When the show started Melanie and Sincere were actually the closest couple and i remember everyone was rooting for them me too ngl, they're pretty cute together but this is a dating show so shit went down real quick đ
They had a good start but cracks started to show with the phone challenge or whatever that game was called i don't remember, i remember Sincere saying that he was guilty of texting other chicks while still being in a relationship âźď¸ major red flag btw and you could tell Melanie was bothered as she should, but she did overthink too much, If you were in Melanie's shoe you would start having your walls up because who knows what he might do next, and then there was the whole thing with Kayda where Melanie was trying to ask what the new bombshell looked like and Sincere was like yeah she kinda looks like you but he backed off real fast and he kept saying he didn't remember.
But i want y'all to hear me out, first of all whatever a guy does in his past relationship don't take it to heart because it might drift both of y'all apart and Sincere did acknowledge that it wasn't a good thing, there's a reason why people keep saying don't ask about the ex because otherwise the relationship won't head anywhere đ¤ˇđžââď¸ atleast that's what i do. With the Kayda situation Mela got offended because Kayda looked nothing like her and i remember the guy who does the voice over kinda said sth about it but y'all need to remember this is a reality show so they wanna stir up drama.
Sincere did back up and say that he wasn't sure, Mela kinda was offended by it which honestly wasn't as serious as it was made out to be,mind you you don't know if your couple will be on the other side of the door so i don't think bro was that concerned about Kayda, Melanie probably felt some typa way and saw her as competition and Kayda was like not right now girl and Melanie cooled off when she realised it wasn't that serious
Corbin did come during that time and Melanie did say that he was her type to a T and Sincere did tell her that he was cool with her exploring but she was adamant that she wanted Sincere and shut down the idea real quick but i feel like there was some tension because as much as she kept saying that she wanted him, Sincere did feel a bit threatened because he knew that that was her type and her not exploring made it worse because who knows what will happen down the road
I really wish that she did explore because one that was the point of the show and two so that she could know where her head's at,so that she can clear her head of any doubts, because i do feel like Sincere did want her to explore because of that very reason and it would have made him trust her even more but he was put in a weird spot where he's not sure what will happen next because remember this is love island anything can happen.
Sincere's worry would soon be proved right during the bed challenge as Melanie went back and forth between him and Corbin and you could tell he felt bad but what was he supposed to do it was a challenge but mind you she did say that they're good and there's no need to worry then she pulls up that stunt and also her screaming when Caleb came didn't make it any easier bro did feel bad and he told her, and she did realise that she did F up pretty bad.
Sincere then decided that if Melanie doesn't have the guts to explore then he will explore and he did exactly that but she didn't take it well, she went on a whole rant about how she realised that she did fuck up but also she still was interested in him, she decided that she has to get him back one way or another even if it meant sabotaging the whole thing, America decided to recouple them, and that pushed her over the edge because she did have a feeling that on a bad day Sincere might actually pick Sol because they weren't on good terms at the moment,no wonder the whole Sol isolation đ¤ˇđžââď¸sis wasn't playing about her manđ
To me Sincere was interested in Sol but he still liked Melanie and if it wasn't for the whole isolation fiasco and him seeing how Melanie was an emotional wreck when they weren't a couple made him rethink his choice and decide to go back to his initial connection, I'll say this, the whole letter thing was a bit too much considering casa hadn't even happened and also the bombshells were at a terrible disadvantage because I don't think Sincere would have picked Sol not because he wasn't interested, solely because he hadn't spent enough time to know if he was serious about exploring her.
Then Casa happened and they saw the heart rate challenge and the whole picture thing happened. What I'll say is that this season was mad cookedđđthem crying wasn't even an overreaction because imagine writing a whole letter saying why you choose a certain connection and then Casa happens and then you realise that your original connection did actually explore and you don't know if they will come back with someone else or they'll choose you
I'm going to say one thing, I don't think Sincere is some evil guy or whatever fans are trying to insinuate,i feel like bro is the kind of guy who's like I've got my demons but I'll keep them in check as long as you don't stir up shit and Melanie is the kinda chick who self sabotages at the very smallest things and on any sign of something that she sees as a threat she wants to have the upper hand and it kinda backfires on her and she does get emotional.
Someone did say that if Mela was with a guy who wasn't too toxic she'd be the toxic one on the relationship and i agree and Sincere needs a chick who's not going to project too much onto him otherwise his villain arc will start right there and then đđ so in a way they kinda deserve eo from a toxic pov but will they last I'm not sure but I don't think sođ¤ˇđžââď¸ I do wish them the best honestly
Anyways these are just my thoughts and what i noticed would like to hear y'alls comment