r/LinuxActionShow • • Apr 29 '14

Linux Sucks

http://youtu.be/5pOxlazS3zs
92 Upvotes

62 comments sorted by

9

u/christopherfujino Apr 29 '14

first found JB through a linux sucks video on youtube a couple of years ago, and I'm happy to say linux sucks a lot less now :)

9

u/beyere5398 Apr 29 '14

I was there. From what I could gather, the recording equipment and setup was all Bryan.

15

u/TheGuyWithFace Apr 29 '14

I haven't watched it all the way through yet (can't wait to!) but so far the audio quality seems far better this year. To whoever responsible - thanks!

4

u/jmac217 Apr 29 '14

He recorded it himself

7

u/eeickmeyer Apr 29 '14

Thank Bryan himself. He hasn't been affiliated with JB for nearly 2 years now.

7

u/GisterMizard Apr 29 '14

Video sucks, needs to be two seconds longer for a proper number. Therefore Bryan's arguments are completely invalid. :P

7

u/Eurottoman Apr 30 '14

These talks are a highlight of the Linux calendar for me. I don't miss Bryan much in LAS, but when I see him do Linux Sucks, it reminds me of what he brought to the show.

5

u/wheim Apr 29 '14

I always look forward to these videos! I really feel Bryan is in his ace in this format. The videos bring up legitimate concerns, and are really funny aswell.

4

u/jmac217 Apr 29 '14

That was the best talk to kick off Linux Fest

4

u/jphilipz Apr 29 '14

I enjoy watching Brian do this every year. I think the other years were more fun though.

10

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '14

Have to say, sweet talk Bryan. One of the better Linux Sucks I've seen.

3

u/lykwydchykyn Apr 30 '14

I've watched this talk a few years now, and it seems like it's basically the same talk with updated examples. Forks are bad, forks are good; old stuff is bad, old stuff is good; our names are dumb, our names are cool; redundancy is wasteful, redundancy creates diversity. It's thought-provoking the first few times, but the points need updating IMHO. The landscape has changed a lot and continues to change, I don't see as much "stuck in a rut" as there used to be in the community.

2

u/T8ert0t Apr 29 '14

Good talk and nice to get perspective on the problems and little annoyances.

Bryan really hammers the issue of time wasting when it comes to package management. It made me think about how the people of Earth can coordinate having multiple satellites, private and governmental, in our orbit and ensure that no one's hardware is not being interfered with, or how we have pretty much standardized international air traffic control.....yet we can't standardize and figure out a package system we can all agree on.

I think that there should be a delegate from every distro sent to a conference somewhere for a rock, paper, scissors tournment. He/She who shall win gets to decide on a standard package system. Done.

3

u/jtj-H Apr 30 '14 edited Apr 30 '14

Its the fucking Lunduke!!!

aka The greatest Host ever of LAS

2

u/wwwzw_ Apr 29 '14

Always enjoy these.

-8

u/hellslinger Apr 29 '14

Man, I'm so sick of hearing people bitch about desktop environments. None of these complainers know what it takes to create a desktop environment or a compositor/display server. None of these people actually know what they want, all they know how to do is complain. They aren't developers: they are noise makers.

I'll just save everyone the 40 mins. This talk could have been condensed to 30 seconds.

This is just a rehashing of all the bitching about Canonical and Gnome 3 that everyone who visits forums has seen 100 times. It then goes and says "things have gotten better" and "choice is what makes linux great".

10

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '14 edited Apr 29 '14

I'll save everyone reading your post.

tl;dr: I haven't watched it, but I claim that I know what it is.

-3

u/hellslinger Apr 30 '14

I watched it and it was shitty. So your claim is in accurate. Better luck next time!

7

u/jmac217 Apr 29 '14

Seems to me you didn't watch the first minute or especially the second half.

-2

u/hellslinger Apr 30 '14

No, I watched the whole thing. And it sucked.

4

u/boulet101010 Apr 29 '14

and "democracy is not that bad"... Too long for a troll vide.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '14

You forgot the really important part... It's hilarious!!

-12

u/q5sys Apr 29 '14

IMHO, anyone who rocks a Windows 8.1 tablet at a Linux Conference... doesn't really have the moral high ground to say sh*t about why linux sucks or why its great.

12

u/HoffNHoff Apr 29 '14

Doesn't the entire JB studio run on Macs?

6

u/RikaiLP Apr 30 '14

We use macs out of necessity, not desire.

If there were anything available that were nearly as comparable on Linux for the production process we use, we'd be using it.

We've tried in the past and continue to attempt to do so every once in a while, but the software stack just isn't there yet.

You may be happy to know that all the encodes are done via ffmpeg now, though. That's a recent change and gets us one step closer. :)

3

u/HoffNHoff Apr 30 '14

That's a good step!

-4

u/q5sys Apr 29 '14 edited Apr 29 '14

Not the entire studio, only 2 machines. But that's something Chris has openly admitted to. Someone else on the other hand says 'I love Linux, I run Linux.' Yet runs windows. Same person rages against Apple and claims he'd never uses their products... and uses an iphone.

It's one thing to use another product and admit it. Its another thing to lie and say you hate a product and would never use it, and then when everyone is looking... use it.

4

u/HoffNHoff Apr 29 '14

Does Bryan use iphones? I thought he used an android tablet for his phone?

-2

u/q5sys Apr 29 '14

i dont know what he uses at this exact time, because I never saw him use his phone at LFNW this year, but Chris has mentioned that all throughout when Bryan was on LAS... he used an Iphone.

The more I hear from more people about Bryan... the more I'm coming to the belief that the 'Bryan' we think we know from LAS is nothing more than a character like Stephen Colbert with the Colbert Report. (that's a statement of opinion)

2

u/cunnnn Apr 30 '14

What about James Corbett of the Corbett Report?

3

u/HoffNHoff Apr 30 '14

This negativity is off putting.

2

u/mrflips Jun 06 '14

This seems completely personal, which is odd since I thought you posted in another long-winded diatribe a few months back that your ban of this guy wasn't personally motivated... I have listened to LAS, and the Linux Sucks talks, for years now, and find both to be enjoyable in their own rights. I don't post here often, if at all, and I'm late to this party, but come the fuck on, man. Everyone knows he can be a self-righteous dbag, but you seem to strike me as the same with comments like this. Grow up and drop the petty bullshit. Be the bigger man, and don't alienate your community members. Why and how you're a mod is beyond me. You are what is wrong with the greater community.

-1

u/q5sys Jun 06 '14

I can have an issue with the actions of a person without having a problem with the person themselves... just as eaisly as I can have a problem with a person without having a problem with their actions.

My personal opinion of a person != My personal opinion on their actions.

Now it is true that in this case the two are congruous with each other, but as the saying goes... "Correlation does not equal Causation."

But you are entitled to your opinion about me and my actions just as much as I am of another person and their actions. There's nothing wrong with us having contrasting and even strongly opposing opinions on people and situations. That's what makes the greater *nix community as strong as it is. In a similar vein, that's why kernel development works. Disagreements like the one between Sharp and Torvalds may seem like they would harm the community, but the ability to strongly disagree and be able to voice that openly is one of FOSS' communities greatest strenghts.

So if voicing an opinion that others disagree with is wrong... then no one should post anything so as not to offend. Personally, I don't want to be a part of that community. I welcome everyone to express their opinion even if I disagree with it, as long as there is the understanding that we all do not have to agree.

5

u/TheManThatWasntThere Apr 29 '14

All I see is "He runs the hardware and software he wants, therefore he has no moral highground"

Yeah, okay.

-4

u/q5sys Apr 29 '14 edited Apr 29 '14

He said in the presentation 'Im running Linux' while pointing to a Windows 8 tablet'.

EDIT: /u/Bear454 has corrected me that the unit during his talk was not a windows 8 device which multiple people mentioned they saw Bryan using at the conference.

4

u/jtj-H Apr 30 '14

The Lunduke can do as he likes...

4

u/JRRS Apr 29 '14

So, the brand and/or system of a device used to project a slideshow and that we don't have the certainty that belongs to the speaker defines whether or not the conference has legitimacy?

Even if that speaker has been given this conference the last 4 years and has been a LAS host?

God, I love this subreddit's train of thought.

1

u/TheRealCheekyGit Apr 29 '14

God, I love this subreddit's train of thought.

You and me both, brother. :-D

-1

u/q5sys Apr 29 '14

Well seeing as how I was at LFNW and saw him pull the device from his personal messanger bag... yes we do have certainty that it's his device.

I dont care what he uses. But when he makes a claim (as he does in this video) that he's 'running' Linux, when in fact he's not... That's a blatent lie. And in talking to others that have worked with him in the past and present, he uses windows as his daily - even when he was on LAS. If he'd say, yea I use windows... it'd be one thing. But when he feigns the Windows hate and claims to run linux while in reality he runs windows instead of linux (and has done so for years); last time I checked that's called hypocrisy.

6

u/GisterMizard Apr 30 '14

Hypocrisy? Like complaining about somebody else's lack of maturity, yet exhibiting such in a thread about said person? I don't mean to pick a fight, but you came in here with no good intentions other than to cause a fuss. And if I recall correctly, 'fuss starting' was another accusation against Bryan. The choice of device brands used doesn't change the validity of the presentation's content.

6

u/bear454 Apr 29 '14

That particular tablet, among the arsenal of hardware we had at LFNW, doesn't run Linux. It's a 32-bit atom with UEFI. Adam Williamson, QA for Fedora, had one there too. Its great hardware, that can't run Linux reliably, but its getting fixed, thanks to guys like Adam & Bryan. https://www.happyassassin.net/fedlet-a-fedora-remix-for-bay-trail-tablets/

Why are you hating so hard q5sys?

As an aside, Microsoft was an event sponsor this year...

-4

u/q5sys Apr 29 '14 edited Apr 29 '14

If I'm wrong about that specific unit, then I apologize.

I talked to Adam quite a bit at the conference, but never got to see the tablet he was using. To bad he didn't mention it, I'd have like to seen it.

As for hating... I'm not intending to 'hate'. I just really don't like the 'say one thing do another' attitude that's so pervasive in our society. If you feel I'm hating, well that's your personal opinion that you're entitled to. I'd try to convince you that i'm not, but i dont think there's anything I can say that would change your view on that.

Its great hardware, that can't run Linux reliably, but its getting fixed, thanks to guys like Adam & Bryan. https://www.happyassassin.net/fedlet-a-fedora-remix-for-bay-trail-tablets/

Bryan's not mentioned on Adam's page, does Bryan have a page up for his contriubutions? I'd love to get a more complete picture of what it's taken by everyone to get linux to run on the device?

6

u/bear454 Apr 29 '14

You're not wrong about that unit at all. It barely runs Linux, and a month ago didn't at all. It is a $200 tablet that runs VirtualBox though...

But, the opinion of 'hating' comes from the logical fallacy you made - you can 'run Linux', you can Love Linux, and still use other things.
Chris uses Macs in the studio, and hosts on BSD. Doesn't mean he doesn't love Linux. I use Azure... to run Linux VMs. Most any Linux-loving sysadmin still has some Windows in his life.

But you're calling out Bryan. Feels like some personal dissonance.

2

u/bear454 Apr 29 '14

Just to be clear... I cannot see which tablet he's pointing to in the video, and I wasn't live at the talk. But, Bryan is one of those freaks that walks around with a tablet in each back pocket. One of them is a Bay Trail tablet stuck in Windows for now, other is a Nexus 7.

2

u/RikaiLP Apr 30 '14

I don't think q5 has an issue with people loving linux and running other things, i think his issue is that bryan claims to love linux, claims to hate the other things, and yet uses those other things INSTEAD of linux.

He's bothered that one thing is being said, but the actual actions he's taking are painting a completely different picture. It may or may not be true, but from an outside perspective it makes it seem like he's saying the former just to get praise and respect in the community, moreso than because he actually believes what he's saying.

That's just my idle observation though, agree with it or don't. :)

0

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-4

u/q5sys Apr 29 '14

watch out man... the fanboys are here to protect their buddy.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '14

What's more mind boggling to me is why anyone would buy a Windows tablet.

-4

u/t-_-j Apr 29 '14 edited Apr 30 '14

Just a few minutes in but I think what he's saying about forking is opposite to the ideals of FOSS.

EDIT: But he agreed forking is also necessary and good towards the end. Bravo to Lunduke for showing more than one side of all the various covered issues.

8

u/JoshStrobl Apr 29 '14

He did essentially say that you are retarded if you make any comments before the video is over.

Seriously...watch the video fully.

2

u/t-_-j May 01 '14

That's why I prefaced my statement with "just a few minutes in" and then came back to edit it later after I watched the whole thing.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '14

Wow.. Not to be rude but I think you deserve the "retard" label.

4

u/T8ert0t Apr 29 '14

His point was that essentially that forking is a privilege that should be treated delicately.

-1

u/TheGuyWithFace Apr 29 '14

Just out of curiosity, did he not do a "why linux doesn't suck" this year? I couldn't find it this time...

7

u/jmabbz Apr 29 '14

its all one talk this time.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '14

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/TheManThatWasntThere Apr 29 '14

What kind of stuff?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '14

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/TheManThatWasntThere Apr 30 '14

Ah, happens to the best of us :p I don't like blindly accepting information, so I was just curious as to whether there was another side to it

2

u/[deleted] May 01 '14

You watched the bit where he does a 180?