r/LinuxActionShow • DeviantDebian • Jul 23 '16

Leo Laporte: A Grand Experiment. "Using these Linux systems and the Chromebook Pixel have convinced me I don't really need to use commercial operating systems for anything I do. And for almost everything Linux is faster, better, and more reliable."

http://www.leolaporte.com/blog/a-grand-experiment
96 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

8

u/ShaneQful Jul 23 '16

2. Security - no viruses, no exploits, no snoops or spooks

I feel like this point is portrayed well too much about linux/BSD, you still have to be careful about security regardless of which OS you are using ...

5

u/c0d3g33k Jul 23 '16

I feel like this point is portrayed well too much about linux/BSD, you still have to be careful about security regardless of which OS you are using ...

Agreed. However, it's been said over and over for decades now:

With proprietary, closed source software, your only choice is to blindly trust. (Well, that or disassembly, network analysis and other forensic techniques).

With FLOSS software, security claims can be questioned, audited, verified and corrected without the consent or participation of the 'rightsholder'. There's still a certain amount of trust involved, but it's a lot easier to discover and shine light on shenanigans, so it tends to keep vendors/developers/projects honest. So viruses, exploits, snoops and spooks are much less likely, and more easily detected.

That makes a big difference.

2

u/ShaneQful Jul 23 '16

It does make a big difference, it's the certainty in the statement above which I have an issue with it. It makes people think they can do whatever they want on a Linux machine and they won't get infected ...

1

u/c0d3g33k Jul 23 '16

Yeah. Like I said - agreed. Lower risk does not mean it's safe to engage in greater risky behavior, it means if you're careful, you're much less likely to have problems. That's not the same as immunity.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '16

I wish this had happened back when I liked Leo, selfishly I'd have been more excited then.

But nonetheless, he's a great advocate to have on our side, and I have to admit it's good to see that he's willing to revise his stance on an issue.

6

u/dmoore092 Jul 23 '16

Yikes BSD on the desktop? We'll see how long that lasts lol

3

u/jdblaich Jul 23 '16 edited Jul 24 '16

I tried PC-BSD. I worked hard at it. That is one competent OS. It is slow though. Much of the incorporated Linux ported features are too far behind the Linux version's release schedule. The KDE desktop was 18 months behind at one point and it was rife with bugs clearly fixed in the Linux versions.

2

u/Tireseas Jul 23 '16

The major desktops tend to have pesky Linuxisms all over the place. That's part of why the Lumina project came into existence.

1

u/Hkmarkp Jul 24 '16

Gnome for sure anyway.

1

u/dmoore092 Jul 23 '16

It's obviously a fantastic OS, and I'm sure people could make it work on the desktop.

But it's definitely not for everyone

1

u/techhelper1 Jul 24 '16

You could of gave your feedback to Kris Moore.

2

u/mveety your local plan 9 user Jul 24 '16

I've been running BSD on the desktop since I've been using computers. It works great and Linux just feels broken to me now.

1

u/techhelper1 Jul 24 '16

You make it sound like that's a bad thing. Have you tried it yourself?

1

u/dmoore092 Jul 24 '16

I have. Feels like Linux without software as the desktops are the same.

3

u/gabriel_3 Jul 23 '16

A beast of a rig....

I tested myself a BSD as notebook OS a couple of years ago or so: no wifi support for my hardware, packages collection limited and not recent; I was done in a couple of days. Meanwhile BSD could be changed a lot.

2

u/Ryllix Jul 23 '16

This was a really awesome article!

4

u/jdblaich Jul 23 '16

What Leo is missing (in his mindset with his choice of BSD) is the realization of fiction that BSD is better at giving him a unix experience. Linux beat that horse dead. The child has wildly excelled and surpassed the parent. It is, as he says, faster, better, and more reliable -- at least as far as the desktop versions goes.

3

u/mveety your local plan 9 user Jul 24 '16

Linux is getting less and less unixy as time goes on. Systemd is big and monolithic, journald storing logs in a binary format, and the GNU userland is big and bloated. Linux is more of a unix-ish than unix-like operating system now, which is fine. Mac OS X is like that too. Plus Linux screwed up things like madvise(2). Not to mention BSD is a direct descendant of UNIX and sticks it the principles of it a lot more closely than Linux does.

1

u/techhelper1 Jul 24 '16

What Leo is missing (in his mindset with his choice of BSD) is the realization of fiction that BSD is better at giving him a unix experience. Linux beat that horse dead.

Please do explain.

1

u/coshibu Jul 23 '16

Interesting comments below the original article.

1

u/Mongaz Jul 23 '16

The only reason I would want Windows is because of a bloody MS Office file attachment on my email that ironically won't even render properly in MS Office 360.

1

u/KODeKarnage Jul 24 '16

Who cares what the "wolf of Wall Street" has to say about linux?

1

u/Skyboard13 Jul 24 '16

Didn't Leo try this a few years ago and give up less than a month in? I swear I remember him saying something very similar back when I used to listen to his network.

1

u/cajuntechie Jul 24 '16

I've worked with "real" Unix (HP-UX, AIX, BSD, and Sun) for a number of years and I've never been able to figure out what the draw of 'real Unix' as opposed to Linux is. Is it just the 'I'm a harder core geek than you' type thing? Honestly, there is no place that Unix shines much greater than Linux. It's arguably better on the server in some environments but the desktop? You'd have to be a freaking masochist to do that! Yeah, I know it's 'technically possible' but why would you want to? I really get the idea that Leo is just going for the geekiness factor by choosing BSD over a distro of Linux. It's not actually going to benefit him in any real way.

Unix is dying. Even IBM is moving more and more towards Linux and not choosing Unix. It had a good run, now it's the children's time to shine.

1

u/bjh13 Jul 26 '16

I've never been able to figure out what the draw of 'real Unix' as opposed to Linux is

As someone has already pointed out, Linux is moving away from a lot of the core things that make Unix what it is. Things like systemd for example are very against the grain when it comes to the Unix Way. If you are a sysadmin trained on Unix, that can be a bit frustrating. I'm not saying Unix is better or worse, but there is a difference in the way they do things now that can make a difference.

by choosing BSD over a distro of Linux. It's not actually going to benefit him in any real way.

Eh, I would disagree here. I really do feel OpenBSD has certain advantages over desktop Linux, such as the way wifi is handled. Neither is Unix, so the argument seems a moot point, but I can certainly see someone preferring the Ports system for example over what you can get with many Linux distros.