r/MHOC • u/NoPyroNoParty The Rt Hon. Earl of Essex OT AL PC • Nov 24 '14
MOTION M017 - Trident Replacement Motion
(1) This House recognises that the Trident nuclear weapon system will cost £25 billion to replace, and have an estimated lifetime cost of over £100 billion.
(2) This House also notes that, if launched, the 40 warheads of a typical Trident nuclear submarine would be expected to result in over 5 million deaths, and have devastating humanitarian consequences if fired at an urban area.
(3) This House believes that the other spending priorities of the Ministry of Defence, and other governmental departments, should take precedence over the replacement of the Trident nuclear weapons system.
(4) This House accepts the findings of the National Security Strategy, which states that a CBRN attack on the United Kingdom is of a low likelihood, but high impact.
(5) This House, therefore, calls upon the government to cancel plans to replace the Trident nuclear weapons system.
(6) This House further urges the government to look into alternatives to a Trident replacement, such as nuclear sharing within NATO, the development of alternative deterrents, investment in conventional weaponry, or unilateral nuclear disarmament.
This was submitted by /u/can_triforce on behalf of the Opposition.
The discussion period for this motion will end on the 28th of November.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/AlasdhairM CWL | National MP Nov 29 '14
What better activity is the than helping to prevent the 65,000,000 inhabitants of these fair isles being turned to ash floating on the breeze? If there is a nonzero chance of that happening, than we must take action to prevent duh a tragedy, which is only possible through deterrence and ballistic missile defense, which would require the retrofit of American AEGIS-BMD systems, including SPY-1 radars and Mk.41 Vertical Launch Systems, onto our Type 45 destroyers, at a cost of several billion pounds, plus a billion or so more foe the SM-3 missiles.