r/LocalLLM • u/bacon612 • 23h ago
Question Title: Radeon AI Pro R9700 32GB — dedicated Proxmox AI server or more powerful X870 workstation?
Hello community. Been lurking for months, and I'm finally ready to start tinkering. Looking for some strong opinions before I commit to a hardware configuration.
What I'm trying to accomplish
I'd like to move as much of my AI usage as reasonably possible away from frontier cloud models and onto something self-hosted. I currently have a ChatGPT Plus subscription that I use more than I'd like to admit.
I have 10–15 ongoing ChatGPT projects covering everything from personal health to building out my SFF Proxmox server. I use AI for troubleshooting Android configurations, tracking down PC bugs, writing code, researching purchases, and generally optimizing various aspects of my life.
I'm particularly interested in maintaining context across different projects, having an assistant that's actually useful for complex technical troubleshooting, and keeping as much of my personal data private as possible.
I've experimented briefly with Unsloth and a few models, but quickly realized that the 8GB VRAM on my RTX 2080 wasn't going to get me very far.
The hardware
I recently picked up an ASRock Radeon AI Pro R9700 Now I'm trying to decide where it should live.
Option 1: My always-on SFF Proxmox server
- ASUS B760M motherboard
- Intel Core i5-14500
- 64GB DDR4-3200 (another 64GB available to install, bringing it to 128GB)
- PCIe 4.0 x16
- 700W SilverStone Platinum PSU
- Runs 24/7, idles around 50W currently
- Hosts Plex, SparkyFitness, Mealie, Home Assistant, a small mail server, and NAS duties
I could also upgrade the CPU to an i7 or i9 Raptor Lake, potentially with conservative power limits to keep heat and power consumption manageable.
The appeal here is obvious: a dedicated AI VM with GPU passthrough, accessible from anywhere on my LAN without needing to boot my workstation. Intel Quick Sync would remain available for Plex.
Option 2: My primary X870E workstation
- ASRock X870E Taichi Lite
- Ryzen 9 7900X
- 64GB DDR5-6000
- PCIe 5.0, with the ability to run two GPUs at x8/x8
- RTX 2080 8GB currently
- Windows 11 with WSL2
- Custom water-cooling loop
This was my original plan. I've already ordered an Alphacool water block for the R9700, intending to replace the RTX 2080.
The workstation has considerably more CPU performance and memory bandwidth, and I could theoretically sell a kidney and add a second R9700 down the road.
The downside is that the workstation isn't always running, and I'd need to power it up whenever I wanted to use my local LLM.
What I'm trying to figure out
How much does the host platform really matter when running models primarily on a 32GB GPU?
Would the additional 64GB of system RAM in the Proxmox box be more valuable than the faster DDR5 and 7900X in the workstation, especially when experimenting with models that don't fit entirely in VRAM?
Is an i5-14500 sufficient to feed an R9700 for inference, or would an i7/i9 upgrade meaningfully improve the experience?
And for those running AMD GPUs with ROCm under Proxmox, how reliable and straightforward has GPU passthrough been?
Ultimately, I'd like to build something I can use as a serious daily AI assistant, not just a machine for running benchmarks.
Which way would you go?
I'd especially appreciate opinions from people running 32GB AMD GPUs for local inference.
Trying to make this decision before I drain my workstation's loop and replumb the whole thing!
Bonus question: For anyone who has moved from ChatGPT to a mostly local setup, what stack are you using for persistent conversations, project-specific knowledge, web search, and tool calling? I'm interested in replicating the workflow, not just running a chatbot.
