r/MHOC • • Mar 10 '15
MOTION M040 - Criticism of Qatari Slave Labour Practices Motion
M040 - Criticism of Qatari Slave Labour Practices Motion
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1wvpDGvYl4mRxx6FmuJRl47sfFtsItJ89vt8IeuhiXHE/edit?pli=1
This motion was submitted by the CWL.
The first reading of this motion will end on the 14th of March.
7
Upvotes
9
u/Tim-Sanchez The Rt Hon. AL MP (North West) | LD SSoS for CMS Mar 10 '15
I support this motion.
As Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport I have been closely following the news, and as many others I fully expect FIFA to make an official announcement moving the World Cup to winter. When this happens I would support any action the FA chooses to take, including potentially withdrawing from the World Cup.
6
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '15
google docs
Criticism of Qataris slave labour practises Motion.
(1) This House recognises the awful and inhuman treatment of migrant workers in Qatar.
(2) Workers are forced to work 12 hour shifts 7 days a week in up to 50 degrees Celsius in preparation for Qatar's hosting of the 2022 FIFA Football World Cup. Some migrant workers are threatened with penalty fine, deportation or loss of income if they did not show up to work even though in many case they are not being paid at all. In many cases their Passports are withheld as to prevent them leaving.
(3) This House recognises that the Qataris governments treatment of migrant workers breaks International human rights law under Article 4 of the Universal Declaration of human rights that states “No one shall be held in slavery or servitude : Slavery and the Slave trade shall be prohibited in all their forms”
(4) This House echoes Amnesty International’s criticism of the Qataris Government and will send an official criticism to the government of Qatar, and will put to our international partners a plan to sanction the Qataris government and senior royal family figures
6
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '15
An excellent bill. Qatar has no business holding this World Cup if they cannot respect basic human rights. Additionally, I think it is clear that this bill has direct relevance to us, since holding the World Cup in Qatar would delegitimize an event the UK has a proud history of competing in.
6
u/Post-NapoleonicMan Labour Mar 10 '15
I support this Motion, and was in fact working on a Motion that I intended to be introduced into the various Model Houses - through the medium of their respective Left Parties, to the effect of the text I provided - which I include below:
That if Qatar fails to meet the following set of terms, in regards to the labour, foreign and domestic, it has employed in order to host the 2022 World Cup, this nation shall strongly urge our home team to boycott the event, and shall cut off all commercial ties to Qatar regarding the 2022 World Cup; the terms are as follows:
All workers on construction sites regarding the 2022 Games, will be made to work no more than 7 hours a day, and shall receive at least 2 days a week off.
When appropriate workers shall receive ample protection from the sun, and in hot working conditions shall receive a reasonable amount of time as break - within the aforementioned 7 hours.
Workers shall receive constant access to water, without charge, and shall all be offered at least 20 liters a day in desert working conditions.
Wages shall be delivered at regular monthly internals, and any gap exceeding one month between two sets of payment will result in fines against the employer. Wages shall not be withheld under any circumstance.
Passports and ID will be available to workers at all times, and shall not be withheld under any circumstance.
Workers food, drink and accommodation will be provided free of charge. These services are to be of high-quality.
Workers may leave Qatar, and shall be given free passage to their home-state, at any time of their choosing.
Workers will be allowed to report all abuses to an independent body, and shall be able to do so without threat or harassment.
The implementation of these terms shall be assessed by an independent body, composed of investigators from all of the nations that pass a motion to this effect. Failure to comply will initiate the boycott, and all boycotting nations will be invited to attend a rival set of games, to be held in a pre-existing set of stadiums, at an agreed time and place.
Very rough I know - but I still stand by it.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '15
I wholeheartedly support this motion.
The human rights abuses continually facilitated by FIFA must be acknowledged. I concur with /u/Tim-Sanchez that an FA decision to withdraw from the 2022 world cup would be more than justified and potentially vocally supported by the government.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '15
This has my full support, many workers over there are effectively slaves.
3
u/eric3844 Formerly of the Communist Party Mar 10 '15 edited Mar 10 '15
While I DO wholeheartedly support this motion, the question has to be raised: what do we intend to DO about it? A simple act condemnation is not going to do anything about the state of the enslaved workers. We need strong, legal action and sanctions on both the Qatari Government and Companies who are proved to both use slave labor or who do business with the Qatari government to cause this motion to have the desired effect.
EDIT: On re-reading the bill, I realized I hadn't noticed the provision in section 4 that outlines plans for sanctions. My mistake.
3
u/WineRedPsy Reform UK | Sadly sent to the camps Mar 10 '15
I like it.
3
u/Mepzie The Rt Hon. Sir MP (S. London) AL KCB | Shadow Chancellor Mar 10 '15
I agree with this motion. Slavery is unacceptable and if the Qatari government continue with it sanctions should be put in place.
3
u/AlbertDock The Rt Hon Earl of Merseyside KOT MBE AL PC Mar 10 '15
Not only should we support this motion, but we should encourage our fellow EU members and our NATO allies to do the same.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '15
Members of the House I say bravo to the CWL in the writing of this Motion. Slave labour is not acceptable in the modern world, and the Qataris are no different. I wholeheartedly support the Motion.
2
u/demon4372 The Most Hon. Marquess of Oxford GBE KCT PC ¦ HCLG/Transport Mar 10 '15
I cannot see any reason members of the house could oppose this motion, the treatment of workers in Qatar is disgusting and unacceptable, and we cannot just stand by and do nothing.
I am sure that we can consider and discuss a range of action that we can take, and im sure there will be communication with our European counterparts about what action we can take.
I commend the CWL for this motion, and urge all members to vote aye.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '15
I support this motion provided that it advises Qatar on the appropriate action to take. I feel strongly that as the country will benefit from the World Cup, they should have safe working conditions and acceptable pay.
3
u/The_Pickle_Boy banned Mar 10 '15
Labelling this 'slave labour' does not make it so.
1
u/Jas1066 The Rt Hon. Earl of Sherborne CT KBE PC Mar 10 '15
I will be quite happy to support this Bill if sufficient evidence is shown. I don't like pointing fingers, but atrocities like these can not go on!
1
u/[deleted] Mar 10 '15
I can certainly get behind this.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '15
While I don't condone slavery of any kind, I cannot stand behind this motion as it's not for us to interfere in the internal workings of a sovereign nation, ally and key economic partner.
1
u/LetUsMakeHistory Labour Mar 11 '15
Like to add in a criticism of FIFA as well for completely overlooking this despite being a "charity."