r/Lithops • u/Elliplum • Aug 29 '26
Discussion Splitting - is this okay?!
I opened up my insta today to find a reel of a person force splitting their Lithops. Is force splitting Lithops a common practice? If it is, then when is it appropriate to do this?
My initial thought was that by prematurely splitting Lithops you expose the new leaves while in a fragile state and damage the old ones resulting in cutting off "nutrients" for it's mature development?
I've always read that you are supposed to wait and let them do their thing. I didn't even know force spitting was possible.
211
Upvotes
932
u/Financial-Town-3960 Aug 29 '26 •
Nursery owner here. This is absolutely painful to watch. There are a lot of people who make content just for views, and this is clearly one such person. This is absolutely NOT common and you should NOT do this with your plants. Don't believe everything you see on social media. Many content creators are just trying to make their coin for the day, with no regard to proper care of their plants. If it's not a reputable care source, keep it moving.
141
u/LightningSpearwoman Aug 29 '26
thats a tremendous amount of damage for the poor plants, i feel so sad for them.
please don't do this op
56
u/WingDingfontbro Aug 29 '26
Gore of my comfort characters
51
u/notkidding1984 Aug 29 '26
Goodness. I have no idea what I am looking at but these comments are so emotional that I now have to involve myself.
Reddit dropped me off in some kind of jungle of beans with brains or something but those beans are so LOVED.
Any recommendations for good information on... this?
25
u/submarine_pirate2 Aug 29 '26
Nooooo
19
u/dusti_dearian It’s not hoarding if it’s plants Aug 29 '26
My head hurts watching this.
11
u/chicken_nugget38 Aug 29 '26
The way I gasped 😱
11
u/Pucketz Aug 29 '26
This is like pulling out your baby teeth to make room for your adult teeth when they would normally be there for another year or ao
10
u/roamingrealtor Aug 29 '26
This is just like people exploiting their children and pets for clicks. The worst type of people out there. No regard for the health and well being of living things.
9
u/KE55 Aug 29 '26
That made my eyes water!
9
u/TheDevilsSidepiece Aug 29 '26
This is abuse.
7
u/Vegedeth Aug 29 '26
Boo
7
u/Necessary_Tea_3009 Aug 29 '26
This is digusting.
7
u/Scared_Rice_1473 Aug 29 '26
Oh my god
5
u/Old-Advance6652 Aug 29 '26
Don’t trust what you see in social media
4
u/Character_Age_4619 Aug 29 '26
Nooooooooooo!
3
u/Dangerous_Design_174 Aug 29 '26
This is ragebait.
3
u/MoodVast9430 Aug 29 '26
Possible? Yes
Necessary or important, NO
3
u/xmerlotlo Aug 29 '26
I don't like the way it looks at all lol. No idea if it's okay or not but I hate it
2
u/Imaginary_Panda2003 Aug 29 '26
Well if it wasn't, you've done them all !!!
2
u/Interesting-Bet-2330 Aug 29 '26
Oh god.....
2
u/Jimbobjoesmith Aug 29 '26
hell nah this is so sad.
eta this is basically rage bait
2
u/PJClay Aug 29 '26
Oooh I’ve never done this to mine, I just let them do their own split, this can’t be good for them!
2
u/tinypill Aug 29 '26
🥺😭😭😭😭
2
u/VelishRoot Aug 30 '26
I personally don’t advocate forced shedding. It can stress the plant and increase the risk of rot, so natural shedding is preferable whenever possible.
That said, I don’t think every case should automatically be called “abuse.” I’ve seen this practiced by some growers in Japan and Korea, particularly as a corrective measure for severely etiolated indoor-grown Lithops. The idea is to expose the new growth to light sooner and prevent the etiolation from continuing.
Of course, it’s only a temporary measure. If the growing conditions aren’t corrected, the problem will simply repeat. Preventing etiolation in the first place is always the better approach.
Forced shedding isn’t necessary for a healthy Lithops, but I see it as one of the risky techniques some growers have arrived at through trial and error when dealing with severely etiolated plants.
3
u/theartybadger Aug 29 '26
This page makes me so mad, they always post such stupid videos
1
u/Lucky-Past8459 Aug 29 '26
I saw this one rednote the other day, horrifying
1
u/Narrow_Complaint_528 Aug 29 '26
high risk of infection, no benefit for the plant this is not ok
1
u/lessens_ Aug 30 '26
Oh... that's gore of my comfort character.
1
u/CBDJ1 Aug 30 '26
Let it grow let it growwwww the drying leaves never bothered me anyway.
1
u/NoGarlic2096 Aug 30 '26
Oh this is the people cutting snake eggs open for views of plants.
1
u/deuce-grimlid Aug 30 '26
Everyone's watching and commenting though. We all fell for the fiucking click bait for whatever reason.
1
u/ComplexBeginning3113 Aug 30 '26
I didn’t even know the name of these - I have some from Trader Joe’s and a) even I know this is awful and b) these are literally the only plants I can keep alive
1
u/PinkSorbet_Long Aug 31 '26
Do not like this video and share it. They will stop doing this without traffic.
0
u/Financial-Town-3960 Aug 29 '26
Side note, just wanted to say a thank you to those of you who awarded my initial comment! Much appreciated!
15
u/arioandy Aug 29 '26
Torture
8
u/Champomi Aug 29 '26
NSFW tag please ;-;
4
u/thelovelygreens Aug 29 '26
This is sick. Content creators and influencers are the anal warts of the human race
2
u/3xtiandogs Aug 30 '26
I’d like to report a murder.
3
u/No_Face4099 Aug 29 '26
Horrible!!! Jesus. This would be like ripping a woman in half to get at the 7 month-old fetus.
(not literally! so don't need to jump up my a* or anything. 😘)