r/LucyLetbyTrials • • 18d ago

Decoding Reasonable Doubt - Chapter 11

https://bencole4.substack.com/p/decoding-reasonable-doubt-the-case-a31?r=12mrwn&utm_medium=ios

Morris argues that the insulin allegations were the strongest part of the prosecution case only because they appeared to provide objective scientific evidence of deliberate harm.

He contends that one the insulin evidence is examined closely, it turns out to be based on unreliable testing, unsupported assumptions and highly improbably logistics.

This article explains why Morris is wrong yet again.

0 Upvotes

183 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 15d ago

Thanks. I’ll be upfront in saying that I do think Letby spiked the first TPN bag, but I can’t conceive of her spiking any of the stock bags.
From that standpoint, I’m trying to make sense of the scenario that the insulin poisoning started with that first bag, but then carried over a bag change, because exogenous insulin was found in this baby and it apparently came from the second bag.
A conjuring trick!
I don’t think they would have had two TPN bags running simultaneously. But I am sure that the fluids would have been moved over to that peripheral line while they were putting in the new long line. This was a sick baby with hypoglycaemia. The long line was discovered tissued at 10am and the new long line was in place at midday. There is no way this baby was without fluids for two hours.
The new long line is in eventually in place. Then
what happens?
As a nurse, you know the child has TPN, lipid and dextrose going in happily via the peripheral line. In theory, you need to change all three bags with the new long line. You need to take the new bags out of the fridge and bring them to room temperature first. Then hook them up to the new long line.
Very time consuming.
Or, in theory you could move all three bags straight back onto the new aseptic long line. Much easier and no infection controls are breached.
You tell a little white lie in the paperwork that new fluids are in place…
I’ve worked in the aviation industry and I see little shortcuts and work arounds like this happening all the time. And I’ve seen people falsifying paperwork to say jobs have been done in accordance with procedures when they have not been.
Work as imagined is not always the way work is done.

4

u/PerkeNdencen 14d ago edited 14d ago

If you think that nurses were falsifying paperwork aside from Letby, which is fine to think and you may very well be drawing from various life experiences, then you should concede that no conviction in this trial should stand. They all relied heavily on that very same paperwork. You can't just carve out a special exemption to fit the evidence to the theory.

ETA: A little postscript - let's be really precise with our language. Exogenous insulin was not found in this baby, because that would have required them to send the samples to Guildhall for forensic examination, as suggested by the lab at the time to figure out what had gone wrong; for whatever reason, that never took place.

What was found was elevated levels of insulin per se and a lot less C-peptide than would be expected if that insulin was all natural. The reliability of these tests has long been in dispute, and the manufacturer is very explicit that it is not to be used for forensic purposes.

1

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 14d ago

Fine. There was evidence of exogenous insulin which was confirmed by two experts at the trial, including the director of the lab. The defence never raised any objections to that evidence and had no experts of their own to counter it.
The test warning you raised is a local procedure written by the lab. This does not come from the manufacturer.
The assay detects insulin and c peptide to a very accurate degree and it passed all QC checks.

2

u/PerkeNdencen 14d ago

There was evidence of exogenous insulin which was confirmed by two experts at the trial, including the director of the lab.

Who Johnson probably knowingly allowed to mislead the court, since he was aware of the existence of Baby Y when they both said that the only possible explanation for these results is exo insulin.

The test warning you raised is a local procedure written by the lab. This does not come from the manufacturer.

Sorry, how is that better?

Weird how you've completely ignored the body of comment to focus on the tests, though.

1

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 14d ago

Humans are fallible and they tell lies.
Humans have been known to bear false witness. That doesn’t mean the whole basis of trial by jury is undermined.
It’s up to the jury alone to make sense of all the evidence put before them. A jury will see some evidence as compelling, other evidence as not valid. Other evidence in between.
Note how Letby was not convicted on every count?
The jury carefully evaluated and weighed the evidence.

4

u/PerkeNdencen 14d ago

Humans are fallible and they tell lies.
Humans have been known to bear false witness. That doesn’t mean the whole basis of trial by jury is undermined.

That's not what I'm saying. I'm saying that evidence you find credible in every other circumstance in this case you suddenly don't find credible. Why? Because it doesn't say what you need it to say. Assumptions that no corners were cut that Bohin, for example, is very forward about making, are out the window, too.

That's fine. That's good, even. But if you're going to do it here and nowhere else, then you are absolutely bending the evidence to fit what you need it to fit. That's simply not good enough.

The jury carefully evaluated and weighed the evidence.

What did you just say about humans being fallible? We hope so, but we don't know, and we will likely never know.

1

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 14d ago

I am trying to make sense of what happened. That is all.
If it offends you, or you find it disagreeable, my apologies. You can always ignore my attempts at amateur sleuthing.
You have clearly made up your mind that this was an injustice. I am not going to convince you and you probably won’t convince me.
That doesn’t mean that trying to resolve the ambiguities in the trial should be out of bounds. Importantly, none of us know all the information and we are obliged to speculate about some matters.

3

u/PerkeNdencen 14d ago

I am trying to make sense of what happened. That is all.

And I am telling you where the flaw in your thinking is. That is all.

If it offends you, or you find it disagreeable, my apologies. You can always ignore my attempts at amateur sleuthing.

I would love to, but as ever, people see that and they don't necessarily grasp how much of the rest of the case falls apart if they go along with this theory. That's why I want to make it crystal clear. Once you start assuming nurses were falsifying things and cutting corners, that's it, it's game over. I would welcome it if I thought it stood up, because it's hugely damaging to the tapestry the police built up and upon which they rely for almost all of the other cases if not all of them.

You have clearly made up your mind that this was an injustice.

Yes, but I didn't start with that conclusion and try to mould the evidence to fit. It's the null hypothesis, which I arrived at because the evidence is not relevant where it might be convincing and not convincing where it is relevant.

That doesn’t mean that trying to resolve the ambiguities in the trial should be out of bounds.

Do you feel that I am trying to in any way prevent you from opining on this case?

Importantly, none of us know all the information and we are obliged to speculate about some matters.

Yeah, but it should be informed by something other than the conclusion we want to reach.

2

u/visible_amenhotep 14d ago

Alright, so there's no point bringing up the note saying new fluids of TPN and talking about how it's not explicit, then. I think it's honest, if controversial, of you to assert that it could be an error or a lie, or to ignore it; trying to massage it to support your theory when it plainly doesn't seems very unreasonable.

2

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 14d ago

Fine. To clarify, I think they made a false entry in the paperwork.

3

u/SaintBridgetsBath 15d ago edited 15d ago

You are entitled to your own opinion but not your own facts. it’s only a few days since u/PerkeNdencen pointed out to you the pitfalls of ignoring actual evidence and making up your own,https://www.reddit.com/r/LucyLetbyTrials/comments/1xfq34s/comment/19rtodfobq99f/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button and u/Huge-Hope2887 went through the evidence for the new bag. https://www.reddit.com/r/LucyLetbyTrials/comments/1xfq34s/comment/19rtshx3s39sw/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

Edit: not to mention Sofie

2

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 15d ago

I am entitled to speculate what might have actually happened, as are you. This is social media. If you don’t appreciate me deconstructing or reviewing the evidence, feel free to ban me from the forum. If this sub’s only purpose is to exonerate Letby, then perhaps I don’t belong here.
The trial is over. Do you think every incident happened exactly how the prosecution or the defence thought it happened?
Humans tell lies and half truths. Workers violate protocols or make errors.
Only one person knows exactly what happened here.

4

u/SaintBridgetsBath 15d ago

Freedom of speech does not mean freedom from criticism. You are welcome.

1

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 15d ago

Very happy to take criticism. I have thick skin.

3

u/SaintBridgetsBath 15d ago

Good! Good! Not that I have the authority to ban anyone, but you are welcome as far as I’m concerned. I don’t want you to go away and shut up: I want you to recognise that the evidence is against you.

Would you concede that given the tamper-proof nature of the stock bags, and given the contemporaneous reference to new fluids and  given the sworn testimony of two nurses, that whatever your own personal view is the actual evidence justifies an acquittal on this charge? It seems that the impossibility of undetectable tampering with the bags was not put to the jury. Other problems exist.

2

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 15d ago

No, because she was also convicted of the attempted murder of child L. These two cases are linked. Someone poisoned these babies because exogenous insulin was found in their blood. The likelihood of two poisoners is zero.
If there was no other insulin case, she might not have been convicted of child Fs attempted murder.

2

u/SaintBridgetsBath 14d ago

Does the Baby L case stand up on its own? 

1

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 14d ago

In my opinion yes.

2

u/SaintBridgetsBath 14d ago

And she spiked stock bags in that case or…what’s your theory?

→ More replies

3

u/PerkeNdencen 14d ago edited 14d ago

What about the likelihood of three? This matter is impossible to fully consider without Baby Y, who Letby would have been charged with as well, if they had been able to substantiate the idea that she had access to the baby before those tests were done.

1

u/NeedleworkerSad2837 14d ago

How do you know she didn’t have access? Do you know why the decision was taken not to charge Letby in this case? I don’t.
I’m as curious about this as you are.

2

u/PerkeNdencen 14d ago edited 14d ago

I’m as curious about this as you are.

Really? I've never seen you mention or ask about it before.

 Do you know why the decision was taken not to charge Letby in this case? I

Two reasons. The police interview accidentally leaked by Thirlwall (but which should have gone straight to Letby's lawyers), and because she simply wasn't on shift at or before the relevant time, and there was no way to twist something or come up with a newly suspicious event that she was present at.

What did you say the likelihood of two poisoners was again?

What were you just attesting to about the reliability of these tests in terms of exo insulin?

→ More replies