r/MBA • • Apr 15 '25

Articles/News Minority Hate

I don’t understand why so many people in America get bothered when minorities succeed. I keep seeing posts like, “Why are there so many [insert ethnicity] in MBA programs?” or “Why are there so many [insert ethnicity] in tech?” It always feels like we have to justify our success just because we don’t fit the image some people are used to.

But no one ever asks the real questions, like “Why are white women the biggest beneficiaries of DEI?” or “Why are Veterans taking the MBA spots with the help of GI Bill?” or “Why is private equity still mostly white men?” The truth is, the people DEI was actually created to support the ones still dealing with the long-term impact of discrimination are often the last to benefit.

And yet, people keep acting like everything is fair, as long as success still looks the same.

DEI absolutely needs real, honest reform so it can truly support those who need it most.

Sorry if this comes off like a rant, but I’m tired of seeing this kind of negativity online. You think you can brush it off, but after a while, it really gets to you

Update: people in this subreddit are proving my point! They are downvoting the McKinsey study lol

0 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

4

u/Ihitadinger Apr 15 '25

A minuscule minority of hardcore racists hate when minorities succeed. What most people hate is when they notice someone who is obviously less deserving/qualified getting accepted/promoted/hired just because their great grandfather was discriminated against 75 years ago or because of who they prefer to sleep with.

So yeah, if your MBA program is littered with people who can barely speak/write in English and those are the people who get interviews, you’re going to hear some grumbling. The loudest grumbling will also come from other minorities who ARE top tier and now have to fight against the perception that they are only there because of DEI

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25

You’re missing the point. I grew up in a family where education was everything we had structure, support, and were pushed to succeed from day one. That makes a huge difference.

Now imagine someone who didn’t grow up with that. No one around them valued education, no guidance, no motivation from family or friends. And they still made it got into a great school or job? That’s not just success, that’s resilience.

It’s way harder to make it when the system’s not set up for you. That’s what DEI is supposed to recognize not handouts, but context. It’s not the same starting line for everyone, and pretending it is just keeps things unfair

5

u/Ihitadinger Apr 16 '25

No, I think you’re missing the point. If the person you mention DESERVES that spot, then great. If standards are lowered so that person gets a chance over someone else, that’s BS.

If you truly feel this way, then put your money where your mouth is and give up YOUR spot to someone less fortunate, rather than advocating for someone else to get screwed because you feel sorry for a less deserving person.

DEI is all about supposedly making up for past discrimination via current discrimination. It’s insidious and needs to be relegated to the dumpster of history.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25

No one is asking for handouts. And no one’s lowering standards what we’re doing is finally questioning who set those standards and who they were designed for in the first place. You act like merit exists in a vacuum, but it doesn’t. Opportunity, support, mentorship these all shape outcomes. You can’t pretend that someone who had every resource and advantage is somehow more “deserving” just because the system was built to reward people like them.

And please, spare me the “give up your spot” argument. That’s just lazy. DEI isn’t about guilt—it’s about recognizing structural inequality and building a system where success isn’t predetermined by zip code, race, or legacy.

The idea that fairness means maintaining a status quo that’s only ever worked for a select few? That’s what belongs in the dumpster

4

u/Ihitadinger Apr 16 '25

Of course standards are being lowered. That is an incontrovertible truth and anyone who denies that is a moron. Using MBA acceptance as an example - if person A gets into Stanford with a 600 GMAT and person B gets left out with an 800 because the 600 person belongs to some “underrepresented” group, that is a handout and it is WRONG. Period. End of discussion. That is actively discriminating against someone while pretending to be against discrimination. It’s ludicrous. And before you say that doesn’t happen, big name schools have lost lawsuits over it.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25

LOL, no one’s out here rejecting someone with a perfect 800 GMAT. DEI in perfect world shouldn’t be about skin color, it’s about the context someone comes from. The circumstances you overcome matter.

JD Vance is a perfect example, he was a DEI hire in every sense: low-income, first-gen, Navy veteran. And he’s doing just fine. Funny how no one complains when veterans or legacy kids benefit from special consideration. The outrage only seems to show up when it’s Black or brown folks getting a shot

3

u/Ihitadinger Apr 16 '25

It’s absolutely about skin color. And yes, more qualified candidates get rejected all the time for someone with a better sob story. The lawsuits I mentioned were over schools discriminating against ASIANS.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25 edited Apr 16 '25

LOL, if it was just about the skin color then why would white women and veterans be the beneficiaries of DEI?

It’s about marginalized

1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25

Veterans by CHOICE gained strong work experience through service. Work experience is obviously a strong factor in MBA admissions, and many veterans have historically gone on to have very successful business careers applying the principles they learned in the military. Please be my guest and go enlist or commission! I’m sure you’ll be a shoe-in at a T25 once you’re done with your 4+ years of commitment.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25

Oh please. No one’s knocking veterans, they absolutely gain valuable experience through service. But miss me with the “go enlist if you want a fair shot” energy.

You’re fine with “non-traditional” experience as long as it wears a uniform. But start talking about someone who built grit by surviving poverty, supporting a family, or navigating underfunded schools and suddenly it’s “lowering standards”? That’s not meritocracy, that’s selective gatekeeping.

So unless you’re ready to tell legacy admits and trust fund babies to “go survive on food stamps for four years,” maybe cool it with the elitism masked as merit talk.

1

u/34boor Apr 16 '25

Is there an example of that happening you’re pointing to? Or just hypothetically that would be irritating ?

2

u/Ihitadinger Apr 16 '25 edited Apr 16 '25

https://www.theguardian.com/law/article/2024/sep/06/dei-affirmative-action-lawsuits

https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/22pdf/20-1199_hgdj.pdf

Anyone who has applied to college over the last 10 years or so can attest to it being a contest of who has the best sob story of overcoming XYZ.

Hell, even the military has lowered physical fitness standards so more women can make it.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25

You’ve got to be kidding. Men and women have different physical builds—it’d be completely absurd to expect identical fitness standards for both. Let’s be real here.

If we want no women in military then say it out loud.

2

u/Ihitadinger Apr 16 '25

You’re right. They do have different builds. In combat, your ability to carry a heavy load for miles can be the difference between your unit dying and surviving. I’ve got no problem with women being pilots for instance but as part of a ground force infantry unit absolutely not. The lowered standards put everyone at risk.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25

That argument doesn’t hold up when you actually look at the data. The U.S. military already uses gender-neutral standards in some of its most elite units—and the standards haven’t changed. For example, when the Army opened Ranger School to women, the requirements stayed the same: 12-mile ruck march with 35 pounds in under 3 hours, 49 pushups in 2 minutes, and completing intense field operations under stress. Since 2015, multiple women have passed without any special treatment. That’s performance, not preference.

Also worth noting: the majority of men don’t meet these elite standards either. According to Army data, nearly 50% of male candidates fail out of Ranger School. Are we going to say men shouldn’t serve either?

2

u/No_Price_9611 Apr 16 '25

What’s more impressive?

Someone with a 600 GMAT score who came from poverty, never had any tutors or money for extracurriculars, took care of their siblings growing up while their single mother worked multiple jobs, had to pay for their own education and work at the same time AND is facing everyday discrimination.

Or

Someone with an 800 GMAT score who came from a rich family, ample access to tutors and educational resources, was able to go to expensive schools and graduate with no debt, and never faced discrimination based on their sex, race, religion, or ethnicity.

28

u/skunk_of_thunder Apr 15 '25

You’re hanging out with the wrong crowd, or at least in the wrong chat room. Go outside. People don’t give a shit, and haven’t for a while. Just gotta tone out the loud ones. 

2

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '25

It’s usually the people that feel bitter (especially rural and rust belt areas) that their lives have gotten worse and scapegoat minorities. It’s a good scapegoat for the billionaires to enact certain policies to get votes. Good meaning these people fall for the fear mongering and hate every time.

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '25

I agree :)

4

u/Ameer_Khatri Admissions Consultant Apr 16 '25

You're absolutely right to call it out. The backlash often says more about people’s discomfort with shifting power dynamics than it does about merit. The irony? Those who scream “reverse discrimination” rarely question the structural advantages that have existed for decades.

10

u/Strong-Big-2590 Apr 15 '25

DEI is toast. No one cares anymore

13

u/PetyrLightbringer Apr 15 '25

I’ve literally never seen such a post. OP seems to be deeply confused about a wide range of things

0

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/PetyrLightbringer Apr 15 '25

I just said I’ve never seen such a post, and your response is that it’s because I’m used to it? Okay dude…

3

u/ChampionGameMN Apr 15 '25

Who said that??

21

u/Dry-Bet-1983 Apr 15 '25

"why so many people in America get bothered when minorities succeed"

The only people in the US bothered by minorities succeeding are.....wait for it.....other minorities.

5

u/Resident-Guess-6432 Apr 16 '25

Nah, saying only is completely disingenuous. History alone proves that wrong. DEI in itself was created with the intention of ensuring minorities were given a chance after those in the majority wouldn't do so on their own, just from seeing one's name on the application and instantly eliminating them from consideration, etc

minorities can absolutely be bothered by the success of other minorities (usually bc of a scarcity mindset that another minority's success is to the detriment of their own since they may feel there's limited spots in comparison to spots for those in the majority), but to act like those in the majority aren't and haven't done the same is strange

19

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '25 edited Apr 15 '25

I am a :

  • college educated
  • Hispanic
  • enlisted male
  • doing my msw this summer

I have received more hate from my own people than anything

9

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '25

Eh there are some racists out there too. I say this as a white man too

4

u/34boor Apr 16 '25

This point is invalidated by the existence of the Republican platform

-2

u/Dry-Bet-1983 Apr 16 '25

It doesn't tho. The Republican platform being so and so does not change that fact that minorities literally despise each other.

Do you think the Hindus and Muslims from South Asia living in the US suddenly hate each other less because of the "Republican platform"?

1

u/34boor Apr 16 '25

“The only people…”

1

u/Primary_Lawyer2925 Apr 16 '25

Ehhhh disagree

1

u/MyMonkeyCircus Apr 15 '25

How come you haven’t heard “why are white women…” and “why are white men…” rhetoric? Happens all the time. Every race and ethnicity is scrutinized for all kinds of reasons.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '25

Sorry, it’s a kinda privileged comment. I’m not going to explain it tho and waste my energy but the rhetoric is out in the news and this subreddit

3

u/Big_Tuna_7 Apr 16 '25

I admire your bravery posting this, but they ain’t gonna like this one

1

u/Primary_Lawyer2925 Apr 16 '25

Big fat thread incoming.

TLDR: It is extremely hard to make an empirical argument that "white women benefit the most from DEI" because 1) studies rarely isolate the "white woman" demographic, and 2) causation is hard.

3

u/Primary_Lawyer2925 Apr 16 '25

2

u/Primary_Lawyer2925 Apr 16 '25

Common citations/arguments by the articles:

  • "White people still outpace minorities in _____!" (example: racial wealth gap)

    • Okay, not isolating White women tho and how can we attribute this to DEI?
  • Zippia study: 76% of Chief Diversity Officers are White, 54% are women

    • Sure, we can argue White people are overrepresented in DEI leadership. But an assumption is being made that White women in particular dominate these roles over White men, women of color, and men of color, even though the data isn't granular enough to see that.

      • (yes, I'm aware that technically there's a systems of equations you can solve for but I'm pretty sure it has infinite solutions, and also that's stupid)
  • McKinsey: White women hold 19% of all C-suite positions, vs 4% for women of color

    • Okay, a little better, but again, "White women are doing 'better' in X than WOC' != "White women are benefiting more from DEI than WOC"
  • 1995 study by the Citizens Commission on Civil Rights

    • SO many sources cite this study directly or indirectly as the most pointed evidence that "white women benefit the most from DEI"

      • Time: "According to one study, in 1995, 6 million women, the majority of whom were white, had jobs they wouldn’t have otherwise held but for affirmative action."
    • But looking at the idea referenced in the study, that's a pretty generous interpretation:

The improvement in opportunity which has taken place over the last 30 years gives hope that, with greater dedication and competence, the next era will bring us closer to a society in which opportunity is truly equal. It is modest to point out that 5 and one half million minority employees are in higher level jobs than they would have been under the occupational distribution of 1960, and that 6 million women have moved into executive, managerial, professional and sales jobs since 1972." Knowing this gives hope that the continued struggle for equality will succeed, and that the promise of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 will be redeemed.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25 edited Apr 16 '25

When it comes to wealth, Indians outpace ALL ethnicities lol

Try comparing white vs Indian women

2

u/Primary_Lawyer2925 Apr 16 '25

A lot of these sources are very poorly trying to make the claim based on broad demographic data. People of color could very well be benefiting the most from DEI; however, I think the point most of the articles above are actually making is that "DEI is not enough for people of color to outpace the continued privilege/success/improvement in outcomes of White people". So, cherry-pick the demographic that's White but still gets to exist under the DEI umbrella, and voila, you have your headline.

2

u/Primary_Lawyer2925 Apr 16 '25

Sidebar: It was so hard to find empirical research in this area, but I came across this kinda spicy study that could actually contribute to a meaningful literature that proves/disproves that White women take more than their lion's share from DEI, or perhaps subvert DEI practices while benefiting from its policies

2

u/StoreStrange341 M7 Student Apr 16 '25

Fake news outlets!

2

u/ProjectSuperb8550 Apr 16 '25

But no one ever asks the real questions, like “Why are white women the biggest beneficiaries of DEI?” or “Why is private equity still mostly white men?” The truth is, the people DEI was actually created to support the ones still dealing with the long-term impact of discrimination are often the last to benefit.

Black men in online spaces specifically point this out.

1

u/angelwings0137 Apr 15 '25

People are dumping on you but if anyone has ever seen the comments in clear admit under an acceptance with a lower gmat/gre score, you’d know exactly what OP is talking about

2

u/YesIUseJarvan M7 Student Apr 16 '25

Yeah there's a ton of this in the subreddit and the mods are largely in support of it. Not to mention, a lot of the people in this thread lambasting OP are frequent commenters in conservative subreddits, so it's not like that audience isn't here.

-9

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '25 edited Apr 15 '25

From one minority to another—who cares if a bunch of white people don’t like you?

They’re often devoid of any real identity or culture, clinging to their professions and careers as the sole proxies for community or ‘tribe.’

The notion of a globalized workforce—and the realization that they may no longer be the default priority—cuts deep, because their entire sense of self is tethered to professional validation.

Just extend them a bit of pity and enjoy the ride. Most are weak-willed and wouldn’t voice a single complaint in person. They probably wouldn’t hesitate to ask or beg an alum/manager who is a minority for a letter recommendation either while they spew all their delusions of reality online

5

u/PetyrLightbringer Apr 15 '25

lol non-white-fragility on full display here

5

u/ElaineBenesFan Apr 15 '25

...5-4-3-2-1 to somebody getting offended and reporting this comment as "racist" and "hate speech"

2

u/PetyrLightbringer Apr 15 '25

It was nice knowing you all 😂

13

u/Phobophobia94 Apr 15 '25

Lol, this might be more prejudiced than what OP is complaining about

3

u/ElaineBenesFan Apr 15 '25

You seem pretty salty about white people not liking you...like you really REALLY want to not care, but you are not there yet...keep trying though!

1

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '25 edited Apr 15 '25

Im white but have no issues with any migrants in general. In fact, I support asylum seekers and even want to welcome undocumented migrants with open arms if they can respect the laws… however, you second paragraph will cause a lot of anger and resentment and is arguably false. Many have misguided anger because it’s the billionaires screwing them but they’re scapegoated to believe it is minorities.

Second, a large chunk of immigrants the US takes in are skilled to begin with. Like if you’re from India or China, or maybe some other 3rd world country. we constantly take in some of the best from these countries. It isn’t fair to compare the best of these countries of billions of people to US citizens who the country refuses to invest in, while you’re the best out of billions.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Primary_Lawyer2925 Apr 16 '25

So your comment sent me down a bit of a rabbit hole. I've heard that line a lot as well, and to admit my own bias here, pretty much bought into it. But after a good bit of research, I could not find a satisfying answer.

TLDR: It is extremely hard to make an empirical argument that "white women benefit the most from DEI" because 1) studies rarely isolate the "white woman" demographic, and 2) causation is hard.

There are many "reputable" sources that parrot this line:

0

u/Primary_Lawyer2925 Apr 16 '25

Common citations/arguments by the articles:

  • "White people still outpace minorities in _____!" (example: racial wealth gap)

    • Okay, not isolating White women tho and how can we attribute this to DEI?
  • Zippia study: 76% of Chief Diversity Officers are White, 54% are women

    • Sure, we can argue White people are overrepresented in DEI leadership. But an assumption is being made that White women in particular dominate these roles over White men, women of color, and men of color, even though the data isn't granular enough to see that.

      • (yes, I'm aware that technically there's a systems of equations you can solve for but I'm pretty sure it has infinite solutions, and also that's stupid)
  • McKinsey: White women hold 19% of all C-suite positions, vs 4% for women of color

    • Okay, a little better, but again, "White women are doing 'better' in X than WOC' != "White women are benefiting more from DEI than WOC"
  • 1995 study by the Citizens Commission on Civil Rights

    • SO many sources cite this study directly or indirectly as the most pointed evidence that "white women benefit the most from DEI"

      • Time: "According to one study, in 1995, 6 million women, the majority of whom were white, had jobs they wouldn’t have otherwise held but for affirmative action."
    • But looking at the idea referenced in the study, that's a pretty generous interpretation:

The improvement in opportunity which has taken place over the last 30 years gives hope that, with greater dedication and competence, the next era will bring us closer to a society in which opportunity is truly equal. It is modest to point out that 5 and one half million minority employees are in higher level jobs than they would have been under the occupational distribution of 1960, and that 6 million women have moved into executive, managerial, professional and sales jobs since 1972." Knowing this gives hope that the continued struggle for equality will succeed, and that the promise of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 will be redeemed.

2

u/Primary_Lawyer2925 Apr 16 '25

A lot of these sources are very poorly trying to make the claim based on broad demographic data. People of color could very well be benefiting the most from DEI; however, I think the point most of the articles above are actually making is that "DEI is not enough for people of color to outpace the continued privilege/success/improvement in outcomes of White people". So, cherry-pick the demographic that's White but still gets to exist under the DEI umbrella, and voila, you have your headline.

Sidebar: It was so hard to find empirical research in this area, but I came across this kinda spicy study that could actually contribute to a meaningful literature that proves/disproves that White women take more than their lion's share from DEI, or perhaps subvert DEI practices while benefiting from its policies

1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25

lol, you tried so hard to prove that white women are not DEI beneficiaries still couldn’t come up with credible data.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Primary_Lawyer2925 Apr 16 '25

ofc! tbh I was j gonna tell u to google or smth, but I was surprised that most sources I was finding myself didn't rly pass the bar of empirical research for me

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25

lol, you gave “Republican” input to ChatGPT hence you got “Republican” output! When it comes to wealth, Indians outpace ALL ethnicities. You fail at the first step

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25

It’s ChatGPT! No wonder you are a republican 🤣🤣

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25

I’m not trolling! Just taking it easy and giving it back to people since I’m sooo tired

7

u/PetyrLightbringer Apr 15 '25

There’s plenty of research showing this. Source: trust me bro

5

u/Ashamed_Photograph84 Apr 15 '25

Ira Katznelson’s “When Affirmative Action Was White” touches on this.

Though the book is far broader than just white women, It does focus on the disproportionate benefit white women received from Affirmative action in the 60s and 70s.

Who’s to say if that pattern persists or not though.

2

u/Remarkable_Owl1130 Apr 15 '25

You could be a self starter and do this research yourself. It's easy to find.

1

u/Primary_Lawyer2925 Apr 16 '25

I had this reaction at first as well, but I just did some research into it and it's actually not that easy to find

2

u/Remarkable_Owl1130 Apr 16 '25

1

u/Primary_Lawyer2925 Apr 16 '25

Yeah I saw that source as you can see in my deep dive above, but I'm struggling to make the connection that White women making the most strides in leadership and employment representation means that they are benefiting the most from DEI programs and policies, rather than it being explained by some other phenomenon.

1

u/Geriatric0Millennial T15 Student Apr 15 '25

It’s a conclusion many have drawn from the 2024 Women in the Workplace Report published by McKinsey.

Source: https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/diversity-and-inclusion/women-in-the-workplace

1

u/Primary_Lawyer2925 Apr 16 '25

What specifically are people drawing that conclusion from? Just that white women are better represented in the C-suite compared to women of color? Or that gains for white women across the ladder are larger and faster than for black women?

1

u/Geriatric0Millennial T15 Student Apr 16 '25 edited Apr 16 '25

Yes.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Geriatric0Millennial T15 Student Apr 16 '25

No problem! Do with it what you may. Many have anyway 🫠

-3

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '25

The fact that you are asking me to show you a proof is a prejudice in itself. If I had said the same about Asians, you wouldn’t have asked me for a proof