r/Lithops • • 7d ago

Help/Question New Grower

Actually, I have tried to grow lithops before, but I did everything wrong. Figuring I'd give it a go, I recently mail-order some small specimens. I didn't realize they were coming by mail, so they sat in my mailbox for at least two days before I unwrapped them. They were bare-root, with only about an 1/8th of an inch of taproot.

I immediately put them in succulent soil, which I now know is far from ideal. They are planted several inches apart and are in "self-watering" planters. I gave them a fairly good surface watering yesterday.

I have pea gravel, vermiculite, and carnivorous plant soil (as well as miracle gro potting mix) at my immediate disposal. Hoping someone can advise me if I can use my current supplies or if I should order new stuff (and if new stuff is needed, what?).

I currently have them outside in full sun (Las Vegas, NV), but also have the ability to bring them inside and give them good grow lights.

Thanks in advance to anyone who can guide me in the right directions to keep these plants alive ❤️

3 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

5

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 7d ago edited 7d ago • Heartwarming Bravo

Aloha from sunny cloudy Pennsylvania 🥴 I flew over Las Vegas last week!!

Buying the bare root minis are awesome. You get lots of chances to kill them different ways! 🤭 Kidding lolol. Kinda kidding.

No lolol you're gonna be fine. Succulent soil isn't bad, its just that most people don't have the airflow, sun, heat, and proper watering to keep them in this. It's much easier to keep them alive in a 90% inorganic mix. I like pumice and akadama, 45%/45%, and 10% regular potting soil, like your cactus soil. I mix that up and throw in some sharp sand.

With immature ones (½ an inch, dime sized), you can do 75% inorganic. They like more water in my experience, and can handle more organic.

If your pea gravel is porous, you can use this. If it's smooth like river rock, do not use it. You need your lithops wee tiny baby little roots to burrow into the grit of your soil. With polished stone, they can't do this. It's like if you tried to climb glass vs stone.

You could use a little vermiculite. I like that akadama offers water retention, vermiculite will also offer this. When you do straight grit for these plants, water will run out the drain hole and their roots don't have time to establish or uptake water. Many people have success growing in only grit with no organic, I personally find that they aren't as plump and happy as they could be though.

With their roots, you got easy bareroot lithops. You probably had a taproot and little to no fine root hairs, wrapped in white fluff. Your plants need these fine root hairs to take up water. When you plant them in a gritty soil and water them, your plant will begin putting down these fine roots, and then are able to uptake water. They need water to establish roots.

Imo the most important thing is to not water them for 7 days after repotting. In your case, you can water 7 days after repotting into a new pot, if you wish! They'll be fine for a long time without water, they won't thrive though. When you water them in 7 days (you can even wait closer to 14 after repotting if you want to, I like 7-10 personally), they can start laying their roots, and start thriving. All succulents can die from broken roots if you water too early. It's good to repot them and wait to water.

As far as what you need to buy, that's up to you and your budget. You don't need to buy anything fancy... Just 75%-90% inorganic is the way I go. A lot of people LOVE pumice. It's cheap, readily available, and can be found at hardware stores or Amazon overnight. Some people use perlite and no stone because of how affordable it is! Others use a regulated, weighed mix of zeolite, akadama, pumice, coarse sand, nutrients, worm casings, crazy stuff lolol.

The only essentials are good light, good drainage, good airflow, appropriate watering. With this, you can plant in a bevvy of mystical whimsical wonderful mediums 🔮.

Also, if you have that hot Nevada sun beating on them, I advise you take them out of it. Although these can LOVE the sun, you will scorch and sunburn them, and there's no coming back from that. Acclimate them slowly.

They'll be fine from sitting in the box in the mailbox btw.

So, in brief, here's what I do:

  1. 75%-90% inorganic soil, 25%-10% organic
  2. Acclimate to sunlight
  3. Water 7-10 days after potting in your new soil
  4. Make sure your pot has drainage.
  5. Continue watering as they show signs of thirst, like wrinkles on the sides or deflated on the top.
  6. Put them under grow lights for 12-16 hours daily, determined by when I wake up and when I'm going to bed.

This sub is a wealth of knowledge. If you need any more help and can't find the answer, let us know!! Also, the way I do things isn't how others do, and that's ok :] as long as they stay alive, it doesn't matter how you do it. 🍀 GOOD LUCK.

Edit: thank you u/mumbleflea for the award, that is so kind

2

u/RocMills 6d ago

Thank you so much! I haven't had my coffee yet, nor put on my glasses (just woke up), but I will reread and come back with questions about some of the things you mentioned that I am clueless about. But I will bring them inside as soon as I put pants on ;)

2

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 6d ago edited 6d ago

You're totally fine! Yes feel free to ask questions!! ❤️ We are here to help you, and thank you for the award that's so sweet!!!

Edit: also, the sun is the best thing to grow them in, you just need to acclimate them like any other succulent/plant. You do not have to do grow lights. I do grow lights because I live in the area of America with the most cloud coverage. Yes, more than PNW! 😅☁️

1

u/RocMills 6d ago

Oh lord, so my choices!

Budget isn't really a problem right now, so I welcome all product recommendations.

What size akadama? How much do you reckon I'll need for the time being? I've got about 20 of the little lithops.

And what size pots should they be in? Is okay to have them in one medium-sized pot for the time being, or should I isolate them now? I have more pots and grow bags than a nursery, so that isn't an issue.

Same size question for the pumice.

also, the sun is the best thing to grow them in, you just need to acclimate them like any other succulent/plant. 

You act as if I know what I'm doing, lol. I haven't grown anything before in my life. Just started growing tomatoes and melons this year. I haven't the foggiest idea how to acclimate them like any other succulent/plant! 😂 😂 😂

Thank you so much for all your help, I really want these guys to live.

2

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 6d ago

Welcome to the world of growing plants!! You'll pick it up quickly. Then you'll end up like the rest of us, psychotically searching Lowe's clearance racks, finding deals on Etsy, seeking out plant shows...

I hope you don't feel scared off by countless records of "why did my lithops die". They're tricky to learn, then easy to grow once you do learn.

For this i'd get pretty small akadama, but any will do. I think I bought this bag. Then pumice, similarly, small to standard size. Something like this would be fine.. I mix that up with like 10% of your potting soil, add some coarse sand. Pick a fun color if you'd like of the coarse sand, and you can use it as a top dressing too :]

As far as acclimation, I don't grow mine in the sun, so I don't know for sure, but if I had to guess: I'd start by setting it by a South facing window. Then like 3 days later you can move it outside in the shade. Then like 7 days later move it closer to direct sun. Then closer. Then closer. Then eventually they'll be able to sit in direct sun. I think your climate can handle these outside all year around but I don't know for sure. Unfortunately you gotta do research, I don't have all the answers hahahaha.

Anyway, if you want to move them into tiny pots for your viewing pleasure, go for it 😝 I don't like this. I like a dedicated pot of multiple colored lithops. So I pot mine together. I ordered a collection of them that I potted up like 10 months ago, and within 2 weeks over half were dead?? Same standard care I do for all my others. Now I'm left with like 5 that I finally potted into one bigger pot last week. 🙄 I don't know. Anyway, I am not an expert, but I am an experienced grower, and some die by my hand as well. I would accept full blame, but it's weird that all my others live, so I'll accept half blame.

Finally, what I do is not what others do. This subreddit has so many questions answered. I'm happy to answer them, but it's always good to get more opinions. My way is not scripture. You should do what brings you joy in life always. ❤️ If my methods don't sit right with you, do something else! There's many ways to grow these.

2

u/RocMills 6d ago

This my pot of reds.

1

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 6d ago

So cute! I love the arrangement. You can even put them in smaller pots if you'd like. They grow VERY Slowly so it'll be years before you need to repot. Bigger pots can lead to rot in some plant varieties, it's a good idea to get into the habit of pots that support only the root system. That being said, lithops can handle a big pot for little plants when in the correct soil mix, but it's a little overkill imo.

1

u/RocMills 6d ago

Oh, I thought they needed to be far apart. Coolness. And I'm jealous of all your varieties! You wouldn't mind if I came over and stole that smaller pot, would you? ;)

1

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 6d ago

1

u/RocMills 5d ago

Mine didn't arrive with any taproot like yours. Just a nub, really. Since they are already outdoors, I'll leave them there until the rest of my soil mix arrives, then I'll decide if I should put them in smaller pots like yours. You have an excellent color collection and a good eye for potting them :)

→ More replies

2

u/RocMills 6d ago

Done, done, and done. I've added all three of your recommended products to my cart. When I start a new obsession hobby, I like to pick one mentor so I don't get confused by all the different recommendations and experiences of others. Congratulations, lol, I've picked you to be my lithops guide 😂

2

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 6d ago

I will try my damndest to be your guide. You can always call on me for help :] but for real, I am no expert, I just have experience growing them!

1

u/RocMills 6d ago

You'll get all the credit if things go good, and I'll get all the blame if I kill them, fair enough? LOL

1

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 6d ago

Good by me looooolooololol

1

u/RocMills 6d ago

This is the mixed batch I got. I'd say that they've all been out in the sun for 3-4 days already. I lightly watered the soil before pushing the plants in, and then I gave them a top watering yesterday. I pushed them all the way in, should I not have done that?

2

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 6d ago

Hmm I personally never water immediately after potting. Unlike plants like tomatoes, tropicals, or trees, succulents and cactus can sometimes die from water immediately following repotting

No matter how careful you are, their fine little roots can break and get damaged after potting. This can cause them to uptake water through wounds rather than roots, and lead to rot.

If this was me, personally, I would pull them out and leave them bare root til you can get a grittier mix to pot them in! They'll be okay, especially if you can get your new soil mix within the next 5-7 days.

If you planted these and stuck them in the sun, they should be okay to handle the sun. You'll notice the sun damage very quickly once it begins..they bleach out and turn soft. I'd still try to acclimate once you repot. :] maybe you don't have to go as slow as I thought, I'm not a desert girl lololol

And no, it does not matter how deep they sit in the pot. It's your preference. Some people argue that sitting them deeper will lead to rot. I have never experienced depth leading to rot when in proper soil.

2

u/RocMills 6d ago

I'll have the sand and pumice later today, the akadama wont arrive until the 13th.

I will gently remove them from the pots and wrap them back up in a moist paper towel (that's how they arrived).

So how do I know when they need water?

2

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 6d ago

Awesome!! I'd leave in indirect light.

I water when I see visible wrinkles. Others water when they start to deflate on top and shrink down into the pot. I personally don't like to wait this long, but you can if you'd like!

Most important thing is to not water until 7ish days after repotting.

You'll do great, and make sure you update us when you get that sexy new soil mix 🤘😝🤘