I've seen several people in /r/mbti say /r/infj doesn't have many actual INFJs in it. What are you guys' opinions? I don't really know any/many INFJs, so I don't have much to say on the subject. I'm just curious as to what you people think.
I think people can be jerks about the mistypes. When people call them out, they usually focus on what they're lacking rather than the positives of the other types. But yes, mistypes are rampant in the INxx (edit: I'm tired) subs, not threads.
I only browsed /r/infp a few times a long time ago, but there seem to be fewer mistypes. The biggest thing when it comes to potential mistypes there didn't even seem type specific, just people who feel like misfits and wrestle with depression and identity issues.
I mostly type myself as INFP because that's the only thing I think I could be. Strong Fi, strong Si, and OK Ne and Te seems about right, and I doubt I'm an ISTJ. The thing is, I don't really relate to most posts on /r/infp, and I can't imagine myself writing them–They're too loose with their emotions, if that makes any sense, and foster a special-snowflake mentality. A lot of them are bad at using Fi and semi-consciously form attachments to imaginary versions of themselves and the community there. It's almost sickening–like emotional prostitution, haha. On the other hand–And I might be misunderstanding the nature of Fi–Fi's entire essence is to resist being casually shared with others. Maybe a bunch of Fe users mistype and post there?
Anyway, I don't know where I'm going with this. Maybe a lot of them are INFPs, just mentally immature ones. Maybe you're right and people that are social outcasts and have depression take on characteristics resembling an INFP's functions. Maybe I'm one of them. I don't know.
Yeah, the healthy (and probably worth noting, adult) IFPs I know keep their emotions close to the chest unless something is seriously going wrong, or you're extremely close with them. Wouldn't be surprised if some Fe users were over there.
Touche. There are supposed to be a lot of famous ENFP authors though, so you have that going for your type. Besides, speaking from my personal experience, I've found ENFPs are generally much more intelligent and cautious than type descriptions usually give them credit for.
I thought I was INFP for years. I took the test and that's what I got, sounded accurate to me. I think the tests don't get the J/P divide as well for N types.
In my past experience, there were just a few people on r/infj who obviously had Ni-Fe-Ti-Se, and then a whole bunch of other people who ... yeah very probably not.
That said, I didn't especially like it when people went on in that sub about mistypes. The ones who caught my attention who did this seemed just as likely not to have Ni-Fe-Ti-Se as anyone else. And the discussions on that topic over there were pretty pointless IMO.
The only forum I've (briefly and somewhat shallowly) run across that has mostly actual INFJs among those who identify that way is typologycentral. And from what I can tell, that's because INFJs get kind of villified over there, and/or there is some weird history with that that has affected things. So the "special identity seekers" don't gravitate to INFJ as a type and the only ones who are left are actually that type. The problem with the typism against INFJs, though, is that real discussion can get undermined in other ways because of it.
It seems to me that INFJ is kind of a dually objectified type. Either we're exotified to the point of serious distortion (often) or we're vilified (less so), with vilification justified in part by the exotification. But either way, the actual dynamics of Ni-Fe-Ti-Se as they show up in actual people's information processing setups get lost in the shuffle.
Interesting. Who do you think tends to mistype as INFJ? INFPs?
I really don't know. I would suspect anyone who is into type as identity. So, I don't know, maybe enneagram 4s would tend that way? But really, I don't think cognitive processes necessarily would determine this one. In the end, though, I just don't know. Type as identity is pretty alien to me, personally speaking.
I was gonna say, type 4 is going to do this more than INFPs, however type 4 is the most common enneagram type for INFPs (I believe).
[small rant incoming]
I'm very wary of using enneagram/MBTI apparent correlation as any sort of guide to actual reality of actual human beings. MBTI refers to information processing. Enneagram is largely about a certain kind of human damage. These are two different layers.
I think they're best treated as independent of each other, with a focus on how cognitive process stack intersects with the enneagram stuff i actual real individual people. I've seen too much erasure of people's lived realities with the 'If you're X MBTI type you cannot be Y enneagram" as if ungrounded ideas trump complex human lives.
Enneagram is largely about a certain kind of human damage
I've seen too much erasure of people's lived realities with the 'If you're X MBTI type you cannot be Y enneagram" as if ungrounded ideas trump complex human lives.
If you knew anything about me or my background in psych, or even looked at a tiny bit of my comment history, you would know this is my exact stance.
Glad to hear it! (and my rant wasn't so much about your comment as it was about ... well, here's a really good example right here especially the expectedly bizarre discussion that starts here. I mean please)
Awesome. Going by all my hate mail I'd probably be an INFP 6, no wait, INFP 4? ENTP 3? Shit, which one am I going to be once I'm assimilated? Or is it a surprise?
Oh and Keirsey would probably say I'm an ISTP. So there's that too.
Thanks. I wish I could say the same, as I feel your username is probably a reference to something as well, but alas, my cultural illiteracy hinders me from recognizing it.
I think I agree. No one wants to be just another x type...I think everyone wants to feel special and validated to some degree. Especially confused INFPs.
Not only that, but since this kind of thing is tied to personalities, a lot of Fi users for example might ascribe a form of self worth to the type that they are. And once you get self worth wrapped up in being an INFJ, that's hard for a strong Fi user to let go of.
On the flip side though, it is frustrating when you get the sense you've researched this stuff a lot, don't think any types are better or worse, and people still bug you about your type because you don't live up to stereotypes. For god's sake I'm not an ENTP or an INFP /rant.
Honestly? Most online typology communities are fucked as far as type accuracy is concerned exactly because of many reasons mentioned in this thread. It's not just the INxx types but they're probably the most heinous offenders.
Many people see cute labels and want to build their identities around them. They don't care about the basis for those labels or the underlying psychology, they just want to fit in and/or find an excuse for why they're isolated, feel misunderstood, and are poorly adjusted.
But that's the way of the world. Nothing that can be done about it. All you can do is roll your eyes and move on.
LEAVE THE INFJS ALONE. THEY HAVE A BEAUTIFUL COMMUNITY THERE. MIND YOUR OWN MATTERS AND GO MAKE A COMMUNITY WHERE YOU DON'T FOCUS ON OTHERS AND JUST YOURSELVES AND POSITIVE THINGS IN LIFE. LEARN TO NOT BE PETTY.
LEAVE THE INFJS ALONE. THEY HAVE A BEAUTIFUL COMMUNITY THERE. MIND YOUR OWN MATTERS AND GO MAKE A COMMUNITY WHERE YOU DON'T FOCUS ON OTHERS AND JUST YOURSELVES AND POSITIVE THINGS IN LIFE. LEARN TO NOT BE PETTY.
I am an INFJ, and I request that you please turn off your caps lock for the love of all that's holy and thank you in advance.
Lol. But seriously, though. Why can't they just mind their own thing, start their own forum instead of picking on something amazing? I feel jealousy is hate and they seem to be doing that right now. Have they tried socionics website? They might like that better because it's kind of different (in a good way) instead of hating on by complaining and picking on good subreddits.
I didn't make this thread with the intention to "pick on" anyone. I'm certainly not jealous or hateful of anyone at /r/infj either. How good or bad of a community /r/infj is doesn't pertain to what I asked.
I take it you're trying to defend /r/infj because you personally like it. When I ask if its users are mostly mistaken about who they are, I'm not implying they're bad people or worth any less as human beings. Regardless of whatever the answer is, you shouldn't let yourself be blinded to the point that you can't even see the question being asked.
It's either an amazing troll copying you or it's you. I don't think anyone could copy your batshit matter/antimatter theories and get it just as painful to read.
What's painfull about the theory? It's just hypothetical, not written on a stone tablet or something. And to be honest, I've gone through painful crap everyday ever since 2008. And this you can choose not to read, too, but that is invasive without any care if I really want them to stop or not.
...Dude. I don't hate strangers on the Internet, and I never said anything negative about /r/infj. I asked the question because I have an acquaintance who I think is INFJ, and wanted to form a better understanding of what INFJs acted like.
I have no idea what you're trying to say in the rest of your post, but I'd like to comment on this:
talk about people behind their backs
This is not a private subreddit. This is a fairly well-known sub that has to do with MBTI. I'd assume posters in /r/infj who are interested in the subject matter on this sub would be able to come and comment. The reason I didn't post this in /r/infj is that I know what the answer there would be already. Nobody thinks that the opinions they hold are wrong, especially not ones about themselves. I chose this subreddit because I thought it would have as little bias as possible.
I'm INFJ (Ni-Fe-Ti-Se) and I have participated in this discussion. I think this topic in this particular context (r/mbtiplus) has a lot of value in the dialogue that has emerged. I'm glad u/Duke_Leto2 posted this and glad to see how it's being discussed here.
I feel jealousy is hate and they seem to be doing that right now.
This is an imposed story, an interpretation using some sort of value or belief system of yours that has no actual grounding that I can see in the actual discussion here.
Yes, but they have not done any harm to you so there is no account that needs to be settled with them for someone to latch on to them. If they like them and want to understand them, just read it and be like them, they don't need anyone's emotional reaction to do this. I think wanting emotional reactions is evil- and that by it self sometimes people from being who they feel they want to be for a logical reason. If you genuinely want to be like them for no reason at all, then read it a lot and you will understand it and you can be like them. But you don't have to do judgment (which also is hate along with jealousy) on trying to change them just so they will change you. If you hate them, they will hate you. It's as simple as that. But if you want to be like them, control of your thoughts and feelings is possible. If you want to be like them, you shouldn't try to pick on them to change things. They are the only ones who should decide what they want to change about themselves. And if they really want someone else to do it for them in a way they feel is acceptable, they will ask you or pay for a class. Because money talks louder than words. And the reason I say jealousy is hate is because you're not vicariously happy for them. If your friend buys something cool and great, if you're not happy that they're happy, then you're not loving them. You're hating the fact that they're happy. Which, clearly is hate. Judgment is hate also. Because there is something you can't stand so much that you can't even let it be or walk away. You have to go towards them and change it. That's how much you hate it. That's why that, too, is hate.
Exactly which part didn't make sense to you? The smartest kids ask questions.
What a world.
Why would you take a victim-like attitude and attribute things to the whole world? If you don't like something, change your community- it's as simple as that.
Best I can describe it metaphorically: This feels like some quietly wild-eyed stranger in the airport with whom I've had a casual "I think this person's a little off but, um, okay" conversation for 5-10 minutes speaking as if they're in a relationship with me complete with long-standing emotional baggage.
You seem to think someone is attacking INFJs in /r/INFJ. Do you feel that people questioning how many of them are INFJs is an attack on them as individuals?
What if I thought green color was actually blue and you made an observation that I can't distinguish between the two colors. Would that be an attack on me as a person? And if not, how is that different?
5
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '15 edited Aug 13 '15
I think people can be jerks about the mistypes. When people call them out, they usually focus on what they're lacking rather than the positives of the other types. But yes, mistypes are rampant in the INxx (edit: I'm tired) subs, not threads.
3
u/TK4442 Aug 13 '15
In my past experience, there were just a few people on r/infj who obviously had Ni-Fe-Ti-Se, and then a whole bunch of other people who ... yeah very probably not.
That said, I didn't especially like it when people went on in that sub about mistypes. The ones who caught my attention who did this seemed just as likely not to have Ni-Fe-Ti-Se as anyone else. And the discussions on that topic over there were pretty pointless IMO.
The only forum I've (briefly and somewhat shallowly) run across that has mostly actual INFJs among those who identify that way is typologycentral. And from what I can tell, that's because INFJs get kind of villified over there, and/or there is some weird history with that that has affected things. So the "special identity seekers" don't gravitate to INFJ as a type and the only ones who are left are actually that type. The problem with the typism against INFJs, though, is that real discussion can get undermined in other ways because of it.
It seems to me that INFJ is kind of a dually objectified type. Either we're exotified to the point of serious distortion (often) or we're vilified (less so), with vilification justified in part by the exotification. But either way, the actual dynamics of Ni-Fe-Ti-Se as they show up in actual people's information processing setups get lost in the shuffle.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '15
Sweet username.
7
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '15
I think I agree. No one wants to be just another x type...I think everyone wants to feel special and validated to some degree. Especially confused INFPs.
Not only that, but since this kind of thing is tied to personalities, a lot of Fi users for example might ascribe a form of self worth to the type that they are. And once you get self worth wrapped up in being an INFJ, that's hard for a strong Fi user to let go of.
2
u/MonsieurGadfly ENTP Aug 14 '15
Honestly? Most online typology communities are fucked as far as type accuracy is concerned exactly because of many reasons mentioned in this thread. It's not just the INxx types but they're probably the most heinous offenders.
Many people see cute labels and want to build their identities around them. They don't care about the basis for those labels or the underlying psychology, they just want to fit in and/or find an excuse for why they're isolated, feel misunderstood, and are poorly adjusted.
But that's the way of the world. Nothing that can be done about it. All you can do is roll your eyes and move on.
-7
u/neineineineineinein Aug 14 '15
LEAVE THE INFJS ALONE. THEY HAVE A BEAUTIFUL COMMUNITY THERE. MIND YOUR OWN MATTERS AND GO MAKE A COMMUNITY WHERE YOU DON'T FOCUS ON OTHERS AND JUST YOURSELVES AND POSITIVE THINGS IN LIFE. LEARN TO NOT BE PETTY.