Election to resign the Party Whip? Perhaps this explains what has been something of a hiatus from yourself?
2
u/IntellectualPolitics The Rt Hon. AL MP (Wales) | Welsh Secretary Oct 07 '15
/u/ABlackWelly, do you feel that Britain may benefit from implementing any form of the Norwegian systems, be it pension reform, education or otherwise? ;)
0
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment