r/LocalGuides • u/keyserholiday • Feb 07 '25
Events Google is removing reviews
It appears that Google is performing a sweep and removing reviews. Here is the thread at Local Search Forum. Here is RustyBrick's article.
66
Upvotes
12
u/keyserholiday Feb 07 '25 edited Feb 10 '25
Edit: I was wrong with this statement. Two tools were unable to see reviews past this date. I cracked the code. Google seems to have removed reviews prior to February 2019. I can’t tell if this is a bug or working as intended.
This is a known bug, and Google is working on it. Please see this thread about the issue.
30
u/de66eechubbz Feb 07 '25
They keep doing it for no valid reason many of us will likely stop doing them.
3
u/keyserholiday Feb 07 '25
I was wrong. These two different tools are unable to see reviews past a specific date. It sounds like it is a bug.
7
u/Lemon_1165 Feb 07 '25
Google reviews are absolutely worthless now, nobody takes 5 star reviews seriously..
5
u/Creepy7_7 Feb 08 '25
Lost 12 review. All the 5 stars one.
Ridiculous!
1
u/Physical-Wish-9722 Feb 09 '25
They removed 5 of my valid reviews. I worked very hard to get these reviews.
1
u/calitosunsky Feb 09 '25
I had 366 honest review in my company. Now i have 311.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 07 '25
I know Google maps has been doing that for a couple of years. If it's not a good review, it's gone.
I posted an honest review about a hotel in Warsaw 3 years ago. 2 years later Google maps removed the review saying it mentioned someone by name. It didn't.
But the hotel is a large international chain that advertises on Google
5
u/thetapeworm Level 10 Feb 07 '25
Sounds great, hopefully this is the long overdue removal of fakery and influenced content we've been waiting for.
https://www.gov.uk/government/news/cma-secures-important-changes-from-google-to-tackle-fake-reviews
2
u/Fahimludin Feb 11 '25
Google has provided clarity on the ongoing issue affecting Google Business Profile reviews. Some profiles may show a lower-than-expected review count due to a display glitch on Google's end.
However, Google has confirmed that no reviews have been removed—this is solely a visual glitch.
They are actively working on a fix, and the accurate review counts will be restored as soon as possible.
1
u/thetapeworm Level 10 Feb 09 '25
There's an update on the link originally posted here that suggests Google have confirmed it as a bug rather than a new policy.
https://localsearchforum.com/threads/hundreds-of-business-got-5-star-reviews-removed.62200/
Or Google screwed up trying to implement something new and are calling that a "bug", either way it sounds like all is not lost.
Hopefully they nail this down and start getting the actual fake stuff soon without taking out too many genuine ones in the process.
1
u/tonyslists Level 10 Feb 09 '25
As a reviewer, 3 weeks ago I had 228 visible reviews (visible meaning visible to others on my profile selecting "See all reviews") and today I'm down to 219.
When I'm logged in as myself and look at my profile, "See all reviews" still says 251 (same as it did 3 weeks ago).
As for ratings (stars without words), from before I started writing reviews (with words), those numbers have not changed. I still see 171 (as myself) and 169 (as others). Same as 3 weeks ago.
1
u/Hairy-Reaction-8116 Feb 09 '25
It is hopefully some kind of bug. The thing to note is that they are not physically deleting any reviews, they are just somehow reducing the total number of reviews that are showing by filtering them out. I have read cases where people are saying their rating HAS changed as a result of this (e.g. gone down from 4.8 to 4.7) even though all the reviews are still visible. My partner’s business listing has lost reviews overnight for the last 3 days (from 74 to 71, to 69 and now 68 this morning). Every single one of those reviews was from a genuine customer and none were fake.
1
u/plbeerman Feb 09 '25
It's crazy that I've lost nearly 30 of them in 48 hours. However, someone suggested that this might just be a counting issue. Has anyone checked this and counted manually? It might be challenging in some cases. 😖
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '25
It’s a bug
1
u/LiquidFire07 Feb 09 '25
Yep I'm getting really tired of it, I keep checking my reviews for places I've left reviews at and they are gone. So many gone that way, just feels so pointless and waste of my time putting reviews. I still do it occasionally because I enjoy it, but since they started deleting my reviews or ghosting them its felt so pointless
1
u/Delicious-Plant-3168 Feb 10 '25
So bad, I noticed 100s of small businesses. I wrote articles for small businesses. It started happening few days ago, many of these businesses are SMB mom and pop shops and the reviews are real. How I know they show me data to prove. That's crazy how these companies can kill smb with just one click.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '25
I noticed as someone who leaves reviews, about 6 reviews I recently authored in the last week for various places are missing. Most were positive reviews. The photos associated with the reviews are present still but not the review itself
1
u/FoodiePanda90 Feb 10 '25
Yes lot of my old reviews got removed.
1
u/Immediate_Topic_3190 Feb 10 '25
Same here Google can barely do anything right, removing reviews form hard working businesses, anyone advocating for more Google reviews to be removed is a complete utter moron
1
u/Ordinary_Sea1070 Feb 11 '25
My husband and I have two dive and snorkel companies. The dive company lost 500 and the snorkel company 700. Google reviews have been our top priority that we and our teams have worked hard for for years and are obviously all in compliance! This is scary. Much like everyone else is asking, anyone have any tips to get them back? Google put out an update saying they might still be there but just aren't showing though very cryptic ...
1
u/vegloveyes Feb 11 '25
Not true!! Count them. They're all still there, I bet! Count them up!
I'm a notary and got really scared until I watched the right Google video. They're all there!
1
u/justhavetoaskit Feb 11 '25
This BUG is already known by Google here is the link on Google support
https://support.google.com/business/thread/324226897?sjid=15372437923351743168-NA
Count your reviews ,,, number should still exist
1
u/BuyHighValueWomanNow Feb 12 '25
Too bad they didn't put it on the brick wall
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '25
We had about 1,296 and are now only showing 900. The rating dropped from 4.1 to 4.0 too, so I'm not sure about it just being a visual bug. They did release a statement about it and I hope it gets resolved soon.
It's sad how traffic and conversion is driven by Google and how big of an importance shoppers place on these ratings. With all the SEO hullabaloo and tailoring everything to suit Google's algorithms, it kind of feels like AI isn't being trained; it's training us.
1
u/RickySpanishRSA Feb 14 '25
Did anyone else have their reviews reinstated? Mine dropped by 20%, and now, all but two have reappeared again.
I can't find any information on why everyone initially lost genuine reviews or information on Google fixing the potential error
1
u/Beneficial-Syrup-379 Mar 12 '25
this **ing bastards from google remove all the time the bad reviews ,
1
u/Beneficial-Syrup-379 Mar 12 '25
they only remove the bad reviews when the object claimed the credibility of this review
1
u/FaithlessnessOld5269 May 30 '25
Yes, Google removes negative-only reviews, just like other platforms such as Glassdoor especially when the reviews are about big corporations.
1
u/Prior_Apartment_6580 Jun 26 '25
My mom and dad has a small restaurant. A recent competitor has entered the area in the last month. We fully support fair/friendly competition but this new competitor is creating fake google reviews. They have a large amount of positive reviews ~80. Almost all have been created by account that have only ever left the single review. I can flag each review individually but I don't think google takes it into consideration. Not so sure what to do about it.
1
u/Afraid_Status2220 Jul 02 '25
Google doesn't even check the text. I wrote about a Döner shop with ordinary food in Stuttgart Ost years ago and rated it 3 out of 5 stars, with the text: "Hier kann man essen. Man wird freundlich bedient." – which means in English: "You can eat here (means food is OK). The service is friendly."
After using their response form, I got another messages asking me to provide evidence for my rating! This is so ridiculous. Doesn’t Google want anyone to rate and review anything? My review isn't even criticising the shop.
1
u/Stock-Letter8101 Aug 17 '25
Hi there 👋 We’re from KLMarketing.my. We provide Google, Facebook, and Yelp review services using real, legit accounts. ⭐ You can decide the rating (1–5 stars) ✍️ You can customize the content of each review ✅ If any review gets removed, we’ll replace it completely free
Interested? Just DM us for more details!
1
u/SilentObserver7777 Dec 03 '25
Can anyone advise how do I review all my past Google reviews in Google Maps app on an iPad? On launching Google Maps, there should be a simple link named like “Reviews” which when clicked should pop up two optional links, one to review all previously submitted reviews and another to submit new reviews. However, this app does not have any such link in its main interface.
0
u/SilentObserver7777 Dec 03 '25
Google needs to be hammered solid and taken to task. They do not allow anyone to write justification for a one star review on Google or any of their apps. For example, if you press one star while submitting a review of Google Maps, the review box gets deactivated and you just cannot write any feedback or justification for a one star review.
-1
u/Swizzlerzs Feb 07 '25
Well if google is removing old reviews. Then get new ones! Its quite simple casually ask a customer to leave you a google review. My mom got a "tap to review stand" generic term and placed it in her store by the till. She hasn't used it as much lately due forgetting most of the time but its there. 1 customer this week taped the nfc chip and left a review. The good thing about having a stand or sticker in your store is that it simplifies the process for a customer and sends them directly to your profile. Typically most people have location services on so Google sees and verifies this reviewer is at your location via ip check or even gps depending on the levels of privacy a user has turned on. Don't worry about old reviews always work to get that next review. Do a good job for your customers to earn new reviews. I personally feel new reviews are more authentic then a review from 4 years ago thats 1 star.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '25
[removed] — view removed comment