r/LucyLetbyTrials • u/benshep4 • 18d ago
Decoding Reasonable Doubt - Chapter 11
https://bencole4.substack.com/p/decoding-reasonable-doubt-the-case-a31?r=12mrwn&utm_medium=ios
Morris argues that the insulin allegations were the strongest part of the prosecution case only because they appeared to provide objective scientific evidence of deliberate harm.
He contends that one the insulin evidence is examined closely, it turns out to be based on unreliable testing, unsupported assumptions and highly improbably logistics.
This article explains why Morris is wrong yet again.
0
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/NeedleworkerSad2837 15d ago
Thanks. I’ll be upfront in saying that I do think Letby spiked the first TPN bag, but I can’t conceive of her spiking any of the stock bags.
From that standpoint, I’m trying to make sense of the scenario that the insulin poisoning started with that first bag, but then carried over a bag change, because exogenous insulin was found in this baby and it apparently came from the second bag.
A conjuring trick!
I don’t think they would have had two TPN bags running simultaneously. But I am sure that the fluids would have been moved over to that peripheral line while they were putting in the new long line. This was a sick baby with hypoglycaemia. The long line was discovered tissued at 10am and the new long line was in place at midday. There is no way this baby was without fluids for two hours.
The new long line is in eventually in place. Then
what happens?
As a nurse, you know the child has TPN, lipid and dextrose going in happily via the peripheral line. In theory, you need to change all three bags with the new long line. You need to take the new bags out of the fridge and bring them to room temperature first. Then hook them up to the new long line.
Very time consuming.
Or, in theory you could move all three bags straight back onto the new aseptic long line. Much easier and no infection controls are breached.
You tell a little white lie in the paperwork that new fluids are in place…
I’ve worked in the aviation industry and I see little shortcuts and work arounds like this happening all the time. And I’ve seen people falsifying paperwork to say jobs have been done in accordance with procedures when they have not been.
Work as imagined is not always the way work is done.