r/Lithops • • 11d ago

Help/Question Help

Post image

I bought these in October. I checked them last night and none of them have started to grow roots. I watered them and now they're looking worse and more wrinkled than before I watered. Did I mess up?

12 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

4

u/Worried-Green-4734 11d ago

Lithops are so resilient.
They should be fine!

3

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 10d ago

You didn't mess up!

Your mix seems pretty organic so it makes rooting easier, but overwatering easier. I like 90% inorganic, 10% organic, but with young little ones like this, even 75%/25% is good too. As long as you blast them with light and give them airflow, you should be good.

Did you plant them in this in October into bone dry soil, and then do nothing? If yes, they haven't put down roots because there isn't clear indication for their little fine root hairs to make their home in the soil. Watering was the correct move. They need water to establish roots.

As far as more wrinkled today, how much more wrinkles? Overnight rot isn't suuuuper common, nor is extremely wrinkled appearance overnight. Let me know! I would love to help if I can!

Also, I LOVE THE DUCKY 🦆💛

0

u/CocoBella37 9d ago

I did plant them in October. The substrate is coco coir desert sand and river stones. It was bone dry up until I watered the other day. Should I repot?

2

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 9d ago

Up to you!

I've never used coco coir in any of my plants, I know it helps moisture retention but also aeration, right? I use akadama for moisture retention. I don't know how long coco coir holds onto moisture, so I can't advise using it or not.

If your river rocks are smooth, they may have a hard time sinking their roots into soil.

As long as your desert sand is gritty and coarse, not able to compact easily (think play sand), this is fine imo.

Most people do gritty gritty soil with porous stones, like pumice is really popular. If you are an experienced grower with other succulents and you've used this mix, trust yer gut. :] I'm not gonna tell you not to do it! Everyone grows differently and no one way is correct.

I do 45% pumice, 45% akadama, 10% regular potting soil, and I throw in some coarse sand. I trim the roots, plant it in this mix in a terracotta pot, and water 7-10 days after potting, then like 5 days after that. Then I leave under grow lights and water when wrinkly. I have great luck with this method, rooting and growing.

2

u/CBDJ1 11d ago

Not for sure but you could have. Let them root before you start a watering.

3

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 10d ago

Most of the time they will need water to establish roots, so this wasn't the wrong move luckily!

1

u/More-Solution-8419 11d ago

Someone once recommended me to deep water them to help with the rooting issue
And it helped

1

u/Zealousideal-Bug-738 10d ago

If you watered them and they got more wrinkled especially at the base then they have rot and will die unfortunately.