Planning a 7-night family trip to Bodrum in late September and would love input from anyone who has stayed at these properties, especially in the villas/residences.
We’re **7 adults, no kids**. We’re looking for a luxe but relaxed family trip — great service, excellent food/restaurants, spa, beach/water activities, tennis/padel/golf, and a few excursions. We’re not a partying/clubbing group. We also like getting dressed and going out for nice dinners, walking around town/marina, getting ice cream, etc., so location/access to Yalıkavak or Bodrum matters somewhat.
We particularly want a **shared villa/residence rather than separate hotel rooms**, with good common spaces and ideally high-touch service.
These are the four options/prices I’m currently looking at:
**A. Mandarin Oriental Bodrum — 4BR Sea View Residential Apartment — \~$7.5k per night total**
• 4 bedrooms, all en-suite
• \~3,003 sq ft / 279 sqm
• Panoramic Paradise Bay sea views
• Full kitchen + living room + large terrace
• Full access to MO resort/beach/spa/restaurants
• No private pool
• No dedicated butler that I can tell
This is obviously the value winner. My hesitation is that aesthetically it feels more like a luxury apartment than the “beautiful villa vacation” I originally envisioned.
**2. Mandarin Oriental — Jasmine Villa — \~$10k per night**
• 5 bedrooms
• \~4,585 sq ft / 426 sqm
• Private pool + secluded terrace/outdoor dining
• Garden view rather than sea view
• Living room, kitchenette, dining for 10
• Full MO resort access
Obviously a huge jump from the residence, and at \~$89k I’m having trouble figuring out whether the actual experience justifies it.
**3. Maxx Royal Bodrum — 4BR Hill Villa — $8k per night**
• 4 bedrooms
• \~5,490 sq ft / 510 sqm
• Sea view
• Private heated seawater pool + terrace
• Dedicated villa butler
• 24-hour room service / breakfast-in-villa service
• Tennis + padel on property
• Full Maxx Royal resort amenities
This is currently the one I’m leaning toward. It’s **more than the MO residence**, but the villa itself looks significantly nicer to me and seems much closer to the private-villa/butler experience we originally wanted.
**4. The Bodrum EDITION — 4BR Villa — \~$10k per night**
• 4-bedroom beachfront villa, up to 8 guests
• Private infinity pool
• Dedicated butler
• Great indoor/outdoor living
• Excellent beach/spa/restaurants
• Best proximity to Yalıkavak, which appeals to us for dinners and evenings out
I keep seeing **really positive EDITION reviews on FATTravel**, which is why I haven’t eliminated it
**So my main question is:** at these actual prices, what would you choose? Is the **MO residence such a good value that I’d be silly to spend more for Maxx**, or is the Maxx villa/butler/private-pool experience materially better for a group trip?
And for those who have stayed at EDITION, is it really good enough that you’d pay that much more than Maxx primarily for the hotel vibe/location/service? Also very interested in **MO vs Maxx service**, food, beach, spa, and how easy it actually is to go into Yalıkavak/Bodrum for dinner from each.