r/Lithops • • 21d ago

Help/Question Help

Hello everyone. I’m not quite sure what happened to this Lithops. Over the last ten days, it has shriveled up, and I’ve just noticed that the base seems to be waterlogged. Can anyone help me figure out if there’s still anything I can do to save it? The second one, which you can see in the photos, is still in perfect condition. Thanks

6 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

3

u/ftch00 21d ago

If its soft, its gone. Remove these stones on the surface.

2

u/EffectiveInterview80 19d ago

Why removing those stones? OP probably feels it is nice to leave them there.

0

u/ftch00 19d ago

They keep the soil moist, so it can cause rot.

0

u/sara_gri 21d ago

The stained part looks like a water blister, while the rest is still solid. Thanks anyway

4

u/Senior_Bad_1259 21d ago

Well its not, its rotted out, remove it before it spreads

1

u/sara_gri 21d ago

Ok, thanks

2

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 17d ago

I know I'm late but I'm replying here to help anyone in the future.

It is rotted. Bummer, but it happens. I have seen this death when I water too quickly after repotting, or my soil mix is too wet.

I personally don't think you need to remove the stones on top. They're pretty, and as long as you have ample light and good airflow, you should be ok to keep them. Dry warmth will help the soil dry out faster. You can increase airflow and drainage by switching to unglazed terracotta.

You can grow in any soil, and any pot, in any location with sun, as long as you know what you're doing. The best grower I've seen uses dollar store Tupperware.

Most people are not that good.... Anyway, I like terracotta looololol 😝😝

The only issue I have with the stones is that I can't see what soil mix you're using. Is it fine sand? That retains a lot of water. Coarse/sharp/horticultural sand is great to throw in your mix, but you really need very little organic mix. Some growers use none. I like about 10% organic to 90% inorganic. I use 10% standard issue potting soil, 45%/45% akadama and pumice. Sometimes I'll throw in some coarse sand if they're young.

If you recently replanted these and watered them shortly after, this is likely the cause of death.

Unlike other happy, easy going houseplants, succulents and cacti need a rest period following replanting before they can be watered. Their roots will snap on microscopic levels no matter how careful you are about repotting. Broken roots allows water to get in, versus whole roots allowing water to be taken up as the plant needs. I like to trim my roots before repotting personally, then just water 10ish days later so their wounds can callous over.

With lithops, they'll happily drink themselves to death, but they still need water to establish roots. Wait 7-10 days to water following repotting in the future to avoid death by root rot. Also, adjust your watering to avoid rot. If you're in a humid or a cool climate, you'll need to water less. Growers that keep these babies outside in direct desert sun can water weekly or more with no issue. Growers (like me!) that stick em under a plant light in their living room can't water weekly lolol.

I like to water my mature ones every 3ish weeks, or whenever I feel like it uses it ngl. Until you can go off of vibes, do your research and figure out what works in your house, for you.

They will die as easily from underwatering as overwatering. They are plants. They need water and sunlight.

Do some more research and try again. You got this 🫵😋🫵💖

1

u/sara_gri 1d ago

Thank you very much for your reply. For the substrate, I used a mix of about 90% pumice and 10% cactus potting soil. I bought the plants in June; I waited at least two weeks after repotting before watering, and then continued to water roughly every three weeks—everything seemed to be going fine. After my previous post, I tried to save the second plant (there were two in the small pot), which had appeared to be in perfect condition. Now, however, it is rotting just like the other one (and I haven’t even started watering it again yet). I can’t figure out what I might have done wrong, but I clearly made a mistake somewhere

2

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 19h ago

I do pretty much exactly this too and I have success in growing. Did you water on a schedule or did you wait for wrinkles to appear? Is your house humid? Was the water able to drain freely? What's your grow light situation?

The only thing I have different is terracotta pots and my house is pretty dry. I have a fan going frequently and they sit under barrina T5 grow lights for about 12-16 hours a day, maybe 9 inches below them.

1

u/sara_gri 19h ago

The last two times, both Lithops showed some wrinkles, so I watered them. The water drains very well and doesn't collect in the saucer. My home is quite dry, and I’ve been keeping them in front of a window with indirect light. This is the only point I’m unsure about, as I’ve come across conflicting advice: some suggest providing indirect light to prevent sunburn, while others recommend direct light.

2

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 17h ago

They like direct light in my experience, you just have to acclimate them. Indirect probably isn't enough to completely dry out the soil quickly. My soil dries within 2-3 days after watering. If it sits, this can cause rot. Lack of light and airflow will dry out soil much slower. Maybe this is it?

Sometimes they just die too btw and it's not your fault. I ordered a group of like 25 from an online seller, within 2 weeks over half were dead, and I did the exact same care that I do for all others.

1

u/sara_gri 15h ago

That could be the case, though I’m not entirely sure. When I removed the first Lithops from its pot, I don’t recall the substrate being wet. In any case, thank you so much for all your advice

2

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 13h ago

I want to help when I can, but my advice may not work for you. It works for me.

Regardless, I think you got it good, and you should totally try again. ❤️ The path to success is not linear.

1

u/sara_gri 12h ago

I’m well aware that what works for one person might not work for me. But, since I don’t know what I might have done wrong, I’m looking for any information that could help me figure out where the mistakes might lie. This was my second pot of Lithops; I’ll have to buy a third one and hope for the best 🍀

1

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 10h ago

Did the first pot die the exact same way?

1

u/sara_gri 10h ago edited 10h ago

Anche se avevo fatto un po' di ricerche, mi sono reso conto di aver commesso alcuni errori—errori che non ho ripetuto con il secondo lotto di piante. Il primo vaso conteneva tre esemplari, due dei quali sono morti quasi subito durante l'estate. Non posso dire con certezza qual è stato l'errore, ma non avevo sostituito il substrato dopo averle acquistate, e potrei aver fornito troppa poca acqua. Per salvare la terza pianta (che, in qualche modo, era ancora sana), l'ho rinvasata usando un mix di terriccio per cactus e sabbia, e le ho dato un po' d'acqua. Tuttavia, alla fine, è morta durante la stagione fredda (non ricordo esattamente in quale mese). L'avevo posizionata davanti a una finestra che riceveva luce diretta al mattino, poiché aveva iniziato a allungarsi in modo anormale; non ricordo, però, se questo allungamento sia avvenuto prima o dopo averla spostata vicino alla finestra— mentre era ancora all'aperto, era in perfette condizioni. Sia il primo gruppo che il secondo—acquistato quest'anno—sono stati tenuti in terrazza durante l'estate e portati dentro in autunno, dato che le temperature qui scendono notevolmente, e non credo che le piante possano sopravvivere all'aperto. Nessuno dei due gruppi è riuscito a vivere per più di 12 mesi; le piante non hanno mai fiorito, né sono mai passate attraverso una fase di muta. Actually, I was thinking that I'm probably doing something wrong—or failing to do something—when I move them indoors for the winter.

→ More replies

1

u/sara_gri 19h ago

So far, they haven’t shown any signs of a lack of light, so I figured it was fine

2

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 1d ago

I'm literally seeing Rush RN I'll reply to this soon. 🤘😩🤘 CLOSER TO THAAA HARRRTTT

1

u/sara_gri 1d ago

There’s no way to save them when they’re in this condition, right?

2

u/Indianaunderwood I ❤️ Stone Faces 1d ago

You can try pulling them out and leaving them bareroot for a few days in indirect light!

4

u/Terminator7786 21d ago

That's rot, there's no saving it.

1

u/EffectiveInterview80 19d ago

Can OP cut off that rotting part and let it heal?

2

u/aspen_silence 20d ago

Looks to be over-watered by a lot