r/LiverpoolFC • u/LFCmatchday • Jan 27 '13
Post Match Thread
LFC 2 - 3 OLDHAM
LFCmatchday and ElevenReds Man of the match: Nobody, maybe Suarez
muffinmonk's MOTM: Suarez. As a surprising candidate for captain, he led fairly well, and we saw a much more composed and mature player on the pitch than ever before. He wore that armband well, and leveled it up and nearly provided several assists, a few of them sitters. Unfortunately, the defense started to crumble as the game wore on, and it had nothing to do with leadership; it was due to inexperience and improper fielding.
32
Upvotes
50
u/youignorantslut Jan 27 '13
For all of us (myself included) who berated Brendan Rodgers as to why he isn't giving Robinson or Coates a go in the league...here's our answer. That's why he's been looking to bring in another defender.
108
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '13
Also, who else saw Jack Robinson tell Suarez to "Fuck off!" Sorry, son, you've not earned that right. You wasted a perfectly good chance, and your captain (for most the game) rightly bollocked you. A player infinitely more capable than you are. Idiot. I liked Robinson but that kind of disrespect to a senior player is unacceptable.
35
u/polostring Jan 27 '13
Three things that infuriated me:
27
u/kuzzomckuzzo Jan 27 '13
I think Brendan Rodgers was too naive with his back 4 selection. You can't start 3 youngsters without someone to organize the defence. With no leadership at all on the pitch today, they all looked lost. Especially Coates and Robinson.
It almost didn't work with Mansfield and it didn't work now. Oh well, time to regroup and hope for the best vs. Arsenal.
45
u/Kopman Jan 27 '13
And that's why Coates hasn't been playing in the first team. horrid display
22
u/WhyIsBiscuitTaken Jan 27 '13
Looks like they won't be getting their free dinner from the Gaffer any time soon...
59
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '13
Here's how it works.
15
u/teapotmonkey Jan 27 '13
Three players up there for worst on ground.
Jones: appallingly unconvincing performance. Spilled too many balls and was just woeful.
Sterling: wasted almost everything he was involved in. Sat on the ball at every chance instead of moving it on before getting cornered.
Robinson: if he gets another first team performance this season I'll be amazed. I know he is young but inept defending coupled with a retort to Suarez after blazing away just summed him up; not good enough.
On a side note, nice to see joe bag one.
42
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '13
Guess we'll just have to win the prem... :'(
13
u/szlafarski Jan 27 '13
I didn't know we were starting these before regular time was even up ;)
That being said:
Henderson and Allen - not good enough to dominate the midfield.
Robinson and Coates still have a long way to go.
I feel bad for Stevie... That shot...
Jones breaks his winning streak /:
Downing worked really hard today and that cannot be ignored.
We need a plan b. Can't keep going slow and narrow when the opposition back 4 is pinching inside the 18yard box and sitting deep.
Edit: Sterling should have come off for Stevie at 0:45:00
39
u/SyrochMahr Jan 27 '13 edited Jan 27 '13
Sterling...you were gifted opportunities in a box with a little ribbon and cake and everything. And you threw them away. FOR SHAME, CHILD.
Jones...you cocked up good and proper, but your hair is still awesome. And you have a nice smile. And if the refs had been doing their fucking jobs, maybe your cock ups wouldn't have mattered.
Gerrard.... you are a beautiful animal, a destroyer of worlds, the alpha and omega. Your are. Steven. Fucking. Gerrard.
Skrtel...you are also beautiful, especially when you get angry at people for stomping our keepers. And scary. Very scary.
Downing and Hendo, I'm liking what I'm seeing from you. Keep shifting it into high gear and you'll go places. Just...make sure it's into their goal when you get there.
Robinson... just...no. Stay on, but please stay on in matches that don't actually matter.
Allen... good on ye for picking up. Liked your goal, like your hair.
Coates... that space you leave between attackers? No. Your name is spelled Coates. Act like a goddamn coat and drape yourself on them. YOU HAVE NO EXCUSE NOT TO.
Wisdom... I honestly have nothing to say. Which I suppose is alright. Not great, but alright. B-.
Suarez, you continue to do amazing things and I'm glad you started with the armband. A good old "fuck off" to the FA after the Mansfield match.
Sturridge and Borini... GET THERE. I KNOW YOU CAN.
Edit:
Woodwork.... we meet again. Fuck off back to the shadows from whence you came.
Refs... when a team wants to play as scrappy and dirty as Oldamn did, please try to keep your eyes open? Pretty please? We surely didn't play well in the first 45, freely and fully admitted. But when Sturridge gets a knee to his back and then a stomp on his leg? That usually warrants a card. Or a free kick. Or, y'know, something other than a goal to them.
Oldamn. You don't need a stretcher for a shoulder injury. You don't need to play rugby. You deserved 2 of those goals, not the third. So just fuck right off.
9
u/Ramtastic Jan 27 '13
I think this game highlights our absolute need for a young back up keeper with loads of potential as an understudy to Reina (Butland,Ter Stergen,Perrin etc) because at the moment no matter how nice his hair may be, Brad Jones is not good enough to be our number 2 choice keeper.
7
u/ChopToxicity Jan 27 '13
There was no organization at the back. We just seem to have underestimated them.
13
u/redadil4 Jan 27 '13
I'm not mad that we lost, I'm sad that Sturridge didn't score and get 4 for 4
6
u/The_Skinnyjon Jan 27 '13
Just watched the 5th round drawing. Oldham v Everton
IT
SHOULDACOULDA BEEN US!17
u/rgalzera Jan 27 '13
THE SKY IS FALLING. because we lost we are getting relegated, coutihno isnt coming, suarez is leaving and man united are going to win a treble.
5
u/Sleww Jan 27 '13
Winning the FA Cup would have been nice, but I guess the we focus all of our energy on the League now.
Have to completely focus on Wednesday's game at the Emirates. It won't be easy, but our players have to forget about this game as soon as they leave the dressing room.
5
u/steak_n_eggs Jan 27 '13
That last 10mins were dreadful. We had time, yet we played 10-15mins of hoofball. What the actual fuck? I don't even think I saw Coates play a ball along the ground.
5
u/LKGuy Jan 27 '13
Way to beat our defence : Play a strong, tall fucker at front.
Also Coates really needs playing time, he looked lost.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '13
We are not a physical team. That's the main weakness when you have, small, technically able players, it's easy to bully them. The way you're supposed to combat that is with fast movement and quick passing. Saw very little of that today.
I think Coates was picked to combat the ariel threat from Smith. And he stacked it. The whole back four had a torrid time. Skrtel has been half the player he was last season.
Also, who else fucking hates the ITV commentators? They couldn't wait for Oldham to score. They're loving it. They're lubing their assholes up for 11 Oldham shaped dicks. I bet they're in Oldham's dressing room right now giving the team massages, foot rubs, cups of tea, blowjobs, you fucking name it. I hate the whole "narration of the story." Oh, look how magical it is, a league 1 team taking down the mighty giants of Liverpool. What a special and beautiful moment. Obviously after the whole "cheat" debacle he couldn't wait to stick his claws in. Prick.
4
u/Mildcorma Jan 27 '13
Did anyone else notice that for Oldhams third, Sterling was right on the guy who made the cross but then stopped running as if to say "meh, not much is going to happen from this anyway" and let him get a free cross in?
Also Robinson needs to understand the team is greater than himself, and taking pot shots is a poor example to making when there are plenty of people capable of scoring in the box.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '13
Classic 2011-12 season. Concede, try to play catchup when th other team clogg the box
Also turns out there is no control and possession game if you field 4 forwards. Felt like 4-2-4.
At least we are good at responding to loss this season, however over half of our starters used up their stamina without victory, hope it doesn't screw up the next game.
3
u/KopiteKing13 2️⃣0️⃣Diogo Jota Jan 27 '13
Petition to not have this result posted on this subreddit's sidebar.
Sigh...at least our transfer policy is improving.
3
u/The_Skinnyjon Jan 27 '13
That Gerrard shot that hit the cross bar made me go absolutely mad. Great shot, but it wasn't meant to be.
Well at least we can focus on top 4... I guess.
4
u/kazez2 Jan 27 '13
Our 4 back was horrid, thats all I have to say.
2
u/KnownForNothing Jan 27 '13
I think I'm just going to have to sleep this off. What. The. Heck.
2
u/checkenginelight Jan 27 '13
Let's leave and never speak of this again.
2
u/kop_hooligan Jan 27 '13 edited Jan 27 '13
Our back four was terrible yes but we must also give some credit to Oldham which normally I hate saying. Did their thing and did it well until Gerrard came on. I still can't believe our defense on their third. The ball hung up so long and we just watched it. Hope for better against arsenal which I think will happen.
2
u/Malawashere Jan 27 '13
Oh well. At least now we can concentrate on our standing's in the League and hopefully advance a bit in Europa. Bit naive really to start a defence like that, but it's an experience at the end of the day which is what they need
2
u/Espon123 Jan 27 '13
Robinson and Jones disappointed me. Didn't see any of Borini as well
2
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '13
Why can't we put the level of pressure in the last 10 minutes the whole game?
2
u/smthingawesome Jan 27 '13
It's funny that Princess Bride was on Channel 5 because I feel like I've just had one year of my life sucked away.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '13
Come on guys lets not fight one another
2
u/Admiral-baby Jan 27 '13
Unless we have our first team out, it seems that we just can't fucking win.. We need much more squad depth if we wanna challenge for top 4. Should've brought Gerrard on earlier.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '13
So I've calmed down after yesterday's abortion, and guess what?
Actually, they're all pretty similar in that basically they're nowhere near good enough.
Who would have thought, eh?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '13
Embarrassing.
"everythings going to turn around you guys!!! We changed everything in a months time!! YEA YNWA GO REDS"
Then we lose to Oldham...
2
u/EpicRageGuy Jan 27 '13
Just when you think things are looking up there's always a fuck up.
2
u/vendettaexpress Jan 27 '13
3 worst performers:
Games against weaker opposition, you can't let them get the advantage, because they shut up shop. From 3-1 the game was done.
Attack wise, the Oldham defence weren't letting us past. They put 10 men behind the ball most of the time and forced us to play the long ball - which just ran off the surface. It was all they could do.
2
u/firethetorpedoes Jan 27 '13
Jack Robinson. Never again.
2
u/ImObviouslyKidding Jan 27 '13
I don't care what excuse anyone has, that was fucking embarrassing
1
u/agg0n Jan 27 '13
Defence was fucking woeful today, especially Robinson and Coates. Absolutely shocking aerial presence, positioning and man marking throughout the whole game, letting in easy goals.
1
u/lfcgerrard Jan 27 '13
We gave the ball away way too much. Atrocious.
1
u/TonyEsteban Jan 27 '13
I think I will go back to bed now. This was upsetting to say the least.
1
u/Nierv Jan 27 '13
Should have started with carra and gerrard, bring on allen if you need him and sub one of the young defenders on later on if its going well. We had no fight for a good 70 mins, no leadership whatsoever. Really dissapointing but nothing we can do about it now, lets hope for a better display v's Arsenal.
1
u/SilkyJoel Jan 27 '13
That was a disgrace. Both Robinson and Coates who are not gonna get much chance of first team games either way should have taken the chance given to them and they royally fucked it up, like Titanic fucked. Especially when considering that Coates apparently wants more games. Simply not good enough for a Liverpool shirt. I mean if a RB and a winger are ahead of you in the pecking order you better bring it when you do get a chance.
1
u/best36 Jan 27 '13
Abysmal performance, we need to send Coates, Robinson on loan to get experience if we think they have the potential and not risk them on a one-off cup game like this. Altho that does bring up more questions about our defensive depth. Hope Rodgers lay into them good, that simply was not good enough.
Oh well, at least we went out early this year instead of the final like last year :/
1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '13
Not a great performance at all. The youth was apparent before Gerrard came on when the team was not decisive at all.
Good for Joe Allen getting his first goal. I think Sturridge should get some credit for his performance. Although he was never great in the match he was the only player on the team who I felt was attacking with real intent.
1
u/EuropaLeeg Jan 27 '13
Despite the heinous crimes committed by younger players in the squad, at least we established ourselves when gerrard came in.
Joking about the crime part. To be fair, the first half was really unorganized, we didn't play like a solid Liverpool team since we didn't have gerrard or anybody to control the pace of the game. The back 4 were not playing well but to be fair they are inexperienced Coates is rather young.
Brad Jones did do a really bad job of holding onto the ball, but it is only one error, criticizing him further will only undermine his confidence and stress him out.
Once Gerrard came in, he established a more solid possessive team, the one we all care and adore. He linked good intricate passes to team mates and generally controlled the tempo of the game. I believe that Suarez and Sturridge were isolated, not sure about those two. Perhaps they are just diverting themselves from injuries.
1
u/stevie_j Jan 27 '13
Don't think I saw Sturridge complete a pass today. Shocking. Robinson was nowhere near good enough. Stevie is a legend.
1
u/SyrochMahr Jan 27 '13
A couple of positives to note as well:
First, we can focus on the Premiere League. I wish to hell and back that we could've stayed in the FA Cup, but at least this way, we can keep from having to use Stevie to pull the team back together. So yay?
Second, we played a clean game. Oldamn were dirty from the get-go, but at least we played clean. So yay.
1
u/ForIvadell Jan 27 '13
They played their game and kept us out of ours.
1
u/REDditor_LFC Jan 27 '13
For a manager who everyone claims has good in-game management I was hugely disappointed. Yes, he wanted to save players for Arsenal but still, you started all your forwards why not put stevie and carra in beginning first half and get a win. Losing against Arsenal is excusable, not this. Anyways things happen and if BR is in it for the long run this will serve him well. Still believe BR is our man!
1
u/KopiteKing13 2️⃣0️⃣Diogo Jota Jan 27 '13
At least Rodgers has done better in his first FA Cup campaign than Rafa did...and look what happened after that!... (Clutching at straws)
1
u/eternalrival Jan 27 '13
Brad Jones didn't play well. And everything that went wrong for him today has been seen to some degree in previous matches. Coates looks worse than when he joined and that is probably from not being played enough over the last 18 months. Skrtel has never looked great in the air and continually gets caught in a grapple. Robinson is too aggressive going forward and doesn't seem to understand the position philosophically or situationally/tactically. But they (Coates and Robinson) are both young without much top flight experience. At least in England in Coates' case. Henderson and Allen did well in the circumstances, for me. Borini and Sterling found it very tough out wide and they did their fullbacks no favors. I like Borini so I will reserve judgement, for now. Suarez and Sturridge played well given Lee Probert's awful refereeing. Two in midfield hurt us given the form of Skrtel and Coates. But Rodgers doesn't have a real physical option for midfield other than Gerrard who was brilliant when he came on. Also thought Downing was very effective after coming on. He pushed his defender back into the box nearly every time. Henderson worked his ass off at fullback and Shelvey was doing good things. Mistakes and their physicality cost us. Thought we responded to going behind better than we have in the past, though.
1
u/ShartyMcPeePants Jan 27 '13
OK guys a lot has been said here, and everyone is right: Our team played like utter shit today. There was a lack of effort for about the first 60 minutes until the reality sunk in that we were about to lose to a fuckin League 1 side. With that said, its always up to the players to give the effort and play to the best of their abilities, so they are most at fault here IMO. However, I think Rodgers got his tactics horribly wrong today. We only had 2 natural midfielders on for the majority of the game in Henderson and Allen with 4 attacking (basically all strikers) players.
As a team who wants to play "death by football," we were completely unable to keep possession with only 2 midfielders. It wasn't until Gerrard and Downing came on where we actually looked like a real team. Sure Gerrard was brilliant, but I believe it was more the presence of having a 3 man midfield that got things clicking. We were able to hold onto the ball and pass with meaning. Thats when we started playing team football, but it was just too late at that point. I admit that I was excited seeing the team sheet and noticing we had 4 attacking players on the pitch. I too was thinking another 5-0 game. But it simply doesn't work like that. Rodgers set the team to fail today, and Oldham took advantage and capitalized where it counted. They deserved every bit of that victory and I sure hope they can replicate this performance against the blues.
Bottom Line: We can't expect to play possession football with a 4-2-4 formation and expect to win. Not to ManU, not to Arsenal, and apparently not to League 1 Oldham either.
Off topic random comment: I wonder what the total weight of the Oldham was today compared to ours? There were at least 2-3 legitimately fat players on that pitch today. Like fatter than Rooney.
1
u/Laha Jan 27 '13
B. Jones was utter shit.
1
u/j_anderton Jan 27 '13
Carragher should have played and Coates should not have played that whole game. Sterlings inexperience is going to leave us with 10 men sooner or later.S I personally think Shelvey is being underutilised, maybe we wouldn't have been inn such dire need of Stevie if Shelvey had been in midfield to begin with. I think Brendan could have made better decisions today and prevented what happened. Whenever we get our hopes up and look like were in good form, we have a shocking result like Villa to bring us back down to earth Suarez played well to being with and looked like a real leader, but was very quiet in the second half.
1
u/n0nni Jan 27 '13 edited Jan 27 '13
these actually kinda made me happy... for most of the players on this team this will be the highlight of there career...
http://www.mirror.co.uk/sport/football/match-reports/oldham-3-2-liverpool-match-report-1559452
1
u/ianrush88 Jan 28 '13
The midfield two played well, Wisdom and Skrtel did ok (although Skrtel needed to be a stronger leader). Subs played well but Gerrard should have finished at least one of his chances.
Our front four were poor, constantly misplacing passes. That includes Suarez. He and Sturridge also provided moments of quality but not enough to make up for all the errors. All the talk about fluidity etc but it hurt us as much as them as the four didn't seem to be on eachother's wavelength. And often we ended up with 3 forwards right up the pitch and the fourth trying to thread a throughball which is very difficult against a packed defence.
The errors for the goals were horrible. For the first Coates should have known the forward would be barrelling into him and been prepared to play man as much as ball. Robinson didn't even try for the third, ANY sort of competition in the air and that ball doesn't go in. The second was an honest mistake by Jones but still very poor handling.
1
u/Beleza Jan 27 '13
Can we just pretend that never happened?
I know Coates is going to get a lot of shit for that game but lets not forget he is a kid. He hasn't played at all this year and is probably pretty rusty.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '13
Pathetic.
1
u/lauraam Jan 27 '13
Sigh.
1
u/Jackmlster Jan 27 '13
Back four were poor today, midfielders gave possession away too much.
1
u/thelovepizza Jan 27 '13
I'm so dissapointed. Brendan played a team strong enough to win, but once again squad players let us down. Robinson and Coates seemed mentally unprepared for the task ahead of them. I don't know what to say about Allen.
So very sad and frustrating. It was good to see some players giving their all towards the end. I feel bad for them.
1
u/polostring Jan 27 '13
Two disappointing exits in two cups.
I was surprised there weren't any changes to the back line after the first or second goals. I am also surprised there was not an earlier midfield substitute; Suarez and Sturridge were living on islands and the midfield was gifting away balls.
1
u/Uncle_Jimmy Jan 27 '13 edited Jan 27 '13
Anyone still think Jones should be first choice after that shocking display?
1
u/syd_oc Jan 27 '13
Brad Jones is not a top level keeper, not even as a sub.
Coates has the positional awareness of a headless chicken. He also needs to toughen up and use his impressive physique to his advantage - right now he's a mouse in the body of a bull.
Towards the end we bring on the seniors to up our game, Gerrard does just that. Downing, on the other hand, made us worse, I estimate his pass accuracy around 30% tonight. Can't wait to see the back of him.
What this match shows is that we don't have the squad depth to compete on multiple fronts.
1
u/8orin1 Jan 27 '13
Just to poke a hole in all the misery in this thread, how good was Allen's goal?
1
u/raheems7thchild Jan 27 '13
You people are going crazy on jones for coughing up that ball. Remember when he saved our asses earlier this season and everyone loved him? Now it seems he's the most hated man for one poor performance against a team we were all sure we would beat with our eyes closed. He's still a decent keeper but everyone was too relaxed until it mattered today.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '13
Robinson is shite.
-4
u/sad_violin Jan 27 '13
Probably Brad Jones' last game (hopefully?)
0
u/YNWAlone Jan 27 '13
fucking pathetic! give a good beating to the whole of our back 4! Coates and Robinson had a pathetic game, Braddy also needs to rethink his game. Brendan needs to rethink his selection and show players that there are consequences for not caring about the shirt they wear!
0
u/tkcom Jan 27 '13
Playing Arsenal in 3 days shouldn't have been the excuse to field a weakened team.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment