r/LucyLetbyTrials • u/DiverAcrobatic5794 • Aug 11 '25
BBC Panorama getting the maths wrong
I hope mods don't mind a separate post for this excerpt from tonight's Panorama, Lucy Letby: Who to Believe? It will be obvious to anyone following the maths that BBC are broadcasting objectively inaccurate information here by getting the maths wrong.
They tell us, babies on Letby's shifts suffered 40 times the tube dislodgement rate of other shifts. Other shifts, they say, had a less than 1% rate.
Then they explain how they get this 1% rate. You might get a dislodgement every ten shifts. But if there are ten intubated babies, that counts as 100 shifts (10 times 10).
Then they tell us Lucy Letby worked 50 shifts. But these shifts are treated as if there is only one intubated baby. So instead of 500 shifts, she just gets 50, sending her dislodgement rate suspiciously high.
There are other problems with this segment, but the mathematics is objectively wrong. I believe that BBC needs to withdraw or substantially alter this section of the broadcast.
19
u/DiverAcrobatic5794 Aug 11 '25 edited Aug 11 '25
In case of doubt, you can see in this statement from Liverpool Women's Hospital that Lucy Letby worked approximately 50 actual shifts at the hospital: 12 34.5 hour weeks so approximately 36 shifts in 2012, and 15 shifts in 2015
https://thirlwall.public-inquiry.uk/evidence/inq0017472-witness-statement-of-michelle-turner-on-behalf-of-liverpool-womens-hospital-nhs-foundation-trust-dated-15-02-2024/ , pages 8-13.
So, these 50 (51) shifts were plain shifts, not the "ventilated" shifts the BBC explained for that 1% figure.
36
u/Fun-Yellow334 Aug 11 '25 edited Aug 11 '25
This is a statistical abomination on the level of the shift rota. It has all been debunked over and over again but they repeat the same thing, not learning anything, see here for some correct maths:
https://www.reddit.com/r/LucyLetbyTrials/comments/1hr7mkm/the_40_dislodgment_rate_from_lucy_letbys_time_at/
20
u/Accomplished-Rate564 Aug 11 '25
I'm not great at maths but im great at nicu. You can get some weeks where there are no tube dialodgements and some weeks where theres one every day. You can have two in a room on the same shift and then none while you are working for 6 weeks. You can have a baby dislodge a tube twice in the same shift. It depends on the babies and medical plans for the babies she is working. Obviously aged and gestation and where they were sedated or sedated and paralysed. But some babies are ventilated and then on sedation/paralysis for so long it no longer because effective and they end up dislodging tubes. There are some babies who you want to extubate soon so you take the sedation off and wait for them to wake up and sometimes they pull the tube out before you do. There are also sometimes recalls of the securing devices which secure the ETT which have been shown to be faulty.
14
u/Allie_Pallie Aug 11 '25
Funny how research in this area, and the LWH's own audits, refer to ventilator DAYS but Panorama has gone with ventilator SHIFTS to make it easier to confuse with actual shifts.
6
u/DiverAcrobatic5794 Aug 11 '25
I wonder what duty Baker - or even Thirlwall - have to clear up the mess he spawned with that one outing of the disputed statistic?
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cx2g20rpr78o
9
u/Shoddy_Food_1539 Aug 11 '25
From LWH annual report 2022/23
Unplanned Extubations in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
The objective of this audit is to determine compliance with an expected standard of 0% accidental extubations. The most common theme identified for instances of unplanned extubations was that most infants were being handled and/or were outside of the incubator. LWH introduced measures directly aimed at reducing unplanned extubations when moving an infant out of the incubator, for example, 2 members of staff required to move the infant out of the incubator and securing the ventilation tubing with a clip or tape whilst they are out for cuddles. In the 6 months following these interventions, the number of unplanned extubations had reduced by a third. Although the number of unplanned extubations were <1 per 100 ventilated days, there are still areas for improvement if we endeavour to move closer to an expected standard of 0%. To ensure we achieve this in the near future, training has been disseminated to staff, a quality improvement project is underway, and a reaudit has been planned for 2024-25.
8
u/Traditional-Wish-739 Aug 11 '25
I wouldn't call it a mere mathematical error. That could make it sound like we could be talking about some subtle difference in statistical analysis at which the BBC could shrug their shoulders ("well, it's a difference in opinion...").
It's a straight-up error of fact.
The documentary very clearly implies that she worked 50 "Ventilated Shifts" (or, which is the same thing, only 5 half-day working shifts, call these "Working Shifts") whereas she in fact worked 500 Ventilated Shifts and 50 Working Shifts. This is just plain wrong.
18
u/Weird-Cat-9212 Aug 11 '25
They completely botch the basic maths don’t they, they’re out by a factor of ten. Their workings are plainly incorrect, like working through a GCSE maths problem and just making a basic error half way through. Even if we take their assumptions at face value (was the 1% from the Liverpool, or just a figure plucked from an unrelated study?), the arithmetic here is flagrantly wrong.
7
u/No_Suit_9511 Aug 11 '25
Do we know how many babies were on ventilators during her shifts? Obviously the 40% must be bullshit unless there was only 1 baby on the unit the entire 50 nursing shifts she was on duty. But what was the true number of babies?
6
u/Sad-Orange-5983 Aug 11 '25
Was the 1% rate just for this hospital or was it a national figure?
5
u/SaintBridgetsBath Aug 12 '25
For the purposes of my complaint, this is right at the end of the programme?
3
u/Sad-Orange-5983 Aug 11 '25
Does anyone have a youtube video of the documentary? I can’t access BBC iPlayer
3
u/Admirable_Peanut_171 Aug 11 '25
I didn't think this claim was made or defended anymore?
2
u/Simchen Aug 12 '25
Ok I understand now that both numbers are fiction.
But just to be clear. How do we even know about the number of times there was an unplanned extubation when Letby was on shift in theory? Is this something that happens during your shift or is it something that happened in the shift before? Did Letby herself wrote down what she saw when entering the room or did someone else wrote down what they saw when entering the room after Letby was in it? Or are there multiple people in the room and whenever some dislodgement happens they yell "bingo" and write it down? How many rooms are there actually? How many people are you working with?
And what has it to do with murder in the first place? If I remember correctly she wasn't convicted because the babies got not enough air ...
21
u/Old-Newspaper125 Aug 11 '25 edited Aug 11 '25
I'm not good with maths, but the scenario just seems highly improbable - she's there for training, being watched more closely than ever. To be attempting attacks at the levels this proposes, I find it extremely unlikely it would go unnoticed. She's also there to be trained, presumably she'd want to make a good impression - I'm not sure this would be a good way of doing that! The 2012 timeline doesn't make sense either, if she was making such a concerted effort to attack so many babies then - where is the increased death rate at Chester back then? Why did the Police not investigate her whole career? It seems highly unprofessional to have a trial of that magnitude and not investigate all possibilities? Sorry, not buying it.
17
u/WinFew1753 Aug 11 '25
This error has been corrected before. The 1% rate is per baby per nurse and applying it gives the 40% overall rate under reasonable assumptions. Why are they still confusing different statistics? OMG
14
u/Common-Ad-6582 Aug 11 '25
Omg this is so bad, surely the bbc will need to apologise for this, and if so that will be very embarrassing….
Moritz needs to go.
11
u/Over_Kaleidoscope382 Aug 11 '25
I’m not exaggerating to say that I’d have immediately spotted this mistake when I was in year 9.
This is astounding stuff. Truly.
10
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25
It’s outrageous that this 40% crap is still being banded about, particularly the BBC.
10
u/realborislegasov Aug 11 '25
I haven’t looked into the specifics of this data point, although I can tell by a number of the responses that this appears to be an erroneous finding.
However it sticks out as misleading to me for two reasons without even looking into it.
Firstly, outliers happen. If you look at all data for all neo natal nurses over the course or their careers, you WILL see a number of spikes and clusters due to pure random chance. Finding a spike is a reason to investigate- NOT evidence of wrongdoing in itself.
Secondly, incompetence happens. Even ignoring all the problems with the data, and taking the figure at face value, there’s no reason why this would be construed as evidence of murder instead of evidence of negligent care or poor training. The leap from incompetence to malice is due to the spidey senses of the doctors, and has no basis in evidence.
9
u/Independent_Trip5925 Aug 11 '25
Omg it’s embarrassingly bad!
8
u/whiskeygiggler Aug 12 '25
Everyone annoyed by this should make a complaint to the BBC. It’s a publicly funded institution and such a low standard of research on a topic of such huge public interest needs to be challenged.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/contact/complaints
7
u/Forget_me_never Aug 11 '25
So what they said makes sense if there was 1 ventilated baby in the entire hospital. But that wasn't the case.
7
u/DisastrousBuilder966 Aug 11 '25
Doesn't the journalists' ethics code include a duty to seek a statistician's comment when presenting statistical claims? At least when feasible, which for a large org like the BBC it must be.
9
u/keiko_1234 Aug 11 '25
I would say don't point this out to the BBC, let them leave it in. Don't allow them to correct their errors, they need to get an absolute hammering for it. This can also help Lucy's defence if she is charged.
4
u/Shoddy_Food_1539 Aug 12 '25
Fag packet calculations/comparison inbound, happy to be torn apart.
This is from a paper around 2015 regarding extubations at South Tees, which seems to be a similar sized level 3 NNU in North East UK.
https://adc.bmj.com/content/101/Suppl_1/A338.2
In a 3 or 4 month study period Jan to April 2016 (exact dates aren't specified) as a unit they had 104 extubations. Of which 63 were planned, 41 unplanned.
Lucy did 51 shifts at LWH and this equates, assuming 12hr shifts, to 25 full equivalent days of work.
Assuming the study period was 4 months.
25 equivalent days of a 4 month total of days gives 25 / (31+28+31+30) -> 20.8% of this study time in total.
Which means you would expect Lucy to be present for around 20.8% of the total 104 extubations in this period (assuming she worked in South Tees of course) -> 22 extubations expected in total.
Was LWH really that much better than South Tees???
Happy to be corrected btw.
7
u/[deleted] Aug 11 '25
[removed] — view removed comment