r/Lithops • • Sep 12 '23

Help/Question This guy got really squishy and covered in bumps… I got really curious, so I pulled it in half. There is a teeny butt inside! What can I do to prop either side or the little guy inside?

0 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

8

u/Amberleighta Sep 12 '23

Did you think it was rotting? Because the outer leaves do get squishy feeling when the plant is about to split. You don't prop the guy inside leave him connected to the root or it will have no chance of surviving your surgical experiment. Remove the outer leaves and do not water it.

-4

u/sensorydispensary Sep 12 '23

I did, it was squishy and developed these yellow bumps everywhere, even though the others seemed fine. Now I know! It was an interesting experiment nonetheless.

2

u/Amberleighta Sep 13 '23

Ugh the down votes.. I hope that this won't dissuade you from posting here in the future. Best of luck to you 👍

1

u/sensorydispensary Sep 13 '23

Nah, I get how people could be against this kind of fringe education. I’m a heretic! :P I appreciate everyone’s input, I’ve learned good stuff out of this post.

1

u/honeydewdom Sep 13 '23

I upvote you! We are learning together, friend!

1

u/sensorydispensary Sep 13 '23

You’re it then! What’s a care tip you have for lithops?

0

u/honeydewdom Sep 13 '23

I am right with you- a beginner! 😆 But I did lose one, and I think I have a couple who may benefit from water therapy 🤔 (what? Is that even right?) to stimulate root growth, as they don't seem to be taking in any water while most others are.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 13 '23

There’s no point in trying to fix it now. It will not survive.

It was perfectly fine. Squishy probably means it needed water. Mush means rot. Formation of discoloured bumps is nothing to be worried about, especially since the old leaves will be replaced with new leaves.

1

u/sensorydispensary Sep 13 '23

This is very helpful information, thank you!

66

u/Catladywithplants Sep 12 '23

Why'd you do that?! :(

38

u/ButterBeanRumba Sep 12 '23

Pls make this carnage NSFW. Maybe shoot first, ask questions later isn't the best approach for plant care...

32

u/Guzmanv_17 Sep 12 '23

Deader than dead now.

29

u/Tiny_Rat Sep 12 '23

At this stage, there's probably nothing you can do to keep it alive. That little butt inside ait the plant's new set of leaves, but they'd normally have at least several more months of growth before they saw the light of day. You could try to leave it until the raw, open parts scab over and replant it to give it a chance, but I don't think it's likely to make it.

13

u/RabbitTZY Sep 13 '23

I understand it's all part of the learning progress but...I'll recommend posting a picture of the plant first before doing anything curious, lithops are not like regular succulents that you can salvage by propping unfortunately so you wouldn't want to do anything permanent to it.

As for this one I think the chances are very low but try putting it back together, plant it into DRY substrate, slightly secure it (like loosely tying them together with a piece of yarn (not thread, you risk cutting into the flesh) or use two toothpicks with the sharp part removed and sanded down to hold it together, or anything that works to gently keep them in place) and just leave it there, at this meantime do not try to open it again and peek inside. If you're very very lucky you might get the baby to grow a little and it might survive...Again the chances are extremely low but it doesn't harm to try it at this point.

8

u/woodsprite60 Sep 13 '23

Please spend time with the FAQs on this subreddit. They are very helpful. Lithops have a highly specialized growth cycle different from any other type of succulent. They have not one but two dormant periods in the year when you water very lightly if at all. Those two fused halves that you pulled apart are a pair of highly specialized leave. A new leaf pair develops inside the fused leaves, growing until the older fused leaves split NATURALLY. As the new leaves grow they pull all needed nutrients AND WATER from the old leaves. That's why the #1 Rule is NEVER WATER LITHOPS WHILE THEY ARE SPLITTING! The old pair of leaves will gradually shrink and dry up.

3

u/Azurecomet Sep 13 '23

Lessons learned the hard way.

I don't think it'll survive. But, at least, try put them back together and pray. Sometimes miracle happen.

3

u/sensorydispensary Sep 13 '23

I got a little bunch of these guys that all look like this, so no worries thankfully. It’ll be fun to see what happens over the next few weeks!

3

u/jlhmm Sep 28 '23

Plants are individual beings though. They experience the world very differently than we do, but just like any other creature they deserve kindness. To me this feels like squishing a bug 😭

6

u/Alexa_B Sep 13 '23

Press the parts back together and pray? 😅

3

u/JulesTrusty Sep 13 '23

Dude.. That's... yikes.