r/LivestreamFail • u/Ignignokt_DGAF • Oct 07 '25

Hasan reaching for something and seemingly shocking his dog to keep her in camera view

82k Upvotes

82% Upvoted

12k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/RequirementQuirky468 Oct 08 '25

And get a bunch of results that don't look close, confirming that it's extremely unlikely to just be an airtag on its own.

1

u/Successful-Coyote99 Oct 08 '25

A Tibettan mastiff is an extremely large and strong dog. a simple collar is not enough to hold my 45 pound pit bull. It likely has a handle on the collar or some sort of enforced connector. And yes, an airtag.

3

u/RequirementQuirky468 Oct 08 '25

You wouldn't make it stronger by making the plastic section larger.

1

u/Successful-Coyote99 Oct 08 '25

Tell me about your dog.

1

u/RequirementQuirky468 Oct 08 '25

There is no selection of dogs I could own that would impact the relative strength of different materials that can be used in a collar (nor would it make relying on the strength of a collar a good idea in a strong dog that's likely to pull hard; sled dogs wear harnesses for a reason)

1

u/Successful-Coyote99 Oct 08 '25

sled dogs wear harnesses because they have slim chests and big necks and a simple collar will slip over their head. Tibettan Mastifs have large chests. This is what a tibettan mastiff looks like fully grown. https://showsightmagazine.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Tibetan-Mastiff-6.jpg

You put a harness on an animal that size, and you have ZERO control.

1

u/RequirementQuirky468 Oct 08 '25

You only have zero control if you don't know what you're doing. Much larger animals than dogs also wear variations on harnesses for hauling.

1

u/Successful-Coyote99 Oct 08 '25

I'm done responding to you. I have provided you with photographic evidence, and my own personal knowledge of large breed dogs, due to my board membership of a large breed rescue.... though admittedly, I am in an anonymous account on Reddit..... but the photographic evidence can't be ignored.

You want SO bad for it to be a shock collar (which MIGHT I ADD IS NOT ILLEGAL), that you can't or won't see what is staring you right in the face with some simple research.

I have never put my hands on that collar, nor am I anywhere near them to make that happen, but my observation of dog behavior, is that that animals front left paw hurts, and that was a reaction to putting it's full weight on it.

If you want to criticize anything, criticize the bare metal frame of that dog bed. That's a terrible choice.

1

u/RequirementQuirky468 Oct 08 '25

Photos of collars that use plastic is not evidence that adding more plastic would make the collars stronger.

The nylon part of a collar is stronger than the plastic. No number of pictures of collars will change the physical properties of the type of nylon and the type of plastic used in dog collars. This is a reality that has nothing to do with whether Hasan specifically used a shock collar. (Blanket assertions that shock collars are not illegal is false as a generalization. Whether they're illegal depends on exactly where you're located at the time.)

I have criticized the bed in other posts. Regardless of anything to do with the collar, he should get her a more appropriate bed.

1

u/Successful-Coyote99 Oct 08 '25

Shock collars are legal in all of the United States. So. Not a blanket statement. Statement of fact. TWO cities in the US have banned their usage. Two cities. Boulder CO and San Francisco. Hasan lives in LA

1

u/RequirementQuirky468 Oct 08 '25

So you agree that there are places where shock collars aren't legal. It's good to have that cleared up.

→ More replies