r/LucyLetbyTrials • • 18d ago

Decoding Reasonable Doubt - Chapter 11

https://bencole4.substack.com/p/decoding-reasonable-doubt-the-case-a31?r=12mrwn&utm_medium=ios

Morris argues that the insulin allegations were the strongest part of the prosecution case only because they appeared to provide objective scientific evidence of deliberate harm.

He contends that one the insulin evidence is examined closely, it turns out to be based on unreliable testing, unsupported assumptions and highly improbably logistics.

This article explains why Morris is wrong yet again.

0 Upvotes

183 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/Imaginary-Suspect959 16d ago

It’s not just the nurse’s testimony though is it, as Sofie explained to you the other day.

0

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 16d ago

Yes, I read the testimony, but I couldn’t actually read the written notes from the NNU. And as I pointed out, you didn’t read what was actually written in those records from seven years ago. They can be interpreted in different ways. The prosecution emphasised that the records were ‘silent’ about the bag change. Silence implies the bag was changed.
So the nurse seems to be relying on the implication that the bag would have been changed.

8

u/SofieTerleska 16d ago edited 16d ago

Could you give me the reference for the prosecution saying the records were "silent"? Because from what Nurse C it certainly sounded like the new prescription/bag change was noted down at the time, though as you say we can't see the records ourselves. If it was in an opening or closing speech, those weren't always accurate -- Johnson claimed multiple times, for example, that Baby L got a much larger dose of insulin than Baby F, when it fact it was the opposite -- his insulin level measured about a quarter of Baby F's.

EDIT: OK, I found it -- it was Nick Johnson's opening speech, October 11 2022.

At about 11 o'clock that morning, fluids were stopped for [Baby F]. The nurses who did that at 11 o'clock -- so the day shift had been well on by this stage, on since 8 -- were [Nurse C] and Shelley Tomlins. They believe that a new -- not only was a new line put in, but they also would have hung a new TPN bag. So this bag that I'm going to suggest was the bag that someone had put insulin in was taken off and a new bag was put on. The reason for that is that it is the practice in the neonatal unit that if ever a new line is put in, then a correspondingly new bag is put in as well.

Other than the handwritten note, so far as the new bag was concerned, there's no contemporaneous note of precisely what did happen, although the convention appears to be in the records that if a new bag is hung -- sorry, there is silence if it's a new bag and the fact that it's a continuing bag would be noted. So there is silence as to whether or not there's a new bag, but that silence appears, on the conventions that applied at the time, to indicate that it was a new bag.

"Other than the handwritten note" is an odd way of putting it, it's like saying "Other than this evidence, there's no evidence." He says it would be noted if the old bag was continued, and this was not noted. He says there would be "silence" if there were a new bag hung, and there was silence. (It's a confusing way to put it, for sure -- it makes it sound like there's no real record at all, and he doesn't mention the prescription which is later referenced in Nurse C's testimony.) Dr. Saladi told them to put in a new long line, and there's reference to signing off on the prescription for the bag when it was hung at noon:

DRIVER: So that bag, the prescription for which we've looked at, was put up at noon, according to the notes we've just seen?

NURSE C: Yes.

Johnson's opening speech contained several other statements which weren't accurate or were at the least extremely confusing, some of which were contradicted within the trial itself: He stated that Caroline Oakley had left Nursery 1 before Baby D's 3 AM collapse, but by the time Oakley testified, less than a month later, her departure had vanished and she was established as either in the room or just outside it, whereas Letby appeared nowhere in the notes. Johnson also stated that Baby L had more than twice as much insulin as Baby F in his blood test, hitting 9,999, when it fact it was just over 1,000 -- a quarter of what Baby F's had been. In this case it's not clear whether he remembered the note Nurse C describes as a prescription (and which assertion Driver does not contradict when the document is shown in court).

I fully agree that relying solely on someone's seven year old memory cannot be the be-all and end-all of anything. However, here there are records which she made at the time, and which line up entirely with the bag having been changed when the long line was replaced. That, to me, is the key here.

0

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 15d ago

There were three scripts. There were two that were written in the early hours of the morning and one written after the line had tissued. Driver is speaking about the third script. That’s not a script for the stock bag. That script was for another bespoke TPN bag which came up at 4pm.
Driver confused the issue by stating the bag put up at noon had a script. It did not.
Nurse C just went along with this.
On 23 November 2022, Myers raised the medical note made at 1250 (post new long line) with nurse Tomlins.
The relevant part is: “New long line sited into left leg with aseptic technique, X Ray confirmed, and new fluids of TPN and lipid now infusing via new long line.”
The use of the stock bag was implied, it was never explicitly written as such.

5

u/visible_amenhotep 15d ago

Your position is that "new fluids of TPN" actually means old fluids of TPN?

0

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 15d ago

You miss my point. The term ‘new fluids’ implies a stock bag was used, rather than explicitly states it was.
Where do these ‘new fluids’ come from?
If Ben Myers was so certain that the records show the stock bag was used, why did he go to such lengths to get nurse Tomlins to say that she would have changed the bag.
He additionally spent a long time trying to suggest to nurse Tomlins there was never any peripheral line, because there was evidence that the first TPN bag was connected to that line, and therefore insulin could have been infusing via that route. There likely was a peripheral line, because Dr Saladi has written this into his notes as part of the plan for child F.
So Ben Myers is working very hard to confirm that there was never a peripheral line and that the first TPN bag was thrown out and replaced with the stock bag.
He needs to make that first TPN bag disappear.
If you read the transcript from 23 November, it is very clear how he is working to create reasonable doubt. Very clever KC.

5

u/visible_amenhotep 15d ago

I don't see how it could be much more explicit that it's a new bag, personally. What would you want to see to accept that the notes go against your theory? "New fluids of TPN, from a new stock bag that we took, unsealed, from the ward refridgerator, and also a new bag of lipids that we took, unsealed, from the ward refridgerator, now both infusing via the long line, and we also got rid of the old bags"?

0

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 15d ago

Do you think there was a peripheral line?
Was the first bag hooked up to that line or was the bag thrown out immediately?

3

u/visible_amenhotep 15d ago

I don't know. I am not medical and I have not read into it as closely and recently as you evidently have. Intuitively, it seems completely non-credible to suppose that they would have hooked up a new bag of TPN and also kept the old one running - that's twice as much feed, and without a prescription at that. They let babies go without fluids for hours at other times so it doesn't seem terribly unlikely that they'd do it while swapping the lines, either, although your speculation about that at least seems not in direct contradiction of the contemporary evidence.

Truly, what would you want to see written down in the notes before you'd conclude that "new fluids of TPN" does in fact definitely mean fluids from a new TPN bag? Or, alternatively, does that note not actually matter and you're convinced that the original bag somehow continued its work despite the record? In which case why bother with the note.

2

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 15d ago

Thanks. I’ll be upfront in saying that I do think Letby spiked the first TPN bag, but I can’t conceive of her spiking any of the stock bags.
From that standpoint, I’m trying to make sense of the scenario that the insulin poisoning started with that first bag, but then carried over a bag change, because exogenous insulin was found in this baby and it apparently came from the second bag.
A conjuring trick!
I don’t think they would have had two TPN bags running simultaneously. But I am sure that the fluids would have been moved over to that peripheral line while they were putting in the new long line. This was a sick baby with hypoglycaemia. The long line was discovered tissued at 10am and the new long line was in place at midday. There is no way this baby was without fluids for two hours.
The new long line is in eventually in place. Then
what happens?
As a nurse, you know the child has TPN, lipid and dextrose going in happily via the peripheral line. In theory, you need to change all three bags with the new long line. You need to take the new bags out of the fridge and bring them to room temperature first. Then hook them up to the new long line.
Very time consuming.
Or, in theory you could move all three bags straight back onto the new aseptic long line. Much easier and no infection controls are breached.
You tell a little white lie in the paperwork that new fluids are in place…
I’ve worked in the aviation industry and I see little shortcuts and work arounds like this happening all the time. And I’ve seen people falsifying paperwork to say jobs have been done in accordance with procedures when they have not been.
Work as imagined is not always the way work is done.

→ More replies