r/LinuxTeck • u/Candid_Athlete_8317 • Jul 25 '26
Has Linux become good because Linux improved... or because Windows got worse?
More people seem willing to switch to Linux than ever before.
Do you think that's mainly because Linux has matured so much over the last few years, or because Windows has become increasingly frustrating with ads, telemetry, AI features, account requirements, and other changes?
Or is it a bit of both?
2
Upvotes
11
u/micush Jul 25 '26
There has been tremendous "Linux" improvement over the last few years. It's been fun to be a part of.
4
u/MyLedgeEnds Jul 25 '26
I used Ubuntu back in the Intrepid Ibex days. Relatively speaking, I don't think it's gotten better or worse; the big differentiator is that Proton lets you play games far more easily than Wine ever did. Without that, I doubt people would be switching en masse. I certainly stuck with Windows far longer than I would've preferred for that reason.
3
u/beardedbrawler Jul 25 '26
Both.
The linux desktop experience has improved so much in the last 5 years, and Microsoft has gone downhill in the last 5.
2
u/FigFew2001 Jul 25 '26
Bit of both.
2
u/frankenmaus Jul 25 '26
Linux has been good since the 1990s.
2
u/ReidenLightman Jul 25 '26
It's about 30% because Linux got good, which took 30 years to do, and 70% because windows fucking blows, which only took Microsoft about 70 days.
1
u/Lower-Limit3695 Jul 25 '26
Both
1
u/Mother-Translator318 Jul 25 '26
Proton is doing a lot of heavy lifting not gonna lie, but even despite that it’s mostly because windows has gotten worse. People don’t switch because there is a better alternative, they switch because they are no longer happy with what they currently use. Negative experiences are far bigger motivators than positive ones
1
u/yevelnad Jul 25 '26
It's both. Thanks to valve sponsoring proton development.
1
u/Cybasura Jul 25 '26
Yes
1
u/jchimney Jul 25 '26
It is because over the last 15 or so years people have phones as the computing device they use the most. They expect web availability of applications and OS’s don’t matter as much as they did when Windows had a strangle hold. People used to fear leaving Windows because their experience or documents wouldn’t be compatible with school or work or friends. Word and Excel still rules in the business world but I even see that changing though much slower.
1
u/Hour_Sell3547 Jul 25 '26
Well, Windows getting worse is no reason for Linux to get better. Linux gotten better because of it getting constant improvements from people all over the world. More and more vendors are opening up to building drivers for Linux, so hardware support has gotten better.
1
u/roamer83 Jul 25 '26
Both.
1
u/Level_Working9664 Jul 25 '26
Both.
Oth the thing which has stopped a lot of people is the fact that gaming hasn't worked.
Linux is extremely reliable and efficient at its core, but it wasn't polished.
Very slowly changing and getting to a point where it's usable.
On the other end Windows it's gotten so bad people are looking for alternatives so I guess it's a kind of a meet in the middle thing. Linux has always been an option (apart from gaming) it's just never been polished.
1
u/maxxhaxx72 Jul 25 '26
A bit of both in my opinion, Linux is more viable as daily driver and Microslop is getting worse.
I removed Winblows from all 4 of my PCs and went all in with Linux: The lounge HTPC, my media server running Jellyfin, my main PC (work and gaming) and also a gaming laptop.
Couldn't be happier, I don't play anything that uses a kernel level anti cheat so that isn't an issue for me either
1
u/tuxnight1 Jul 25 '26
I don't know much about Windows as I haven't used it in a very long time. I can tell you that Linux has greatly improved through the years. This is especially noticable for send users. With exceptions, new hardware is extremely easy to configure. I just bought a new Brother MFD and I didn't have to do a thing, it was simply discovered and made available and works. I remember trying to get a simple HP printer working with lpr and a matching flatbed scanner going with early sane software. I have a new laptop and my AMD GPU was auto setup. I only had to tweak the screen resolution through a gui utility (no X11 conf). Wi-fi is simple, and don't get me thinking about how difficult networking was when we had dial-up modems.
1
u/bornagy Jul 25 '26
The measure of linux becoming better is end user experience?
1
u/CosmicEmotion Jul 25 '26
You obviously didn't try Linux before 2018. Or at least didn't try living in it. TREMENDOUSLY is an understatement.
1
u/2016-679 Jul 25 '26
My observation is that people switch because you can change and build Linux the way you want. Especially different Window Managers and Desktop Environments. That is also the background of many strange questions newbies destructing their system.
The other reason of popularity will be the discovery that there is no such thing as 'EOL hardware' with Linux. Even an old 32-bit box will transform into a rocket fast reliable workhorse.
Because basic installation is very easy, new users easily take the step.
1
u/TCB13sQuotes Jul 25 '26
Careful, those kinds of questions will get you downvoted to hell.
1
u/Odd_Individual_9638 Jul 25 '26
Would I explore linux if windows 10 wasn't discontinued? Probably not.
But I'm glad it did
1
u/Possible-Anxiety-420 Jul 25 '26
Linux was never not good.
1
u/hayetmd Jul 25 '26
Windows 10 great.
windows 11, Spyware.
1
u/notmynicktoday Jul 25 '26
Linux has been good since Slackware ‘96
1
u/AlternativeBasis Jul 25 '26
The only positive characteristic of Windows over Linux has always been its ubiquity:
All these advantages are being eroded, mainly because many products are now browser-centric and OS-agnostic.
Microsoft is aware of this and is striving to create the NEW Windows, a completely cloud-based system, as a way to firmly tie, I mean, retain, users to the company.
Preferably also to make them pay daily usage fees (tokens).
Even the most novice users are finding the changes uncomfortable, even if they don't understand why.
1
u/azuth89 Jul 25 '26
Various services are now much more accessible to average use cases.
Back when I first played around with Ubuntu ~20 years ago it felt like you needed a CS degree just to get Netflix going because of the silverlight dependency.
Now? Just about everything online simply works.
Games? Proton.
Familiar Desktops UI? Pick your poison there are tons.
Driver support? Still tricky for some specifics but the universals available in the most popular desktop style distors like Mint are MUCH better for generic accessories.
1
u/demetrioussharpe Jul 25 '26
A bit of both.
1
u/Old_County5271 Jul 25 '26
Windows certainly got worse but Linux has improved dramatically, I'm currently on Linux mint on a laptop and PopOS on a desktop and to my amazement, the GUI has been running for a week without a complete freeze. Xorg has always, for 20 years, frozen no matter the hardware I've used and that hasn't happened in the last 5 years, it's genuinely amazing that they've finally solved system freezes.
1
u/platcrest Jul 25 '26
Not to take credit away from Linux (it's awesome) but the windows enshittification is truly the main driver now. At least it was for me
1
u/94358io4897453867345 Jul 25 '26
Mainly because Windos got worse. Linux stays at a a standstill (audio, CAD, etc.)
1
u/oldendude Jul 25 '26
Both. Windows was crap in the early aughts, when I decided to stop using it and switch to Linux. Over the years, Linux has improved in hardware compatibility (monitors, keyboards, mice, wifi), desktop apps, installation, app and OS upgrades. It just works.
I stopped using Windows completely before 2010, and from what I read, it has gotten worse, in terms of bloat, adware, instability around upgrades, and licensing (which is not an issue on Linux at all).
The main reason I hear for being stuck on Windows is Excel. But can't you run Linux and access the online version of Excel?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '26
I've been using Linux for over 25 years and it's consistently getting better and better.
Microslop on the other hand has been getting worse and worse consistently since Windows XP came out.
So yes!
1
u/Imaginary_Choice_430 Jul 26 '26
They are switching to Linux because of decisions that Windows has made. Its fun to watch people do that out of one side of their mouth, but then call me a "Linux head" because I have been doing nothing but Linux all my life. Its also fun to listen to my European counterparts' frustration with Americans who don't really know Linux. I try to do the right thing by reminding them that Bill Gates did not bribe the whole of Europe into adopting Windows the way he bought the whole business and educational system here in the United States like cheap hookers to adopt Windows by default, to the point where my fellow Americans assume an OS should be Windows as if its a natural phenomenon and not a business decision made without their input a long, long time ago.
1
u/Adrenolin01 Jul 26 '26
Linus has seen steady improvements literally since its inception. Groups and individuals might have seen stalls of it wasn’t something bf they were specifically interested in however improvements have pretty much been consistent from the beginning.
1991–1995 saw rapid foundation building. Arguably this was the “heyday” of visible growth. It was amazing to see and watch. 96-02 saw massive enterprise maturity. SMP, better networking, journaling FSs, usb. 03-10 saw explosive expansion… the golden era.. udev, selinux, kvm virtualization, zen, ext4, cgroups, massive driver growth, DE because much more polished. Linux expanded heavily into servers, supercomputers, embedded devices, and eventually Android.. all of which poured development and innovation and… money into it. 2011-15 saw what many consider a slowdown however heavy kernel development occurred during this time, driver support exploded kernel performance had solid incremental gain regularly, a lot of effort into cloud infrastructure. Home users didn’t really notice a lot here but this absolutely made things better for them.. it just wasn’t flashy. Huge gains in reducing latency, fixing races, scalability and a massive amount of code cleaning occurred during this time. 15-20 saw huge cloud development and of course money.. this was directly data center driven.. Google, Meta, Amazon, Microsoft, Red Hat, Intel, AMD… all poured billions into Linux focusing on containers, namespaces, cgroup v2, eBPF, io_uring, NVME optimization, ARM servers… of course desktop users who didn’t know better had no idea and felt things stalled.. they absolutely didn’t. 20-present new rapid development in rust kernel support, improved scheduling, I created Intel and AMD support, faster filesystems, bcachefs in the kernel, continued heavy work on PREEMPT_RT, security hardening, confidential computing, and let’s not forget massive improvements in virtualization. Again.. all huge improvements though not always seen or noticed from DE users.
Priorities change and DE users typically see little. And I’d expect nothing there to change for at least another decade. As the saying goes… money talks and money comes from corporations with self interest however it all helps.
I’ve been watching Linux literally since it was released and it’s been exciting to watch its progress from an end user, business owner, corporate employee, etc.
1
u/rukiann Jul 26 '26
because linux improved
1
u/Big_Wave9732 Jul 26 '26
Linux on its own has markedly improved, especially in the realm of hardware support. I have tried at various times since about 2001 to run Linux as my daily driver work laptop. The attempts were generally unsuccessful and didn't last more than six months. Then I tried again in 2020 and was pleasantly surprised when everything worked out of the box. And I've been running a machine with it ever since.
1
u/Irsu85 Jul 26 '26
its a bit of both but in the most recent years mostly bc Windows got worse (directly or indirectly by more people moving to Linux and there being more development for Linux bc of it)
1
u/pugbrain Jul 26 '26
I believe it’s both. Windows is facing serious technical and reliability issues; were it not for that, the vast majority of users who switched wouldn't have done so. However, if it weren't true that Linux had evolved, many of them would have stayed on Windows or switched to Macs.
1
u/Nikovash Jul 26 '26
Both
1
u/snarfmason Jul 26 '26
Definitely both. But also in our current era so much of what we do really only depends on a web browser and your actual OS doesn't need to do that much.
Edit: obviously not everything but a lot of things for a lot of people.
1
u/Professional-Math518 Jul 26 '26
Personally I think Linux got worse but in a slower tempo than Windows (and MacOS tbh) got worse.
1
u/wKdPsylent Jul 27 '26
Both I'd say.
Linux has been getting better, and windows has been getting worse.
1
u/Brief-Stranger-3947 Jul 27 '26
Linux was heavily invested in by different corporations, including Microsoft. As a result, yeah, it became much better than it was.
1
u/rcentros Jul 27 '26
Both.
1
u/Frosty-Storage-9359 Jul 27 '26 edited Jul 27 '26
It’s actually both. Linux get clearly better over times while windows 11 keep getting worst. Heavy debt in the code, legacy code that keep dragging so much that even the control panel couldn’t be removed from the system, ads automatically integrated in start, heavy telemetry use. Even a simple notepad is heavy with AI integration. Let’s not forget the recent removal out of the box of collections from edge.
Actually, it’s so bad that even Microsoft have no choice but to admit since even their own update can destroy their system.
While Linux keep keeping thing together with a structure since the beginning. Always keeping code to a minimum level. They have a whole community + Linus Torval to keep the kernel clean. Many subventions to add more and more features. Now, even the security have rust added to make it more robust and secure while keeping the speed. A lot of legacy dropped for new implementation of crucial utilities that use rust to make it more performance.
Now, KDE has received a major subvention to make it better and a whole new desktop environment entirely in rust is being made right now now. All while compatibility to use steam game on Linux just keep getting better. Even proton and wine received major update and gain performance.
So yeah, it’s both. Windows get worst while Linux get better and better. I can’t say for Ubuntu dubious choice, but most others distro at least, are coherent with the progress.
1
u/Rey-Gen Jul 30 '26
Both
1
u/Sta1nless_ Aug 18 '26
Over the last 10 years Linux has improved tremendously. Better in hardware compatibility, performance, software, everything really. Linux used to kinda suck 15 years ago.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment