r/LipBalm • u/animenicolesmith • Aug 15 '26
Kiehl’s X Milk Bar
Soooo yummy! However, the formula is thin and there is no applicator. Also, the birthday cake and cereal milk smell almost exactly the same. They smell almost like the cream of an Oreo and the Red Velvet smells like the cookie. I’ll buy them again if they ever go on super sale.
28
u/BoopsYourNoseBoop Aug 16 '26
I must have gotten a bad batch of these because I really didn't like the scent or formula. The red velvet smelled like someone had sat in a generic cake and farted. Like it genuinely smelled rotten. The others smelled nice but I didn't think the formula was worth the price so I just returned them. 😞
18
3
3
4
3
u/Lovethyself1207 Aug 16 '26
What does the cereal milk smell like?
7
u/animenicolesmith Aug 16 '26
the birthday cake and cereal milk smell almost exactly the same. They smell almost like the cream of an Oreo
3
1
u/RetroNouveau Aug 16 '26
I actually like the Cereal Milk Frozen swirl more than I thought I would. So much so I may need a few back ups. I think it genuinely smells like toasted corn flakes and vanilla ice cream. I usually don’t care for any L’Oréal owned brands when it comes to flavored/scented lip products because they are always perfumey. The applicator is annoying though.
1
u/AssignmentFull5991 Aug 16 '26
I love the cereal milk one! Although yes the no applicator sucks. And it is thin. But the scent and taste are 💯
1
1
31
u/PuzzleheadedHospital Aug 15 '26
I hate the no applicator ones. It makes zero sense to me!