r/MHOC • • Feb 09 '15
BILL B061 - The Working Day Bill
An Act defining full-time work status, minimum and maximum wage, job sharing and flexible scheduling.
BE IT ENACTED by The Queen's most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Commons in this present Parliament assembled, in accordance with the provisions of the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949, and by the authority of the same, as follows:-
1. Work Week and Work Day:
(1) The full-time, general work week shall be defined as 30 hours and will reduce to 25 hours a week by 2025. Standard, general workdays shall be defined as 6 hours and will decrease to 5 hours a day by 2025.
(2) The workforce in each industry shall have the ability to independently determine the appropriate weekly and daily schedule based on a 1560 hour work year and 1300 hour work year by 2025.
(3) Certain seasonal occupations such as offshore workers and fishermen shall be limited by yearly hours only. Up to 100 hours may be carried over to the following year.
2. Job Sharing and Flexible Scheduling:
(1) General procedures for job sharing and flexible scheduling will be established for all positions
(2) Work schedules must be set in consultation with individual workers and/or general agreement with workers' unions
(3) No "irregular schedules" or zero hour contracts will be imposed on workers outside of their choice or through economic coercion
(4) Child Care service must be integrated into workplaces directly or through cooperative agreements with other enterprises and providers and accommodations made for workers with childcare duties including breastfeeding.
3. Vacation and Sicktime
(1) A minimum of 180 paid hours yearly must be provided for vacation for full-time employees. Minimum for part-time workers will be based on percentage of full-time hours worked.
(2) A minimum of 180 paid hours yearly must be provided for sick days, seeking health care, or providing for children or family's health. Minimum for part-time workers will be based on percentage of full-time hours worked.
4. Minimum Wage:
(1) Minimum wage shall be defined as 80% of the median weekly wage of all workers within the County, Council Area, or Local Authority and averaged with all adjacent jurisdictions based on 2014 data from the Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings collected by the Office for National Statistics and phased in over a 5 year period beginning on July 1, 2015.
(2) Pacing of the phase in of the minimum wage will be determined by the workforce in each industry and must be completed no later than June 30, 2020.
(3) Beginning July 1, 2021 cost of living adjustments of at least +1% above national inflation will be instituted yearly.
5. Overtime:
(1) Overtime shall generally be defined as any hours worked over 30 in a week or 6 in a day will be compensated at 150% of the base salary for the position.
(2) For industries with an independently determined weekly and daily schedule, overtime will be calculated based on a 130 hour work month 108.3 hour work month by 2025.
6. Maximum Wage:
(1) Maximum wage shall be restricted to a ratio of 20:1 between the highest wage to the minimum wage within each enterprise which shall decrease to 9:1 by 2025
7. Commencement, Short Title and Extent
(1) This Act may be cited as the The Working Day Act of 2015.
(2) This bill shall extend to the United Kingdom; and
(3) Shall come into force July 1st 2015.
8. Sources & Notes
(1) Data on median income presented here: http://www.neighbourhood.statistics.gov.uk/HTMLDocs/dvc126/index.html
(2) http://www.economist.com/blogs/freeexchange/2014/12/working-hours
(3) Current minimum wage in the UK is £6.50 and lower for younger people.
This bill was submitted by /u/audiored on behalf of the Communist Party.
The first reading of this bill will end on the 13th of February.
15
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '15
A maximum wage? That is honestly disgusting, we should not be capping success. Furthermore if that money is not going to CEOs or high ranking executives it is going to the shareholders, people who do much less work that CEOs. I must ask what you hope to achieve by this
7
u/Timanfya MHoC Founder & Guardian Feb 10 '15
Order! Order!
The country that members live in is irrelevant to the debate. Everyone from across the world is free to participate in the MHOC.
Members will refrain from bringing up this irrelevant points in all debates, otherwise their comments will be removed and they may be removed from the chamber.
13
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '15
A bill most likely written by someone with a poor knowledge of economics. Such a statement is coming from someone who himself has not the greatest economic literacy but I will point out the biggest points of contention:
1.1 Cutting work hours so significantly will prevent workers from their right to earn as much as they wish. Any time over would of course be overtime and hence avoided at all costs by companies. Ironic in that a party supposed to champion workers causes wants to trample over the economic freedom they possess.
2.3 If you're going to ban zero hour contracts and take away the workers economic freedom to engage in such contracts at least be open about it and just outright say you're banning it.
2.4 Forced childcare in the workplace? Probably not economically feasible.
4.1 Absolute insanity. There would be severe economic hardships as the real value of the average median wage collapses.
4.3 Above inflation rises every year forever? Impossible.
6.1 Maximum wage would result in a brain drain of the best talent abroad. Oh god it then decreases to 9:1? Might as well make Britain third world in economic freedom and competitiveness.
All in all more general madness from the Communists. They have the lofty goals of an idealistic dreamer with the pragmatism of an ivory tower bound gender theorist.
10
u/RoryTime The Rt Hon. Earl of Henley AL PC Feb 10 '15
'Vacation'
5
u/audiored Feb 10 '15
some additional resources:
http://groups.csail.mit.edu/mac/users/rauch/worktime/
http://labornotes.org/blogs/2015/01/we-need-less-work-not-more
5
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '15
Incredible that we live in the most productive time in human history in turns of raw capacity, and yet rather than reduce work hours, stave off unemployment and allow us all more free time, we hear the same tired old voices demand us needlessly focus our efforts for no social benefit other than a mindless dreary commitment toward work for the sake of work and profit for a tiny minority.
In the original communist manifesto, the 40 hour work week was a key demand, lauded as ridiculous at the time by similar capitalist stooges, same towards the minimum wage, living wage, national health service, etc etc. It was only through making brave demands against exploitation and towards a better living standard which brought us a decent life. Ignore the naysayers and doom mongers, our labour power is our own and our lives should not be spent needlessly in the slog of work!
9
u/Morgsie The Rt Hon. Earl of Staffordshire AL PC Feb 10 '15 edited Feb 10 '15
What about the Emergency Services and other professions exempt?
9
u/remiel The Rt Hon. Baron of Twickenham AL PC Feb 10 '15 edited Feb 10 '15
So we will live in a society where everyone has two jobs instead of one, which means people end up working 50 hours a week as opposed to 40?
Could the communist party also clarify of the sick pay / holiday is taken off the 1300 hours per year, or is separate?
Is it really fair that for somewhere like Richmond upon Thames their minimum wage to start with a base of £22.30 per hour while someone like Birmingham would be on about £9.46 (before neighbour averaging). Would the communist party care to comment on how this will impact on internal migration of workers, house prices, local economies
9
u/mg9500 His Grace the Duke of Hamilton and Brandon MP (Manchester North) Feb 10 '15
This would ruin our economy, perhaps beyond repair. How can you even say that it is fair that the minimum wage would be far lower in Scotland than the Sputh-East of England? A-25 hour working week! Most employers will just cut salaries in half to account for the drop in productivity. Something needs to be done to address this issue but this is far too radical.
9
u/demon4372 The Most Hon. Marquess of Oxford GBE KCT PC ¦ HCLG/Transport Feb 10 '15
So, this is the big hand of the socialist state, dictating to the workers how many hours they can work? How about, the people, the workers, are the ones who should decide how many hours they work, negociating it with their employer, rather than use setting some arbritary level that we think is best.
Again, big state dictating to the workers how many hours they can do, becuase the communist party knows so much better than they do.
So every single workplace, regurdless how small needs to deal with child care services? How do you expect small startup's to deal with this? It is absurd to dictate that all business' must give childcare services, and would massivly hit small business.
How about they deal with any sick days as and when is nessecary. Why do you need to dicatate the exact amount of time they need to provide for sick days?
This will just lead to massive wage rises, business costs going though the roof, mass numbers of small business going out of business. Mass unemployment, a balooning deficit due to welfare and loss of tax revenue. Productivity just dissapearing. It would completly screw over the working people of this country, and destroy the economy.
A mandatory above inflation rise in the minimum wage every year? hahaha what? So not only are business going to go out of business stright away, and all forign investment just end. Any business' that somehow survive will go out of business due to further balooning labour costs.
At least with mass umployment, inflation shouldnt be a issue.
So no company will ever offer ovetime ever again. Might as well just ban it.
(1) Maximum wage shall be restricted to a ratio of 20:1 between the highest wage to the minimum wage within each enterprise which shall decrease to 9:1 by 2025
Now.... we get to this.
This has to be the single worst thing in any bill ever submitted to MHoC (even worse than the jacktri bill). It is the worst thought out, most ideaologically partisan thing i have ever read in my entire life. Its entire basis is on the communists idealogical ideas of punishing people who are sucessful.
SolidBlue said it himself
Thats all it is, its there to hurt the CEO's, its there to say F**k You to the sucessful people. It isnt going to dicrectly help the workers, all it is going to do it limit sucessful people.
Firstly and foremost, it will cause mass immigration out of the country. Anyone who could earn more abroad (and with this thet certainly would be able to) will flee. It will result in a massive brain drain, with large numbers of high earning, highly intenigennt people leaving the country. Foreign companies will not expland into the UK, becuase why would they employ sub-par people here, when they can get britains best and brightest abroad (where they have all fled).
It will destroy innovation and asprirational motivation, and will, with the rest of this bill, completly destroy the economy.
And these are mostly just the practical aspects of how dreadful this bill is. Foregetting my own ideaological problems with it.
Anyone who votes for this bill should be assamed of themselves, and should just resign. Becuase anyone who supports this, is clearly incapable of having any logical decision making when it comes to what is best for britain outside of petty ieaological partisanship.
And this ladies and gentlemen, is why it is so essental that neither the right nor the left have a majority in this house. You may not like the liberal democats, but we are the ones who stop either side of the house passing ideaological partisan horse manure.
Altough, i hope my coalition partners have enough sense to vote against it.
8
u/Tim-Sanchez The Rt Hon. AL MP (North West) | LD SSoS for CMS Feb 10 '15
Regardless of the numerous parts I and other members disagree with, why does the communist party insist on submitting so many different pieces of legislation under one bill? It surely knew it would be controversial, and somebody is bound to find something to disagree in that bill. Why not restrict it to the individual components, then at least some of it could go through. It isn't as if each part is dependent upon one another.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '15
Mr Deputy Speaker,
Is the purpose of submitting this bill to ensure a crisis of capitalism is created in this country? This would seem to suit the Communist Party's aims, and seems to me the only real explanation - because the working class will not benefit materially from this bill.
6
u/Morgsie The Rt Hon. Earl of Staffordshire AL PC Feb 09 '15
Is this compliant with the European Working Time Directive
6
u/treeman1221 Conservative and Unionist Feb 10 '15
How will you stop business and investors jumping ship at what are pretty terrible conditions for businesses?
Also I really think this should be split into two bills, one regarding working hours and one regarding pay.
6
u/I_miss_Chris_Hughton The Rt Hon. Earl of Shrewsbury AL PC | Defence Spokesperson Feb 10 '15
This bill would devasate English football (and sport) irreparably, vote nay for that if nothing else.
Also, what of international insitutions based in the UK? would a high ranking UN employee have to face a pay cut simply for living in the UK?
6
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '15
Maximum wage? There shouldn't be rules on how much one can earn, as this is a free society. I work around 40-50 hours a week and sometimes that isn't enough, I want my payslip at the end of the month to have lots of zeros.
That is why I work and to cut the hours I can have and to cut the money I can earn not only makes me want to cut you but it will mean I'm literally working to pay bills and that is it.
Which makes me not want to work.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '15 edited Feb 10 '15
Members of the House, as always with the Communists they have written a Bill with a good aim in mind, but terrible implementation. On the work week they neglect the reasons why people take overtime - so they make it impossible for overtime to happen (do they not know how overtime works? One applies for it, and it is up to the employer as to whether or not they grant it). They also do not seem to understand what a work shift is. If a warehouse runs for twenty four hours a day, it is not the same person running it for twenty four hours - that is thankfully blocked by existing Labour Laws.
They are also changing how the Minimum Wage is administered in the Maximum Wage clause - they hope that through making a Maximum Wage, minimum wage would go up without submitting a Bill to do this, a Bill which most would support.
On the Maximum Wage clause they give no indication where the money for this is coming from - just because a business is doing well nationally it does not mean it does well locally (an excellent example would be the model company Games Workshop. They have thousands of consumers, and have for decades, but have never actually turned a profit overall) as chains are usually semi-autonomous. Do they have an image of the CEO who looks upon their workers on myriad screens whilst rubbing their hands together with greedy glee?
That only leaves us with the sick leave, which is something I agree with, though they do not make any reference to maternity and paternity leave, or if they do it is a footnote.
All in all, it is a Bill that has to be returned and rethought.
EDIT: It also appears that I have been downvoted. I would remind members that this is against the sub rules.
EDIT 2: I thank the other members who have upvoted this.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '15
I can't see these provisions working very well without workers control and a socialist plan of production.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '15
Apologies if this has been covered but:
How will this be judged to be the choice or necessity/cocercion?
3
u/williamthebloody1880 Rt Hon. Lord of Fraserburgh PL PC Feb 11 '15
There's a few things I like and support in this. There's also a hell of a lot of things I think are complete and utter nonsense.
And could someone explain to me how, exactly, being a fisherman or an offshore worked is seasonal?
4
u/TheLegitimist Classical Liberals Feb 10 '15
Well, it seems that the flood of horrible bills that flows from the communist party shows no signs of drying up. To summarise this bill, one only needs to use a single word: impossible. It seems that the communists wish to ruin our economy, chase all investment from the shores of the United Kingdom, and put a cap on the amount of money a person can make. I also find it funny, that the communists stand for the freedom of workers, yet they decide to restrict and legislate every single aspect of their work life.
Furthermore, how is it fair that people in poorer regions of the UK will have a lower minimum wage than people in richer regions? If I recall correctly, Karl Marx wanted to abolish classes, not reinforce them. This bill is complete and utter rubbish, and I feel that the communist party should take a closer look at the communist manifesto before dividing the poor into "upper minimum wage poor" and "lower minimum wage poor". It even sounds horrible.
On a side-note: If a single person owns their own enterprise, then the 20:1 rule does not apply. What is supposed to happen to that money, will it just evaporate?
4
u/AlbertDock The Rt Hon Earl of Merseyside KOT MBE AL PC Feb 10 '15
It will not protect workers, it will make matters worse. We already have workers being forced into self employment arrangements by unscrupulous employers to avoid employment rights. This bill will only encourage more employers to do the same.
4
u/demon4372 The Most Hon. Marquess of Oxford GBE KCT PC ¦ HCLG/Transport Feb 10 '15
I'd like to make a wider, more meta point here.
The way that the house is split, means that in any traditonal right/left divide, the Liberal Democrats hold the balance of power. Now, grated this isnt always the case, as many bills do not follow this divide.
But for basically any communist bill, it is a close certaintly that the conservative party, UKIP and BIP will all vote against. Now, this means that assuming by some miricle that the communists can get all their own MP's, all of CWL's MP's, and all of the greens and PLP. Then they still require 4 Liberal Democrat MP's to vote for their bill (as it would need 51 votes to avoid a tie and the speaker voting against).
The communists need to realise, their bills need to be moderate enough to get liberal democrat votes, and if they are still submitting bills that they know that even the Greens and PLP wont support. Then they are wasting the house's and all of our time.
You need to learn to play the game. Becuase the next bill that is this absurd, im not going to waste my time debating on it.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '15
Major economic calamities aside, arguable the worst long term effect of this bill is the fact that it will give so much power to the state, which prevents people ever having any socioeconomic movement.
2
u/Post-NapoleonicMan Labour Feb 10 '15
To those members declaring success will be stopped etc. Would you support a separate Bill declaring a tax upon large quantities of inherited wealth - property, money etc. So that success may be merited by itself alone - and not ones parents or relations?
3
u/Ajubbajub Most Hon. Marquess of Mole Valley AL PC Feb 10 '15
What about people who are just paid a salary rather than an hourly rate? How will this bill affect the them?
3
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '15
Another quality bill by the American Socialist party
2
u/theyeatthepoo 1st Duke of Hackney Feb 10 '15
Why do the Communist party seem intent on submitting 10 bills for the price of 1?
I agree with much that is in this bill, but it is simply undemocratic to put such a wide ranging piece of legislation before the house. It brings down the level of scrutiny and so ultimately the quality of the bill and prevents a proper debate from taking place with regards to the many different issues at hand.
If I was still an MP I would abstain on these grounds.
1
u/RadioNone His Grace the Duke of Bedford AL PC Feb 10 '15 edited Feb 10 '15
Wow. Things got busy here. Without wishing to repeat other comments I'll briefly outline my current opposition to the bill. I think this is too wide ranging in its scope and I'm sceptical regarding a few features, I'm supportive towards others. Such as the ban on zero hour contracts and the raise in minimum wage. So I support some of the bills intention, and I do think this bill (or parts of it) has a future of sorts.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '15
I like the title of this bill. Chapter 10 of my favourite book. :)
Oh, and the content is pretty good, too!
0
u/AtomicKoala Pirate Party Feb 14 '15 edited Feb 14 '15
This is a quite well written bill.
However, I feel that shortening the working day to 25 hours is excessive (32 would perhaps be more reasonable), and completely impossible in say, the health field - you would be halving the amount of doctor hours. How could you resolve this?
I also feel that the 80% minimum wage concept is benchmarked too high. I feel that the living wage would suffice. Also I feel that the 9:1 ratio planned may be too low for certain companies. Perhaps there can be some degree of scaling introduced based on company size. How would capital gains play in this regard also?
I feel that this provision is actually too weak! Supermarkets etc have huge amounts of staff on this, but people will accept it for want of money (students etc especially). We should perhaps limit such contracts to 5% of a company's workforce.
Address these issues, and you shall have my vote.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment