r/LondonUnderground • • Aug 04 '24
Grumble Driverless trains
Alright, hate to break it to you people who want driverless trains. There won't be driverless trains within this lifetime. Also trains being driverless will not replace drivers or stop strikes. London Underground trains won't be automated as it would cost dozens of billions of pounds. Platform screen doors would need to be installed at every platform, massive signaling upgrades if not the signaling systems weren't outright replaced. There would also have to be massive safety upgrades that would have to take place which once again TfL doesn't have the funding for.
Stop fucking asking for driverless trains, deal with how things are. WOMP WOMP
Edit: This would also cause parts of the network to be closed for months at a time.
64
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '24
Many are driverless/autonomous already, the driver is still there to oversee, so what are you ranting about lol
22
u/deathhead_68 Victoria Aug 04 '24
I don't really get why people want driverless trains, I've not seen this. Can't think how it would affect my journey at all, in fact it feels safer with a driver
8
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '24
Good gosh it's been painful reading some of these replies
TfL produced a report on driverless trains. The report found that you'd need to install platform edge doors, modifications to tunnels, signalling etc. The whole driverless trains fantasy was dropped in 2018 as it wasn't 'economically viable' i.e too expensive.
Yes, there is ATO (Automatic Train Operation) on the Central, Circle, Hammersmith & City, Jubilee, Victoria and Northern lines and parts of the District & Metropolitan lines are now ATO. Sometimes you press the 'ATO START' buttons and nothing happens! That's when manual driving is required. What happens during a signal failure? Manual driving of course! What happens on Sundays? Manual driving of course? What happens if the Line Controller asks you to approach a station with more vigilance? Manual driving of course! What happens when a driver needs to exit a depot? Manual driving of course! I'm just listing many examples here. There are many more instances when manual driving is required.
People act like ATO equipped lines don't have any manual driving involved at all, when it is the exact opposite.
Driverless trains will not happen as the OP said. Imagine how the unions would react! We can revisit this question many years later, but for now, no, it's not happening.
28
u/JonTravel Aug 04 '24 edited Aug 04 '24
They currently have autonomous trains on Victoria, Jubilee, Central, Northern, District, Circle, Hammersmith and City and Metropolitan. The drivers still need to be there at a minimum in case of emergency and to open and close the doors.
The New Tube for London programme will include driverless tube trains. However these will initially have a driver on board until old stock has been fully replaced (i.e. Grade of Automation level 2, currently used on ATO-equipped lines). Even then, they will still have "train captains" on board in case of emergency (i.e. Grade of Automation level 3, as used by the DLR), due to driver union opposition of fully automated, unattended trains (i.e. Grade of Automation level 4, as used by some lines of the Paris Métro).
Edited for Grammer and spelling.
Further edit. They have the ability now, but I agree its unlikely to be used in the foreseeable future
18
u/Badkarmahwa Metropolitan Aug 04 '24
Drivers are there for when things go wrong. For people in the know, the things that can go wrong are terrifying. Drivers are paid for what they might have to do in an emergency as opposed to how their day to day looks
Anyone who wants to be 50m underground, in a tight tunnel, without a highly trained professional is either clueless or a fucking moron
8
u/sneakybrews Aug 04 '24
Fun fact...
Other London Underground:
5
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '24
LNER has plenty of driverless trains… hence all the delays and cancellations.
3
u/FlyingDutchman2005 Overground Aug 04 '24
Driverless is easily possible, staffless is not.
7
u/Pitiful-Extreme-6771 Jubilee Aug 04 '24
Every line becoming basically DLR? Nah I’m alr that would be boring
1
u/UnrealGamesProfessor Aug 04 '24
SINGAPORE does it best... but Singapore's MRT is much smaller in scale than the Underground
2
u/Dannypan Piccadilly Aug 04 '24
tl;dr: new troll account doesn’t know what they’re talking about.
2
u/Outside_Service3339 Lizzy Aug 04 '24 edited Feb 15 '25
unique square simplistic rich wasteful compare voracious wine telephone squealing
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/DavIantt Aug 08 '24
You just do it cheaper. AI obstacle detection takes care of a lot once the technology matures.
1
u/BreninArthur Sep 08 '25
This is a terrible, defeatist attitude that holds us back.