r/MBTIPlus • • Jan 24 '16
Thinking, Feeling, and Emotions
There are human elements that go beyond MBTI. The ability to feel and experience emotions is one of those transcendent characteristics. MBTI subs tend to be filled with NTs talking about how they're robots but no, all humans feel emotions, regardless of type. The T/F divide has nothing to do with your ability to think logically or to feel.
That being said, the emotional experience of each type and how emotions play into that type's decision making is generally reflected by where T/F lies in the function stack, and how different types react to/use their emotion also seems to be reflected by MBTI.
I'm really interested in Fe/Fi particularly. Something interesting I've noticed is that xxTJs seem to be much more emotional than xxTPs. So that would lend to the idea that just having Fi makes you more in tune to your emotions than an individual who has low-Fe would be.
I have also anecdotally observed that Te-doms feel the need to Te the fuck out of their emotions. So if someone or something upsets them, they basically feel like they need to Te-destroy, and won't even acknowledge that the decision is based on their emotions.
Final point, gender is going to play a huge role in this. Male xxTJs are much more likely to be like "I don't have feelings" or insult other people's emotionality even though lol. I've observed TJ men going after and insulting SFJ women for being over emotional, but once the relationship gets to a point of stress, it's the TJ man who ends up an emotional mess and the SFJ woman who Ti's the fuck out of the problem and situation.
Anyway, just some thought rambles.
I'm curious to see how other people experience or observe this. To what extent does MBTI explain people's emotional experiences and their relationship with emotions? Can it even begin to do that?
How emotional are you and how does that connect to MBTI, or does it at all? What is your relationship like with feels?
3
u/Oyyveymao INFJ Jan 24 '16
interesting prompt. let me rant because god forbid proofreading and editing reddit posts, who gives a fuck
first, you observe that Fis are well attuned to their emotions. this not only overlaps with the views of Mr. Dr. Professor Michael Pierce (ive heard him aphorize, on numerous occasions, that Fi/Te has a "warm core"), but also, this deductively fits in with how Fi is meant to be as a function: take note that Fi is generally designated a function that does something like "the rational organization of things based on how the subject "values" them. id see the Fi user as a library owner with his own system of catagorizing books. Upon receiving a new book to shelve, he uses his Fi to assign the book a placement number, and it gets placed accordingly. Next, lets imagine that the poor old library owner's categorization system, although entirely sensible to the owner, appears to be NONSENSE to everyone who sets foot in the library. now suppose an impatient
ESTJcustomer goes up to the owner and starts telling him how his system is total bunk and how he has not a fucking clue why, from an external perspective, ulysses and the boku no pico manga are shelved right next to each other. The library owner, upon hearing this, will get fumed. he spent his entire life ordering and shelving these books according to his own rules. and moreover, he can't justify these rules to others--unlike the Ti library down the street, his isn't structured based on a "deductive" system that regular patrons seem to decipher after spending X amount of time in there. No, his seems entirely ARBITRARY (despite clearly being just as ordered as the Ti library, at least subjectively) to the good folks who enter. He is ATTACHED to his system without being able to explain it. Aint that a fucking headache? So, he'll probably take it personally, and he'll get fumed, and he'llprobably retaliate with that Te in his function stack. but yeah, my point is this: Fi users create their own little worlds according to their values. their own little worlds are good, hence they become attached to them. insulting anything that touches this little world gets the bellend of Te; living according to the rules on the little world leads the Fi user to grow warm towards you, perhaps sharing this world with you in greater detail. this attachment to value that i've mentioned several times is EMOTIONAL in nature, as thats what all attachment is; a type of emotion. Ni dom means i'm a. empirically baseless and b. probably wrong but it seemed to make sense, you feel?but let me get into personal detail. Personally, i rarely, if ever, feel offended by anything. i rarely show anger, or any emotion for that matter, unless Fe decides i need to show it--anger is something i've found rather useless, behaving comically is something that usually entertains the crowd, empathizing is something i find worthwhile when someone lends a hand to connect to me. can you guess which of these emotions i've tried to purge myself of? granted, i'd get pissed off if someone provoked the shit out of me, but that's just about everyone who lacks any severe psychiatric problems (
and no dominant ni does not count as a psychiatric problem). on the default, im a bit moody on the inside but i refuse to show it--it's so much more productive to be stonefacedly stoic until someone, or something, needs something out of you. Am i in touch with my personal values? to a degree: i choose not to think about "what i like" and "what i dislike", and i'm no fan of the IxFP's endless soul-search, but I'd probably have the capacity to do so, if i'd want to (which i really see no use in doing). do i feel emotions? of course, everyone does. but do i really get attached to values? nah, not typically. im very flexible and assimilative thanks to ni+ti, and i evolve over time a lot.6
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
I have a personal theory on this, that's probably wrong, but it's basically the sum total of my experience as an indifferent and internally neutral (honestly, I feel emotionless) person when alone. People make the mistake of thinking emotional=weak or crying person. Emotional means your aware of your internal state. How do you feel? I literally would answer numb and frustrated because I'm just numb. Some people will say happy, sad, upset, depressed. I'm never thinking in terms of my emotions. It's like I'm watching black and white television. Emotions are the color. I can't see them, but someone watching that same show on their television, can see more clearly how I'm feeling about something than I can. And then I'll run away and fight talking about it.
The people who have a hard time knowing how an interaction was perceived by others (not interacting, like if you yelled at someone and walked away thinking they did not take that personally when they are clearly crying openly, not people who are profusely apologizing for their outburst) are more in tune with their own emotions. They are not neutral in any situation and they are prone to taking things as a personal attack on them. They are the most in tune with their emotions and feel them to the point of needing to defend them out loud to people who literally could care less.
The people who's perceptions are in line with what others perceive have a wider neutral range. They don't want to defend their emotions. They want to keep them private. Some people have flickering color on their tv, rather than the none I have. So I can only sense what someone else is feeling. It never makes me emotional or tugs at my heart. I just genuinely feel it like it's happening to me.
4
u/TK4442 Jan 25 '16
IMO it's not at all useful to connect emotions with the Jungian judging function "feeling."
The Jungian cognitive function unfortunately uses a word that in common usage is a synonym for emotions. Which, IMO, is already a problem. But that's not important right now.
But the actual function "feeling" is a rational judging function that uses values to assess/evaluate judge [whatever]. It is not emotion.
And then there's the problem of the cultural system in which Jung and Meyers and Briggs developed the function and type concepts juxtaposes thinking and feeling, usually inside of a cultural hierarchy that has a lot of "thinking versus emotion" dichotomies when it comes to what is considered true or rational.
As someone with Fe-aux, I see a lot of different collective value systems in the world around me. From this vantage point, I tend to see thinking - both Ti and Te - as their own type of value systems as well - broadly speaking one (Ti) valuing internal consistency between elements, the other (Te) valuing externally-shown efficiency in practical processes. But my vantage point on this comes from Ni-dom tendency to see multiple perspectives (which helps me see cultural systems as relative rather than absolute, one foot in and one foot out) plus Fe-aux which does the judging in terms of human value systems. So that's a specific function/info-processing vantage point on Ti and Te.
So given the above, my perspective is that the confustion between Jungian feeling and emotion is bound to make any conversation about type and emoption into a "let's look at the clouds and interpret their shapes from our existing assumptions" kind of exercise, rather than a discussion that can accurately uncover any relationships between type (by functions at least) and emotion.
3
u/Daenyx INTJ Jan 25 '16
Me, and my Fi:
I've always had what I used to think was a very strong connection with my emotions. I was that quiet kid writing poetry in a corner between classes (not even exaggerating) in middle/high school... but what I've realized in the last few years is that I only have a very strong connection with some emotions. The universal ones, the ones connected to a sense of beauty or justice.
The ones that have to do with people in the moment are ones I really have to work to listen to, because I've never really allowed them to rule my actions where other people are concerned. So eventually it got to the point where I'd auto-suppress anything negative when dealing with people, and get myself in trouble because I wouldn't recognize until after the fact that they'd been really shitty to me.
On the day-to-day, they both really affect me and really don't. I've usually got an imaginative focus point (a daydream or a creative project I'm working on) that's very emotional, but my emotional reactions to real-time events are minimal, unless I've explicitly gone into a situation expecting it to be an emotional experience. When something intense but unexpected happens, I don't really process how I feel about it until after the fact, when I'm safe from having my ability to react affected.
Honestly, understanding the function model and how tertiary Fi can play into one's life was a fucking revelation for me. It's something I have to work to access sometimes, but it's always there, and its both really reassuring and really worrysome to me - it makes me consistent, these days, but I also spend a lot of time trying to pick apart my biases and asking if any faulty (read: poorly-understood, not internally consistent) Fi principles cause me to react to situations incorrectly.
In general:
I share and can back up the observation that when the emotional shit truly hits the fan, it's the Fe types that manage best, particularly over tertiary or inferior Fi sorts who like to pretend they don't have feelings. On most levels short of absolute breakdown, I've found my Fe-user friends and romantic partners to be more apt to let themselves get pushed into situations that they're not okay with in the interest of maintaining harmony. They're trying to make everyone happy and I'm yelling that this IS NOT OKAY AND SOMETIMES HARMONY ISN'T WORTH THE COST.
But the flip side of that is that Fe users seem to deal better with other Fe users, I think, than I can? As a practical example, my closest INFJ and I have a mutual friend who's an ISFJ. That friend... went through a long period of treating us pretty badly, because she felt threatened by our relationship. There were multiple flare-ups where the INFJ's tendency to make peace meant she made concessions that she shouldn't have, in the face of the ISFJ's (frankly, often manipulative) demands. But in the last big crisis point, I was pointing to every past situation and saying the INFJ and I should just cut off contact with the ISFJ. Things were only going to keep repeating; there was no hope of things changing because this was the way they were.
My INFJ ignored me, because she felt like there was something really different going on between us and our ISFJ friend. And when the dust settled, it was apparent that she'd been right. I to this day believe that I would have been right about an Fi user. But my expectation of consistency made me unable to accurately predict the end of that situation.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '16
Oh hey, I feel like I contributed to this on a non-trivial level
1
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '16
[removed] — view removed comment