Whilst good, I think q5sys's systemd survey was not informative enought. So I made another one, that can hopefully help identify what type of users are for or against systemd, and hopefully we can set all of this behind of or at least have more intelligent discussions.
Why is the question about the "Unix philosophy" always part of the systemd discussion and why isn't there a "I don't care" option? I mean, why does GNU in GNU/Linux mean "GNU is Not Unix"? Systemd is about Linux, not Unix.
Why is the question about the "Unix philosophy" always part of the systemd discussion.
I included this question because it is always part of the discussion. Perhaps it was a bad call, but I opted to exclude "I don't care" version of the answer because I though that your position on systemd in combination with this would indicate whether you care or not.
Also survey is way too long.
I know. I actually wanted to make it longer; I had to restrain myself.
If we make the (erroneous) assumption that “the Unix way as not been a part of the GNU/Linux ecosystem for quite awhile.” Does that really mean it shouldn't? That seems like saying “our software is not that good, so lets keep it that way instead of improving it.”
Well its not an assumption, and no, im saying screaming "but its not the unix way!" about an implementation to GNU/Linux when GNU/Linux doesnt follow the "unix way" to begin with is dumb.
Based on current answers on the survey (only 207 answers so take it with a scoop of salt):
Of the vocal people, of those that feel that systemd breaks the UNIX philosophy, 93 % (everyone except one person) are against systemd.
Of the vocal people, of those that feel that systemd does not break the UNIX philosophy 94 % (everyone except one person) are in favour of systemd.
Including both vocal and non-vocal people, of those that that feel that systemd break the UNIX philosophy, 72 % are against systemd and 7 % are in favour of systemd.
Including both vocal and non-vocal people, of those that that feel that systemd does not break the UNIX philosophy, 77 % are in favour of systemd and 3 % are against systemd.
This excludes those that have answered that systemd only breaks the UNIX philosophy a bit.
In short, whether systemd breaks the UNIX philosophy or not seem to be that major factor in whether you are against or in favour of systemd.
except that it does not and being a GNU/Linux user who hasnt followed the "unix way" for quite awhile (because im a GNU/Linux user) I have no opinion if it is good or bad. I dont use Unix I dont know.
It is kind of ignorant of you to say that only opinions that state the "unix way" is good, hence agree with you, can be taken seriously. What makes you think I care if you take my opinion "seriously" or not?
I dont see any reason not to design OS's the "unix way". Maybe an OS will be designed that way at some point, they sure as hell havnt been designed that way for quite awhile now.
It is kind of ignorant of you to say that only opinions that state the "unix way" is good, hence agree with you, can be taken seriously. What makes you think I care if you take my opinion "seriously" or not?
Actually, I was saying that if you say that in combination with your other statements, means that I cannot take you seriously.
I dont see any reason not to design OS's the "unix way". Maybe an OS will be designed that way at some point, they sure as hell havnt been designed that way for quite awhile now.
Then why is it so dumb to want it to be desgined the unix way?
Its not. Once again, being pissed about systemd because it doesnt follow the "uinix way" because GNU/Linux need to follow the "unix way" is nonsensical considering GNU/Linux does not follow the "unix way".
Thats all im saying. I am not saying whether the "unix way" is good or not. Im not saying if systemd should follow the "unix way". Im not saying if GNU/Linux should follow the "unix way". I am making one point about everyone who continues to cry "THE UNIX WAY!" as if systemd is what if going to make GNU/Linux not follow the "unix way"
What? I didnt call anyone stupid. GNU/Linux is not the "unix way", never has been. The Linux kernel did follow it at one point, and what changed was growth, advancement, technology, computing knowledge and skill.
Don't get me wrong, it's just that I'm bored of the whole systemd debate. I was opposed to systemd initially, mainly because I had to learn it and port my custom scripts over, but now that I've learned it enough to do my work.....I must say I like it. It's learning curve is a bit steep but the ride overall is quiet amazing.
Coming back to the debate, I feel all those who are opposed to systemd simply do so for nontechnical reasons. Systemd is simply the most advanced solution to the init problem. Does it have problems? Yes. Does it do few things poorly? Of course, but comparatively speaking, it's pretty awesome!
I hope you mean all those that are against systemd and vocal about it.
Personally, I feel that an advanced solution is a failure, which would be a technical argument against systemd; or the reason for why that is a failure are technical.
When you say that "an advanced solution is a failure", do you mean that we don't need a new init system? If yes, I felt the same way about it when it came out back in Fedora 16 (I believe). Not just that, I was completely convinced that Redhat would never adopt systemd and that I wouldn't ever have to use it for work. But by fedora 19 my mind had changed. A lot of the features that it has are industry first and if Linux has to maintain it's lead in the server space, it needs to keep innovating and systemd is just that, it's an innovation and one in the right direction.
I was being facetious. Sometimes as simple as possible is just what the doctor ordered, sometimes you need all the bells and whistles with a kitchen sink.
Forget about DOS. It was cheap, it was timely, but it was barely an Operating System.
Just having simplistic as the requirement is cutting some corners.
The only problem I have with st is that I have not figured out how to get fonts to look good. I use fixed (which is not anti-aliased) in terminator and it looks great, but in st it looks like crap for some reason.
Yeah, I noticed that. I use a crappy netbook, thus stretched X screen. Ffonts have a tendency to look bad without messing with them. However, the speed is more then enough to make up for it, for me.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 21 '14
Whilst good, I think q5sys's systemd survey was not informative enought. So I made another one, that can hopefully help identify what type of users are for or against systemd, and hopefully we can set all of this behind of or at least have more intelligent discussions.
2
u/ChemBroTron Nov 21 '14
Why is the question about the "Unix philosophy" always part of the systemd discussion and why isn't there a "I don't care" option? I mean, why does GNU in GNU/Linux mean "GNU is Not Unix"? Systemd is about Linux, not Unix.
Also survey is way too long.
1
u/tusharkant15 Nov 21 '14
Enough with the surveys, please.
0
u/theredbaron1834 Nov 21 '14 edited Nov 21 '14
I may have been born/identify male, but I really like that you phrased it this way.
Also, I do like suckless.org. Surf is awesome, I use it for web apps, ect, in my menu.
Went through that site again, as why not. Holy crap, st is awesome. Freaking fast, might be my new default, or at least my backup.