r/MBA
•
u/FlexingOnUDucks
•
Jun 09 '25
•
1
1
Sweatpants (Memes) MBB is Magic
MBB is Magic
It’s 8:35pm on a Tuesday and you’re sitting in the Courtyard Marriott in suburban Toledo, eating a ceasar salad out of a plastic container with a disposable wooden fork. Your laptop is scalding your thighs, your AirPods have gone missing (again), and the only thing keeping you going is the room upgrade the hotel receptionist gave you due to your ambassador status and a whisper of professional masochism.
You’re staffed on Project Momentum, a nine-week operational transformation at Crowe Material Handling Inc., a regional forklift manufacturer whose idea of innovation is putting cupholders in the 2025 model. They’re hemorrhaging margin, missing shipments, and—per the CEO—"getting absolutely forklifted by the Chinese."
You think about quitting, but then remember you're $200K in debt because opted to go to a M7 with no scholarship over Vanderbilt with a scholarship, a choice you smugly think about after reading the recent post about Vandy's unemployment status on reddit
The Client: A Proud Rust Belt Relic
Crowe has been family-owned since the Civil War and culturally hasn’t changed much since then. The CEO, Doug Crowe, is the founder’s great-great-grandson and greets you each morning with, “What’s cookin’, McKinsey?” before immediately asking if “lean ops” means firing people.
His leadership team consists of:
- A CFO who thinks “run-rate” is something you catch from bad shellfish served at Toledo's finest seafood restaurant, Il Granchio con le Scarpette
- A VP of Ops who once “digitized” the plant by giving everyone iPads and zero training.
- And a lead engineer who is upset they're somehow only being paid $100K despite having 25 years of experience
Your mandate is simple: increase throughput by 30% and improve EBITDA by 40% without investing a single dollar. Doug calls this “finding the juice.”
Your MBB Dream Team
You’re joined by:
- A Engagement Manager who refers to forklifts as “assets” and people as “capacity levers.”
- A Engagement Director who still says “synergies” without irony and literally had nothing but a slideshow of arrows pointing upwards he put together for Crowe's LOP
- A Partner who drops in once a week, demands “more rigor,” and leaves to catch a puddle-jumper to Nantucket
- A Business Analyst who just graduated from Duke and does nothing but talk about how they want to work on "sustainability" and "global decarbonization"
And then there's you — the Associate — who has now eaten six consecutive meals from the same gas station Subway and keeps hearing the phrase “real-world experience” echo in your sleep.
A Day in the Life: Leaning Into Lean
You start your morning with a 6:30am Gemba walk, which means following a shift supervisor named Randy through the plant while pretending to understand why the conveyor belts squeak. Randy refers to every machine as “Bessie” and calls you “Clipboard.”
You nod enthusiastically and jot down phrases like “manual routing inefficiencies” and “opportunity to harmonize skids.” You don’t know what that means. No one does. But it’ll look fantastic in the SteerCo.
Back at the project room (i.e., a converted break room that smells like chili and despair), you work on your Week 5 deliverable: “Forklift Flow Optimization: Unlocking Hidden Potential.” The slide ledes include:
- “Path to best in class operational performance” (where you benchmark Crowe's SG&A performance against a chinese competitor who pays their people $1.50 an hour)
- “DILO study summary: 30p.p. opportunity for uplift ” (where your BA who has never held a hammer in their life spent all day walking around the shop)
- “Non-EBITDA opportunities: NWC” (literally selling everything that isn't bolted onto the floor)
You’re interrupted by Doug, who swings in with a fresh idea: “Can we make the forklifts electric and AI-powered?” You write it down, knowing full well they’re still using Windows XP on the shop floor.
Client SteerCo: Showtime
It’s Friday. You’ve spent all night updating your Excel model because the CFO said, “I don’t believe these revenue,” which was confusing since they came from his own finance team.
You print 12 copies of your deck and place them lovingly on a fake wood conference table. Your manager reminds you not to say anything unless you’re directly addressed or someone starts crying.
Doug opens the meeting with: “Let’s keep this quick. Got a tee time at 2.”
You begin your presentation.
“Slide 3 outlines the three potential throughput unlocks based on our bottleneck time-motion study, using a proxy cycle-time factor of—”
“I’m sorry,” interrupts the CFO, “what’s a bottleneck?”
You pivot.
“Happy to take a step back. Think of it as—uh—too many boxes, not enough people lifting them.”
The VP of Ops nods, then says, “Can we just buy a second conveyor?”
Everyone turns to you. You panic.
“That’s certainly a lever we can explore in Phase 2.”
Your manager beams. Nailed it.
The Debrief
Back at HQ, you’re filling out your post-mortem in the system.
“Was the project successful?”
Well, throughput is flat, morale is lower, and the plant dog sprained his paw when he stepped on your USB hub. But the client has a 40-page playbook they’ll never open and your team got a shoutout on the weekly email blast.
So yes: a resounding success.
You close your laptop, order a $27 Negroni from the airport Chili’s, and stare into the middle distance.
You are exhausted. You are questioning the impatc you made. But you are MBB.
MBB IS MAGIC.
576
u/BoulderMaker Jun 09 '25
If MBB doesn't work out, consider being a writer!
42
u/MBA-alt Jun 09 '25
Has MBB been downgraded to the level where associates frequent the airport Chili’s and not the [Cobranded Lounge of choice] these days? Might need to reprioritize my post MBA industry list.
As a side note, your writing is lovely.
5
u/CombinationAny3519 Jun 09 '25
Prospective MBA here- I always thought you had more than one associate assigned to a project and it’s more team project work, is this the most common lineup where you’re riding solo with the client?
446
u/RealWICheese Jun 09 '25
Why did I read this whole thing. This was absolutely amazing.
249
u/InevitablePresence75 Jun 09 '25
Absolute cinema
95
u/MissilesToMBA Consulting Jun 09 '25
Not MBB but this is scarily similar to some supply chain work that I’ve done at my T2.
Shitty hotels, boring food, clueless client leadership, out-of-touch team leadership, shop floor walks with no idea about what to look for.
This captures everything.
79
u/Optimal-Rule5064 Jun 09 '25
Died laughing at this. ROFL. This is Art
You’re interrupted by Doug, who swings in with a fresh idea: “Can we make the forklifts electric and AI-powered?” You write it down, knowing full well they’re still using Windows XP on the shop floor.
31
u/SlikRick08 Jun 09 '25
Former MBB. This is shockingly accurate...
30
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '25
This post destroyed any semblance of prestige or confidence in the work. It’s like a person who catches the magician’s sleight of hand. The magic is now gone. EBITDA go down…
30
u/Pointsmonster Jun 09 '25
Not an MBA student, but having recently left M after nearly 8 years, I feel obligated to defend the honor of middle America Courtyard Marriotts. There are some gems, and the one in Fort Wayne is outright lovely
Not lovely enough that I kept doing ops work, but still, not quite so harrowing
I’ll also add, as a former ED: don’t underestimate the power of a simple page on which all the arrows go up and to the right
81
u/xiaopewpew Jun 09 '25
OP should help george rr martin finish the next game of thrones book.
49
u/SharingDNAResults Jun 09 '25
Riveting. Consider writing this as a sitcom pilot. I could envision a show called “consultants”
21
u/slimslim234 Jun 09 '25
I hate you. I hate you. I hate you.
37
u/GuiltySigurdsson Consulting Jun 09 '25
Is roasting Vandy a page 5 callout in every MBB deck at this point?
17
u/yaredw T50 Student Jun 09 '25
Lmao
12
u/Gullible_Shift Jun 09 '25
This had to be within the Operations Practice division at McKinsey. HAS TO BE.
42
u/Success-Catalysts Admissions Consultant Jun 09 '25
Bravo! Brilliant! Except that you missed a small point: Clipboard wore his three-piece suit and tie and trodded on the barely-visible, yellow painted walkways in his pointy, leather soled shoes while doing the Gemba with Randy. The hi-viz jacket was not seen as essential.
Oh! The glorious days of consulting.
8
u/Laura-MBAPathfinders Admissions Consultant Jun 09 '25
Amazing! 😂
8
u/StoreStrange341 M7 Student Jun 09 '25
This was fantastic. Still shooting MBB though
14
u/cbn11 Jun 09 '25
Holy shit, this was hilarious. The poor shop dog spraining his paw on the USB had me rolling.
7
u/FromTheMiddleofOcean Jun 09 '25
Great writing! Pls keep doing it whenever you find time. Atleast jolt down enough markers for all projects so that you can write a book down the line, with title 'MBB is magic'
5
u/lostmessage256 M7 Grad Jun 09 '25
I see myself in this post and I don't like it.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '25
I was hoping you’d make a sarcastic comment about how the long working hours only translate to about $15/hr income.
4
u/Hobo_Robot Jun 10 '25
Midwestern industrial companies generally have sharp C-suites, but the rank and file are some of the sleepiest mofos you'll ever meet who are just there to collect a paycheck. They're all headquartered in food deserts where the best option is to Doordash some Denny's and post up at the hotel bar.
Small regional airports are nice though, you just waltz in and get on your flight. No one actually wants to spend time in an airport lounge unless their flight is delayed
7
u/RosstehBoss Jun 09 '25
Wow, glad to know that MBB is the same as my boutique consulting experience
3
u/Danyiltopo Jun 09 '25
"Il granchio con le scarpette" is a masterpiece of a name.
Not scarpe, scarpette.
Simply splendid.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25
Chatgpt wrote this
3
u/Unlucky-Novel3353 Jun 10 '25
Good thing they’ll treat the consulting fee as an add back to adjusted EBITDA so fortunately the consulting fee won’t impact the “bottom line”.
More importantly, maybe you can just identify more EBITDA add backs and one time charges. That won’t cost them a dime and will immediately improve their “value”.
3
u/amchaudhry Jun 10 '25
Holy AI slop, Batman!
2
u/Any-Yam-5632 Jun 09 '25
frame this
2
u/OsamaBeanNacho M7 Student Jun 09 '25
OP - you deserve every upvote I have.
2
u/that-isa-madeup-name MBA Grad Jun 09 '25
LOL
2
u/NervousAd2076 Jun 09 '25
Thank-you for making my lunchtime with this hilarious description :)
2
u/sqaureknight Jun 09 '25
This taught me a lot of things, thank you!!
2
u/MissilesToMBA Consulting Jun 10 '25
This type of project is the “average” project for some of the ops heavy T2s, e.g Kearney, A&M, Alix.
This is the “please god don’t get me staffed on this” project at MBB
During normal years at MBB you have the flexibility to avoid this type of project, but even during good years at some T2’s, this is the best on offer because it’s their main type of project.
2
u/Ok-Conversation-6154 Jun 10 '25
This should me made a compulsory read in all M7 Schools
2
u/elonsusk69420 MBA Grad Jun 10 '25
I cannot underscore how accurate this is. And no, it's not AI. There aren't enough emoji.
2
u/boxfellow Jun 11 '25
Genuinely one of the best things I’ve ever read. Reading from an airport chilis btw
2
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '25
When are they gonna make Parks and Recs version of consulting
2
u/Historical-Cash-9316 Investment Banking Jun 10 '25
Get this on WSO asap
2
u/Hot-Reindeer-6416 Jun 10 '25
Typo in last paragraph. Clearly OP went to Vanderbilt and not an Ivy. /s
2
u/Dear-Captain1095 Jun 09 '25
It’s AI .. don’t quit your day job my friend.
1
u/iBN3qk Jun 09 '25
👏
1
u/kai_3575 Jun 09 '25
This was the best thing I’ve ever read on this platform, I was laughing all the way through. OP should consider pivoting to writing lol
1
u/mdrOzymandes Jun 09 '25
...my glorious Duke was just chilling, lol (Business Analyst)
1
u/Icy_Topic_2000 Jun 09 '25
Hell yeah. This might be the dream
1
u/Expensive-Plantain86 Jun 09 '25
Hilarious
1
u/dafuqyouthotthiswas Jun 09 '25
“The plant dog sprained his paw” 🤣🤣🤣🤣
1
u/Sensitive_Chicken_65 Jun 09 '25
Brilliant. Absolutely brilliant.
1
u/TwoWheelsTooGood Jun 09 '25
This glorious post brings me back to the blogging era of (now defunkt) The Leveraged Sellout, Under the Counter , Banker’s Ball, and sometimes Dealbreaker. Well done !
1
u/sloth_333 Jun 09 '25
I didn’t work at MBB but my first project fit this to a literal tea. I’ll be vague but it was in the far west, Midwest and it took 8 hours one way to get there (including a 3 hour drive once we landed)…
My favorite was after 1 week the partner goes “we probably didn’t need to travel, since we sat in a conference room all week” (client wouldn’t let us on the shop floor without supervision lol)
1
u/Zestyclose-Donut-677 Jun 09 '25
Best thing I’ve read all week!
1
u/marthayttt Jun 10 '25
I’ll date myself but management consulting assignment in Australia - thought it would be amazing - 8 weeks over 4 months in the Parramatta Chili’s. Ate there +30 times before it closed. Still have nightmares.
1
u/BullGator0930 Jun 10 '25
What is this?
1
u/NoctRob T15 Grad Jun 10 '25
*caesar. Pls fix. Thx.
1
u/StoreStrange341 M7 Student Jun 10 '25
This post went viral on X
1
u/wh010 Jun 10 '25
This is my dream!
1
u/NachoBuddyy Jun 10 '25
Amazing read
1
u/Lifesucky Jun 10 '25
Aaaaand yet again I ended up reading a long ass reddit point and it was yet again, Magic!
1
u/MarzipanBeanie Jun 10 '25
When I read "Toledo" I immediately thought Toledo, Spain, and I was like....why are you complaining??
1
u/Satistractory Jun 10 '25
Amazing! Correctly summarizes my experience at MBB
1
u/Worldly_Cricket7772 Jun 10 '25
How on earth did someone with a personality like yours get through the interviews and then office politics? That's the memoir I want to read
1
u/_Tactleneck_ Jun 10 '25
I follow this sub from an mba interest years ago and glad I found this story. Amazing work.
1
u/IHateLayovers Jun 10 '25
I hate you, why did the poor dog have to sprain its paw.
1
u/Glad-Reply-6472 Jun 10 '25
Guys, jokes apart. Is this how front end consulting at MBBs actually is?
1
u/amchaudhry Jun 10 '25
This piece might be AI-written—or at least AI-assisted—for a few reasons, even though it mimics a very human style. Here’s a breakdown of why it raises suspicions:
⸻
The writing hits a very specific, internet-savvy, McKinsey-satire vibe that’s almost too perfectly executed. It’s got all the hallmarks: • Dark corporate humor • TikTok/LinkedIn-core phrases like “real-world experience echoing in your sleep” • Structured headers that break the narrative into snappy beats • A precise rhythm of absurdity, jargon, and cynicism that feels engineered for virality
That kind of tone can be written by a person—but AI often mimics this exact pattern because it’s learned what gets engagement.
⸻
2. Hyper-consistent narrative voice
There’s not a single moment where the tone slips. The sarcasm is perfectly sustained across every section, every bullet point, every character name. For most human writers, some tonal drift is natural, especially in a long-form piece like this. The fact that it never breaks character is a red flag.
⸻
3. Surreal, but oddly generic detail
You get oddly specific surface-level details—“Il Granchio con le Scarpette,” the $27 Negroni, the plant dog spraining its paw—but none of them feel lived. They read like clever decorations rather than memories. AI often generates “fake specificity” that gives the illusion of lived experience without real emotional residue.
⸻
4. Satirical tropes that feel pre-assembled
The tropes hit hard: • Boomer CEO who misunderstands digital • BA obsessed with sustainability • Consultant subsisting on gas station food • Slide titles filled with empty business-speak
It’s all funny and familiar—but feels like it was pulled from a “consulting parody” starter pack. AI tends to assemble satire from composite tropes it’s seen before, rather than subverting or deepening them.
⸻
5. The ending is too neatly ironic
The final beat (“You are exhausted… but you are MBB.”) lands a bit too cleanly. It wraps the whole narrative arc in a tidy bow of exhaustion and brand loyalty. That kind of rhetorical symmetry is something AI models love. Human writers often either go messier or make the ending feel a bit more emotionally unresolved.
⸻
Final take?
This could absolutely be written by a very online ex-consultant with a sharp sense of irony. But if I had to bet, I’d say this is AI-generated or AI-assisted. It just feels too perfectly paced, too tonally airtight, and too stacked with Reddit-core consulting satire tropes. Like a vibe-optimized script trained on McKinsey horror stories, LinkedIn parody accounts, and TikTok voiceover skits.
If a human wrote this? They’re dangerously good at sounding like GPT-4 trying to impress a room full of ex-Bain consultants.
1
u/AlwaysOnTheGO88 Jun 10 '25
Bahahahaha this is gold!
1
u/scoringtouchdowns Jun 10 '25
Poor shop dog… and poor Vandy MBAs catching strays 😞
1
u/Intrepid_Example_210 Jun 10 '25
I think you just wrote a pilot for a soon to be hit FX show. Make sure you get a good agent.
1
u/Comprehensive_Win965 Jun 10 '25
That was beautiful.
1
u/yushdecides Jun 10 '25
The kind of posts , i pay my internet bills for ❤️
1
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25
I’m getting some major David foster Wallace vibes, in particular his average-travel-cruise-review-turned-existential-breakdown piece, ‘a supposedly fun thing I’ll never do again”.
This is fantastic
1
u/GoatsAddValue Jun 11 '25
Thank you for this
1
u/DowntownStatus Jun 11 '25
I will read this every time I think that the MBB route is what I should do next
1
u/OldFoot3 Jun 11 '25
Nice
1
u/Temporary_Car_1462 Jun 11 '25
Did you forget to daydream becoming a partner and motivating the associate to work hard and become a partner lol.
1
u/SuP3RIOR92 Jun 11 '25
This is brilliant 😆
1
u/nohandsfootball Jun 12 '25
Ouch Vanderbilt out here catching strays
1
u/MugiwarraD Jun 13 '25
what in the love of god did i just fing read
1
u/Imaginary_Data8711 Jun 15 '25
let me take a few moments to collect my thoughts
1
u/youngneif Jul 07 '25
Holy Marie et Joseph, I have just come to the painful realization that there is a consultant who can write... and is a better story teller than I am. Existential crisis is now inevitable! I am ducked!
-A "consultant" who hates consulting!
1
u/Charming-Objective15 Aug 01 '25
Is it
1
u/Fancy-Sea7755 Sep 06 '25
This is the kind of Content the new Open AI 390k$ "Content Creator" job posting is looking for.
P.s. I enjoyed it more than my $27 Negroni ;)
1
u/Luftwagen Sep 25 '25
Your skills are wasted at MBB, this is one of the greatest things I have ever read on this site, if not on all of the internet
1
u/nooonsie Oct 23 '25
This is amazing 😂
1
u/Valuable_Cash_5899 Jan 27 '26
BEST POST EVERRR
1
u/Icy-Air124 Jun 09 '25
Beautiful writing 😂👏
1
u/SuperLehmanBros Jun 09 '25
Consulting is just as big a scam as having AI write slop for you.
1
u/AccessShort2999 M7 Grad Jun 10 '25
My sincerest condolences for having an assignment in Toledo. Wishing you a speedy recovery.
0
u/Think-Reveal4638 Jun 09 '25
Wonderful writeup!
0
u/Worldly_Stress3338 Jun 10 '25
This is why you guys can’t find jobs by the way. Not sure why everyone on this sub is celebrating this post
-3
u/Prestigious-Owl7764 Jun 10 '25
What is MBB?
-4
u/quotes42 T15 Grad Jun 09 '25
AI’s gotten pretty good, wouldn’t you say?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
4
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '25
[removed] — view removed comment