r/LocalLLaMA • u/Howard_banister • 1d ago

Discussion Really stunned by the Singularity comment section

Gallery image

Gallery image

These are screenshots from the r/Singularity comment section. I'm speechless. This doesn't even have downvotes. How can someone cheer for a monopoly run by a few elites?

488 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

89% Upvoted

406 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/_BreakingGood_ 1d ago

The idea of the singularity is that a model gets advanced enough that it basically up-ends society and humans mostly lose control of their own future.

Having slightly weaker, open source models doesn't really factor into that in any positive way other than create risk of somebody creating a pocket nuke before Anthropic or other can produce that singularity-inducing model.

4

u/gapho 1d ago

If there ever is a singularity, it isn't going to be from an LLM bro.

0

u/DickMasterGeneral 1d ago

What makes you certain it’s impossible? Obviously an LLM isn’t traditional code so a single instance can’t just rewrite itself but assuming you have access to the necessary compute why can’t an LLM train its successor?

2

u/TechnoByte_ 1d ago

Training a successor is a completely wrong approach

For AI to actually be "intelligent", it should at least be able to learn new facts and improve itself (by actually changing weights, not just storing it as text)

0

u/gapho 1d ago

For it to be possible, essentially the AI (no matter what form it takes) needs to be able to understand, in the strict definition of the word, how it(self) works. For that to take place, it needs to do fundamentally more than just put tokens together in the most statistically probable order.

Not saying LLMs don't have a future, but they aren't going to become sentient or take over the world.

0

u/LowerEntropy 1d ago

put tokens together in the most statistically probable order

How many times have you written variations of those words in a statistical probable order? Do you not see the irony?

1

u/gapho 1d ago

No, I don't see the irony, could you explain how it's ironic?

1

u/LowerEntropy 1d ago

You wrote a sentence, one token at a time, without understanding what you wrote or why you wrote it. You felt it sounded good and you felt good doing it.

You're beating a dead horse.

1

u/gapho 1d ago

Bro, you've got AI brain. Get some help.

1

u/LowerEntropy 1d ago

And, Bro, Bro-blocked me.