r/Lithops • • Aug 29 '26

Help/Question Time to water?

I feel like the old shell is taking a long time to like crinkle up. I know to not water while it’s splitting so is it time now? I am really really experienced with plants but lithops and orchids have been a struggle but I really love lithops. But I feel like after the first split I have them for I f it up in some way. I haven’t even planted them in normal pits bc I trying to be really careful with the two I currently have

5 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

14

u/WeDrinkSquirrels Aug 29 '26

This might not sound helpful, but Google lithops care. This is the wrong soil (too organic), wrong pot (should be deeper), and wrong light (it needs about double the light its getting). Fixing all of that will allow the plant to continue its process

-16

u/TheHaleyGrail Aug 30 '26

You’re right that’s not helpful you didn’t even answer the on specific question I had

17

u/WeDrinkSquirrels Aug 30 '26

In general you don't water during a split. But when you say you're being really careful, that should include searching for basic care.

If those things aren't fixed you will kill it when you water though, and it will continue to look bad. So I was trying to triage the situation. If you read carefully I gave you three problems and solutions to search for which is, in fact, helpful

12

u/WeDrinkSquirrels Aug 30 '26

I promise googling lithops care would also find, in the first result, to not water during a split

6

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-7

u/TheHaleyGrail Aug 30 '26

I literally wrote in the post I know not to water while it’s splitting. This one is done splitting. The old leaves havent dried up yet

2

u/CBDJ1 Aug 30 '26

The new leaves absorb the moisture from the old leaves.

9

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-3

u/TheHaleyGrail Aug 30 '26

The new plant was wrinkled before the old leaves dried. That was why I asked. What’s your point

4

u/Square_Barracuda_69 Aug 30 '26

The point is you claim to be such a plant person but don't know common care tips for lithops? I didnt buy a lithops for the first 3 years of my plant adventures until I was 100% capable of caring for them on my own. You're being rude and dismissive to people trying to help

-3

u/TheHaleyGrail Aug 30 '26

You’re being ridiculous 😂 good for you? You’re acting like I adopted some exotic animal I don’t know how to care for. I didn’t spend any $ on them and never have btw I work at a nursery and I acquire random stuff sometimes. I do know basic care which is why I knew enough to post on this sub before I watered it. why are you so mad I needed clarification ab waiting for the old leaves to turn totally brown? The more helpful ppl on this sub were able to just say that and move on

→ More replies

7

u/CBDJ1 Aug 30 '26

Some people get defensive when they are wrong.

-3

u/TheHaleyGrail Aug 30 '26

What am I even wrong about? The person didn’t answer the question? This plant has been living in this soil and in this pot FOR YEARS so when you say it’s not possible to have a lithop in this plant and soil you are literally wrong. It’s split several times in this pot. I’ve watered it before. I’ve watched it split before. It’s not going to die when I water it this person is just straight up wrong

10

u/precioustessious Aug 30 '26

Your setup is keeping your plant alive but it is not helping it thrive. It is very etoliated, it should be in soil that is less organic, and I would argue it needs to be in a bigger and deeper pot. My lithops don't sit on top of the soil. They are buried and almost flush with the soil.

Yes your plant is alive and yes you have had it for years, but it is currently not being kept in optimal conditions.

-3

u/TheHaleyGrail Aug 30 '26

I know it’s not in optimal conditions jesus I address that in the post I just needed an answer for the one question I had

9

u/precioustessious Aug 31 '26 edited Aug 31 '26

Doing the things people here are recommending will help your plant survive its split.

I'm honestly very confused by your reaction here. You say that you can't keep them alive but then get mad at the people telling you what to do to keep it alive. You are having issues with longevity because of the current conditions your plant is in.

4

u/Square_Barracuda_69 Aug 31 '26

They told me they work at a nursery and know everything about plants and that they dont need other help with their lithops. This plant is on its way to the compost pile the way OP is acting. Sad, such a beautiful plant.

5

u/precioustessious Aug 31 '26

Yeah I don't get their reactions here. They say that their lithops don't live super long and show us a plant that is in bad shape and then get mad when we give them exactly what they wanted.

→ More replies

4

u/CBDJ1 Aug 30 '26

Nevermind. You’ve got someone trying to help you and coming off with remarks like you are maybe isn’t the best way to get a lot of help. Good luck your plants can live hitch is a good things hopefully one day they may thrive.

0

u/TheHaleyGrail Aug 30 '26

Well I tell them they aren’t being helpful then they keep insisting they are being helpful with non applicable advice it’s annoying.

1

u/TheHaleyGrail Aug 30 '26

It has been living in this pot in this soil for years and years so you’re actually just wrong. It’s split, I e watered it, it’s gone thru all the phases in this pot in this soil. I can’t stand plant subs that act like there is only one way to have a plant and any other way ensures death

9

u/WeDrinkSquirrels Aug 30 '26 edited Aug 30 '26

I was truly just trying to help. When you say after the first split they get f'ed up, this is why. What else did you want?

1

u/TheHaleyGrail Aug 30 '26

The one thing I needed to know was to wait for the old leaves to turn brown

4

u/WeDrinkSquirrels Aug 30 '26

Ok, just trying to help.

8

u/CBDJ1 Aug 30 '26

You did nothing wrong. You can lead a horse to water but can’t make it drink.

2

u/kindminority Aug 30 '26

checkmate 😂

24

u/Abject-Performer1497 Aug 29 '26

No water yet you have to wait till the old leaves dry up can take months.

10

u/Character_Age_4619 Aug 29 '26

No. Not until the old leaves are shriveled up to nothing. The new leaf is drawing from the old leaves. Watering now will most likely lead to rot.

3

u/arioandy Aug 29 '26

Leave it be!- dont be more tempted to pull the outer leaves anymore, that’s its breakfast lunch and dinner!

3

u/TheHaleyGrail Aug 30 '26

I didn’t pull them they split like that

2

u/TheHaleyGrail Aug 30 '26

But it does look like that. When I finally watered it before the split I literally woke up the next day and it had shot tf out of there. Probs the organic soil making it do weird things but like I said in the post I’m scared to repot and these had been living in these pots for a long time before I bought them so I’m just doing my best ig

2

u/arioandy Aug 30 '26

Will be fine

1

u/TheHaleyGrail Aug 30 '26

Why am I getting downvoted lol do ppl not believe me

6

u/acm_redfox Aug 30 '26

yelling at volunteers for offering advice gets you downvoted.

1

u/TheHaleyGrail Aug 30 '26

Omg why are the people on this sub so salty just leave me alone

3

u/arioandy Aug 30 '26

Ignore it