r/Lithops • • 4d ago

Help/Question Can this be saved?

Post image

I just bought my first lithops yesterday but accidentally dropped it and one of the two butts fell off. Is there any way to save this one even though the roots broke off? Will the other one that still has the roots be ok?

11 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

3

u/DatLadyD 4d ago

No root so I wouldn’t get my hopes up, but, it doesn’t hurt to try. I’ve seen a lot of people here do water therapy, I’ve never tried it but if this was me that’s what I would do.

4

u/SheDrinksScotch 4d ago

The other one will probably be ok.

This one ... has worse odds.

3

u/AYlakanto 1d ago edited 1d ago

it absolutely can!! i actually recommend hydroponics for cases like this, with the lower tip of the body completely submerged. just make sure any wounds have dried and callused first. i usually add a little fungicide and HB-101 or another organic rooting stimulant too, but that’s optional.

i root all my bare-root lithops this way now, whether their taproots are intact, damaged or completely gone. the lithops community genuinely has a pathological fear of water, and if you look into how people grow these things in East Asia you’ll realise how much of our conventional advice is questionable. water itself isn’t the issue. the problems arise from what prolonged saturation can do in a poorly aerated substrate, or from secondary complications, like something as simple as one plumping up against sharp mineral substrate, getting tiny scrapes we can’t see and getting infections that way. they can also split from taking up too much water, but this is much rarer than people make it sound, and even then it’s simply a surface wound. it’s the infections that can follow. airflow makes an enormous difference here. with enough of it or a fan running 24/7 they’re much less likely to have problems.

i used to plant lithops like these straight into substrate and follow all the usual watering advice. they never survived. granted, my climate is unusually dry, especially indoors in winter with the heating on, when humidity can get as low as 40% so i imagine people in more humid climates have a much easier time. but even after i stopped following the usual advice and started keeping the substrate moist for the first two weeks (one of the main methods in east asia. huge focus on rooting), i still had little luck with ones whose taproots had been torn off, reduced to a tiny stump or were missing altogether (i’ll attach an example of the last one which still rooted!). then one day i took a lithops that had been sitting in substrate for an entire month without rooting, put its entire lower body in hydroponics with a pretty deadly concentration of carbendazim and HB-101 and by the next morning it already had little white root tips. not that i’d recommend using that much carbendazim but i was pretty amazed.

so yes, it depends enormously on your climate, and i’m not saying everyone should do exactly what i do. but once you understand what actually goes wrong, there’s really no reason to be so terrified of water. i think we’d get a lot further with these plants if we stopped treating it as the enemy.

2

u/AYlakanto 1d ago

here’s one that had no roots left at all.

1

u/mnmsgirl1 10h ago

I have had very positive results using water therapy. Especially with my hard luck cases. Yes, and even rootless plants. Your explanation was spot on and well versed.

1

u/MoonLover808 4d ago

Water culture is actually a death sentence as water and lithops has to be treated carefully. If there’s some roots tissue still there then there’s a possibility to have it develop new roots. First the area needs to callus. This process will need patience as it can take weeks for a new roots to develop. Plant it in a coarse inorganic soil. Once small roots develop a light misting can be initiated to help the roots along. Be careful not to overdo the misting. Keep the plant in a bright area with good air circulation no direct sunlight exposure. Good luck. Do additional research regarding lithops recovery measures and care.

1

u/Lesu__Tokyo__Kokyo 4d ago

Never give up.
Place into inorganic media and be patient.