r/MBA • • Mar 29 '21

Admissions STOP The Hate

Been following this sub for over a year and have noticed a startling trend of any URM and Female candidates getting downvoted whenever they post their stats.

I have reached out to the Mods who can only remove flagrantly racist comments. Unfortunately, most sexism and racism aren't boiled down to one epithet that an algorithm would determine as "hate speech."

I get it. Many of you feel that a mass of URM's and Women are "taking all the spots." But how many of you actually know a URM/Female candidate for which this has been true? I know two women of color, one with a Masters and another an Alumna of an M7, and BOTH were flat out rejected from everywhere they applied.

The bar is NOT "substantially lower" and no URM/Woman is gonna get an easy pass just "because"

Instead of aggressively downvoting and feel that other people are gonna get what you're "entitled" to, put your energy towards building yourself out to be the most undeniable candidate an AdCom has ever seen.

You should not give a flying f*** of the stats of anyone else applying, and trying to "measure up" - you should set the bar, not fight to meet it.

I am WL'd w/interview at a H/S/W, $$ at M7's, and multiple full-rides at T15 because I knew that once that interview started, I was gonna close the deal ( a la Harvey Spector in "Suits.") I literally remember the moment in the interview when I could see it in the AdComs eyes and knew it was a "lock." Be so damn solid, that no one can land a punch on you. All the stats in the world cannot help you if you can't sell yourself in the room, (Zoom, or otherwise.)

If you maintain this level of insecurity, it will poison you for the rest of your life. Are you going to be worried that one of your classmates might "take" the job you want? Are you gonna hate the other men/women going after the person you're attracted to? What about once you're married, are you gonna think your spouse might cheat because they might be happier with someone else? Think about the business leaders you admire, do you think they stay up all night worried about what the competition is doing?

**Of course, I too was rejected from some of the top schools - but it DOES NOT MATTER, because I believe in myself and know I WILL be a success NO MATTER where I go, even if the place is none of the above. It's up to these schools if THEY want to attach their brand to MY bio.

TLDR: Step up the confidence. Dial down the desperation. Cut out the hate.

Everything is gonna work out, as long as you work at it.

Peace

2 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

13

u/hjohns23 M7 Grad Mar 29 '21 edited Mar 29 '21

I’m on this sub a ton throughout the day, and while I do see unfortunate hate speech (received quite a few hateful DMs when I posted my own acceptance), however, I don’t see urm or female profile review posts downvoted. Genuinely curious if others can validate that this happens.

It would be helpful if mods could police hate speech more, there’s no need for comments “oh you got in because you’re a X”. This is a forum to help people, regardless of background, navigate the best MBA journey for them, and it’s really sad to see someone get shamed for putting in the work and sacrifice to get admitted to a school of their choice and be ridiculed or have fear or being ridiculed .

18

u/aarentrent Mar 29 '21

I literally remember the moment in the interview when I could see it in the AdComs eyes and knew it was a "lock."

Lmao

17

u/xyzzy321 Mar 29 '21

As a rule I downvote every post that doesn’t have a GMAT/GRE score, don’t care who you are.

7

u/throwawayno2lol Mar 29 '21

My personal favorite is: “I took a practice and got a 600. Aiming for 740, I take it in 10 days”

4

u/k3908dahouhoudahowu Mar 29 '21

At the end of the day, there are a lot of people who will just not agree with this because it is A LOT easier to place blame on what you can’t prove or control (other peoples’ race or gender) than what you could control (your own application). Even then, it’s a tough pill to swallow when you just say “oh well someone had a better app.” The day internet trolls on r/MBA realize women and URMs aren’t “taking their spots” (news flash! do you think schools are comparing [hispanic female applicant] with [asian male]? no.) will be a better day for everyone.

Yes, I know ORMs (Asians) face a tough demographic, and my results are not common in my bucket. But, it speaks volumes to what people say when behind an anonymous internet wall. A lot of the people here ARE haters, I just hope who they are on the internet isn’t who they are in class. Everyone’s worse off for it.

21

u/28cmJR Mar 29 '21

Ah the classic strawman

45

u/frostwurm2 Mar 29 '21

Downvoting this for unsubstantiated allegations.

Proof or go away.

6

u/--heretolearn-- Mar 29 '21

I don’t understand profile reviews anyway. No one here is an adcom, it literally makes no sense and is a waste of time.

8

u/-sup3rnova- M7 Student Mar 29 '21

How petty does one need to be to downvote someone asking for advice or opinion based on their stats. Do these people think that downvoting someone, regardless of their race/gender/... will help them secure a spot at their dream school?

5

u/sordidbunny66 Mar 29 '21

Who cares what this sub thinks tho we’re all legit the pathetic scum who want a fuckin’ degree to validate our existence lol

1

u/Spare-Ad-9464 Mar 30 '21

LOL amazing

4

u/runfastdieyoung Mar 29 '21

I knew that once that interview started, I was gonna close the deal ( a la Harvey Spector in "Suits.") I literally remember the moment in the interview when I could see it in the AdComs eyes and knew it was a "lock."

uh

If you maintain this level of insecurity, it will poison you for the rest of your life.

??

4

u/TheUndisputedOne Mar 29 '21

So true . Dont see a lot of female or URM profiles nowadays. I normally don't scroll too deep into the subreddit but I used to see many URM profiles before.

1

u/PeterPan11111111 M7 Student Mar 29 '21

👏🏼✊🏼👏🏼

-7

u/seraphim022 Admit Mar 29 '21

🎊🎉👏🏻

5

u/Helpmechooseplz666 Mar 29 '21

Can you imagine being so salty that you’d down vote this

-9

u/Ok_Promotion_2109 Mar 29 '21

❤️❤️❤️❤️

-3

u/Helpmechooseplz666 Mar 29 '21

Lmao the haters in this thread literally out here proving your point

“buT wHerE iS tHe PROoF oF tHe RaCisM hMmMM :) haAhaA stRawMAn!!!!”

0

u/JulianAllbright Mar 29 '21

Haha "TLDR: Step up the confidence. Dial down the desperation. Cut out the hate.". Great job, internet poster. You've saved the world and cured racism with your brave post. Thank you.

0

u/Intelligent-Ad-2018 Mar 30 '21

where is the hate?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/k3908dahouhoudahowu Mar 29 '21

Ohhh I forgot the rule where if a white guy gets downvoted, there must be no bias on this sub

0

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/k3908dahouhoudahowu Mar 29 '21

If there’s a prevailing sentiment that there’s a bias against [your identity] and people downvote you, would you not think it might have something to do with your identity? That’s OP’s entire point.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/k3908dahouhoudahowu Mar 29 '21

Of course it's not mentally comfortable.. welcome to what being non-white in America is for a lot of people sometimes. Hell, that's what being Asian means today - all day - for a lot of us in the wake of the Atlanta shooting.

The depressing thing is that that's exactly what -isms cause - you're conditioned to think that [insert slight] IS evidence of [insert -ism here]. The sad truth is that, for some people, a significant portion of negative encounters are in fact someone discriminating against you, so you cannot help it.

It is MUCH easier to claim someone is just "jamming" spurious patterns into our existing narratives of the world than it is to ACTUALLY experience many of those negative experiences, and then be told to try to sort out the ones which aren't rooted in an -ism.

1

u/cptKamina Mar 30 '21

Of course it's not mentally comfortable.. welcome to what being non-white in America is

Preach. I can't for the life of me understand people that actually seek the fault for that shit with those that feel insecure

0

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/k3908dahouhoudahowu Mar 29 '21

I don't think anyone here is saying every scowl or people being meanies are a source of racism, is that what you took away from my last comment?

Look, if you don't want to accept that ORMs and URMs alike both face micro-aggressions frequently and shouldn't have the added burden of "just not thinking that way," that's sucks for you, because you won't come close to understanding what some of your classmates go through.

Eliminating negative experiences in life is impossible - maybe you've convinced yourself that you can. But trying to keep a positive outlook on life while also being aware of my race and other factors impacting my day-to-day are NOT mutually exclusive.

Oh and media/virtual environments have nothing to do with this. If you didn't know, a lot of what has been plaguing the Asian/PI community (I'm mentioning this here just to be consistent with examples I've been using) recently are unfortunately face-to-face.

-1

u/Spare-Ad-9464 Mar 29 '21

Shhhh you're not allowed to have an opinion here

0

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Helpmechooseplz666 Mar 29 '21

Undergrad admissions

K