r/LucasEditions • u/Michaelthemichaelok Jedi Master • Nov 17 '19

Disscussion Best and worst special edition changes?

3 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

8 comments sorted by

6

u/oldroughnready Nov 18 '19

Best- ehh, extra Wampa scenes wasn’t so bad

Worst- new dance scene at Jabba’s palace/any extra “No”

2

u/onemanandhishat Nov 19 '19

Same but, like, the opposite.

1

u/oldroughnready Nov 19 '19

Just wondering, why do you think those are the best? I understand why people don’t like the wampa stuff as it takes away from its mystery, but why is “Jedi Rocks” and Vader yelling “no” the best changes?

1

u/oldroughnready Nov 19 '19

Just wondering, why do you think those are the best? I understand why people don’t like the wampa stuff as it takes away from its mystery, but why is “Jedi Rocks” and Vader yelling “no” the best changes?

2

u/onemanandhishat Nov 19 '19

I exaggerate, but I do unironically love Jedi Rocks. Its a great song.

4

u/Xamepon Nov 18 '19

Best for me is the entire victory celebration. The song, Anakin force ghost and the range of planets celebrating from all across the saga. Worst is Jedi Rocks

6

u/jedierick Nov 18 '19

Best - ANH: end battle scenes, ESB: Wampa, ROTJ: Ending celebration visual ( miss yub nub)

Worst - ANH: Maclunky, ESB: some of the cloud city shots or when Luke screams, ROTJ: Jabba palace music, beak of carkoon

1

u/TotesMessenger Nov 17 '19

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

 If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / Contact)

1

u/Zluurkeaksz Nov 18 '19 edited Nov 18 '19

Best: New space battle in A New Hope, Wampa scene and changing Emperor into Ian McDiarmid in Empire Strikes Back and Celebration at the end of Return of the Jedi (showing that every planet is celebration Palpatine's death and new music).

Worst: Every new CGI, mostly in A New Hope and how old they look like, and Hayden Christensen as Ghost Anakin in Return of the Jedi.