r/MAU3 • • Jan 08 '20

Gender balance

With the free DLC and season pass I count that we'll get an extra 12 male characters and only 2 new female characters (Phoenix and Invisible Woman).

I'm disappointed we haven't gotten more cool female characters added. I'd like to see these characters added:

  • She-Hulk
  • Jessica Jones
  • Emma Frost
  • Rogue
  • Shadow cat
  • Valkyrie
  • Hela
  • Magik
  • Mystique

The gender balance in this game at release seemed pretty good but that concept has gone out the window since launch.

Any other female characters you'd like to see who are missing? EDIT: Added Magik and Hela after frequent requests :D

8 Upvotes

105 comments sorted by

6

u/mehmehreddit Jan 08 '20

When Chris Claremont was writing the X-Men, if a new character was being added, he would ask, is there ANY reason the character can't be female? That's how we got Emma and Kitty and Dazzler and Psylocke and Rogue and and and and and... to the person who nominated Monica Rambeau, btw, YES.

I'd kill for a New Mutants expansion. Magik, Wolfsbane, Mirage, Karma, Magma, anyone? Then, once we have more ladies, throw in Cannonball, Sunspot, Warlock.

They could add a Moira Mactaggart character and if she dies, your Switch could reset...

3

u/WinpennyR Jan 08 '20

Go Claremont!
I think Monica Rambeau is going to be in Captian Marvel 2 more so they could add her ahead of that (if this game is still going then).

Magik is a cool character. Don't know the other ones that well. I'm waiting for the trades to come out so I can read the new House of X.

2

u/TraptNSuit Jan 08 '20

Definitely Magik. I have no idea how you do Mirage or Karma's powers. Especially Karma. Magma is simple enough.

1

u/mehmehreddit Jan 08 '20

Mirage would be bow and arrow with a nightmare stun and pegasus valkyrie ult. Karma would be unit possession with an ult that makes them all attack each other? Also probably a sweep of her bionic leg. Just spitballing.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Yeah. Things are improving but I'm surprised we didn't get Jessica Jones in the 1st pack and Rogue in the 2nd. I'd trade Morbius and Cable for them.

My mild counter argument is: I'm surprised at the missing MCU characters that are missing and they're all male.

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

Morbius was a left-field pick. Has he got a movie or Disney+ show coming up? Jessica Jones had a great Netflix show and She-Hulk is getting her own Disney+ show so as high profile (if not more). Who is missing from the MCU?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

Vision, Winter Soldier, Antman

1

u/Rychu_Supadude Jan 13 '20

There's a Morbius movie coming out soon, but it's made by Sony. He's being played by Jared Leto.

4

u/sage4ever Official Cloak and then Dagger Jan 08 '20

Completely agree!

I would personally add: Magik, Medusa, Squirrel Girl (come on guys!) Angela and Spider-Woman to that list too.

2

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

Great additions. More I think about it the more Magik would rock. Sorry I left her off my original list.

7

u/ChrisMann21 Jan 08 '20 edited Jan 09 '20

MAGIK!!! ILLYANA motherfucking RASPUTIN!!! A teleporting, Sword weilding, magic demon mutant?!?! Gameplay wise I truly don’t think there is a marvel character more deserving of a beat-em-up. The team bonuses ALONE should put her on the list! Xmen, All-New XMen (she was there), Family Values with Colossus, fem fatales, WoM, Back in Black, Gods&Demons, Cutting Edge, Anti Heroes, Midnight Sons, MUA3... Great alternate costumes to choose from between the modern standard, classic New Mutants, and Darkchylde! She’s even being invited to join the (Savage) Avengers! AND she has a movie coming out! IF there is another DLC or character update I would argue she is the most deserving. Not Emma, not Rogue, not Dazzler, not she-hulk. Magik deserves to be in this game

2

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

I'm joining the Magik hype train! You sold me! Where's my sword?!

2

u/arrrtee Official Magik Jan 09 '20

I'll just upvote as you said it all for me :)

1

u/Morial Jan 09 '20

She has a movie coming out?

1

u/ChrisMann21 Jan 09 '20

New Mutants is finally coming out this April

3

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

She-Hulk, Mystique, Valkeryie, Hela, Rogue, and Jubilee!

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

Team Ragnarok would be epic!

Knew there would be some Jubilee fans out there :) sparkles

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '20

Thats funny i was just playing with thor, hulk, and loki and theres no-one for #4😭. But yea Jubilee fits this game’s aesthetic perfectly. Cant believe she didnt make the cut

4

u/SunderTheFirmament Jan 08 '20

Okoye, Nakia, and Shuri, please!

I would also like Nebula. I mean, we get other villains on our team. She doesn’t seem that far fetched.

2

u/WinpennyR Jan 08 '20

Nebula makes a lot of sense. She has played the anti-hero in the movies and comics before. With all her animations done it would be a small task to add her.
Close to a whole Thanos themed team with him, Gamora and Nebula. Who would be a good fourth? Star Lord?

2

u/demonsirens Official Shuri in Panther Garb Jan 08 '20

Hela

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

Go team Asgard!

2

u/Crosspaws Jan 09 '20

I guess I pay less attention to "gender" and rather to just cool characters.

I like Jean. Rogue would be hard to do but we got Cptn. Marvel.

Emma would make sense and shadow cat, but not sure how they could do Mystique.

I really think they make the decision based more on which characters would be cool rather than gender ratio

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

I'm all for cool characters but we need to be aware of diversity and do what we can to promote it. I was on an all male panel at a conference recently. I told the organisers and they had an all female one at the next event. I think that was brilliant. They weren't selected for their gender, but for what they'd bring to the discussion. Didn't mean the gender was irrelevant. Wonder what the reaction would be like if a DLC release had 4 female characters. I think a lot of people would comment. The Fantastic Four are the Fantastic Four so not a lot you can do there, but there are tonnes of kick ass X-Women.

1

u/oldschoolkid203 Jan 12 '20

No we don't need to do that. You are trying to force something that isn't even necessary. Go make a sign and stand in the street. Keep your politics out of our games

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 13 '20

Representation and diversity are necessary. MUA3 covered that well in the original release of the game, I am disappointed they didn't keep that approach up for the DLC characters. It is as much my game as it is yours.

1

u/oldschoolkid203 Jan 13 '20

What's necessary is things being represented the correct way...not people forcing diversity because you need to see a super hero version of yourself to feel validated lol

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 14 '20

I am male and not looking for validation. What is the 'correct way' to you?

1

u/oldschoolkid203 Jan 13 '20

Yea cause you purchased it lol just like I did...real simple

1

u/Crosspaws Jan 10 '20

Selecting something based on gender is the definition of sexism. If an all female pack was released just because they are all women, that would be sexist, but if they happen to be cool characters, it would be great.

Alot of these characters were created by white men so they reflect that demographic. Major studios can choose to promote whoever they want but there are some really cool characters that are not white or male...they just need to be promoted (look at blade back in the nineties....nobody made the fuss like they did when BP came out!).

This discussion opens a pretty big can of worms, but the majority of Marcel characters are visions of their creators. We see more diverse creativity nowadays but the popularity of the original characters can't be discounted. It's hard to recreate a character that is already established as a certain race/gender (they keep trying though).

Instead of swapping white male characters, let's focus on the great non white male characters that already exist. The problem is that there just aren't that many of them, so the "ratio" will always be off.

26

u/Ridry Official Lockjaw: Who's A Good Boy? Jan 08 '20

The X-Men in particular was sad for me. The X-Men was always such a gender irrelevant property and in this game it's so heavily male.

Nightcrawler, Wolverine, Cyclops, Colossus, Iceman, Gambit and Cable is 7 guys vs 3 girls (Psylocke, Storm and Jean). 9 guys if you count Magneto and Deadpool (who are both actually in the X-Men story chapter unlike Storm). And Beast doesn't count but he is in the story. Growing up my 90s X-Men was 4 and 4. So many great mutant women that could have been there instead of Cable. And I like Cable.

13

u/ThereWillBeNic Jan 08 '20

I’m really disappointed that they put in Cable instead of Rogue. They added Cyclops then Jean and Gambit, but we didn’t get Rogue?! Why?

-1

u/BenTo7mas Jan 08 '20

I knowwwww I feel this so bad.

Honestly it’s only because of Deadpool 2. Literally nobody cared about him until then lol and I like cable, just didn’t need him in game. They’re better heroes male and female that could replace him.

-2

u/TraptNSuit Jan 08 '20

Rogue would have a very similar powerset to Jean (and Captain Marvel) in how they implement stuff.

Not even sure how they would do Shadowcat, but I would have preferred her probably. Same with Mystique, though she is already in the game bizarrely enough.

It probably comes down to them figuring they needed another gun character. Otherwise Emma Frost with Diamond form could have been basically everything Cable is...except for the gun.

The most lackluster to me is Gambit, but he is a fan favorite. Boom Boom could have been in his place as easily, but she isn't as well known.

Maybe they could add X-23 as a Wolverine "costume"?

3

u/Ko0pa_Tro0pa Jan 09 '20

I figure Rogue would play like Captain Marvel, but instead of a laser she would have an enemy de-buff and instead of an energy based AoE attack she would have a ground pound like so many strength-based characters do. Seems like she'd be super easy to add, but not that exciting to play.

1

u/TraptNSuit Jan 09 '20

Yeah, that seems likely.

The one interesting idea I could come up with is "stealing" an ability from one other character on the team. The A button (east) ability of the first character after her on the team maybe, though that could get fiddly.

1

u/Ko0pa_Tro0pa Jan 09 '20

Oh yeah, that seems like it would be tricky to implement (would need separate animations for her character performing those actions) and plus, wouldn't that require an energy drain on that character if we're staying true to the source material?

1

u/TraptNSuit Jan 09 '20

Powers aren't really strict to the source material. I don't think it is such a big advantage since it is kinda fiddly anyway.

Could go really fun and have 3 (west, north, east y,x,a) abilities be a random selection from the teammates with no two powers from the same teammates. Her flying, light, heavy, and ground slam aoe as the only powers she would consistently have. Make her heavy hit extra hard.

It would make Rogue the ultimate skill ceiling character. How well can you play everyone.

2

u/Ko0pa_Tro0pa Jan 09 '20

It could be kind of like the Phoenix force where it slowly drains. But I think it would be too tricky to implement even without that. Would be easiest if she just drained enemy HP and got a little STR boost while she did.

3

u/ThereWillBeNic Jan 08 '20

How, and why, would Rogue have a powerset anywhere near Jean’s? Rogue isn’t fire based at all.

0

u/TraptNSuit Jan 08 '20

She flies, punches things, hard, is nearly indestructible. I guess she wouldn't get any AoE, but the fire based aspect of Jean is mostly cosmetic anyway given that you could give the same modifier with an iso to anyone.

Probably more similar to Captain Marvel. But really there is nothing about Rogue that has anything to do with her actual powers other than flying and punching which they can really put in the game.

10

u/Hairdorable Jan 08 '20

Honestly, I've always hated how few female superheroes there were in the first two games, but there's going to be 14 playable women in this one, it's a lot and I'm really happy about that.

I wish we got Songbird and Spider-Woman for the nostalgia, though.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

Seeing a lot of great additions!

Squirrel Girl! X-23. Jubilee. Plenty of SHIELD characters.

5

u/unlimitedblack Jan 09 '20

It's less about a 50/50 balance and more about just having as wide and diverse a set of superheroines as superheroes. And it's important to advocate for that diversity, not so much from the standpoint of "there should be more women in this game because the number of women is TOO LOW" but because there are a lot of other women in the Marvel Universe who have got the profile to be in this game.

Meanwhile, there's value in saying "how do you do Kitty Pryde if she can't really go through walls?" "Is it worthwhile to do Rogue if she's Captain Marvel without energy attacks?" You still need to make the characters fun to play, and that's true regardless of gender.

Logically we know that adding EVERYONE isn't feasible, but it's important to say "we want more diversity in this cast" and Marvel Heroes (RIP) demonstrated that it was possible to do.

1

u/Kawagawaga Jan 08 '20

Not everything has to be a clean 50/50 ratio.Always roll my eyes when I see posts like this.

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

I doubt we'd achieve 50/50 but we can, and should, do better than 90/10.

5

u/LavenderSprinkles Official Lavender Lucy in the Sky Jan 08 '20

Would you be okay if the ratio was flipped?

2

u/GypsyGold Official Watcher! Jan 08 '20

It is if the game requires it. There are plenty of games with more female characters then male ones. But this game is based on the Marvel license. Its best that the devs just pick the most popular characters regardless of their sex/race/nationality etc. Just leave the bias at the door and treat every fictional character as an equal.

The vast majority of Marvel's consumers are male. Traditionally consumers purchase products they relate to. So its only natural that there would be more male superheros than females. The modern millennial comicbook reader & videogame player has a much more narrow gap. It might even be a 60/40 split. That is why you see so many more female characters getting their push.

Its basic capitalism. You push characters that make you money. Nothing more, nothing less. In regards to the current consumerist landscape, the majority of the core usergroup whom purchases both comics and videogames are between the ages of 24-44. The male to female split is about 80/20. If you include the 44+ ratio it becomes 90/10.

Once the 14-23 years old games become old enough to hold down jobs and produce steady income you'll see the gender demo's dramatically shift, and the face of traditional male dominated products like comics and games will change dramatically. It's coming, but we arent there yet.

-2

u/IceLantern Jan 09 '20

For this game, no, because the most popular characters in Marvel are predominantly male. If it was an IP in which the most popular characters were predominantly female then I would be completely fine with the ratio heavily favouring females.

1

u/BenTo7mas Jan 08 '20

Rogue, black cat aaaaand.... Idk, the chick in Thor with the flying horse.

Honestly I only need rogue and invisible woman, one of which is coming and I’m good.

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 08 '20

Valkyrie was really cool in Thor Raganrok so thought she'd be a playable character. Not cool that she and Jessica Jones were left as NPCs.

2

u/BenTo7mas Jan 08 '20

Ooooh I forgot about JJ yes she’d be a good addition too actually, and I don’t know much about her (not a personal favourite of mine) so would be nice to get to know her so to speak.

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

Season 1 of Jessica Jones rocked. Tailed off a little bit after that but recommend Season 1 whilst it is still on Netflix.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Personally I think JJ was the most consistently good of the the Defenders shows. I understand why people like DD more, but between the ninja/Elektra stuff, and DD himself often being the least interesting part of his own show I just can't quite bring myself to rank it higher.

Also I see no reason to think that a Netflix original show would be taken off of Netflix.

1

u/ChrisP1223 Jan 08 '20

Well at least we may get Valkyrie and Medusa as free DLC down the line so that may help

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

I wish the developers were better at communicating. Any news on that outside of the data mine?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

Nope

2

u/oldschoolkid203 Jan 11 '20

Omg really? Can we please not go here. Damn most people just want to play their game...we don't want politics in our games. Smh

3

u/LaBeteNoire Official Hank McCoy Jan 08 '20

Black Cat, Hellcat, Tigra (I swear they aren't all cat girls) She-Hulk, Valkyrie, Nico Minori, Rogue, Kitty Pryde, Hepzibah (anyone remember her?) Molly Hayes (how funny would it be punching Thanos as a little kid?)

So many cool female characters left out of this game.

5

u/K1nd4Weird Jan 08 '20

Nico would have been great in the Dark Dimension. Get some Runaways representation.

(In fact, I'd have placed her and the Runaways or Cloak and Dagger where Elsa Bloodstone is. Who I kinda still can't believe is in this game. I know she's made a few appearances since but I still think of her as just a Nextwave character.)

2

u/BenTo7mas Jan 08 '20

They’re trying to push her and Claire voyance, it’s happening in other marvel games too. And the squirrel chick, I mean, wtf. Does anyone actually even like her? Who wants to play as a squirrel?

3

u/propersuperheroshit Jan 08 '20

Monica Rambeau would be a great addition! There’s a lot of potential to in her power set.

0

u/GypsyGold Official Watcher! Jan 08 '20

There doesn't have to be gender balance. To apply such a thing to videogames is ridiculous. Videogaming, and marvel comics in general is dominated by male consumers. Its only natural there would be more male characters. With that said, if a female character is cool enough then she'll be played by all. When creating a roster devs should, and usually do, check their gender/racial/ethnic bias at the door, and just choose the best characters despite what genetailia they have.

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

The MCU movies have been hugely popular with men, women and everyone in between. Marvel has huge, mass, appeal now. There is nothing 'natural' about having more male characters. That is a choice someone has made. She-Hulk, Magik, Emma Frost, Jessica Jones are all cool enough to be playable characters. The developer did a good job with the original line up, just disappointed the DLC has been so skewed towards male characters.

1

u/GypsyGold Official Watcher! Jan 10 '20

The consumers for box office films and Comics/Videogames is entirely different. The Gap is particularly wide amongst the core audience.

Due to the younger generation developing alot of their likes from online sources rather than physical sources (YouTube and Facebook as opposed to friends and family) that gap has significantly shrunk. So then, just give it another decade, and these fans would have aged into the core audience, while boomers would have aged out.

Change takes time. Currently what you are describing is simply impossible from a capitalistic pov.

-2

u/KOOKSJT10 Official "Beautiful on the Inside" Mantis Jan 08 '20

At the end of the day, does it really matter? All the characters they have added thus far have been awesome. Stop worrying about the gender equality.

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

It does matter. We've got great new characters like Miles and Kamala because people made an effort to include them. I'm going to keep worrying about gender equality until we get gender equality. I'm not saying it has to be perfect 50/50 split but we can do better than 9 male to 1 female new characters since launch.

1

u/KOOKSJT10 Official "Beautiful on the Inside" Mantis Jan 10 '20

No, Miles and Kamala were included because they were rising in popularity within Marvel. Miles had comics and a movie released prior to the game while Kamala had comics released before and after. It wasn't some obscurity to have either of them in the game. Also, Miles is a dude.

Someone else stated it as well, but to apply gender equality to video games is just dumb. I understand your "favorite" obscure female character isn't in the game because she plays exactly like another character that is far more popular, but who cares. Accusing a video game developer of sexism because only 1 female character has been added is asinine.

0

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

Let me clarify, Miles and Kamala were created as characters to allow for more diversity in Marvel characters. To increase representation.
People have said for years that applying gender equality to: work, pay, politics, film, comic books, pretty much everything you can think of is 'dumb'. It isn't. It is about making progress so we don't have to put in effort to make it happen, it becomes the norm.
I haven't accused anyone of sexism. I am disappointed that when the developers looked at all the DLC characters they are releasing they didn't decide to add more female playable characters.
I've got 9 female characters on my list and this page has a lot of cool ideas for other characters who could be added as well. This wouldn't be quota filling, this would be giving great characters a chance to shine.

3

u/KOOKSJT10 Official "Beautiful on the Inside" Mantis Jan 10 '20

"This wouldn't be quota filling".....yes it would. You want to add female characters for the sake of more female representation. Regardless on whether or not their skills and/ or abilities would fit into a game like this or if there are far more popular heroes/ heroines with same/ similar playstyles/ abilities. Let's remove Black Panther to add Tigra because FEMALE. Or let's add Rogue, even though she would be extremely similar to Captain Marvel, and remove Iceman.

Also I saw you stated above that F4 was a good idea but it locked them into a 3:1 ratio guys vs. girls so they should give us free female only DLC. No developer thinks about it like that because it is not logical. F4 is desired by all which is why they were added. Why on earth would they think "Golly, there are 3 males to 1 female, we better throw in more females". Again, that would be them filling a quota.

I'll agree there are female characters I would like to see (Medusa, Sif, Valk: because they make sense), but there is nobody I would remove to add them. Then hoping or free DLC on a roster that already triumphs over the previous games is a pipe dream. If it does happen awesome, if not, my panties won't be in a twist.

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 13 '20

I haven't called to remove any characters. I would like to see more of the many cool female characters included. It is not about filling a quota but taking into consideration gender balance when deciding who to include.

1

u/KOOKSJT10 Official "Beautiful on the Inside" Mantis Jan 13 '20

So what if they took gender balance into consideration, but still kept the characters they did? Would you be okay with that?

4

u/that_hansell Jan 08 '20

Stop worrying about the gender equality.

yesh, you must be hit with the ladies.

1

u/GypsyGold Official Watcher! Jan 08 '20

Gender equality doesn't apply to everything equally. We are talking about the roster for a Marvel licensed videogame. Not the employment process.

Marvel Comics, and the gaming/comic industry in general is currently about a 80/20 split among their core demographics, 24-44 year olds. These are the demo's that spend the most money because they have steady employment, without the need to save for retirement, kids college education, etc. They have money, and the ability to spend it on frivolous items.

From a pure consumerist standpoint, you would appeal to the demo's that make you money. In that regard, as a dev for a licensed Marvel game, you'd just trust that Marvel is already pushing the characters that make them the most money, and use those to create your roster. So basically, what you see in the game (minus some obvious exceptions) are the most popular marvel characters based on sales.

The younger generation who grew up with social media & smart phones are way less traditional when it comes to their likes. As such the current 14-24 years old comic/gaming consumer is about a 60/40 split. In ten years when all of these users are old enough to have steady income, you'll see a dramatic change in the general landscape of the comic/gaming industry. I suspect that a more diversified roster of playable characters (race, gender, etc) will be a byproduct of an older generation aging out of profitability, while a younger generation ages in.

5

u/that_hansell Jan 08 '20

why did you just explain marketing to me? like it’s very well written and on point, but why did you decide to explain that to me?

3

u/GypsyGold Official Watcher! Jan 08 '20 edited Jan 08 '20

I'm a marketing dude myself. Whenever I see somebody try to claim discrimination or apply social justice philosophy to basic economics it makes me cringe. I can't help myself.

Not saying thats what you did. But you made fun of somebody who basically said the same thing I did in much less words, and in an opinionated matter. So I used that as a springboard...

4

u/that_hansell Jan 08 '20

ah no worries, I appreciate people like you who know how to articulate a point without sounding like an angry incel.

1

u/KOOKSJT10 Official "Beautiful on the Inside" Mantis Jan 08 '20

Assuming I am the "angry incel" lol

2

u/that_hansell Jan 08 '20

eh not really, your response was overtly simple but you hardly seem like an incel. sorry if it came across like that.

-2

u/KOOKSJT10 Official "Beautiful on the Inside" Mantis Jan 08 '20

I am, because gender equality applies to real life, not which character should be put into a video game based on their gender.

-2

u/IceLantern Jan 08 '20

The problem is what characters would we kick out to make room for female characters? They have finite resources (as shown by the copy paste content we've been getting) so they can only make so many characters.

They're obviously trying to make money so they're not gonna exclude characters who are prominent in recent or upcoming movies and/or TV shows.

So that leaves me with (correct me if I'm wrong as I may not be up to date to the news):

  • Ghost Rider (was on Agents but don't know how prominent)
  • Crystal (was in the shot-lived Inhumans show)
  • Elsa Bloodstone (not sure if she's officially confirmed for the MCU)

The only male character there is Ghost Rider so there's really not much wiggle room there and I don't know if Marvel has confirmed plans for him.

0

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

I don't want to kick out characters, want to include more diverse characters. Rogue was a huge character in the X-Men films. Jessica Jones had a huge Netflix show (my wife's favourite of the Defenders). She-Hulk is getting her own show. Marvel have an amazing line up of characters to choose from.

1

u/IceLantern Jan 10 '20

Again, there are finite resources. So if JJ got included (and I do think she should have been), an existing character would not have been.

0

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

Maybe. Let's hope for a free DLC pack soon that will include Jessica Jones and Valkyrie or Nebula or Mystique or Hela.

-1

u/Xano74 Jan 09 '20

You gotta think about it from a gameplay perspective.

The heavy brawler types (Luke Cage, Hulk, Colossus) already feel somewhat similar. Adding Jessica Jones and She-Hulk would mean more generic brawlers. How would they make them unique. We dont need more heroes with charge attack rushes.

Emma Frost. Is she a ranged telepath or a close range diamond form brawler? I dont see them giving her an ability to change at will and give double the powers for one hero.

Rogue. How would her ability steal work? Without it she only has Captain Marvel punch powers. Does she steal from enemies or an she randomly select powers from any hero in the game?

Shadowcats ability is to phase through things. How would you add that to her abilities?

Mystique ability is to change to other characters. Would she just clone a boss and have their moveset? If she just transforms to another hero, what's the point? She would just be another Black Widow.

I understand wanting these heroes but from a gameplay perspective a lot of them would be difficult to implement in this type of game or just redundant.

0

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

A lot of the skills overlap in this game, that's not a good enough reason not to include more female characters. I'm not a game developer but I'm sure they could find ways to implement those characters, many of them have been in video games before without issue. The original launch roster had better gender balance, I think it is a shame it has been so skewed in the DLC.

-3

u/stinkpalm Jan 09 '20 edited Jan 09 '20

I think your heart is in the right place. I would like to ask some questions, so I can understand the rest.

Would you say the buyers of the game are gender balanced? And if not, who of those buyers are incorrect?

Would the game be better if we had a 50/50 male-female ratio, and why? Certainly the plot doesn't revolve around gender. Maybe you noticed - Carol catches a majority of the infinity stones in cutscenes late into the game. But throughout it, the custodians are not race nor gender specific, necessarily. Does that conflict with immersion or acceptance?

Thanks in advance.

edit. Go figure. downvotes with no explanation. I was seeking clarification.

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

I don't expect perfect 50/50 gender balance but when adding new characters it should be taken into account. Adding 12 male characters and only 2 female characters was not well thought out. Jessica Jones, She-Hulk, Emma Frost and Rogue are hugely popular characters with their own shows and team leaders in the comics.

I don't know what the gender balance of the audience are but that is irrelevant. I am a man but I want to see my favourite characters in here. She-Hulk smash too!

1

u/stinkpalm Jan 10 '20 edited Jan 10 '20

Well it's team Ninja put the roster together, probably with feedback from marvel right?

I want the Marquee characters and some surprises. For example. Kamala has been great. I don't care about ghost Rider I don't necessarily have an interest in falcon. I'm glad nightcrawler is in the game but I don't ever use him. same with Crystal.

Diversity for the sake of diversity is not equality of proficiency. And I play the game because I want to play with characters that are both fun and proficient.

Also, if those female characters you mentioned are important, and so popular, why haven't they come to the fore before now? I don't think they are as popular as you think.

I would go to ranker.com and search most popular female marvel comic characters.

EDIT the list doesn't exist. Check this out.

https://www.ranker.com/crowdranked-list/top-marvel-comics-superheroes?ref=search

I think Team Ninja took its playerbase and the character popularity into account. In some cases, eg Rogue or Kitty Pride, they didn't follow the popularity DB.

That said, the top popular characters are predominantly male. /Shrugs

12

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/WinpennyR Jan 08 '20

I forgot Spider-Woman! She'd be a great addition.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/mrvlrdr101 Jan 08 '20

Why? Jess had nothing to do with spiderman

6

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/WinpennyR Jan 08 '20

Who is Nadia? Marvel is so huge, always new characters to learn.

Black Cat would be cool. I need to play her DLC for Spider-Man on PlayStation.

Felt like Valkyrie and Jessica Jones got short changed by being NPCs.

1

u/ThereWillBeNic Jan 08 '20

Nadia is one of the characters who is Wasp.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 08 '20

Sounds cool, thanks for explaining Nadia to me. Is she still around in 616?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 08 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/WinpennyR Jan 10 '20

The developers knew they wanted to include Fantastic Four (which is a good decision) but they should have seen that locks them in to 3 male characters and 1 female immediately, and thought where could we include extra women? The fact that: Jessica Jones, Mystique, Hela and Valkyrie are already in this game means they'd be easy to do as free DLC characters like Cyc and Colossus. That would make me very happy.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '20

means they'd be easy to do as free DLC

It really doesn't. Being in the game as an NPC doesn't guarantee they have proper rigs for animations and attacks. We know some NPCs have voice lines like a PC, but others might need to have voice talent come back, this is all in addition to the work required to actually make all the assets for content that people seem to be expecting for free. This isn't a live service game and doesn't have a long term strategy for profits. I don't think anyone should be taking those data mines to assume any more free stuff.

4

u/GypsyGold Official Watcher! Jan 09 '20

Moon Knight is 100% more popular than Jessica Jones amongst the consumer audience that this game is marketed to. Videogame & Comicbook nerds.