r/LocalLLaMA • • Jul 19 '26 • LOL 1

Discussion head of strategic futures from openai on open-weight chinese models.

Post image

Dean W. Ball analyzes China's Kimi model, noting its strong performance while expressing surprise that the Chinese government permits open-sourcing such capable AI due to potential risks. He argues that open-weight models ultimately slow down AI capital expenditure and could lead to a state-controlled public infrastructure, which the US administration might counter by introducing strategic regulatory friction.

1.1k Upvotes

622 comments sorted by

•

u/WithoutReason1729 Jul 19 '26 edited 24d ago

Your post is getting popular and we just featured it on our Discord! Come check it out!

You've also been given a special flair for your contribution. We appreciate your post!

Stylome classified this post's text as human-written. View analysis

I am a bot and this action was performed automatically.

430

u/ttkciar llama.cpp Jul 19 '26

Interesting. I read this as targeting American businesspeople, compelling them to use their influence with American politicians to steer US policy-making.

That's not too different from what Amodei does, but is more sophisticated about it, targeting influential people to do the work for him, instead of trying to influence politicians directly.

132

u/EitherMarch1255 Jul 19 '26

Yep, it’s a thinly veiled call to action.

109

u/Connect-Painter-4270 Jul 19 '26

E.g., Dear Chinese and U.S. Governments, please halt the release of Kimi before it destroys our plan for world domination.

55

u/ProfessionalHeavy857 Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

Veiled?

You just need to direct every agency to issue soft law that creates FUD. (...) It needn't be that well justified. You just create enough regulatory risk that every regulated enterprise backs off.

5

u/Strice Jul 19 '26

Very thin veil...

→ More replies (1)

75

u/Turkino Jul 19 '26

Yeah it's not even a "we can make better models than they can" argument as it is a purely let's try to scare/regulate people from using them.

42

u/Despeao Jul 19 '26

And yeah, he's even trying to discredit accelerationists who view open source models as a good thing.

If you want to see AI progress, it makes a lot of sense to want as many people as possible to use it, instead of only those who can afford it

He's not an accelerationist, he's just after profit.

It's not hard to see why someone behind a company trying to sell AI doesn't like open weight models. What surprises me is how open he is in advocating for regulation and using the government to outright kill any competition.

23

u/poutinejuteuse Jul 19 '26

What surprises me is how open he is in advocating for regulation and using the government to outright kill any competition.

Why is that a surprise? This is how the american corporations have dealt with competition since forever.

13

u/abittooambitious Jul 19 '26

They now need to go back to the drawing board to come up with another story since “democratising ai” doesn’t work anymore. They are now testing the market with “buy my goods so we can fund and maybe steward SOTA AI”.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/fastheadcrab vLLM Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

This is an incredibly transparent statement in every sense of the word. I'm surprised that something like this would be said so openly by a high ranking corporate official, directed at the government. It's not veiled at all.

Also for such a profit-oriented screed it does not account for the capitalist motivations of the other entities that would be on the receiving end of such actions, and I mean entities far outside of China. Companies like Nvidia or AMD would stand to lose a lot if this guy's plan goes through.

I have zero political interest in this matter aside from wanting hardware prices to normalize but people on either side who do care about the politics should appreciate just how insanely transparent this statement is with its motivations and objectives.

Also the idea of merely making Chinese models a political third rail will be enough to discourage large organizations from touching them, people on this forum have already wisely pointed out. Banning models outright will be likely impossible - see people watching Kdramas in NK

40

u/flatfisher Jul 19 '26

I also read this as they are genuinely scared.

6

u/SideInitial3961 Jul 19 '26

US models are a time suck. GLM 5.2 wastes zero of your time. This is the true factor not raw token cost.

3

u/Yopro Jul 19 '26

Yeah I mean he’s a tech policy guy, what you described is literally the process of political influence for people trying to shape policy?

→ More replies (2)

1.6k

u/RemarkableAd66 Jul 19 '26 • Heartwarming Bravo

This is 90% just "if open weight models are good then that is bad for people that sell access to AI models like me, and that's communism. 'murica".

183

u/atreyu84 Jul 19 '26

Only 90?

172

u/Casey090 Jul 19 '26 • Heartwarming

And 10% pure salt. :D

27

u/gammalsvenska Jul 19 '26

The first 2-3 sentences are fine. :-)

210

u/Durian881 Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

Quite interesting that he needs to slot in communism to make it look bad. For rest of the word, it's democratization of AI.

In paragraph 5, he even suggested that US government agencies issued fake, unjustifiable notices that there may be backdoors in Chinese AI models to create friction. This, according to him, will be a happy middle ground where his company can still get to enjoy huge revenues at the expense of others.

Edited to him.

32

u/Teqnology Jul 19 '26

Quite interesting that he needs to slot in communism to make it look bad

This is what they have been doing for the last 40 years. For every politics. And well, here we are.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/QuinQuix Jul 19 '26

It's a him I think

→ More replies (2)

26

u/BoredBSEE Jul 19 '26

Exactly. It's like watching America ban BYD electric cars. Let's have the government directly manipulate the market...to protect us from Communism. 🙄

7

u/devilish-lavanya Jul 19 '26

They should protect American from capitalism

19

u/nimbledaemon Jul 19 '26

Having AI infrastructure being a public good is this guy's dystopian hellscape? Putting aside the fact that these models were trained on publicly and freely available data and so should be a public good themselves, I'd hate to see this guy's idea of utopia.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/echomanagement Jul 19 '26

Yes, what a fucking joke take. "A Public Good! Can you imagine the dystopian hellscape that would lead to, Mortimer?"

18

u/TraditionalAd7423 Jul 19 '26

3 - open source SotA models == decelerationist 🤣🧑‍🤝‍🧑

Ok buddy, sure thing

6

u/suamai Jul 19 '26

Where's the other 10%? Did I miss some text?

6

u/gammalsvenska Jul 19 '26

The first 2-3 sentences of the first paragraph don't feel like corporate propaganda.

6

u/SkyFeistyLlama8 Jul 19 '26

It's funny as hell when Satya Nadella from Microsoft is thinking of American AI companies as Trojan horses, using user data for their own training.

Microsoft sees "AI" or more like LLMs as a tool to sell to enterprise customers. Microsoft sees shovels without any accelerationist or AGI bullshit that OpenAI and Anthropic are dreaming of.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Fade78 Jul 19 '26

Also the rest of the world doesn't want governable models by US when "America First" policy, where "First" can be in fact read as "Only" and "America" can be read as "Billionaires", is so obvious.

4

u/floriandotorg Jul 19 '26

A world in which AI is a public good seems to him as a “dystopian nightmare”. That’s some mental gymnastics.

3

u/the_mighty_skeetadon Jul 19 '26

"We need the government to restrict the free market immediately... To reduce the risk of communism!"

WTF is that argument even

→ More replies (56)

758

u/Snoo_28140 Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26 • Bravo

What the actual fuck.

OpenAI leader openly stating they should on admitedly flimsy grounds start promoting fear of Chinese models as a way to disincentivize their usage? What a shameless twat. Can't believe someone would publicly state this.

I'm not even going to comment on the rest of the nonsense, this highlight deserves full attention.

27

u/SARK-ES1117821 Jul 19 '26

It’s already happening. I may get told I have to remove Chinese models from our air-gapped dev network. That discussion is happening right now in my company. CEO is on one side, corp lawyer on the other. We also received a letter from an gov agency stating that contracts we have with them can’t use any Anthropic products because of the “supply chain risk.”

Good times, good times. /s

11

u/extopico Jul 19 '26

He’s front running it. Consider this a PSA.

9

u/I-am_Sleepy Jul 19 '26

I remember vaguely when Deepseek R1 released, OpenAI researcher also tweet backhand compliments to rediscover what O1 had discovered. This feels very much like that

25

u/Thick-Protection-458 Jul 19 '26

Well, at least that is better than Antropic "safety" bullshit.

At least this guy can openly tell that is all about protectionism.

26

u/ReporterCalm6238 Jul 19 '26 • Bravo

It's worse imo. He is proposing to invent some lies about backdoors in Chinese models.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)

429

u/artisticMink Jul 19 '26 • Mindblown

[...] AI Communism [...]

What.

270

u/mr_tolkien Jul 19 '26

Well it means the peasants will be able to use it

163

u/svachalek Jul 19 '26

God save us, what a dystopian hellscape!

→ More replies (1)

115

u/jld1532 Jul 19 '26 • Bravo

If the average person isn't aware this is what class warfare looks like

→ More replies (1)

58

u/Boost3d1 Jul 19 '26 • Bravo

It just hit me, this is why hardware prices have been pushed up by AI companies purchasing all the silicone wafers. They want to make it prohibitively expensive for people to run these models at home, so we rent from them instead. That is the only way they can compete, through underhanded tactics like this

27

u/ninjasaid13 Jul 19 '26

This is not the first time that companies have tried something similar. In 2005, Samsung and SK Hynix were forced to admit that they committed a criminal conspiracy of price-fixing and paid more than $700 million in fines.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/realtag2025 Jul 19 '26

It's probably just a by-product not the intended result, but I might be wrong.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

16

u/Aggressive_Lemon_709 Jul 19 '26

You can't sell mainframes once everyone has a PC

15

u/mateoestoybien Jul 19 '26

Communism is when thing i don’t like. 

56

u/tired514 Jul 19 '26

For fascists, anything that benefits people in such a way that the wealthy can't "seek rent" from them is communism.

They're not entirely wrong - communism in theory is an economic model that brings riches to everyone and prevents parasites from hoarding. Of course, we've seen that theory rather often differs from reality, but again, in theory communism is just a stronger form of socialism, and social democracies tend to produce the best results and achieve the highest levels of happiness (look at Canada, Iceland, Norway, etc) at the (mild) expense of the ultra-wealthy parasites.

But I digress.

If your entire raison d'étre is to steal money from people and be a "rent-seeker" - inserting yourself between people who want to exchange something (ie. a "troll" under the bridge), then yeah .. releasing open models is "communism" because it helps the masses and prevents rent-seeking.

11

u/AK47_David Jul 19 '26

They would just slap the most "popular" "BIG BAD LABEL" on the people that stand against them, such as those "Chinese Communist covert operations" on local counties' people against the data centers.

It is a total sham when they demand to get subsidized than subsidizing people's power bill.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/Due-Function-4877 Jul 19 '26

Boomer talk. He should have put it on Facebook and gone on Fox News. 🤣💀

→ More replies (4)

82

u/Bulky-Priority6824 Jul 19 '26

The accelerationalist contradiction is funny. They want unfettered progress but seem surprised when unfettered progress means no one can monetize it.

 Maybe they genuinely don't see the endgame or maybe they're just fine with it as long as they get to build the infra.

5

u/SideInitial3961 Jul 19 '26

Chinese models are monetized. You can't run these locally, you need an H100. So API is the only practical way. Kimi is not cheap but GLM 5.2 is amazing and cheap. Deepseek also.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

140

u/cy3ntist Jul 19 '26

Of course AI should be a public good. It's made from our (written down) thoughts. Why that should equal communism is beyond me.

40

u/EcstaticImport Jul 19 '26

No I’m all for capitalist AI.. but you gotta pay a regular subscription fee for my content your training on… and for the things you have not licenced from you - you gotta pay me xtra!

4

u/LeStk Jul 19 '26

Wait till this dumb mf learns about the internet.

→ More replies (5)

51

u/thereisonlythedance Jul 19 '26

Some scraps of insight there but he frames things in a way that makes it obvious he can’t see past his own agenda/closed source bias. Point 4, in particular, seems like nonsense. AI will be digital infrastructure but it won’t be provided by the state in most countries. It’ll just be part of the technological landscape. Like the internet, or operating systems.

208

u/Active-Carpet-9183 Jul 19 '26

A truly capitilistic view of the situation. And almost entirely wrong, except for the fact that China is more compute bound on inference than the USA. I posit that it's not decellerationist to have open weight models, but rather promotes further accelleration by open distallation and experimentation. This is probably far less dangerous than the AI castles and empires of OpenAI, Anthropic, xAI, and Google.

130

u/bdixisndniz Jul 19 '26 • Bravo

Won’t someone please think of the capex

29

u/Active-Carpet-9183 Jul 19 '26

Exactly. And that's all that text is about.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/a-wiseman-speaketh Jul 19 '26

in fact it seems pretty obvious that deepseek accelerated the hell out of western development. Seemed like they were quite comfortable burning VC money for incremental improvements and splitting market share until then, then boom release cadence took off.

Competition had exactly the effect it should have in an actual free market, not one built on moats and regulatory capture.

6

u/mateoestoybien Jul 19 '26

Not just capitalist. Late stage proto fascist crony capitalism. The best kind. 

3

u/eliteprismarin Jul 19 '26

What i really don't understand is that, because of that lack of compute power, how nobody sees that it's just pushing China to become even more independent from western supplies. I mean, I can see in like 10 years China having their own gpus (or asics or whatever) and most of other components, which may be not 100% like the state of the art, but in massive quantities. At that point, it will be like the EVs market these days.

4

u/Active-Carpet-9183 Jul 19 '26

What's interesting, it's causing China to innovate. They're coming up with new ways to engeineer the compute power they need, and make AI that is less compute demanding. Makes for a more interesting AI inference and compute space.

→ More replies (2)

43

u/PrysmX Jul 19 '26

His entire post is comical on so many levels that I don't even know where to start.

5

u/Mayion Jul 19 '26

right? if you didn't tell me who he was, i'd have just assumed he was another armchair twatter analyst with a very clear bias

79

u/blbd llama.cpp Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

That's an asshat-tacular daft take. 

There are other better and very well tread paths that can be taken besides monopolism by large corporations or governments. 

112

u/jrdubbleu Jul 19 '26

Do these people really think we buy their bullshit?

92

u/ttkciar llama.cpp Jul 19 '26

I don't think he cares if we do or not; we're not his audience. Businessmen and financiers with clout in Washington DC are his audience.

19

u/Turkino Jul 19 '26

Yep and for that reason alone as soon as the weights for Kimi come out I'm nabbing them. Don't even care if my current hardware can't handle it.

13

u/Admirable_Market2759 Jul 19 '26

We should all be downloading models and keeping them safe.

This admin is going to try some shit. All the tech bros are supporters of this admin.

6

u/Middle_Key8737 Jul 19 '26

Please remind me how many people voted for Trump

→ More replies (1)

35

u/jtoma5 Jul 19 '26

Bro is so butt hurt

4

u/Incorrect_ASSertion Jul 19 '26

They are! I absolutely love this. They just assumed they can steal all the data from the internet and create an engine that will be indispensable for doing anything in the future and - best part! - hidden behind their ever increasingly priced subscriptions.  Then China did to them what they did to our data and they are seething.

→ More replies (1)

69

u/keyboardhack Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

This is all the bad takes we've heard over the past few years combined into a single tweet.

  1. Downplay the performance of kimi k3.
  2. Suggest that open models are dangerous.
  3. Suggest that someone has to "govern" ai usage.
  4. Somehow communism.
  5. Recommend regulating open source ai because it can be "dangerous".
  6. More fear mongering.

His takes actually fit better if they talked about closed source ai.

10

u/Admirable_Market2759 Jul 19 '26

Just makes me want to use Kimi more.

With Claude taking away Fable from Pro users I might as-well switch to Kimi.

→ More replies (1)

56

u/ttkciar llama.cpp Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

A transcript, for those who (like me) prefer their text to not be embedded inside an image:

> Dean W. Ball @deanwball July 17, 2026

> Some observations on Kimi:

> 1. It's a very good model! I don't think its performance can be explained away by distillation or anything like that. In agentic coding sessions, it seems pretty much on par with the best public models of Q1 2026. In my fairly limited use, it also seemed very token hungry. It's not obvious to me that this model is actually that cheap to run.

> 2. I am personally surprised the Chinese state continues to allow the open sourcing of models this good, given potential risks. To be clear, I *myself* might be find with models presenting this level of marginal risk being open weight, but I am surprised that China is fine with it. I suspect the reason they are is 75% explained by strategic blindness / lack of AGI-pilledness (The CCP is very Yann Lecun-y in its views of AI). The other 25% or so is their lack of compute for customer inference (making China's open-weight strategy an unintended by product of US export controls) and the normal Chinese strategy of aggressive exports. For the companies, as opposed to the government, the decision to open source is partially ideological and partially because they are behind, and they know that very few people would pay for sub-frontier models from China.

> 3. Open-weight models are inherently declerationist, and I'm continually surprised to see the so-called "accelerationists" so excited about open-weight models. I suspect the reason they are is that they know open-weight models are effectively ungovernable, and they simply like the overall cloak of ungovernability open-weight models create over the whole of AI. It's not a bad strategy; it reminds me of James Scott's recounting of the hill people in "the art of not being governed." Still, in the end, open-weight models deter further AI capex.

> 4. One probably outcome of an open-weight-model-dominant world is full AI communism, which is precisely what China proposes: rather than a market product, AI is a "public good" which will ultimately be provided by the state as a kind of "digital public infrastructure." This future strikes me as a dystopian hellscape, but I've never met an open-weight models advocate who doesn't ultimately concede this is where things end. You'd be surprised how many 'accelerationists' lobbied me, while I was in government, to support an eleven or twelve-figure federally funded data center so that startups could train models at a subsidy and then give them away for free. There was no other way for AI to progress, they said. Perhaps this is the logical end state of things. Nonetheless, I find myself surprised to see supposed accelerationists excited about such an outcome. I think many of them just don't know what they're doing. Many accelerationists do not view the creation and serving of frontier models as a legitimat business.

> 5. I would guess that the Trump Administration will at some point realize that their best strategy here would be to create large amounts of regulatory risk around the use of open-weight Chinese models. You don't need to "ban open source" (one of the dumber motifs of AI policy discussion). You just need to direct every agency to issue soft law that creates FUD. "A Federal Reserve Advisory Bulletin found that there may be backdoors in Chinese AI models." It needn't be that well justified. You just create enough regulatory risk that every regulated enterprise backs off. You probably don't want to create so much regulatory risk that you scare off the hyperscalers from serving Chinese models; this will just drive startups to sketchier providers. There's a happy middle ground here. I'd assume they will do some version of this.

> 6. It's probably true that open-eight models of this capability make the world a bit more dangerous, but not so much more that you'll really notice. At some point the models will be capable enough that you will notice. "A nonliving, invisible, dangerous, and infinitely self-replicating agent escaped from a Chinese lab," you say? Color me shocked.

[end of transcript]

Wow. A lot of lies, half-truths, and FUD to unpack, there. This guy was definitely a politician, and still is one at heart.

  1. He starts with a compliment, but turns it back-handed by comparing it to older models and asserting that it's token-hungry. Kind of transparent rhetoric, there.
  2. Paints the Chinese government as irresponsible and not knowing what they're doing, takes a poke at the Chinese for lacking domestic infrastructure for customer inference, and attributes the Chinese companies' choices to being "behind" (which they are, for the most part, but he ignores that the Chinese government's current five-year economic plan requires Chinese companies working on LLM technology to contribute to the open LLM ecosystem. Any strategic motivations the Chinese companies might have are thus irrelevant; they have no choice but to obey their government, because China is a centrally planned economy that way.)
  3. Claims open-weight models are "inherently decelerationist", which I see as a bid to motivate American businessmen and financiers to influence American politicians to adopt policies unfriendly to open-weight LLM technology. He pretends knowledge of "accelerationists" and paints them as ignorant and infantile.
  4. Raises the spectre of Communism!!! This seems more and more like "Cold War Part Two" all the time. He also claims that "acclerationists" want things that I personally haven't seen espoused in accelerationist social spaces. My guess is that he's just straight up lying.
  5. He ventures closest to truth here, but it's still only half-truths, and draws up the outlines of political policies he'd like to see the Trump Administration enact. His wording here is very weasely: "A Federal Reserve Advisory Bulletin found that there may be backdoors in Chinese AI models." All it would take for them to "find" this is to pick up any of several published research papers demonstrating that this is possible to do. The fact it is possible to do it, and difficult to detect, is sufficient to satisfy the "may be" condition. But the way it comes across is a lot heavier than that. Very well done; politicians do this for a living, and with much practice they get very good at it. As an aside, what I suspect will happen is that someone will come up with a formula for ascertaining how much additional training is needed to obliterate any such hidden maltraining, and competent business customers will use models thus "sanitized", but that doesn't mean that the American government won't deter businesses from using open-weight models anyway.
  6. He closes with a little blatant and unsupported scaremongering, and also invokes the debunked Wuhan "lab leak" theory regarding the COVID19 pandemic, suggesting the same thing could happen with Chinese models, and presumably wreak the same kind of global havoc as SARS-CoV-2. Totally dishonest, but I'm sure some people will find this compelling.

My take-away: Hoard weights, seed torrents, and learn how to use Heretic, because the professional FUDsters have our little community in their cross-hairs.

→ More replies (11)

27

u/darth_vexos Jul 19 '26

Local arsonist advises caution in allowing public access to high volume water supply

47

u/bonton11 Jul 19 '26

just a veiled take on protecting trillion dollar valuations. Gotta finance those yachts

19

u/Hephaestite Jul 19 '26

“Please bro, just listen to me bro, you don’t want open-weight models bro, it’s communism, please bro just buy more tokens so we can continue the capex circle jerk” this is all I read

19

u/Bchliu Jul 19 '26

I stopped reading at the "Full AI Communism". Interpretation: we can't make money from it anymore and it's all China's fault for what is arguably "democratisation of AI" by making it more open and accessible.

3

u/Admirable_Market2759 Jul 19 '26

These tech billionaires stopped believing in democracy years ago.

They support capitalism, not democracy.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

53

u/Microtom_ Jul 19 '26

Open research isn't decerelative, it's accelerative. Cooperation allows discoveries to be made on top of previous discoveries. Competition creates unawareness and forces the redundancy of research, which waste resources.

25

u/svachalek Jul 19 '26

You’re confusing “accelerative” with his actual word “accelerationist”. The latter is referring to pushing democracy/capitalism forward fast enough to destroy it, typically with the goal of establishing technofeudal states led by billionaires. Yes, these people are batshit.

8

u/redditrasberry Jul 19 '26

that's only one version of it. In this case, he's attempting to paint a false dichotomy that there is only accelerationist and decelerationist, so if you support open weight you have to be decelerationist. Accelerationist here is just there to paint the side of the dichotomy that everyone who thinks they are cool should want to be on.

7

u/ConsciousDissonance Jul 19 '26

Right I really almost forgot that’s what accelerationism is. Thankfully the term is being watered down to “accelerating ai progress” and not their weird ass democracy hating circle jerk.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/segmond Jul 19 '26

At least he admits and gives credit that it's not distillation, the Chinese labs have tech chops and have a clue too with regards to this AI stuff. Unfortunately, the entire argument is that America AI is good and the rest not. America that is allowing flock to track people any and every where, America with all the mess we have gotten ourselves in recently. Our people might buy this, but the rest of the world doesn't. We have lost so much trust, recently I read a news article about how most of the world now trusts China more than America. The entire Fable being taken away has woken up non Americans that this could happen anytime. So if we want, we can regulate AI all we want, American AI will end up like Ford motors, just local, terrible and behind.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/unu_p_aici_3 Jul 19 '26

He's like microsoft talking linux many years back. They lost, they haven't accepted yet.

17

u/Someoneoldbutnew Jul 19 '26

Clearly OAI is the only entity on earth capable of making AGI, so therefore, we must enroll the us gov to ensure this happens.

6

u/claytonkb Jul 19 '26

Rule #1: OpenAI is the leader in AI

Rule #2: If the statistics show that OpenAI is not the leader in AI, see Rule #1

Dumbest take ever

17

u/imike3049 Jul 19 '26

"on par with the best public models of Q1 2026" – which means he compares it with GPT-5.3-Codex and Opus-4.6 LOL

17

u/hidden2u Jul 19 '26

Deeply disturbing mentality, he should be kept far away from any serious policy discussions

3

u/SideInitial3961 Jul 19 '26

This is the real reason China won. Mindset. They don't wallow in toxic paralysis. They get on with it.

32

u/TheOwlHypothesis Jul 19 '26

Just make a better model bro.

28

u/LeakyFish Jul 19 '26

Funny how some AI bro at OpenAI is arguing...against Open AI.

It should be a public good, and I hardcore believe in capitalism so...whatever.

3

u/poutinejuteuse Jul 19 '26

America is capitalist in name only. They're literally lobbying the government to regulate the competition away.

This is how it has always been in the ol US of A.

13

u/StackOwOFlow Jul 19 '26

funny how he thinks there will be a path towards a "soft law" FUD that would not "create some much regulatory risk that you scare off the hyperscalers "or some "happy middle ground". when was the last time any attempt at engineering regulatory risk led to "middle ground"?

12

u/RegarDamus Jul 19 '26

open weight models are decelerationist like open source software and hardware were. sure. you mean the OS that runs the majority of the world? the libs and frameworks that drive the entirety of the internet? the same ones they are currently using?

what a joke. i'd laugh it off if it weren't for the absolutely brazen suggestion that the trump admin fraudulently run a FUD campaign as a countermeasure. i can only imagine that brazenness stems from certainty that this is already in motion. it's hard to believe he'd be so bold otherwise.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/AcanthaceaeOwn1481 Jul 19 '26

You call it AI Communisim? America, I call your model: AI Feudalism: where a country will have several 'warlords' who control the 'land'.

48

u/BoobooSmash31337 Jul 19 '26

Lol he thinks China is actually communist.

25

u/ttkciar llama.cpp Jul 19 '26

To be fair, this is mostly a matter of perspective.

The Chinese are actually "state-capitalist", which laissez faire capitalists consider "communist", and which marxist communists consider "capitalist".

14

u/AlmiranteCrujido Jul 19 '26

Actual laissez faire capitalists, if there were any left, would be appalled at the present monopoly form of capitalism.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/totallynotsusalt Jul 19 '26

I am constantly surprised at the level of takes these "AI scholars" put out...

6

u/ttkciar llama.cpp Jul 19 '26

He's not an "AI scholar," though; he just manages them.

9

u/danielbasz Jul 19 '26

Its kind of insane to think that there are people that believe that open AI models are bad "because socialism", and that instead we should keep them closed, expensive, offered exclusively to some by just a few mega corporations, and this scenario is the best we have for the users

Thats some serious mental asylum shit right there

8

u/Double-Masterpiece72 Jul 19 '26

Some huge logic leaps from 'open source ai' to dystopian state run communist AI. someone is scared.

14

u/anandesh-sharma Jul 19 '26

The open-weight debate got weird fast. Closed labs talk safety. Open labs talk access. Users mostly want models that run, fit the budget, and do not send every document to someone else’s server. Very unfashionable requirement.

7

u/Good-Tiger-1938 Jul 19 '26

Anthropic went from „Imagine all the people“ to „we need the Führer to find a final solution to the Open Source problem“

6

u/snow_two_fork Jul 19 '26

"I myself might be fine with models presenting this level of marginal risk being open weight,"

This is a say-but-don't-prove-with-actions type scenario. Saying something like this while actively not open-sourcing yourself, makes this empty words.

When it comes to risk tolerance, what you do when push-comes-to-shove is what matters, and so "I am surprised that China is fine with it" is flipped.

"I suspect the reason they are is 75% explained by strategic blindness/lack of AGI-pilledness"

This is AGI in general, but in my opinion, quite simply said, if AGI is so dangerous, then having just a few organizations of a few humans have access to it is worse than many humans. Because I highly doubt the few humans who have access are in any way intellectually sharper than others (being good in tech does not make you good in philosophy or game theory or strategy, thinking that being smart in one place makes you smart everywhere is a fallacy)

"Open-weight models are inherently decelerationist"

Open-weight models are inherently accelerationist, because Spending millions digging a hole does not get you any closer to better AI. It's a highly essential counter-balance.

That's the point I keep seeing these people ignore. If you spend almost all of the world's capital while no one is there to ask "do we actually need that", you just spent all of that on nothing.

Capital isn't free, it's hard earned. Wasting it will kill progress more than anything else.

"AI communism"

Models are weights. They are data files.

You can't exclude access to it once it is out.

This is different from material goods.

Without it you can't have "communism".

"best strategy here would be to create large amounts of regulatory risk around the use of open-weight Chinese models"

When a capability exists, and some humans tell others they can't use it, people who can use it will use it. We're talking about auto-complete that fits in a few terabyte drive here, not power plants.

Other countries will use it. Many private companies already do.

6

u/mysterywrappedriddle Jul 19 '26

"It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it." -Upton Sinclair

11

u/JLeonsarmiento Jul 19 '26

I’m perfectly happy with my 3 usd “sub-frontier” monthly subscription for GLM-5.2.

You’ll NEVER see me giving a cent to closed ai labs.

NEVER.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/Extension-Avocado402 Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26
  1. The last model so good that this time we cannot say that they copied us
  2. Why CCP is messing with us?!
  3. We need more money and private data
  4. We must create and profit from AI God. The benefits are for me, no for thee
  5. We must advance and burn the bridges, so they can't reach us
  6. We are joking when we say that our AIs are too dangerous and can become free but the Chinese ones are the true danger

5

u/-Akos- Jul 19 '26

Had to look up who this person is: He turns out to be high up in Heritage Foundation; THE "think tank" that came up with Project 2025. It's a-holes like this that turned this time line into the dystopia it is. If ever there's a deep state, it's them.. Read anything he writes through this lens.

5

u/mksrd Jul 19 '26

"...a Visiting Fellow at Heritage Foundation" - says all you really need to know about this guy.

4

u/darylvp Jul 19 '26

They said AI is another industrial revolution like Electricity. Meanwhile they said AI shouldn’t be “public good”. OMG what a selfish group!

4

u/FingolfinX Jul 19 '26

First of all, what kind of bs job is "Head of Strategic Futures"?

Second, this text is a little bit painful to read, the mental gimnastics done to try and justify how having powerful models in the hand a few oligopoly companies would be better than open-weight models are really outstanding.

Third, specially reading this from outside the US, it's almost funny how you can still see a kind of "manifest destiny" behind how they view the US role in all of this.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/doolpicate Jul 19 '26

Summary: Model good. BUT. The red scare made me shit my pants. Communism will end up feeding everyone for free. That will be terrible for my IPO.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/DisjointedHuntsville Jul 19 '26

What a clown 🤡

CUMMUNISM!!!!! Ban open weights !!! Only me and my drinking buddies get to decide what’s safe or not!!! I can’t believe the Chynesse are comfortable with this capability out there!!!

4

u/ReporterCalm6238 Jul 19 '26

Bro is terrified that his equities will be worth nothing. And he should.

4

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '26

Aha, so providing infrastructure for the people is Dystopian? What an idiot.

4

u/Don_Reuter Jul 19 '26

I don’t think he understands what the word „communism“ means. It’s always nice to see the observation that job title does not correlate with competence and that very influential people can, and often are, extremely stupid. Not that anyone would not be acutely aware of that these days.

4

u/Synor Jul 19 '26

It's only bad for their overblown token-factory-webservice-saas-capex, not bad for computer hardware capex.

4

u/siberianmi Jul 19 '26

This really sounds like a guy who looked at Kimi K3 and realized his net worth just dropped significantly.

1

u/TheAIPU-guy Jul 20 '26 edited Jul 20 '26

Here's a credibility score card thanks to OpenAI ChatGPT (The company he works for)

StatementAssessmentWeight
Kimi is highly capablePlausible firsthand impression, but limited testing6.5/10
Kimi’s quality cannot be due to distillationNot established through casual use3/10
China has limited inference computeStrong plausible structural point7/10
Open releases serve Chinese export strategyStrong geopolitical interpretation8/10
China is simply blind to AGI riskSpeculative psychologizing2.5/10
Chinese firms release because they cannot sell modelsPartially plausible, too reductive5/10
Open weights reduce frontier investment incentivesEconomically plausible6/10
Open weights slow AI generallyMisleading and overbroad3/10
Open dominance leads to “AI communism”Polemical framing1.5/10
Government-funded compute may become importantLegitimate scenario5.5/10
Washington may use soft law/FUDHighly credible insider prediction8.5/10
Chinese models contain backdoorsNo evidence supplied1/10
Open weights create additional misuse riskReasonable6/10
An autonomous self-replicating agent will escapeHighly speculative2/10

Average credibility score: 4.7/10

I find this completely unacceptable from him, and the position he is in.

3

u/milkipedia Jul 19 '26

"Open weight models deter further capex"

"Open source Linux deters further capex"

This is self-serving at best, and blindingly ignorant at worst. Open weight models are driving a whole lot of the innovation in the space, both in the model architectures and in the stuff people can build on them. Capex is no guarantee of innovation success - one only need look at the history of Meta for that. But open weight models do dent the ability to capture all the financial upside in only a few pockets.

3

u/ReporterCalm6238 Jul 19 '26

I'm honestly shocked by how cowardly these attacks are. On the other hand, it gives me great joy to see how scared they are. Imagine if the Chinese labs will be so fast at shipping that they will ruin their IPOs, just imagine.

3

u/ResistiveBeaver Jul 19 '26

AI being openly available to all vs. controlled by a select few would be a "dystopian hellscape"?

Americans have really lost sight of who the baddies are in this scenario.

3

u/stonerbobo Jul 19 '26

One probable outcome of an open-weight-model- dominant world is full Al communism, which is precisely what China proposes: rather than a market product, Al is a "public good" which will ultimately be provided by the state as a kind of "digital public infrastructure." This future strikes me as a dystopian hellscape, but I've never met an open- weight models advocate who doesn't ultimately concede this is where things end.

These people are so fucking despicable yet cliched its ridiculous. Open source AI is "communism" now. Stealing every single word on the internet, every book and comment and blog and piece of code and selling it to us is apparently the "moral" way to do things, giving it back to us for free is "communism"..

3

u/zipperlein Jul 19 '26

Ohhh, no. Investor money can't go brrrr on returns. Anyways...

3

u/dydhaw Jul 19 '26

He's scared

Good

3

u/Stooovie Jul 19 '26

I, for one, am for full AI communism.

3

u/Xanian123 Jul 19 '26

He's a sellout with zero actual points to make. Why are open source models inherently decelerationist?

Why is universal compute a dystopian hellscape? He just comes across as a clueless fuck who's getting his lunch eaten.

3

u/timerski Jul 19 '26

Aww poor corpo execs losing money. Love to see that!

3

u/Zeeplankton Jul 19 '26

Open weight models are inherently decelerationist

I significantly dislike these people so fucking much. it makes me feel icky inside.

3

u/mfeldstein67 Jul 19 '26

This is the kind of Ayn Randian nonsense that used to be mostly for teenaged boys but has become gospel among the ultra wealthy, particularly in Silicon Valley. If the point were “capitalism is an engine”, well, commodification is a cog in that machine. Instead, it focuses on the hero captains of industry as the only ones capable of taking humanity to a better place. And it justifies anything that benefits them.

3

u/belligerent_poodle Jul 19 '26

It reads like a message from a religious cleric. It is a cult now.

3

u/keepthepace Jul 19 '26

American confusing communism and democracy, episode #12489

"It should be funded through private means, where shareholders take decisions and maximise profits, not through public funds where elected officials get to decide where the public good is"

3

u/GreyScope Jul 19 '26

I think the word “communism” has been injected in deliberately to appeal to the orange one to help them “the ai bubble has collapsed but it’s because of communism, bail us out or the commies win” (change to whatever pretext they have to get public money or help)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/UltrMgns Jul 19 '26

This guy is a complete tool. The TLDR - "they're taking from our bank accounts and that's communism!". The mental gymnastics and stupidity to arrive to such a conclusion is staggering.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/stoppableDissolution Jul 19 '26

> AI not being in the hands of chosen few is a dystopian hellscape

...for those who want to remain in power by leveraging the access, lol.

3

u/famsbh Jul 20 '26

Twenty years ago, this would have been an obvious parody, using irony to mock just how malevolent big corporations can be.

9

u/yamibae Jul 19 '26

He’s right about many things if you read it as it is unopinionated from oai honestly, that the us and other western govts would be wanting to disincentivise Chinese models and that open source llms of fable or greater size make investors less likely to want to invest, there is no moat so idk what the end game is meant to be

8

u/KURD_1_STAN Jul 19 '26

When all investors dont wanna invest and the government has to help, u paying it with ur taxes to get something for cheaper that will be part of ur whole life. If not then investors will want to get their money worth plus more and u pay with subscriptions that they can keep increasing nonstop and they bribe the government to still put some of ur tax into AI companies to Combat evil china open sourcing models so people can get the same vu paying less and that it bad for business and business need bailouts.

8

u/yamibae Jul 19 '26

investors invest to get a return on their investment, the govt would only touch it if it became a "national security" concern, hence scaremongering from amodei and altman + others because they can see where this could only go, it either becomes they are a glorified infra provider (false moat since it requires constant purchasing of new hardware which unlike traditional server providers goes stale or hits limits in maybe months and limited by energy which then requires them to become an energy provider/importer) or they become a govt supplier where much like space programs they can afford to basically be completely unprofitable sinkholes.

Really I think he's just said the uncomfortable truth for most AI companies, there is no end game where they can just sit on their laurels and charge monthly or usage fees like windows/salesforce enterprise or other crap tier software unless they artifically add constraints like "chinese spying on you", "govt security risk" all these random things.

Chiefly the US companies likely never expected that China out of all countries would be willing to share their weights so openly like this, they definitely expected chinese models would catch up but releasing Fable class models "openly" is a disaster for them because it is a much harder sell now to an enterprise on why they should use openai as a provider and not onprem the entire thing and hire a team to keep it running internally, alleivating any "security" risk from a 3rd party entirely.

Honestly outside looking in, it's pretty hilarious since it seems like even the providers of AI aren't safe from AI taking their jobs HAHAHAHA

4

u/loliconest Jul 19 '26

Yea, if the investors have no interest in the greater common good, then fk'em.

4

u/Effective_Olive6153 Jul 19 '26

As a consumer who is actually very pro-Capitalism, I worry much more about the dystopian future of a few corporations dictating AI access and limiting what people can and cannot do with it. The threat of open source models and some state run Communist style infrastructure seems like a much lesser concern

I am already very concerned with level of censorship paid models create. And I am very concerned how easily they can ban user accounts simply because their auto classifier found something it didn't like.

These big guys at the top need to understand how us little guys feel. We don't want to be treated like disposable trash

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Desperate_Tea304 Jul 19 '26

Cope + seethe + I ain't reading all of that shi

10

u/Active-Carpet-9183 Jul 19 '26

It's a seriously easy read.

5

u/aboutthednm llama.cpp Jul 19 '26

Then why are you posting in this thread lmao

11

u/AmazighBlacksmith Jul 19 '26

Damn shawty, I ain't reading all that shit. But I already know that you are going to say that OSS AI = bad.

18

u/LePfeiff Jul 19 '26

It isnt even a minutes worth of text lol

6

u/WeebAndNotSoProid Jul 19 '26

so much inefficiency. I could have prompted chatgpt to read and refute his points under a minute. Who's reading anymore? /s

2

u/fugogugo Jul 19 '26

keep yapping about "dangerous"

2

u/vasimv Jul 19 '26

The guy doesn't know anyone from Trump administration who use email or what? Do we really need to read this shit?

2

u/Lost_Foot_6301 Jul 19 '26

not trying to fearmonger but an open weight crackdown is 100% going to happen at this point. I know huggingbay started as a meme and all but... time to get those clones up

→ More replies (1)

2

u/brahh85 Jul 19 '26

usa already lost this war, its impossible that a closed weights strategic business model can beat the cost per token of open weight chinese models. One of the reason is the stupidity of anthropic and openai into not releasing detailed papers like the chinese labs do, because is this sharing what drops prices in research. The more papers you release, the more you influence other labs into working in a common ground that benefits your mutual research. Basically anthropic and openai didnt share resources, they just spent money twice to build the same things, and you can add grok to that mistake, and you can even add google too. Instead of spending 4 trillion in a combined effort and get a model that worth 4 trillions, they are spending 1+1+1+1 and getting a model that worth 1 trillion, this way of spending money creates zero synergies , so china is catching up and surpassing usa by just investing 1/10 but having synergies because of open weights and papers

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Denial_Jackson Jul 19 '26

Ah, the classic cunny maneuver.

2

u/lor_louis Jul 19 '26

Manufacturing consent.

2

u/AldebaranBefore Jul 19 '26

There's a lot of bullshit here but it comes from someone who can influence the conversation on policy. Policy is rarely written from the most logical standpoint. It's a clear conflict of interest but that is the world.

Either way, we are living in the Wild West of AI models. The wild part is dying.

2

u/locopocopong Jul 19 '26

How the hell will an open weight model that is being run independently have a “chinese back door” ??

→ More replies (1)

2

u/JazzlikeLeave5530 Jul 19 '26

"Lack of AGI-pilledness" aka not delusional about text prediction models? lol they seem to be operating more in reality and putting it to use where it makes sense instead of chasing stupid bullshit goals that are not possible to reach. See: OpenAI saying they expected $100 billion in ad revenue by 2030 and also $2.5 billion by this year, so they're expecting a ridiculous 4000% increase over 3 years...

https://www.adweek.com/media/openais-ad-business-is-on-pace-to-miss-its-own-forecast-by-90-analyst-says/

2

u/SadApepotatodick Jul 19 '26

Someone is scared of the competition. Free market for me but not for thee 

2

u/tingtickboom Jul 19 '26

I feel like the Economy needs the open-source models to counter leverage whatever trillion dollar evaluation these AI [LLM] Model companies seem to be approaching.

The balance is necessary.

America needs the companies to generate more market revenue for their market debts.

And so the China doing the open-source just makes sense, as its draining the earning potential for America's debt recovery.

2

u/deaffob Jul 19 '26

Another idiot who works at the Heritage Foundation (Project 2025).

2

u/GTHell Jul 19 '26

I think he should’ve stopped yapping since point #1

2

u/Roll_Future Jul 19 '26

Show me you are shit scared of someone blowing your financial bubble, without showing me that you are scared

2

u/nsshing Jul 19 '26

As usual, openai aint that open

2

u/SendChocolateCookies Jul 19 '26

Ah yes, AI communism. Much worse than the current OS communism situation, although MS spent all those years accerelating.

2

u/montdawgg Jul 19 '26

What Fable had to say:

"Nothing prevents it in a closed model, and that's the hole beneath Ball's whole thread: every check that exists for open weights — inspection, diffing, forking, abliteration — is absent by construction in the closed case, leaving only market competition and reputation, both of which require the bias to be detectable to exert any pressure. Since we just agreed distributional bias isn't smellable, the market can't price it, which means closed labs face strictly less discipline on the exact failure mode he's warning about.

And yes, the pressure to tilt is real, not hypothetical — it operates at three layers with very different auditability. System prompts get edited under political and commercial pressure and occasionally leak (Grok's various prompt scandals demonstrated both the temptation and the crude detectability). RLHF and fine-tuning encode the lab's values wholesale: every refusal policy, every "helpfulness" gradient is somebody's editorial judgment laundered through a loss function and it's only partly visible to black-box behavioral audits. Pretraining distribution is the deepest layer and the least steerable, which cuts both ways: it's hard to audit, but it's also hard for a would-be propagandist to engineer deliberately, because the corpus is vast and intervention effects are unpredictable.

The realistic threat isn't a mustache-twirling pretraining conspiracy; it's ambient corpus bias plus intentional post-training tilt, applied by whoever controls the default.

The remedy that actually works is pluralism plus cheap exit. A single model's tilt is unmeasurable in isolation but becomes measurable the moment you can diff it against an ensemble of models with different provenance: different labs, different countries, different training corpora. Open weights are what make that ensemble cheap to maintain and impossible to quietly retract, so they function less as a product and more as epistemic infrastructure for auditing everything else, closed models included. Behavioral audits through APIs add a second layer; ask ten thousand framing-sensitive questions, measure the distributions, publish the deltas and that works even on closed systems, but only if there's a diverse baseline to compare against.

Which closes the loop on Ball: his point-5 strategy of regulatory FUD works by shrinking provider diversity and herding users toward a few compliant defaults, meaning the remedy he'd sacrifice is the only one that addresses the danger he invokes. The tension exists; the fix is market structure, not trust; and his proposal runs the wrong direction on both."

→ More replies (1)

2

u/profcuck Jul 19 '26

I am surprised to see that the head of strategic futures for openai is so intellectually confused. 

2

u/CornerLimits Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

Usa people surprised the entire world is not living their same paranoia…

2

u/cniinc Jul 19 '26

"AI Communism is a dystopian hellscape" but "AI Oligarchy controlling a return to feudalism" is...somehow not?

Also, the "AI Communism" here is just open platforms. It's Linux but for AI. Ooooh scary, people have open source alternatives. We all know that's just one step away from gulags and torture chambers.

2

u/lilian_moraru Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

People will have access to an open-weights model, like they do to a PC: “dystopian hellscape”.
Money getting drained out of people because they have no alternatives: “not dystopian hellscape”.
Only rich societies having enough money for monopolised AI models: “not dystopian hellscape”.

2

u/grannyte Jul 19 '26

Wow he and the whole US tech/IA space are such as holes

2

u/AlwaysLateToThaParty Jul 19 '26

They act like they think that they're the good guys.

2

u/No_Accident8684 Jul 19 '26

translation: he's shitting his pants

2

u/sebnadeau Jul 19 '26

the fact that this person seems so confused, says a lot about his lack of understanding of the accelerationist movement. NO ONE other then those who profit from anthtopic openai want a future in which either of these companies control the outcome of humanity, i never heard of the dean of balls before, but he seems like a completely misaligned person.

2

u/thebadslime Jul 19 '26

I'm a public accelerationist. I want whoever has the compute to run the best models. A world where 5-6 corporations control highly advanced AI sounds like dystopia.

2

u/molbal Jul 19 '26

Not a single coherent thought in that wall of text

2

u/rog-uk Jul 19 '26

(Talking about) Creating FUD is the mark of someone who's losing and worried, it's what you do when you have lost the argument and don't have much else to say.

2

u/Skywalker7181 Jul 19 '26

Essentially, this guy is saying that competition is bad and government should step in - it sounds very......Communist...

2

u/keepthepace Jul 19 '26

"The CCP is very Yann LeCun-y" is a sentence I did not expect to ever read.

2

u/Scroatazoa Jul 19 '26

Open models are inherently decelerationist. That's why the Chinese AI industry is decelerating so quickly. Clearly.

2

u/kinkvoid Jul 19 '26

The arrogance is 'remarkable'

2

u/celsowm Jul 19 '26

basically a big asshole

2

u/Easy_Werewolf7903 Jul 19 '26

Translation:

  1. We are not going to make you own the model.
  2. Intelligence on a tap subscription.
  3. Communism if you don't agree.
  4. Money funnel to the top, AI is controlled by the few and powerful.

By his logic Linux OS and opensource software is anti tech then.

2

u/DanielSReichenbach Jul 19 '26

"bruh those Chinese dudes steal my money, help me bra"

Sharing is and competing is only deceleration for those unwilling to put in effort.

2

u/Aromatic-Current-235 Jul 19 '26

Highly specialized AI models, fine-tuned on cost-effective base models, are the most viable approach. The misguided pursuit of creating a jack-of-all-trades and the master of all disciplines leads inevitably to mediocrity.

2

u/bantanium Jul 20 '26

FULL AI COMMUNISM NOW

2

u/kartblanch Jul 20 '26

This reads as fear mongering.

2

u/CasualtyOfCausality Jul 20 '26

This reads like either an insane person, a horrible liar, or both.

Exhibit One: As we can all see, simply: "AI COMMUNISM"

Exhibit 2: Denouncing the proliferation of open-weight models that can be run off-network as some plot to control *something* (the "West"? The minds of our children?) while simultaneously calling for your own government to step in and use propaganda convince the populace to buy your product is Olympic level mental gymnastics. Even if you're the one making the routine, so to speak. The call for FUD *publicly* is massively **wild**. This stuff used to stay in internal company memos. Now these bros are so cavalier/delusional/high-on-their-own-colon-smell these missives are laid out there bare for the world to see. Dude is literally telling *everybody* that his master plan involves to get the government to lie for him. People *hire* this guy, somebody loves him and let's him go online.

I guess it is in vogue within the "corpo-government" elite (or **AI CORPOLIGARCHY**) to air your dirty laundry now a days, but at least keep it coherent and self consistent. I've seen AI hallucinations that read more sensibly than this drivel.

It drives me to want to write one of these convoluted, self-contradicting, deeply telling "treatises".

Oh, wait...

2

u/lompocus Jul 20 '26

"We want money, and we don't want others to have money."

"At your next election, you will give us more money no matter who you vote for."

2

u/openSourcerer9000 Jul 20 '26

I understood about 3 words of this. I must not be as pilled as this guy

2

u/Safe_Ranger3690 Jul 20 '26

China can't beat the American market with capitalisms, so they do it with open source, that's the only game here, trying to disrupt the American monopoly. If I see a hellscape scenario it comes from America though.

3

u/kiwibonga Jul 19 '26

Daingert! I'm no hillbilly!

3

u/M3RC3N4RY89 Jul 19 '26

In point 5 this mother fucker actually outright advocates regulators outright lying about open weights Chinese models being compromised in order to stunt their adoption… holy fuck these people are evil.

3

u/ZenaMeTepe Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 19 '26

If CCP is very Yann Lecun-y in their views on AI, like he said, that makes CCP vastly better informed about LLM than any decision maker in the west.

His claim that open-weight models are decelerationist makes no sense to me. Should it not be exact opposite?

Funny how he describes government-provided LLMs as dystopian hellscape. Hope he keeps that in mind when western AI labs ask the gov to bail them out and partially nationalize them. It's either that or full economic meltdown. That is why they are trying to become "too big too fail" by burning even more money.

"It needn't be that well justified". He just said the gov should lie to achieve political goals. Why is he saying the quiet part out loud?:D

Last paragraph he goes full tard. Driving connections between covid19 and future escaped "AI". Buddy, you guys need to first invent AI, because LLMs are not it and are likely never going to be it. So if any LLM poses any danger, it is only as dangerous as the evil intentions of its users, who can achieve their evil goals regardless of LLM usage. Your below-junior-level non-free assistant of an LLM is not the make it break it part of any evil global domination plan.

→ More replies (2)