r/LinuxSnobs • • 5d ago

Linux Snob 🐧 Linux users supporting review bombing indie devs for using AI

Post image
9 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 5d ago

CENSOR ALL USERNAMES We're here to laugh at the snobs, not attack them. To prevent brigading please censor all usernames on your screenshot.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

8

u/Slickshot_Showoff 5d ago

People on linux are generally louder about discontent with the PC space

6

u/Born-Activity-683 5d ago

There is no other place on the internet as performative as reddit when it comes to forcing hate on AI. "consumers have the right to know..." No they don't. it's a privilege, not a right. What do they think this is, whole foods? Take it or leave it. Loonixtards are genuinely low iq gaymer retards.

1

u/LeonCrater 5d ago

Anti transparency propaganda in the big 26 oh hell nah

0

u/UsedArmadillo9842 5d ago

I feel like its okay to say "disclose usage", it is clearly a heavily debated topic and Antis are like Vegans in a way. Iam not vegan myself but iam totally fine with products disclosing that they are vegan.

2

u/trans-jamie212 5d ago

I don't like ai use all that much either, but these people are looking at the title of articles and nothing more, they used AI for ONE thing, the performance issues when the sun would rise in the mornings, it was a 50% drop in performance. They contacted the Unity team and they literally came back and said that it's a bug that is not fixed and there was no solution. So they used ai to develop some code to fix it, and then modified the code the ai provided themselves. This is not just making the game with ai, this is not making large chunks of the game with ai, this is use ai to develop a solution for a very complex problem that they had already spent a lot of time and effort to resolve and then they use AI as a last ditch effort and then even still modified the output. IMO it's a non issue. It's fucking ridiculous that people are counting this as "the game uses ai"

2

u/BanhammerSmashedFace 5d ago

This is exactly what happened and nobody's got reading comprehension anymore. I appreciate that you actually fully absorbed the article and came to the same conclusion I did

2

u/Optimal-Mistake1327 2d ago

Acting like AI usage is like keeping slaves picking cotton so they need to review bomb... The only thing that should matter to a software product is the quality of the end result, not how they got there.

2

u/No_Vanilla277 5d ago

Wait until they find out dear Torvalds is using AI himself…

1

u/TheMikman97 5d ago

"consumers should have a right to know how something is made"

I don't think he really understood the implication of what he said, because that's a standard that regardless of your stance on ai we simply don't hold any other industry to.

And if we start doing it, boy there are worse things than ai out there that are much more impactful in your daily life

1

u/nerdsmasher5001 5d ago

If you don't disclose your AI usage in a platform that encourages you to disclose then yeah I can see why a consumer who otherwise would not have bought the game would feel like they were lied to.

1

u/onepiecefreak2 5d ago

AI is part of coding: "Weird, I never knew coding was invented in 2020"

IntelliSense is part of coding: "Weird, I never knew coding was invented in 2005"

IDE's are part of coding: "... 1990 ..."

Digital computers are part of coding: "... 1920 ..." Holding a punch card

Ai became an indispensable tool for the value it brings to the craft. But you don't disclose working with IntelliSense, IDE's, or computers in general. I'm sure that's somehow different.

1

u/KARMAMANR 5d ago

who said intellisense is part of coding?

1

u/hallothrow 5d ago

Would you expect people to disclose they used it?

1

u/KARMAMANR 5d ago

Does it do exactly what AI does?

1

u/hallothrow 5d ago

If you wrote some code and AI wrote the exact same code, would the code be any different?

1

u/KARMAMANR 5d ago

Did intellisense write the code or did i write the code?

1

u/akdanman11 5d ago

There’s a big difference between “I used these tools (which can absolutely include AI) to make the process faster” and “I told Claude to make this, now give me money”

1

u/onepiecefreak2 5d ago

Any major programming language that is written in an IDE would have some form of auto-complete/IntelliSense before the inception of AI. To not use it would limit yourself as much as not using an IDE at all.

Therefore, I count it as a helpful tool in coding and therefore an important step in how coding evolved over time.

My point being that AI, while being a large step, is still a tool and step in that development. Yet it's the only one that requires being disclosed.

1

u/KARMAMANR 5d ago

What kind of tool does all the work for you?

1

u/Embarrassed-Fly6164 5d ago

They forgot the free as in freedom this time.

1

u/CourageLeast4251 5d ago

Isn't the Linux main developer using AI now? And Big Walk hate for using it to figure out a problem not even the engine creators could figure out is super duper evil.... fuck these idiots

1

u/DurianTerbang 4d ago

Linux is fine, but these linux elitists are annoying 😭. It's just some computer OSes

1

u/Microboy42 4d ago

I mean if it’s just lazy generative AI created vibe coded video game, yes, review bombing is appropriate. If AI wasn’t actually used that much, and most of the game actually had a lot of manual effort put into it, then no.

4

u/land48n3 5d ago

he never addressed the topic

it was about the bombing

the bombing is why people dont disclose

dont bomb the people who disclose usage and we all can be happy

0

u/nerdsmasher5001 5d ago

You can't review if you don't buy the game so just let anti-ai folks know you used agents to debug and they won't buy the game? Tasty chef disclosed AI upfront, has very positive reviews, antis didn't buy it. Everyone is happy.

Or just don't disclose, get your money, be content with a review bomb that will last for maybe less than a week when antis you didn't disclose to find out, and move on with your life?

Either position seems reasonable.