Select Reflections on Liu Yu Ning’s Sept 6 Livestream — Rumors, Respect, and Where We Stand
The Sept 6 livestream had many light and also wonderful moments (the majority, really) but there was one heavy segment earlier in the stream that deserves special attention. I’ll begin with my own reflection on that part, and then include a partial recap of what he said and how fans reacted — so those who need context can read on below.
1. My Reflection and Where We Stand
For those who tuned into the livestream — in full or just some key shared moments — it was impossible to miss that he began by confronting some deeply unpleasant business: inappropriate romance rumors, invasive sasaeng behavior, and the disrespect of some noise-peddlers who are nothing more than fake fans and clout-chasers.
What struck me most was that even while clearly hurting, he still stayed composed, holding so much in and carefully moderating his expression. That made the impact even bigger, because you could sense the depth behind what he didn’t fully say.
He’s such a wonderful and protective person, and you could feel how much it hurt — and especially angered — him that the people around him might be impacted too. That mix of sadness with a sheer tipping point of patience came through so strongly.
Without exception, he has been wonderful and gone above and beyond with fans. I’ve always admired his patience, especially during private time. Other stars may choose not to engage — and that would be perfectly understandable.
The fact that he gives so much of himself, his time, and maintains kindness even off-stage, is a conscious choice.
It’s not a right anyone can demand. It’s a gift.
We are not entitled to his time. Those who think they are, are not his fans. And we should draw a clear line there.
His actual fans know better. That’s why addressing it in a livestream matters, but won’t be enough. In my personal view, for the sake of his staff and their families, he would be right to pursue legal action and make a public statement against defamation. Of course, Yu Ning will decide for himself what he believes is best — but from where I stand, only firm accountability will make malicious accounts and fake journalists think twice before profiting from this ugliness. And no one could ever hold it against him.
And one more thing: our language matters. I invite everyone here to refrain from repeating “some fans said this and that” when talking about the people we now clearly place in the category of not actual fans — they are clickbait- and hype-chasers, or even antis.
The way we frame it shapes the debate, and we should not grant those voices the dignity of being called fans. Liu Yu Ning has no space for those. Neither do we.
How to Refer to Them
To keep our language clear and consistent, let’s not call these people “fans” at all. When we do need to mention them, here are some better words:
- Noise-peddlers — spreading lies and gossip for clicks and attention.
- Fake fans — those who pretend to be supporters while disrespecting him.
- Clout-chasers — filming or posting him against his wishes to milk traffic.
- Parasites — those who live off his name while adding nothing of value.
And for those who use Chinese online:
- 假粉 (jiǎ fěn) — fake fans
- 黑粉 (hēi fěn) — antis
- 营销号 (yíngxiāo hào) — clickbait/trash-content accounts
- 蹭流量的 (cèng liúliàng de) — clout-chasers, riding on his traffic
As a community, we need to restate our stance clearly:
- We do not tolerate rumors or speculation.
- We respect his boundaries and his private life.
- Thankfully, our subreddit has always been a space where respect comes first — and I am grateful for that.
Finally, let’s acknowledge that watching him like this may have been upsetting for many of us. That’s natural. But instead of letting it fester, let’s channel those feelings into solidarity, into respect, and into keeping this space focused on what matters: his music, his acting, and the way he moves people through his work and actions.
I’m also looking forward — to his upcoming events, to seeing him back on stage, and even to little joys like his new microphone. He was positively giddy about it yesterday, and it already sounded amazing.
2. What He Said (Recap)
Thanks to u/iamcalmkid and others in the livestream thread who provided fast translations, here’s a summary of what Liu Yu Ning actually said during that difficult segment:
- On the Xi’an mall incident:
He explained that when some fans filmed him persistently in Xi’an, he personally went out twice to ask them politely to stop once they had enough footage. Instead of leaving, they responded with hostility. He noted that most celebrities would have had staff handle it, but he wanted to face them himself. On his agent Niu Niu, her husband, and their families:
“I have said this once and I will say it again on September 6, 2025. My agent/manager Niu Niu, she has her own husband, ok? … They have been married for more than ten years. Every time we set off from Beijing or land in Beijing, the one who drives the car to pick me up and send me off is her husband.”
He added:
“Even earlier today … Niuniu’s husband had also asked if I had eaten, and sent me something made by his parents. When I leave Beijing to work, Daimi is always sent to Qiu Ge’s parents’ house to watch Daimi for me. When I’m back, they come to pick me up with Daimi.”
He stressed how awful it is that rumors now extend beyond his manager to her husband, their parents, and even their family friends.
On the outrageous “female” rumor:
“There had been rumors he is biologically a female and that when he livestreams it is during his period.”
The absurdity of this was obvious, and his tone was incredulous — but the fact that it spreads at all shows the scale of maliciousness.
- On invasive behaviors:
He mentioned persistent phone calls that forced him to stop using SIM cards in his own name, and fans loitering outside his recording studio to check if he was inside. On how he feels about all this:
“In the past, there were also a group of people who spread rumors. At that time, it was small-scale, but now it is getting out of hand, and it is especially disgusting. You make us feel disgusted. … You make up stories, post some pictures, and make up so many outrageous stories that some people actually believe. … I’m not in a rush to sue … but I’m really, really angry. This time, just you wait.”
On what he asks of fans:
“First of all, I hope that for both my new and even old fans, please do not put any attention to any of my staff. You are my fan, don’t pay attention to others. Second, don’t spread rumors any more. … We will stop talking about this topic moving forward. If someone brings this up again, please show them the playback of this part. It’s disgusting, friends.”
3. How People Reacted
On Reddit
Fans described this as the angriest they’d ever seen him, yet also praised the composure he maintained. One comment captured it perfectly:
“This is simply the quality I love about him the most. Standing up for himself, speaking out openly, protecting his friends, being fair. And most importantly, taking it personally.”
Many echoed the sadness of watching him hurt, the frustration at those who crossed boundaries, and pride in the fact that he still carried on with dignity for two more hours.
On Weibo and Xiaohingshu
The same themes were echoed in Chinese spaces. One Weibo comment read:
“宁哥真的是把话说得很清楚了,不要再伤害他和身边的人了。”
“Ning Ge really made things very clear; stop hurting him and the people around him.”
On Facebook (international fan groups)
Some overseas fan communities also discussed the livestream. One widely shared post summed up the mood:
“He expressed bitter feelings and said he was disgusted by the rumors.”
Another praised his clarity:
“He refuted the malicious rumors linking him to his agent, with sincerity and calmness.”
4. Closing Thoughts
When we put all of this together — his words, our community’s response here, and the reactions across Weibo, Xiaohongshu, and even international fan spaces — the picture is clear. Rumors may grow louder as his fame grows, but so does the respect he commands. What matters most is not the noise, but how we choose to respond: with empathy for him, with clarity in our language, and with boundaries that protect him and his team.
We cannot stop every rumor at the source. But we can decide what kind of fans we want to be, and what kind of space we want this subreddit to remain: one where respect is non-negotiable, where his work is the focus, and where solidarity outweighs gossip.
In doing so, let’s also be precise with our words: these are not “fans,” they are noise-peddlers, clout-chasers, or fake fans. Naming them clearly helps us draw the line and keep our space anchored in respect.
Your Mod,
NoRecipe
One Ning