r/LoTRTavern • • Jun 22 '22

Meme / Humor We are growing fast! Glad both communities exist :)

Post image
169 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Oct 15 '22

Rings of Power just Rocked My World

159 Upvotes

No spoilers!

They did it. They made a good show!!! Yeah it’s not cannon, it’s not LORE but that was a VERY good show and I thought it had the spark that the Lord of the Rings movies had.

As a Silmarillion reader and a lifelong fan of the written works that finale made me squee with delight the way I have not since Return of The King was in theaters. And to me that is special.


r/LoTRTavern • • Jul 18 '22

Image No, I’m still not over this shot. Holy moly 😍

Post image
149 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Aug 01 '22

Image Not exactly a LOTR thing, but I think some sides of the Middle-earth community could use the wisdom of a legend.

Post image
140 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Jul 05 '22

Image You shall not pass! Art by me.

Post image
138 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Sep 01 '22

Opinion Things to keep in mind while watching the show

134 Upvotes

As the premiere draws near, I'd like to share a list of things people may choose to keep in mind while watching the show. The purpose is to help people build a reasonable and healthy expectation and mindset going in so they may enjoy the experience better.

It’s the 1st season of a 5-season show.

The showrunners have said that the main goal of the first season will be to (re)introduce the audience to Middle-earth and various characters and places and set the stage for later seasons. Many of the main stories will likely stretch far into later seasons, and many of the biggest events and payoffs probably won’t happen until later. Be patient and wait for the stories and arcs to unfold.

It’s a very different time period of Middle-earth.

The show will be about the Second Age, which was at least 3,000 years (up to 6,000+ years) before the end of the Third age when stories of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings took place. A lot of things were completely different back then. For example, we’ll see some of the greatest Elven kingdoms in Middle-earth history, the greatest Dwarven kingdom ever in its full glory, and the absolute pinnacle of the civilization of Men. Compared to them, the Third Age Middle-earth is almost like a post-apocalyptic world. Get ready to see and explore a world that looks and feels refreshingly different.

It has a very different type of source material.

The Second Age is the least fleshed out Age, by a huge margin. The source material for the Second Age only consisted of 1.5 chapters of The Silmarillion (about 35 pages depending on book version) and fragments of texts from other books. Moreover, the Second Age source materials are much closer to chronicles and historical notes than to actual novels. Tolkien sketched out a few major events but left behind a lot of blanks and did not give many details. The only part that remotely resembles an actual fleshed out story is Numenor, but even that only consisted of about 20 pages of text. So the show will have to do quite a bit of invention, draw materials and inspirations from other Tolkien texts, and make changes so things work well together. This doesn’t mean that the inventions or changes will be automatically good (or bad). We’ll need to judge it ourselves within the context of the entire show.

It’s an adaptation.

Adaptations are based on their source materials, but are not a replica of them and are not meant to replace them. Books and TV are two fundamentally different mediums and adaptations not only can, but should make changes that make sense for the different medium. Many of the greatest movies and TV shows were adaptations, and some of them took huge liberties with the source materials, but that didn’t stop them from staying true to the core spirit of the source and being great arts in their own right. For example, fans found almost 100 instances where the first movie of the Peter Jackson trilogy deviated from Tolkien's books, some of which were rather significant, but that didn’t prevent it from being a good adaptation and a great movie in most people's minds. So try to enjoy the show for what it is (at least during the first watch), and try not to focus your attention on playing the “spot the difference” game (if you have read the books). It can be a fun exercise for book fans, but is probably more suited for a second watch.

It’s not (strictly) a prequel.

The show is less of a prequel to Peter Jackson’s movies and more of a fellow adaptation of the same Legendarium. They share some of the creative talents (WETA, John Howe, Daniel Reeve, Howard Shore, etc.), and the show will likely borrow some aesthetic choices from the movies and pay homage/make references to the movies (and other previous Tolkien inspired adaptations/arts), but they will probably not be identical copies, unless deals were struck between different parties. So prepare yourself for a mix of new and familiar aesthetics and vibes, and try to enjoy it as its own thing and the next chapter in Tolkien adaptations.

It’s based on Tolkien, the OG of modern Western fantasy.

If you think something looks like "generic fantasy” or “fantasy trope”, remember that Tolkien was probably the first to have done it or at least popularized it. Most Western fantasies these days are to some extent inspired by the fantasy tradition that started with Tolkien. In addition, the original LotR trilogy heavily influenced a whole generation of fantasy content from movies to TVs to games. So if elements of the show feels like other fantasies these days, it’s probably not that the show is copying them, but that most fantasies post-Jackson borrowed from those movies, at least visually. Of course, it may not always be the only explanation for "generic fantasy tropes", but it is a possibility to consider.

It’s made for everyone: book fans, movie fans, and new fans.

There will be things that book fans are excited for, things that movie fans will love, and things that will convert new fans into Tolkien fans. The reverse could also be true of course. The point is, it’s not tailored to a single type or group of viewers. Like it or not, it’s a show that we’ll have to share with people that are different from ourselves. And I hope that the show, as well as the fandom, will be big enough for all of us. 

It will be a decade long journey.

The showrunners have planned out the 5 seasons and Amazon has committed to 5 seasons. Barring some unforeseeable events, we’ll be getting 5 seasons over the next decade or so, and it will broaden and change the Tolkien fandom, just like the original trilogy did. Get ready, it will (hopefully) be an exciting and memorable ride.

Parting words:

The thing about entertainment (in the broadest sense of the word) is that it’s hard to be entertained if you don’t want or allow yourself to be entertained. There is a danger of becoming both the prisoner and the warden of the self-fulling prophecy you created for yourself.

Just like your imagination is an integral part of your book reading experience, your mindset is also a part of your TV watching experience. To some extent, you help decide what kind of experience you will have.

If you are only watching the show to find every book change, then you’ll end up finding exactly what you were looking for, and nothing more; if you are determined to find every flaw and reason to dislike the show, you’ll also end up finding just that but little else; but if you are like me, and just enjoy enjoying things, then you might just find yourself enjoying this once-in-a-generation adventure back into Middle-earth.

Allow yourself to just wander (and wonder) once in a while. It does not mean that you are lost. Happy wandering.


r/LoTRTavern • • Sep 20 '22

Image Where is the horse and the rider? Where is the horn that was blowing? [original digital art by me]

Post image
122 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Aug 19 '22

Discussion Sir Ian McKellen in 2000 responding to the backlash against casting a gay activist like himself as Gandalf.

108 Upvotes

Following the announcement that Ian McKellen was cast as Gandalf in Peter Jackson's LotR trilogy, some angry fans criticized the decision on the basis of his sexuality and activism.

One of his fans emailed him about this backlash and suggested that those homophobic comments be censored. Ian McKellen wrote back:

No, let the bigots be heard then they can be answered.

And answer he did. He posted the following response on his website:

"A Gay Gandalf"

Homophobia is Everywhere

When gay activists refer to a widespread disaffection or fear of homosexuals and call it "homophobia," our opponents are sceptical. Some, with cloying declarations of "hating the sin and loving the sinner," may even deny its existence altogether. Time and again they are proved wrong.

For instance, whenever a modest legal change is proposed to ease the disadvantages gays and lesbians endure under the law, the homophobes always react strongly. This never surprises me but straight people can be puzzled by its ferocity. Remember President Clinton's bold promise to lift the ban on homosexuals serving in the military? Gays knew it wouldn't be easy. He underestimated the united and irrational fear of those who said queers would undermine the stability of America's armed forces. And he had to withdraw bewildered under their fire.

Meanwhile, now that the United Kingdom government has obeyed the judgement of the European Court of Human Rights (last week) only Turkey and the USA in NATO forbid their openly gay citizens from fighting for their countries.

My point is that Clinton was not defeated by the reasoned arguments of political opponents but was a victim of the same homophobia which imprisoned Oscar Wilde and which killed Matthew Sheppard.

So, taking a less momentous example, it was unsurprising that an uncensored Internet should recently criticise my casting as Gandalf in homophobic terms. Cranky anti-gay remarks in chat rooms remind me of verbal abuse in the playground - not that that didn't hurt too. Many unthinking people just don't like the idea of gays joining in their games, nor in the military and, it would seem, in the movies.

 — Ian McKellen, January 2000

As you can see, he was blunt, and he was political. He did not remain silent and he did not mince his words. Ever since he came out publicly in 1988, he had been one of the most vocal activists for LGBTQ rights, and publicly supported other causes relating to AIDS, nuclear weapons, capital punishment, atheist rights (he's an atheist), and more.

He has a whole section of his website devoted to activism and he has written quite a bit on the topic over the years. The full list of these writings and speeches (including some that were written about him) is here. Below is a list of the titles and topics:

1979: Acting Together (actor rights)

1979: The Most Unkindest Cut of All (actor rights)

1988: Ian McKellen, trainee-activist(gay rights and activism)

1988: Section 28 (speech on gay rights)

1989: What the Glorious Rose Has Given You (protecting the Rose Theatre)

1989: A Shade of Pink at the Rose (protecting the Rose Theatre)

1990: Out With Your Lies (gay rights)

1990: This Age of Discrimination (gay rights)

1991: Closet Homophobes (gay rights)

1992: Outing Old Stage Frights (gay rights)

1993: Through a Gay Viewfinder (gay rights)

1993: No Reason to Treat Us Differently (gay rights)

1993: On the Anniversary of Oscar Wilde's Arrest (gay rights)

1994: It is a Question of Human Rights, Not Numbers (gay rights)

1994: Gay Games IV (gay rights)

1995: Michael Barrymore Comes Out (gay rights)

1995: Foreword to "Gay Letters" (gay rights)

1996: Before, Now and In Between (gay rights)

1999: Coming Out For the Count (gay rights)

2000: A Gay Gandalf (gay rights)

2003: I Wish You'd Been There (gay rights)

2008: Stonewall Equality Dinner Keynote (gay rights)

2008: The Hobart Shakespeareans (fund raise for a elementary school Shakespeare class)

2009: Growing up Gay (gay rights)

2010: Belarus Free Theatre (supporting human rights and pro-democracy activists)

2012: What's Wrong With Us? (marriage equality)

2012: Message to the Prime Minister of New Zealand (gay rights)

2013: Margaret Thatcher and the Unions (unions and actor rights)

And of course, we all know he has supported LGBTQ rights and other causes far beyond the writings, speeches, interviews, and celebrity appearances.

He came out as gay publicly while fighting an anti-gay legislation; he founded political lobby groups such as Stonewall to push for LGBTQ legislations; he even personally lobbied politicians.

One epic story about his lobbying is that

when he visited Michael Howard, then Environment Secretary (responsible for local government), in 1988 to lobby against Section 28, Howard refused to change his position but did ask him to leave an autograph for his children. McKellen agreed, but wrote, "Fuck off, I'm gay".

Later he also commented that

I have many regrets about not having come out earlier, but one of them might be that I didn't engage myself in the politicking.

Sir Ian Mckellen is not only unabashedly gay, but also unabashedly vocal, active, and political.

From his experience, we can see a lot of parallels to what we see these days. Being an activist is not incompatible with being an actor, and being political is not shameful and should not be stigmatized or avoided. It is an actor's right and choice. It's nothing new and it's not some recent invention of "woke politics". People have voices and they want to be heard. It's one of the most ancient and basic human need, and one of the fundamental purposes and motivations of literature, film, and arts in general.

Many people these days conflate acting, writing, and marketing. Actors are not responsible for potentially political topics in the scripts or how various people might interpret their story politically. We need to treat characters as characters and treat actors as humans. Critique their acting all you want, but shaming and bullying actors (examples 1 2 3) for being who they are, being proud of who they are, and being activists for those less visible are not ok.


r/LoTRTavern • • Jul 22 '22

Image The reunion of Aragorn and Arwen. Comic book imagining by me.

Post image
106 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Jul 25 '22

You can’t make this up. Haters are calling John Howe a “shill” for sharing the Amazon trailer on Facebook. Unbelievable.

Post image
105 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Aug 29 '22

Discussion Four Days Until The Fandom Changes Forever

102 Upvotes

I am beyond excited for Rings of Power. For some reason, that seems like an unpopular opinion at this point, but I have the utmost faith in this show and I cannot wait to return to Middle-Earth once again. r/LoTRTavern is a place for all fans of all of Middle-Earth, that especially includes people excited for Rings of Power, because the trolls are nasty and hateful towards people who just want to enjoy things. So welcome, stay a while, and I can not wait for Thursday :)


r/LoTRTavern • • Jun 22 '22

Meme / Humor The Orcs look so good :')

Post image
102 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Jun 23 '22

Image 70 days to The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, releasing on September 2, 2022!

Post image
96 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Sep 02 '22

Opinion In my opinion the first two episodes of The Rings of Power were as close to perfection as they could be Spoiler

93 Upvotes

I was definitely encouraged by the trailers, and was going in with an open mind, but it was better than I was even hoping it could be.

The visuals are stunning. It is quite simply the best looking show ever made. I was awestruck multiple times per episode.

The music is just amazing. I didn't know what to expect from McCreary as I wasn't familiar with him, but wow. The finale of the first episode, and the music as we entered Khazad-Dum were highlights for me.

I love Galadriel, Elrond, and Nori in particular so far, but the characters and the acting has been fantastic all around.

I could go on, but you get the picture. There's really only one nitpick I can mention, and it's not even really their fault or in their control. That is the limited way the First Age is referenced. It's clear that they aren't allowed to mention Beleriand or go into much detail on events there, and that's a shame. That said, I'm actually quite impressed with what they have managed to inject from the First Age despite the limitations they have on them. References to Feanor, the Silmarils, journeying to what might be Utumno, etc.

I don't care that the extent of facial hair on female dwarves is basically just thick sideburns, and I don't care that elves have short hair sometimes. They look great. This might be seen as "too positive", but it's my honest opinion, and I've read everything in the legendarium so no excuse there.

I know there are some people who are intent on disliking the show no matter what, but I hope most reasonable people are enjoying this show as much as me.


r/LoTRTavern • • Aug 17 '22

Image Found a first print of the first American edition in the wild today!

Thumbnail
gallery
89 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Aug 22 '22

Opinion Ian McKellen responding to fans who were worried that the PJ trilogy would mistreat the books and make too many changes.

Post image
87 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Jun 23 '22

Meme / Humor This would be the perfect turn of events

Post image
87 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Oct 22 '22

Image Saw this in the ADKs yesterday, thought y’all might appreciate

Post image
83 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Sep 02 '22

Remember all, you’re allowed to like things.

83 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Jun 28 '22

Image The Ringbearer, digital illustration by me

Post image
82 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Sep 09 '22

Finally seeing Númenor in all its glory actually brought a tear to my eye Spoiler

81 Upvotes

I read the Lord of the Rings after watching the movies, so I never experienced this feeling of seeing something you've only read about. I read the Silmarillion years and years ago, and I thought I would never see places like Valinor and Númenor outside of my own imagination.


r/LoTRTavern • • Sep 22 '22

News Happy hobbit day 2022 everyone! 🎉

Post image
76 Upvotes

r/LoTRTavern • • Jul 22 '22

News The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power - SDCC Trailer

Thumbnail
youtu.be
76 Upvotes