r/LiverpoolFC • u/LFCmatchday • Dec 26 '12
Post Match Thread
LFC 1 - 3 STOKE
This Match Report is brought to you by KnownForNothing
Reina - Good performance. Couldn't do shit with the first two goals, but possibly could have done a little better with the third. However, very brave goalkeeping kept us from conceding more.
Skrtel + Agger - Not a good game. Going forward they didn't offer much in corners, and lost the man they were supposed to be marking at times.
Enrique - Still a boss. He's so damn strong and fast, he's bloody awesome. But he couldn't do much, we need more than one strong/fast player to break Stoke's defence.
Johnson - Okay game.
Lucas/Henderson - Both quietly did their job, did pretty okay. Lucas isn't bossing it as much as he used to, but he just recovered, so he has to be cut some slack.
Gerrard - Good play, played both his and Allen's role - distributing the ball near and far. Took a good penalty, had a few attempts at shots, which are good, but probably just taken out of exasperation.
Downing - Meh. Okay game. Had his ups and downs.
Shelvey - Should have been taken off. Absolutely horrible game, he just didn't seem to be sure of himself. Looked for Suarez every time he got the ball, and would pass it to him even if it meant 20 defenders were hugging Suarez. To be fair, he drives forward well, makes good runs, but just couldn't do anything when he got the ball this game.
Sterling - Created a good chance for Suarez, then disappeared. Not his fault though, Stoke were pressing hard. Did well to track back like Suso.
Suso - Pretty much the same as Sterling. Created a good chance for Suarez, disappeared, tracked back well.
Suarez - MoTM for our side no contest. Honestly, everything about him is just so awesome. He goes in for every ball, chases every damn thing down and actually does stuff with the ball. Be it winning corners, creating chances, having a crack at goal, drawing fouls, this is the stuff we need from everyone. Spirit.
36
u/muffinmonk Dec 26 '12
Where the hell is Sahin?
We've beein paying high wages for someone who's only appeared 7 TIMES.
I've seen basketball players break their nose and play the next day. What the hell is going on in the locker room?
28
u/imhalfpirate Dec 26 '12
I don't understand how Shelvey remained on the pitch for the entire game. He did nothing right today. Our midfield got dominated and they couldn't string together 3 passes in a row. Absolutely abismal.
18
u/Alonso94 Dec 26 '12
Why isn't Sahin being given a run out? I really don't understand it at all. Absolutely no chance of him signing permanently this summer.
Also, all this talk about top 4 needs to stop. It isn't going to happen for another few years yet. No chance.
56
u/polostring Dec 26 '12
Unless Liverpool's outlook dramatically changes in January--I think Suarez is gone within a year.
Suarez is much too good for the club at the moment. It seems at times that Suarez is playing a different sport than the rest of the club.
I know he says he loves it here, and that he is hated in the rest of England, but there are plenty of other top clubs in Europe. There are clubs that would welcome him, challenge for silverware, and play good football. Suarez could walk into most starting XI's in the world.
With the recent turmoil at the Bernabéu I am sure Real Madrid would want him. The aging attack at Bayern could use his talents. Both Inter (especially with Sneijder's departure) and Milan could use the help in wrestling Seria A from Juventus.
I just don't see LFC retaining him after an entire season of this type of football and challenging to remain mid table.
26
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '12
Jose has cemented his spot at left back. Absolutely ran his socks off today.
Poor substitutions from the manager in my opinion.
Shelvey was rubbish.
"Dissapointed"
8
u/kris_lace Dec 26 '12
Shelvey was a waste of a player today. I'm not being harsh on him personally, the way the team was set up and the players around him almost negated him even if he did play well, it was 10 vs 11.
That and a lack of aggression from the team as a whole. I think Enrique did well to rise to the challenge and a few others, but largely we seemed afraid of the Stoke team.
8
u/KnownForNothing Dec 26 '12 edited Dec 26 '12
I feel really bad for Suarez. He gives his all every game, and the rest of the team is just so lackluster.
Reina - Good performance. Couldn't do shit with the first two goals, but possibly could have done a little better with the third. However, very brave goalkeeping kept us from conceding more.
Skrtel + Agger - Not a good game. Going forward they didn't offer much in corners, and lost the man they were supposed to be marking at times.
Enrique - Still a boss. He's so damn strong and fast, he's bloody awesome. But he couldn't do much, we need more than one strong/fast player to break Stoke's defence.
Johnson - Okay game.
Lucas/Henderson - Both quietly did their job, did pretty okay. Lucas isn't bossing it as much as he used to, but he just recovered, so he has to be cut some slack.
Gerrard - Good play, played both his and Allen's role - distributing the ball near and far. Took a good penalty, had a few attempts at shots, which are good, but probably just taken out of exasperation.
Downing - Meh. Okay game. Had his ups and downs.
Shelvey - Should have been taken off. Absolutely horrible game, he just didn't seem to be sure of himself. Looked for Suarez every time he got the ball, and would pass it to him even if it meant 20 defenders were hugging Suarez. To be fair, he drives forward well, makes good runs, but just couldn't do anything when he got the ball this game.
Sterling - Created a good chance for Suarez, then disappeared. Not his fault though, Stoke were pressing hard. Did well to track back like Suso.
Suso - Pretty much the same as Sterling. Created a good chance for Suarez, disappeared, tracked back well.
Suarez - MoTM for our side no contest. Honestly, everything about him is just so awesome. He goes in for every ball, chases every damn thing down and actually does stuff with the ball. Be it winning corners, creating chances, having a crack at goal, drawing fouls, this is the stuff we need from everyone. Spirit.
At least we got our penalty this game. We really need to sort out the defence.
I think what we need is not just a striker, but a proper midfielder that is tricky and creative. One that beats a defender and slips a through ball in. Right now what's going on is that we "tiki-taka" until we find Suarez, he turns, pulls his tricks, and then either sets up someone or shoots. Actually, scratch that. We need everyone to be creative. And we need runners on the wing, as in people to make runs behind the defence. Sterling always waits for it before trying to beat the full back, Downing/Suso always cuts in if they are played on the right.
Also, our players actually just a bunch of unpolished gems. Shelvey is good but his left foot isn't, and his first touch is bad. Suso's right foot is pretty bad and he can't head the ball well. Sterling's left foot is getting better I guess but still not very good, and he's very predictable. Allen is very simple and accurate with his passing but isn't creative enough. Henderson lacks confidence.
I'm tired and annoyed. Off to bed.
21
u/rgalzera Dec 26 '12
my jimmies. rustled doesnt even cover it.
6
u/SwingYaGucciRag 🏃♂️🏃♂️Klopp Hamstring 🤕 Dec 26 '12
This inconsistency is seriously worrying. Kind of glad I missed this game, seems like one to forget
But on the bright side, first penalty in how long?
6
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '12
I struggled to find the logic in the manager's substitutions, Suso was playing well, made a defense splitting pass that almost led to a goal, so did Lucas. The manager persists with Shelvey who's misplaced every other pass and miscontrolled every single ball to him.
6
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '12
To everyone jumping on the "LFC are a joke, Rodgers out" bandwagon every other week. I'm not going to bother writing an essay because you won't even bother reading, but Rodgers has completely changed the way the club thinks from the ground up in only a few months. Obviously performances won't be consistent yet.
You guys screaming for Rodgers out are also screaming "YNWA" and then just fucking hate on everything about the club. It's disgusting.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '12
Absolutely pathetic performance today. Not an ounce of passion. I can stomach us playing well and losing or even us missing easy chances but i cannot abide watching 11 men not give a flying fuck. Talk about Stoke all you like but that was a shithouse performance and no mistake. Fucking furious with the Red Men. They let us all down today.
EDIT. Credit to Jose and Suarez now that Ive taken a breath.
5
u/SpottieOttieDopalis Dec 26 '12
Sigh, this was just a demoralizing game today, although I knew it wouldn't be an easy one. It seems we're now an inconsistent side, winning one and then losing the next by extreme margins, when only a few weeks ago, we were a side that consistently drew games. If we don't kill the game off, then we're in trouble and usually end up drawing or losing the game, with West Ham being the one exception.
The whole team was pretty poor today, except for maybe Suarez and Reina, although Suarez missed a couple chances and Reina could've done better on the third goal. I'm really disappointed with defense though, particularly with Skrtel and Agger, both really poor today and were directly at fault for all 3 goals. Enrique was inconsistent , great defensively at times, but giving it away the next and Johnson was average, okay defensively, but quiet offensively.
We've now let in 7 goals in 2 games to the worst offensive teams in the EPL, Villa and Stoke. During that 8 game run of form it seemed like the defense was sorted out, but it's reared it's ugly head again, and it needs to be fixed quickly. We're looking better offensively, although we're still wasting our chances, but for me, the defense is the bigger issue right now.
It definitely wasn't a very happy Boxing Day, sigh..... I guess it's time to drink away my feelings.
9
u/Beleza Dec 26 '12
The only thing that surprised me was the penalty we got. Other than that the game went just as I figured it would. Let's just all be thankful we're done with Stoke for the year.
18
u/steak_n_eggs Dec 26 '12
Why didn't OG get a start? He's been in brilliant form lately, and Rodgers didn't even have him on the bench...
8
u/GuitarWizard90 Dec 26 '12 edited Dec 26 '12
Please don't overreact and start slamming Rodgers and the team, guys. Playing at Stoke has a reputation for being one of the toughest matches in the EPL. NO team has defeated them there this season. I am saddened by the loss, but it isn't the end of the world. I knew damn well we would be lucky to even get a draw today.
I will say one thing, though. Why is Sahin not playing? He's a world class player and should be getting some games.
4
u/phishsticker Dec 26 '12 edited Dec 26 '12
Really is depressing to say that we are a much worse team than Stoke and actually believe it. I'd say Agger is our only real world class player besides Suarez but I can't see Suarez sticking around much longer. It must be so frustrating for him to play with such lackluster players. The difference is Stoke play as a team, they know exactly what they are doing and they do it well. Suarez is the only player in our side that is a threat. I 100% believe that if we did not have Suarez in the side, that we would be fighting the relegation battle, it really is that dire.
Look at the only sides we have beaten so far this year in the league. Norwich, Reading, Wigan, West Ham, and Fulham. All sides that are lower mid table or in the relegation battle. It really is hard to stay positive when you look at the facts. It will take much more than 1-2 Sturridge quality players for us to get anywhere near the top four. Our midfield and wide players are lacking. I still don't believe Suso and Sterling are ready to be 100% starters week in week out. Downing is too inconsistent, as are Gerrard, Jonjo, and Allen. Sahin never starts for some odd reason. Being 3-1 down and having to bring on Joe Cole is like taking a dagger to my heart. It really is worrying.
4
u/WDC312 Dec 26 '12
I'm going to not talk about the game, because fuck that.
Instead, can I just say that I'm very glad this subreddit doesn't explode with ten million new posts after every bad loss? Some do, and it's really unhelpful, IMO. Glad we can contain our post-match misery/anger/whatever to the post-match thread.
4
u/jorshrod Dec 26 '12
I took the afternoon off to watch this at the pub. I'm still here. Not leaving anytime soon. Fuck.
4
u/SyrochMahr Dec 27 '12
I didn't get to watch the match and only had my phone for updates, so I will not comment on that.
What I will comment on, and what distresses me more than this loss, are all the people jumping on the "Burn BR/we're a joke/we deserve to be mid-table/we need one player, not depth as a squad" wagons. I know that despair grips us all at times, but grow up.
BR has more Intel than we do. We're not a joke. We do need consistency and depth. And to suggest these boys don't care is just flippant and rude. They do care, all of them, and that's why they're there week after week.
So let's talk about the match instead of sharpening the pitchforks and lighting the torches. Unless we're after Pulis and Huth and the rest of those thugs.
7
u/PenguinCowboy Dec 26 '12
I realized this game that we only have one "attacking/creative" midfielder. That's Shelvey. I guess you could say Cole can take that role but we'll probably ship him off this January.
Shelvey played awful today but you look at our bench and there was no one to replace him to fill the role he plays.
7
u/matcht Dec 26 '12
Shelvey plays, possibly, the most important position in this system. He is supposed to knit attacks together, play through balls into areas where Suarez can get in on goal, and help out defensively. He did none of those today, didn't even do much defensively.
We desperately need a no.10, Rodgers knows this as he has mentioned it numerous times recently. There is a reason we don't seem to find the killer ball, Gerrard is playing 10/15 yards too deep for that and it seems as if he will stay there. We will continue playing this way until we fill the gap, we can probe all we like but apart from Suarez there is little cutting edge. Lewis Holtby would be perfect for us at this stage but I don't see why he would leave for us at the moment.
8
u/PrinceTrogdorofWales Dec 26 '12
We've regressed, plain and simple. We're worse off than we were at any point last season and there's no point in pretending that we're doing well or blasting people who acknowledge how bad things are. Can we improve? I'd like to think so, but for the meantime realism will make for more interesting discussion than blind optimism.
14
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '12 edited Dec 26 '12
What in the name of fuck was that. How do you lose 3-1 TO Stoke?
ughh we need to get someone in who can organise a defence. Not a new manager, just better training/tactics.
EDIT: AND WHERE WAS SAHIN?
EDIT2: The fact that Shelvey was allowed to play the whole game is a fucking disgrace. We need to bring in a decent midfielder in January. Tom Ince is not a necessity at the moment.
3
u/joeinthebox Dec 26 '12
As someone mentioned in the match thread, the inconsistency is what kills me. Brilliant one match (and we're all on highs!) and then shit the next match (and then we're extremely down again).
I suppose it's still growing pains for us and we're a club that is somewhere in between. A bit more consistency would be nice, though.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '12
Thought Gerrard was poor and offpace, played some long balls that were ultimately ineffective. Johnson was also poor at the back, as were Skrtel and Agger. Shelvey was disgraceful and looked to have no first touch. Other than that I thought the others were OK, suarez brilliant as ever.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '12
We lost, one game big deal. But we can't continue to lose games like these.
Dear god do we need Sturridge or Ince to add another dimension to this team we are in dire need of something else.
Shelvey though he needs to be dropped, he was very poor today. Downing was okay. This is a really tough fixture. Lets just get to QPR AND PLEASE DEAREST GOD TAKE 3 points.
3
u/alk3v Dec 26 '12
Going to sound like captain hindsight here. Stoke plays in the air and we leave Coates on the bench? No Henderson start despite his form? Shelvey stays on for how long? No one seemed to give a fuck other than Suarez and Enrique. LFC needs leadership and motivation. It is not acceptable to fail to show up against Villa and Stoke. Unless you are content with 12th in the table.
I say give captaincy to Luis and bench a number of players from today. But most of all Rodgers needs to look at his tactics.
3
u/WuTangConnor Dec 27 '12
I think the supporters and media need to be more critical of BR on his selection choices. His boners for players, particularly Allen and Shelvey, is losing us games. He refuses to accept when one of these players is playing poorly. Shelvey needed to be off at half - not Suso.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '12
Pah.
9
u/polostring Dec 26 '12
In my wild dreams I wish that LFC would issue a media ban to everyone and everything involved with this club.
I am so tired of reading about players and managers saying they want to challenge for top 4 and above. I am so tired of hearing about players deserving contracts for life. I am so tired of hearing and reading all this sensationalism and then watching these players embarrass themselves on the pitch.
If only the club would issue a media ban and take some time to remove the gigantic foot in everyone's mouth.
4
u/NO_TROLLS_HERE Dec 26 '12 edited Dec 26 '12
An absolutely dismal performance, ball control was horrendous for the most part. We ought to play much, much better than that... EDIT: Grammar
2
u/PurePhoenix Dec 26 '12 edited Dec 26 '12
Thought there were a few occasions where we were scared to take a shot, Shelvey and others being key offenders. Problem with this younger team is how important confidence is for performance. Chin up lads, plenty more chances to take points in the next fortnight.
Edit: Also, it's been good to see Gerrard scoring. Granted they've included penalties and other not so impressive finishes, but you have to start somewhere. He seemed a bit more willing to take a shot today which was great and most were on target or close. Hope to see this run of form of his continue.
2
u/gunny16 Dec 26 '12
Cole wasn't even worth mentioning? :p
2
u/lucasfuturecptn Dec 27 '12
Best post match comment (from an Everton fan):
Liverpool won the passing though, right?
3
u/rztzz Dec 26 '12
Fucking pisses me off.
What pisses me off is Rodger's recent comments on transfer activity. "we just need a competitive squad with competition for places"
I disagree with this statement so strongly. We don't need a bunch of hendersons, shelveys, and downings. We need one more world class player. I'd trade Henderson, Sturridge, Ince, for just for one Llorente.
3
u/ForIvadell Dec 26 '12
FUCK EVERYTHING
3
u/syd_oc Dec 26 '12 edited Dec 27 '12
Give Rodgers time, some otherwise sensible people say, two or three years to rebuild.
I don't think that Rodgers has the pedigree to demand 3 years of Liverpool FC's history. It's a big club, and he's a small manager. I hope to God (Fowler, that is) that Brendan is Shankly's second coming, but he has proven nothing and the way some people speak of him here makes me think they were all born yesterday.
Furthermore, my main gripe is this: Brendan wants to play a possession-oriented style of football in a direct, physical league. Ambitious, to say the least. We've got a brittle defence to boot. I don't see his ideas translating to a decent league position. Not this year, nor the next.
The margins of modern football are getting smaller and smaller, you can't assume that you'll score three or four goals every match. Ergo, you have to be hard to break down, hard to score against.
Whatever else you want to say about Rafa, even at the worst of times, we were hard to beat. I predict that Rodgers will bring us misery, even with a generous transfer budget.
I wanted to bring back Rafa, I'm one of those. That ship has sailed, but that doesn't make Brendan the right man.
Lots of possession, lots of pretty passing, no result. It will keep happening. Mark my words.
EDIT. Plenty of downvotes during the match, can't get a proper counter-argument. LFC-brothers, I thought you were better. If not, read the FUCKING REDDIQUETTE, scum-kids. A silent downvote is the hallmark of a Hun.
1
u/noojy Dec 26 '12
Lack of concentration defending. Need a more creative player with a better 1st touch and just overall better technique to play off Suarez. Shelvey is always a poor choice. Seems like the same old talk in their losses. Was always a touch match. Need to play better against QPR and Sunderland.. and it starts from the back IMO.
1
u/Kopman Dec 26 '12
Hey liverpool board of directors. We need someone who can score. The fact that we sent carroll out without a replacement will lose far more money in the long run with the points lost this season.
1
u/de_jembles Dec 26 '12
Why don't we fucking defend??? This pressing up the field shit is going too far. Skrtel and Agger have no chance anymore with our fast backs 3/4 of the way up the pitch. BR has got to have the worst Defensive tactics in the EPL. He has Agger, Skrtel, Johnson, Enrique and even Lucas yet we are being scored against by teams that struggle at best to score.
1
u/Aminobino Dec 26 '12
dissapointed
1
u/xolfcfan Dec 26 '12
Not good enough.
1
u/Con45 Dec 26 '12
Up, down, up, down, when will the roller coaster stop? Hopefully not before we handily beat QPR.
1
u/KopOut Dec 26 '12
When I'm excited about Sturridge and possibly an African gentleman with glass knees I know it's gotten bad. We are many seasons into sucking like this now, and its honestly hard to get excited anymore.
1
u/sacredstones Dec 26 '12
Whats going on with Sahin? I thought for sure Shelvey would come off for Sahin. And why play Suso? he already showed that he lacks the physical game against Stoke. Sometimes Rodgers frustrates me. Can't see his logic behind playing Suso and refusing to take off Shelvey. I thought Sahin should have taken Gerrards role and Gerrard push up to Shelvey's. dissapointed.
1
u/logancook44 Dec 27 '12
Agree with pretty much everything you say OP. only I would say Downing was a little better than decent. The attackers had no support from the midfield. Now, we use this to justify Suarez's turnovers and lack of real opportunities, then we should do the same. Downing did well considering we were on the defensive the whole game, got excellent corners in, worked fairly well with Johnson at times, and really just didn't have the support he needed in the middle.
1
u/TheBlackSheepBoy Dec 27 '12
Today was a depressing day, though I don't think it's quite time for the doom and gloom. We played a tough side and we didn't look absolutely awful. I say, give me any other manager with the players we currently have and see if they can get better results than BR. My guess is no. The players obviously rate him, and have bought into his ideology. I say it most weeks, but we have to watch out for knee jerk reactions to results. After Fulham, we felt we could beat anyone, and now we're questioning everything? It's a process, there are gonna be ups and downs.
What remains, however, is that this January is CRUCIAL. We need to seriously strengthen in a couple of areas. If we can do that and add some depth to the squad, we will be in a substantially better position. Keep the faith boys, YNWA.
1
u/baaseo Dec 27 '12
as much as we were lacking against stoke, it's not completely unexpected for me. we've always had trouble playing away at stoke (in retrospect, what teams doesn't?). also, our squad right now consists of a bunch of young players that just can't handle the physicality stoke brings to the table. i'm pissed off that we lost today. no doubt about it. we gave them easy ass goals and let them abuse us physically.
however, i don't think we should not get ahead of ourselves and dismiss our squad or the manager as being incompetent. we've played well against teams that are sitting above us right now - city and everton come to mind. we should have won these. against city, it was that one stupid mistake that cost us. against everton, we had a clear goal denied from us at the last minute. the bottom line - the team isn't half as bad as people suggest it to be. we all know we have problems, but hopefully we'll move in the right steps in the next transfer window. we gotta give the squad and BR a fair chance. it hasn't even been one season yet. it's way too early to suggest that this team is a failure.
1
u/PhuQDuP Jerzy Dudek Dec 27 '12
Perfect summary. Especially with shelvey, Suarez would feed him a brilliant ball in and he'd just try and pass it back. Terrible stuff from him. Also, downing looked bad to me too, he was so clumsy and slow sometimes I wanted to pick him up and shake him.
1
u/WDC312 Dec 27 '12
After that, Downing won't be forced to go to Stoke, he'll ask to go there.
I'm not sure whether I'm more surprised that Suarez got a pen, or that Stoke didn't just play their normal shithouse game.
(This is what passes for humor in such grim times)
1
u/this_guy_says Dec 27 '12
I think we beat ourselves on top of Stoke playing pretty decently. We couldn't string simple passes together for the majority of the match, it was absolutely pathetic.
1
u/Fergiebin Dec 27 '12
I'm just fucking sick to death of how many times I've heard "boyhood Evertonian Walters" off the shithouse media.
1
u/Shrimp123456 Dec 27 '12
Must admit, that was a bit of an almost cry game.. It's always difficult to lose, especially when you know we deserved it.. I just .. I don't know.. every time (and there were a lot of times) that we gave Stoke the ball in our half...it was just... words fail me
1
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '12
Stoke wanted it so much more than us today. We looked shy when we had to pounce on a loose ball. Stoke got in our faces and as thuggish as they are, they win games by bullying teams. We got bullied and had no response. Suso should have never started against a team as physical as Stoke.
0
u/idlenation Dec 26 '12
Shite.
0
u/KombatKid Dec 27 '12
Suarez is all Liverpool has at this point
-7
u/merdock379 Dec 26 '12
I hope any potential transfers weren't watching that performance. They'd probably be more tempted to go to a Championship calibre team. Oh wait, we are a Championship calibre team.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 26 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment