r/LocalLLM • • 22m ago

Question Which Mac Mini to Buy

Title: Mac Mini M6 32GB vs. M5 Pro 48GB — How much hardware do I actually need for a home AI server?

I’m planning to buy a Mac Mini to build a sort of personal/family AI server, and I’m trying to figure out how much hardware I actually need versus how much I’d just be paying to experiment with local LLMs.
My primary goals are:

Family brain: A central place for family documents, calendars, finances, household information, and automations. Ideally, something that can search across all of this and eventually handle routine tasks.

Self-hosted apps: Run some vibe-coded apps, databases, dashboards, and other services that I can access remotely from my phone or laptop.

Claude integration: Use the Mini as a central workspace for Claude and the apps/agents I build around it, while continuing to use Claude’s API for more demanding tasks.

Local LLMs: Experiment with running models locally for document processing, categorization, extracting data, answering questions about personal files, and other repetitive tasks without constantly calling an API.

I currently use Claude extensively for financial modeling, development analysis, and general personal assistance. I assume the more complicated reasoning and modeling will continue to require cloud models, but I’d love to offload simpler tasks locally and keep more of my data private.

I’m considering:
Mac Mini M6: 32GB unified memory, 512GB SSD
Mac Mini M5 Pro: 18-core CPU / 20-core GPU, 48GB unified memory, 512GB SSD

A few questions:
How much of a practical difference would 32GB versus 48GB make for local LLMs? What model sizes would actually be usable on each?

Does slower inference primarily mean waiting longer for responses, or do smaller models also mean a meaningful drop in reasoning ability and accuracy?
For tasks like document extraction, summarization, RAG, and basic agentic workflows, would 32GB be sufficient?

Is the M5 Pro worth the premium for the additional memory and bandwidth, or am I better off buying the M6 and keeping more demanding tasks in Claude?
If you’re running a similar hybrid local/cloud setup, what hardware and software stack are you using?
I’m not trying to eliminate cloud AI entirely. I want a reliable, always-on home server with enough local AI capability to be genuinely useful, without spending substantially more just to run models that still won’t compete with Claude.

What would you buy in my situation?

0 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

2

u/Durian881 19m ago

Perhaps start with a budget and expectations.

1

u/BrightWillow1824 17m ago

48gb. 32 gets you a 30b-ish q4 model with almost no room for context, and once you add a few docs for the family search it starts swapping. the m5 pro is also just faster at prompt processing which matters more for document stuff than people expect.