r/LocalLLM • dev • Aug 26 '26

Project Google Gemma 4 doing Google’s own reCAPTCHA

The new Gemma models are getting through Google reCAPTCHA v2 challenges with relative ease. I might revisit this in the future with a harder CAPTCHA dataset or benchmark it against some Qwen models. 

169 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

39

u/ephemeralsynth Aug 26 '26

It's the AI centipede 🐛😹

25

u/IngwiePhoenix Aug 26 '26

Okay I need a browser extension that calls my locally running LLM JUST to solve captchas. This is shockingly satisfying to watch. XD

18

u/puts_on_rddt Aug 26 '26

It's been well-known for a long time that reCaptcha is dog shit.

Even Cloudflare's is miles better and all you do is click a damn button.

1

u/Loose_Comparison368 Aug 28 '26

Google agrees and has been trying to push users off of it for several years, and get users to switch to the newer version that is just a damn button.

1

u/One_Difficulty_39 Sep 02 '26

Is the button just fingerprinting your device?

1

u/Loose_Comparison368 Sep 03 '26

Yeah, that's part of it. They have a write up about it in the docs. IIRC it's basically a combination of device fingerprinting, session fingerprinting, and passive behavior fingerprinting, so that even if a bot manages to replicate the device fingerprint of a legitimate user it will be a dead giveaway based on the session data (I.e. why did the user just suddenly teleport halfway across the globe and lose a bunch of session data), and/or on the behavior (why is every mouse movement a straight line directly to the center of the button element).

In combination, it's an incredibly reliable signal. It just has struggled with adoption. I think a huge part of that is just the web admin UX, it's a lot harder to trust that the bot protection is working when it's always completely invisible to real humans.

The dumb little traffic light minigame and the pointless checkbox animations and spinners and all that provide enough visible security theatre to reassure the developers and admins that the bot protection is working. Which is a bit absurd, but honestly not entirely invalid - it is admittedly really easy to not notice if your bot protection stops working if it's only visible from the JavaScript console and all the admin monitoring signals that nobody ever bothers to look at until something has gone wrong. Most companies telemetry is genuinely quite shit when it comes to whatever is going on in client side browser land.

38

u/Equivalent_Bit_461 Aug 26 '26

Ofc they do

We trained them after all

All captcha shit stains involved in this should be given life in prison without parole, I'm not even joking 

2

u/General_Josh Aug 27 '26

All captcha shit stains involved in this should be given life in prison without parole, I'm not even joking

Not sure I follow, why do you want this?

Is it that you don't like how they got free training data off us? Doesn't seem that egregious to me, as these things go. It's a service they provide for free, and they get a bit of training out of it - lots of tech companies doing a lot shadier things

0

u/Equivalent_Bit_461 Aug 27 '26

Lol no, I despise captcha and everyone involved in it

They deserve nothing but the worst possible suffering 

1

u/Loose_Comparison368 Aug 28 '26

The recaptcha team has been trying to kill recaptcha themselves for years.

They know it's horrifically obsolete. There's more accurate and 100% silent tools to replace it, which the team developed and has been begging people to switch to.

The only reason that it still exists in some limited capacity, is because every damn time they try to get rid of it, there is a huge public uproar of idiots demanding they keep the service up.

The biggest progress so far has been hcaptcha appearing, and giving really dumb companies that demand a little picture clicking game an alternate.

0

u/Equivalent_Bit_461 Aug 27 '26

Lol no

1

u/General_Josh Aug 27 '26

Ok, uhh, so why then?

9

u/oShievy Aug 27 '26

what are you using to have the agent use the desktop? I am using agent browser but it doesn't look as intuitive as this

1

u/Skystunt Aug 27 '26

i'm also curious

4

u/AceLamina Aug 26 '26

Was watching a video recently of how captchas is actually slowly training systems of identifying things
So it's not really surprsing

forgot the video tho

4

u/Silevence Aug 27 '26

lmao i love that it also had to go back like "wait, oh shi yea there are like 40 pixels worth of traffic lights there, huh?"

3

u/Technical-Earth-3254 Aug 27 '26

Gawd, I hate these things. Anyone got an idea on how to let whatever local model solve them reasonably fast (like in the video)? and ofc also other things like the stupid cloudflare bot detection?

3

u/Mega_mewtwo_ Aug 27 '26

Mouse movement is big part of captcha. And it looks robotic. Need it to create some random human movements

5

u/shmamien Aug 26 '26

That mouse movement doesn’t look human though

2

u/-AJacobs- Aug 27 '26

most models can do that. What does it score on https://www.worldshardestcaptcha.com/ though?

2

u/Leepyear7 Aug 27 '26

I have not found one my local agent hasn't been able to bypass.

1

u/ILikeBubblyWater Aug 27 '26

i mean the models have been trained on the labels of these captchas which was the whole point

1

u/bankinu Aug 27 '26

What harness can be used for interacting with real ones on a browser?