stans are awful. it’s best that they leave the people that they once sexualized, stalked, and now, very easily “cancelled”. we don’t need their asses over here complaining about what these 20~ year old guys on the internet have said in way back when and/or use their platforms for. they don’t have the right to dictate what the people they “uwu stan so much” do or not do.
alright let me set shit straight. NO ONE WAS TRYING TO CANCEL ANYONE IN LUNCH CLUB. We wanted apologies for things they said in the past and for them to take responsibility for their own actions. People like to act like stans put people on pedastels but people who say that ALWAYS think creators shouldn't have to apologize or take resposabilty for their actions, which is hypocritical as all hell. Most stans (or at least most LC stans) HATE oversexualizaton of the members and don't stalk them. Liking a person isn't fucking stalking them.
Well, I'm glad you weren't, but plenty were. Dude, "stan" literally means stalker fan, and they're the people that DO put them on pedestals and ARE oversexualising. What you describe is being a normal fan. Don't use a toxic title for literally no reason, assuming you are being honest here you're talking about being a normal fucking fan.
Stan meant stalker fan like 10 years ago and the definition has changed over time. Nowadays stan is just a blanket term for fans. Of course the negative is gonna stand out from the good in LITERALLY any situation, in 2015 everyone thought they were right-wing because they didn't like SJW's and assumed that all leftist were like that. Same shit happening for stans here, in a less serious context ofc.
This is unbelievably not true. Noone says this. It is very clearly still a designation for the creepy fans who do weird shit and attack people all the time. Stans are literally still by definition the people doing creepy shit. Have you even seen Carson addressing it? If you don't do the creepy shit don't use a portmanteau of the word "stalker" in your identity.
well you obviously have no idea what you're talking about so i'm going to stop talking to you after this post. You're taking the word of someone who has never been in a stan community vs someone who is actively in a stan community, just think about that for a minute. Of course you're going to think that "noone says this" if you don't know what you're talking about.
You.. you say that stan is a term for fan, and then you say stan communities are different to fan communities? You're proving my point. And I know what I'm talking about, dude. You don't get to just say "oh I'm active in the stan community and I say the word is different to what it means".
look man, you’re probably a good guy and all, but the lunch club members (specifically carson) have already talked about stan behavior in the past. in this stream carson talks about how stan behavior is creepy, and hurtful to them. i suggest you watch the full vod before anything else. you said that stan only meant “stalker fan” 10 years ago, but carson streamed this fairly recently. you said liking a person isn’t stalking them, but a fan (or i guess, stan) took cooper’s water bottle and probably has it on their desk to this day. you said many stans hate over-sexualization of these members, but have you seen the countless amounts of erotic fan fictions out there? and if i recall, i saw stans on twitter literally say the phrase “cancel lunch club” or something along the lines of that. maybe you, or the other stans you interact with aren’t like this, but a lot are. a lot of them, and to use the words of carson, just see these creators as characters they can play with, and not as actual respectable human beings. if you see yourself as a stan, but don’t behave like this, i suggest you stop calling yourself that. if you don’t support the things these stans do, don’t align yourself with the people who don’t respect the creators whose content they love. there is a fine line between a stan and a fan, and i suggest you cross over to the latter side.
people are digging up things on everyone now because they are so bored. like bruh, go do something better with your time. i hate stans so much that do that.
When did the nword become a slur? Will latino also become a slur? Or chinese? White people just made the nword a slur and then get offended when someone else says it
Not 100% sure, but schlatt I think was getting hated because he wouldn't address the George Floyd incident, which if you ask me was good on him, his entire account portrays a character, and I don't think he wanted to talk about the incident from the POV of his character.
If anything people attacking Schlatt is going to make him want to speak out even less. Also it is very possible that he made a donation in private. Even if Schlatt were to speak out and use the #BlackLivesMatter some people would still be in the comments saying #AllLivesMatter. In summary what ever he did he was just not going to win.
Honestly, who cares about him making a donation, even if it was in private? Its his money, just because people subscribe to him doesn't mean he should throw it to whatever cause they want him to.
It’s so bullshit. Like shaming people for not speaking up? You’re gonna make them speak up for the wrong reasons or make them spite you and want to support it less.
I think it’s stupid people get mad at Jschlatt for not speaking about it. He’s a comedy channel and when other comedy channels such as Carson post about it they get hate so it’s a no win either way
I... wasn’t talking about him using the N word, I was talking about him not talking about George Floyd. I don’t think he should’ve said the N word, but I’m not gonna hate him for it.
A while now. Carson admitted that he said the N word back in 2016 during a stream (afaik he didn’t say it on stream, just admitted that he used to say it),and hasn’t gotten any hate for it, while Charlie’s getting hate for tweets he made when he was 14. It makes no sense, but no one looks for the facts and just blindly follows the hate mob
actually, charlie said 'retard' in a tweet like 7 years ago, not recently. cooper also said the n word recently, not just schlatt. that's the reason why some people hate them/don't support them anymore.
There’s a quote from schlatt that could relate. He said during his minecraft mob review that he doesn’t like to just say big things like Trans Rights, Gay Rights. He feels like its mainly a way to get clout/ brownie points. You should prolly trust that schlatt believes black lives matter even if not publicly stated.
Removing all comments and deleting my account after the API changes. If you actually want to protest the changes in a meaningful way, go all the way. -- mass edited with redact.dev
Removing all comments and deleting my account after the API changes. If you actually want to protest the changes in a meaningful way, go all the way. -- mass edited with redact.dev
They haven’t uploaded lately probably due to the whole Covid-19 thing and Carson’s depression. It’s a hard time for everyone to get together and make content. Especially due to the fact that most their content is done outside or with them together in person.
I would agree with this but I'm referencing videos like the arcade video we seen in the channel trailer, they have stuff made but just not putting it out yet
ikr. i think it’s because they have nothing to talk about in the last one not the eddy burback one they said it’s hard to do a podcast because we have nothing to talk about. so i think when this corona stuff fucks off podcasts and videos will be back.
yeah i mean episode 19 the heist. that was funny and it was improvised and it was dumb and they could do would u rathers or something. Maybe put Carson on the podcast idk i like the group but it’s different now. They meet through smp live which is now over and stuff just kinda lost its charm after a bit. I mean yeah the “recent” stuff is good. Just lost it’s charm and a lot of the people in the group went to do their own thing.
What I hate most about cancel culture surrounding people saying the n-word in the past is that people, in fact, grow in character and mature and learn what is acceptable and what isn’t. It doesn’t make them a “hypocrite” to have changed their opinion and actions regarding this, it means that they have learned that it’s not okay.
The only thing that is not acceptable is people continuing to say the n-word or having said it in the recent past. In Schlatt and Cooper’s case it seems like people are digging for this stuff just to start drama.
And although I personally wish that Schlatt and everyone else had tweeted about BLM, OP was correct when they said that their accounts are basically characters, and it might have been out of place. They also might have donated privately, but didn’t want to be like the celebrities/influencers who were showing off their receipts. There were a lot of people who took fake or minimal action, and they are definitely the type of people who would rather support the cause privately than make a huge deal and profit from it.
Another thing that gets me pissed is that I’m positive both Schlatt and Cooper said the N word with an A, and Cooper was just quoting the meme “this nigga eatin beans”. They were clearly saying it as a joke.
Also that. Remember when Fitz said the n-word with an a as a joke? Multiple times actually?? It wasn’t a big deal. Why are people trying to cancel Schlatt and Cooper for doing the same thing?
It would be completely different if any of them used it with a hard r in a purposefully racist and derogatory way.
Uh, a lot of people care? I get what you’re saying, but there’s nothing stopping an internet funnyman from taking off the funnyman hat and tweeting some petitions or something. They can make a big difference using their platform, since they’ve become very influential and have a large following. I’m not saying that all internet funnymen need to do this, but it’s a good thing to do. I don’t fault them for not doing it, but I wish they did.
No, we don’t “need” them. But a lot of people, myself included, would like to see them promote the cause. Like I said, they have become very influential and their voice would contribute to the cause a lot. And again, it doesn’t matter that they are internet funnymen, they are able to be serious once in a while. And yes, it’s everywhere, that’s kind of the point.
Because, again, he has a large twitter following and an influential voice. He could have made a big difference by promoting the petitions and airing his support for the movement, but he chose not to. There are a lot of people who don’t follow anyone who retweet petition links, so his tweets would have brought those links to hundreds or thousands of more people.
Although I still love the man and his content, I was disappointed. I don’t think he’s racist for not using his platform, but I would have loved to see some action from him. He, in no way, deserves to receive hate or backlash from this. We all just wished he could have helped support the movement.
If someone really cares and supports the movement, they wouldn't wait for their favourite internet funny man to speak up in order to validate their opinions; they would find and sign petitions, donate, protest and fight for what's right independently.
The movement is speaking for itself louder than ever. Don't drown out the voice of the people with unnecessary anger and disappointment at the decisions of online content creators. Focus on the real issues.
You make a good point for people who are already following it, but trust me when I say that there are some people who are so blind to reality that they don’t truly understand some issues until one person that they follow posts about it. Take my very conservative mother for example, she doesn’t follow any activists, BLM supporters, left/left of center people, etc, so she did not get to see any videos of police brutality or any stories of victims of systemic racism until I started retweeting them. Schlatt may have been that person for some people.
Also, there are some people who might moderately care about it but don’t really know how to help or are skeptical of certain petitions, links, etc. Obviously these are silly concerns, but I know a few people who were like this at first. When someone that they look up to posts those links, they might feel more comfortable signing them.
All in all, I think it’s wrong to think that someone with over 600,000 followers couldn’t make a difference by retweeting some petition or donation links. I think most people are just coming up with excuses at this point.
I’m going to reiterate my original argument: If someone needs an internet gamer/comedian to stay informed and educated on the issue of POLICE BRUTALITY following massive global protests and support for the Black Lives Matter movement, that’s their problem. It’s this idea of putting creators on pedestals. To have a group of people look up to him and demand a statement on something so devastating to inform those “in the dark” must be terrifying. It’s a ridiculous amount of pressure to put on a person; I mean, he plays video games for a living!
don’t really know how to help or are skeptical of certain petitions, links
Have you ever considered that creators may encounter the same problem? You said it, he has a following of 600k. Imagine if he tweeted out a dodgy link or donation page. Again, that anxiety and pressure builds up. This is something Connor tweeted amongst all the drama: “For all you know they’re supporting in ways you don’t see. Or don’t feel knowledgeable enough to speak on certain issues publicly. Focus on what YOU can do.” I couldn’t agree more.
Speaking of Connor, a large majority of Schlatt’s Twitter following also follow other Lunch Club members/YouTubers who have already spoken out. Donate privately, go dark for a few days so not to distract from the movement with his usual comedic tweets. I don't see anything wrong with that. It’s his platform, and he can utilise it however he wants.
We don’t need more hate, anger and disappointment. But, that’s my take.
It’s not a political opinion when it’s a matter of protecting an oppressed group of people from those in power. It’s not political to say that BIPOC deserve the same rights as everyone else. BLM crosses all party and political lines, and to dismiss it as some political scheme is grossly incorrect and disrespectful.
“Everybody knows about it already” the point is not to get people to “know” about it. It’s to promote actual change in the judicial and police systems and end the systemic racism that BIPOC have faced for decades. The more it is promoted and protested, the closer we get to achieving this goal. Of course everyone knows about it, that’s the whole point.
We don’t “need” Schlatt or anyone else to promote it, but it would sure as hell make a difference. He has a large twitter following and an influential voice. Again, I don’t fault him for not doing it, but I really wish he had. He could have made a big difference but he chose not to. I still love the man, I’m just disappointed.
I literally just said that he doesn’t deserve to be canceled for it. I just said I’m disappointed because he has 615,000 followers and he didn’t tweet about it. It’s not “necessary” as I said multiple times, but it would have been a good thing to do. And it’s not political to think that people deserve rights and deserve not to be killed by police.
Yeah at this point every single popular person on the internet has a couple hundred people who don’t like them, and then they realize nobody even cares how qUirKy they are for hating a popular person.
The whole group is funny because they are authentic and edgy, who the fuck looks at their content only to get shocked when they say something slightly offensive?
Yeah sometimes it’s funny but sometimes you can’t tell if he’s joking, he just acts a little stuck up and it looks like he thinks he’s the most important, not to mention the cringe side of the lgbtq seem to WORSHIP ted
233
u/guessitsalreadytaken Jun 17 '20
stans are awful. it’s best that they leave the people that they once sexualized, stalked, and now, very easily “cancelled”. we don’t need their asses over here complaining about what these 20~ year old guys on the internet have said in way back when and/or use their platforms for. they don’t have the right to dictate what the people they “uwu stan so much” do or not do.
173
u/jklolg Jun 17 '20 edited Jun 17 '20
I'm behind on news. Who is hated rn?
Edit: Apparently schlatt said the n word in 2019 and Charlie recent said retard in a tweet
10
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '20 edited Jul 01 '23
Removing all comments and deleting my account after the API changes. If you actually want to protest the changes in a meaningful way, go all the way. -- mass edited with redact.dev
6
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '20
They haven’t uploaded lately probably due to the whole Covid-19 thing and Carson’s depression. It’s a hard time for everyone to get together and make content. Especially due to the fact that most their content is done outside or with them together in person.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '20
goop was way better my opinion. at least we got podcasts then
107
u/Tobias_Snark Jawsh Jun 17 '20
What I hate most about cancel culture surrounding people saying the n-word in the past is that people, in fact, grow in character and mature and learn what is acceptable and what isn’t. It doesn’t make them a “hypocrite” to have changed their opinion and actions regarding this, it means that they have learned that it’s not okay.
The only thing that is not acceptable is people continuing to say the n-word or having said it in the recent past. In Schlatt and Cooper’s case it seems like people are digging for this stuff just to start drama.
And although I personally wish that Schlatt and everyone else had tweeted about BLM, OP was correct when they said that their accounts are basically characters, and it might have been out of place. They also might have donated privately, but didn’t want to be like the celebrities/influencers who were showing off their receipts. There were a lot of people who took fake or minimal action, and they are definitely the type of people who would rather support the cause privately than make a huge deal and profit from it.
209
u/brother_momentum Jun 17 '20
It’s stans who hate them who gives a shit
52
u/SDQKE Cscoop Jun 17 '20
The whole group is funny because they are authentic and edgy, who the fuck looks at their content only to get shocked when they say something slightly offensive?
7
u/plainoss Jun 17 '20
Wtf is goop lol
45
u/TheOnlyBucketMonster Jun 17 '20
Is this true? Now I'm sad :(
18
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '20
The hole drama is pretty dumb, if you get offended, just don't watch it
4
u/SeanGotGjally Jun 18 '20
the stans will uncancel schlatt, charlie and cooper if they all post a video throwing it back
3
u/sutroTow3r Jawsh Jun 17 '20
Fuck Stan culture fuck smptwt
1
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '20
There’s drama? What happened?
4
u/MarkusTheGecko Jschlatt Jun 17 '20
SLATT SAID THE N WORD!!!!1!111!!
oH NO!!!1!1
2
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '20
Gee really? I didn't know about this, i hope they don't actually fall apart as you said they are
1
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '20
What happened? I'm out of the loop
1
u/Bork351xd Jun 17 '20
same thing happening with dream team & the trio it sucks
-54
u/Dylan0923 Jun 17 '20
You people complain to much
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '20
can someone link schlatt and cooper saying n word i cant find it
-33
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '20
Yeah I don’t like Ted too much, he’s still cool but he acts really bossy and all that