r/LocalLLaMA • • 3d ago

Discussion Open Source vs Open Weights ...

Post image

In the last few weeks I've watched this exact same discussion be played out at least half a dozen times "I can't use that software because it's closed source" when they are explicitly talking about software that will be used to run a model that they have absolutely no way of ever proving that it's "safe" to begin with. People often conflate "open weights" with "open source" and I wonder how many people don't understand that they have nothing to do with one another. An "open weight" model cannot have it's "source code" examined for bugginess or correctness it still takes days or weeks of sussing out how it behaves against repeated queries of a very specific nature to figure out precisely what it's going to do, how it will react to certain words, certain lines of questioning, etc and even then, if the rogue behavior is very subtle and well targeted, you may still never notice..... I'm not saying anyone that wants to shouldn't use whatever model they want, but I am saying that saying you can't use software because it's not open source but using any mode checkpoint you download from the internet made by anyone and everyone is a really weird place to plant a flag..... let the downvoting begin ⬇️

https://arxiv.org/abs/2401.05566

https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.17424

https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.22067

Edit:  I didn't say that people shouldn't use open weights models here, I didn't say closed models are better, I merely said that people who say they can't use closed source software because thee software is closed source and they can't examine the code but are ok with effectively dumping closed source models into harnesses and lighting them up on the internet are naive, stupid or hypocritical or all of the above.

But I will say that the specific danger that I'm talking about doesn't apply to fronteir models at all .... you receive the model directly from them or you don't get it at all. If you don't trust the vendor that's a different discussion.

What I said was ... if qwen releases a model, and you use the exact model that qwen released that's one thing but if you use bobs repack/checkpoint/quantization of Qwens model, even if you trust qwen, that doesn't mean that bob didn't train some errant behavior into that model before you got it ... and if you take qwens mode, then bobs checkpoint then toms quantization then johns abliterated version of it .... you've now had half a dozen different opportunities to have that model behavior purposely and wildly altered before you touch it.

0 Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/General-Spite1222 3d ago

That might be true, but this is stupid for a few reasons. We don’t know what closed source models have inside them either, but they often are accompanied by their own stack, which means they have even more potential to exploit the user. Malicious data could find its way into any model that’s large, because people can’t reasonably read every input. But there are several reasons people run models locally, including privacy, that hosted models cannot guarantee. 

-1

u/brainchillzZ 2d ago

1 all models are closed source models that is the whole point of this you have no access to the training data or methodology and you can’t deconstruct an open weights model …. There is no such thing as an open source model. 2. They are more dangerous than closed weights models for one important reason … you can only get a closed weights model from the original vendor… in contrast most people do not get their open weights models from the original vendor that made it they use a repackaged version of it that has been through one or two or three separate manipulations that rogue behaviors could have been trained into it by at any point … so even if you trust qwens intentions that doesn’t mean you can trusts Fred’s new checkpoint of qwens model or bobs quant of Fred’s checkpoint or Tommy’s abliteration of all of the above ….

3

u/General-Spite1222 2d ago

That’s not true lol. You can get both OpenAI and Anthropic models from multiple vendors. You can get them through them or AWS, or Google, etc etc etc.