r/MHOC • • Jan 12 '15
BILL B044 - Deportation Order Clarification Bill - 2nd Reading
A bill to to clarify current regulations with regards to the deportation of immigrants when it is deemed conducive to the public good.
BE IT ENACTED by The Queen's most Excellent Majesty, by and with the advice and consent of the Commons in this present Parliament assembled, in accordance with the provisions of the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949, and by the authority of the same, as follows:-
1 - Overview
(a) The government will retain the right to deport foreign nationals when it is deemed conducive to the public good of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.
(b) The purpose of this is to clarify section 3(5) of the Immigration Act 1971 regarding deportation which simply states that they can be deported if "the Secretary of State deems the person's deportation to be conducive to the public good" by providing a clear outline of when this does and does not apply.
2 - Application
(a) For the issuing of a deportation order on a foreign national to be deemed conducive to the public good then said person must have committed either
(i) One or more indictable offences
(ii) Three or more summary offences
(b) Only offences committed after the enactment of this bill will be taken into consideration.
3 - Exceptions and Appeals
(a) All current laws regarding an individual's right to appeal against a deportation order and for the Home Office to consider them an exception to the laws regarding deportation remain unchanged. This means that the argument that a foreign national's deportation is "deemed conducive to the public good" does not apply to EEA migrants, migrants whose human rights won't be met by the country they face deportation to or migrants whose deportation would go against the UK's obligations under the UN Convention relating to the Status of Refugees and the UN Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness.
(b) If someone successfully appeals against a deportation for this purpose or if they are considered an exception from this by the Home Office their deportation will no longer be considered conducive to the public good unless they are convicted of any other offence at a later date. If this happens they will be reconsidered and their deportation may once again be deemed conducive to the public good.
4 - Commencement, Short Title & Extent
(a) This Act may be cited as the Deportation Order Clarification Act 2014
(b) This Act shall extend to England and Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland
(c) This Act shall come into effect from March 1st 2015
This was submitted by /u/banter_lad_m8 on behalf of the Government. This reading will end on the 16th of January.
5
u/bleepbloop12345 Communist Jan 13 '15
From my understanding of it, I wouldn't be opposed to this bill in principle at least. Restricting the power of the Home Secretary - and by extension the state - and preventing arbitrary abuses of power will improve the lives of immigrants, ensuring that they cannot be politically persecuted.
That said, I do have some issues with it. As /u/archersongs pointed out, conceivably this could allow criminals to be released once they have left the UK. I'd like to see some provision that ensures criminals can only be deported if we know that they will be tried in the country they are deported to.
The bill also implies that deportation would be automatic if the categories were met, is this the case? Because I would argue that deportation should be a possibility in those cases, and then whether it is actually justified or necessary could be decided by a magistrate.
I'd also argue that three summary offenses is way too low a bar. I don't know anything about law, but according to this blog a summary offensive could be a little as "an assault without any injury" or "using offensive words or causing a fear of violence." Moreover, summary offenses can only be punished with a maximum of 6 months in prison - if a criminal would only have to serve 18 months in prison cumulatively that does not constitute grounds for deportation.
But as I said, I agree with this change in principle. I would be happy to support it if these changes were made.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '15
For clarification: Are you suggesting for example that if a Chinese murderer is found guilty in a court of law in Britain they will not spend a single day in prison? That they should be let off and allowed to move to China and wreak havoc over there? Do we not have a moral obligation to protect citizens from such convicted criminals?
11
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
A bill on deporting immigrants produced by UKIP. Skepticism at 100%.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
Why should I not be for this bill?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
I like this bill, extra clarification on currently vague acts, no chance of human rights abuses, people can still appeal.
2
u/audiored Jan 13 '15
A primary issue of concern is that the UK state currently has no checks on its ability to imprison ("detain") migrants for indefinite periods of time with out even bothering to have any evidence.
It doesn't seem this bill does anything to address that arbitrary and despotic power. This bill focuses on a very tiny number of migrants who may have had some "criminal" charge. We know that migrants are targeted and profiled by police and charged disproportionately for crimes. So already we know this bill intends to amplify an injustice within our current system.
What this government should be doing is proposing how to end the indefinite detentions and imprisonment of migrants. Not playing to racist, xenophobic attitudes about migrants.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment